I was in town visiting family when we swung by the Red Horse Tavern for dinner. A quaint spot with a classic look the Horse has friendly staff and a parking area that is easy to get in and out of. The recent menu has a great diversity of options ranging from salads, sandwiches, and entrees. I elected to go with the Birra ramen, not something I would expect to find at this establishment or in this neck of the woods. I was knocked back at how good it was. The broth had rich flavor and the right amount of spice, not enough to burn your mouth, but warm it up and tingle your lips. The beef was tender and cooked to perfection. It hit the spot on a chilly winter night. If you find yourself in the gap and looking for spot to grab a good hearty bite to eat and drink, the Red Horse is your spot! read more

Red Horse Tavern - American Near Me - Pleasant Gap, Pennsylvania

See all

First timers and overall the food was amazeballs and service was good. Parking was not the greatest, but what do you expect for 630 Friday evening. We started with fried pickles and they were good..I'm not much of a pickle guy. I had the old fashion burger with froes and a side salad. Burger rocked and the fries were amazing. The side salad was top notch, my favorite dressing orange vinaigrette. My wife had the french dip and loved it. My daughter and her best buddy "E" shared the smashburger and burria taco dishes...they loved it and were stuffed. Thank You Mikayli for the wonderful service and such a friendly server. read more

See all

Exciting place to eat! They have a unique menu with birria ramen and yellow pepper pasta with squash and burgers and more! I got the yellow pepper pasta which makes my mouth water thinking about it. It was delicious! Staff were nice. Place is beautiful and there was plenty of seating. I also got to try a sip of the birria ramen and it was amazing too! read more

Red Horse Tavern - Inside - American Near Me - Pleasant Gap, Pennsylvania

See all

Delicious food, you have to try the Banoffee Pie. Really nice workers, very prompt. Shout out to Sorcha (sorry if I'm spelling your name wrong girl), very kind and helpful. Quiet, clean, really cute interior. read more

Red Horse Tavern - Mom had fun too!! - American Near Me - Pleasant Gap, Pennsylvania

While driving west we spotted the Red Horse Tavern and decided to give it a try. The menu was limited, but the Caribbean Jerk Salmon caught our eye and we were not disappointed! The salmon was excellent, the bed of sticky rice was wonderful, but the corn salad that was doused on the plate didn't seem to fit in with the other flavors. The service was excellent and the ambiance was fine too. I would have given 5 start but the corn salad, in my humble opinion, detracted from the other flavors. read more

See all

Decided to take the drive out of state college and it was a very good decision. We tried the Brisket Grilled Cheese and it did not disappoint. Very cheesy and great flavor. Our server, Nova was fabulous and very entertaining. She took great care of us. We finished our meal with the Banoffee pie. Wow it was very good. We will be back to enjoy it again!! read more

Food sub par at best , staff not over friendly. Place needs cleaned tables and floor had food on it . Not planning to go back .

We were attending Thon and wanted a nice birthday dinner. I had reservations for 6pm and got seated immediately. I would have loved a table near the fireplace but I didn't know to ask. The red horse tavern looks like a historic old building with an entrance for the tavern and an entrance for the restaurant. We had excellent, attentive service and started with the Korean barbecue ribs. It had a kick to the flavor and was accompanied by a slaw. It was delicious. Our entrees were the salmon and pork chop. Both were so good especially my green beans with shallots. To end this amazing meal was the highlight. Red Horse Tavern is known for their pies and they didn't disappoint. We had a banoffee and peanut butter slice. Both were generously sized and phenomenal. We can't wait to go back during our next trip to Penn State. read more

See all

Inside this tasty establishment is a family friendly dinning area separate from tavern. Food is amazing, fresh and homemade pie to die for! Staff are friendly, accommodating and timely. Would definitely return if we are in the area again. read more

See all

Disappointed. I tried this place based on Yelp reviews and was hopeful that it being further away from Penn State campus during family weekend would a mean a better experience. There were four tables at the restaurant that were full. Lots of empty seats. It was 8 pm and I had reservations and we arrived on time. We ordered a charcuterie board to start - waitress never put the order in. Bummed bc those are my daughter's favorite and this was the start to the Family Weekend. Waited a long time for drinks and the glass of wine that arrived wasn't even halfway full. It looked like a shot. Basically seemed like whatever was left in the bottle got poured into the glass Burger was burnt and didn't have the toppings requested. Waitress was rushed and ran off before we could even finish placing an order. I'd understand if the place was packed and mistakes happen- but there was hardly anyone there so I don't get it. There were only two dessert options - a Banoffee pie - which was super sweet but good to share and some dessert that was alcohol based as the waitress pointed out and wouldn't be served to anyone under 21. Um ok? So there's one dessert option then? Pro - the fries were good. My daughter liked the chicken sandwich. read more

Food quality is excellent! Good enough to outweigh the loud shabby dining room, and small portions. I basically bought 2 entrees to get full but both were excellent. I would have liked to know the quinoa with broccoli that came with my salmon, was dressed in a spicy oil though. The beet and arugula salad with added shrimp was excellent too. read more

Red Horse Tavern - Salmon entree, and arugula beet salad - American Near Me - Pleasant Gap, Pennsylvania

Went last night for the first time in a while. Just after the dinner crowd left. We were disappointed that they were out of the braised beef, ribs, and that hadn't been mentioned when they handed us the menus. Brisket grilled cheese sandwich was good, and the pretzel board was excellent as was the banaoffee pie. On the downside, the waitress was okay, but not very personable. It was mid-thirties outside but freezing inside the dining room. I like it cool, but I had a sweatshirt on and was almost uncomfortable. It was sad to see that the damaged ceiling tiles that were there are the last time we were there had still not been replaced. I will come back - I really want to try the braised beef ribs - but it would be nice to see them have a bit of climate control, fix the damage ceiling, and raise the level of hospitality to that of the food itself. read more

See all

We were in the area and thought we would try it. Expectations were low based on the exterior, but the reviews were decent. I got the brisket grilled cheese with handcut fries (an upgrade) and my husband got the old fashioned burger with house made chips. Pleasantly surprised. Everything was delicious and fresh. For kicks, we tried a drink from the bar; very tasty. The dining room was very clean. The service was professional. Loved the decor, especially the pictures of pies on one wall and doors on another. Unfortunately, we were stuffed from our meals and had no room for the delicious-sounding pies. My only suggestion is to add homemade soups or chili in the Fall/Winter. Overall, a good experience. Will have to leave room for pies the next time we come. Thanks! read more

We came here for dinner on a Friday night and we loved this place! They have a great draft list for beer! We split the pretzel bread appetizer, then I had the French dip sandwich and it was INCREDIBLE. My wife had the mushroom ravioli, my sister had the squash tacos, and my mother in law had the harvest bowl. Everyone said their food was great. The server was attentive, nice, and efficient! The environment was relaxed and the restaurant was busy but it was not loud. We finished with the banoffee pie and it was pretty good! We would definitely come back. read more

Red Horse Tavern - Banoffee Pie - American Near Me - Pleasant Gap, Pennsylvania

Great friendly restaurant. The quality of food was excellent. We had the Harvest bowl and Brisket sandwich, both delicious and made with fresh quality ingredients. Sandwich came with homemade chips which were thick cut and crispy. Seems like a popular place as it began to fill up right after we arrived. read more

Red Horse Tavern - Harvest bowl (front) and Brisket sandwich. - American Near Me - Pleasant Gap, Pennsylvania

Good food. Squash tacos were awesome. Good comfy atmosphere. Nice option that you need to know to try

We go to this place on special occasions (birthdays) and for their killer brunch on Sundays. Great food and great space. We love this place.

Tried Red Horse at the suggestion of a student who works there. Very busy at 7pm Saturday but they found me a table in the bar. Had a very, very good Reuben sandwich and, I can't remember what they called it, a caramel and banana pie, wow! read more

Awesome service! The French dip was great and husband had the Reuben and gave it a thumbs up. Worth the stop ! Good happy hour too . read more

Red Horse Tavern - French dip - American Near Me - Pleasant Gap, Pennsylvania

Fantastic. We had a larger party so got to try a lot of things on the menu and it was all spectacular. The tavern stew was delicious, The pork chop, amazing! Love the pretzel bread and their signature banoffie pie was to die for. . My only criticism is our waitress seemed annoyed for some reason but she still took excellent care of us. This place is well worth the visit read more

The food here is amazing!!! If I lived anywhere nearby, this would be my "Cheers" and they would have to chase me off. We did not go to the bar, just the restaurant side. It was super comfortable, and Tara (our server) was the best!!! They had my wine, my strawberry salad with added grilled shrimp was perfect, hubs had the perfectly cooked and sauced pork chop (not overdone...and with an excellent sauce). The matcha pie was to die for (even for the hubs, who doesn't like desserts). The dining area is comfortable, not pretentious. If you are ever in the area, EAT HERE!!! Relax and enjoy! read more

See all

Was visiting State College for a wedding and did not want to go to a chain restaurant for dinner. Searched Yelp and found the Red Horse Tavern. Waitress was very friendly, food was delicious, and came out in a timely manner. After the three hour drive and missing lunch, we were a tad bit hungry. For starters, we shared steak chimichurri tacos, street corn, and fiery chili garlic shrimp. They were all delicious. Next, I had the Harvest Bowl, my daughter had the Pittsburgh Black and Blue salad, and my grandson had the Carribean jerk salmon. Portions were the perfect size, and prices were fair. With the credit card companies charging ridiculous service charges these days, they do list on your receipt, the cash price, and the credit price, which is standard practice. If I happen to take another trip back to State College, we will definitely visit again. It started to get busy after we were seated, so I would suggest reservations, especially if it's a PSU game day. read more

Red Horse Tavern - Small plates on top, entrees on bottom - American Near Me - Pleasant Gap, Pennsylvania

This place is hit or miss for me now. Sometimes I go and the food is good and fresh and sometimes it tastes old and microwaved. It's convenient to go to but I wouldn't recommend anyone go out of their way to go here. read more

Second time here and even better than the first time! I need a 6-star option! Quaint, great service and awesome food. Phenomenal tavern stew just spicy enough with the most tender fish, clam, mussels and shrimp with black lentils and andouille. Wow! Great chicken pot pie and homemade pretzel roll! BBQ ribs fall off the bone. This will be a regular spot. Make reservations! read more

See all

Great local spot with good vibes! Rachel provided excellent service and the food was delicious! read more

Red Horse Tavern - Harvest Bowl - American Near Me - Pleasant Gap, Pennsylvania

See all

The Red Horse Tavern was awesome! We were traveling from CT to Canton and decided to refuel at the Red Horse. We sat at the bar where everyone was so friendly. It's nice when the locals are welcoming! The food was great and so was the service. Highly recommend read more

Started off with Green Fried Tomatoes. Delicious. Goat cheese and strawberry jam added a nice touch and blended nicely. We had the classic burger and salmon blt. Both were cooked to perfection and again delicious. Would highly recommend this quaint little spot. read more

Always a great meal at the Red Horse... Our go to place in Pleasant Gap. A nice variety of menu options and appetizers...

We stopped here when bringing our children back from camp and needed a quick dinner option and we weren't in the mood for fast food! I found this place from YELP! Thank goodness! We were quickly seated, our server came and was more than accommodating and patiently recommended her favorites! We got the chef Charcuterie and empanadas as an app. So happy with our choices!The kids got chicken tenders/fries, my husband got a quinoa/steak bowl, and I got the frendh dip sandwich with a side of brussel sprouts. The portions were more than enough, the food was fresh, nicely plated, and the staff were all KIND! Of course we couldn't leave without having their Bannafle Pie! Bummed they ran out of peanut butter pie, so glad we found this little gem of a place in our travels! read more

See all

About twice a month I travel in to the Penn state area for work. I'm only there for a few hours and then back on the road towards home. Red Horse Tavern makes the trip worth it every time. The atmosphere and the staff are fantastic but the food is even better. Trust me and take the time for lunch one day soon. You will find yourself going back and back and back!!!! read more

Not much to look at, but the food and drinks exceeded expectations. Had a sample of appetizers, fried pickles, pretzel board and bacon wrapped shrimp over polenta. With new trails brew. zombies are people too pumpkin ale. You had me at zombies and ale . Not much of a parking lot that was the only nock on the place. Food service and prices were impressive. Definitely will be back! read more

Red Horse Tavern - Sign signs everywhere signs. - American Near Me - Pleasant Gap, Pennsylvania

See all

The Red Horse Tavern is a cozy little spot located close to Bellefonte and State College. We decided to try it out on a whim, sure glad we did! There's a separate bar area however we tried the dining room side. We were greeted and seated immediately. I tried the chicken pot pie and my husband had the piggy burger. Generous portions and both were delicious!! The service was amazing as well. We will definitely be back read more

The Red Horse was half full today at lunchtime. I tried the Old Fashioned Burger with rye bourbon aioli - it was awesome! Who needs Ketchup? Home made chips were a wonderful surprise. My lunch date had the Brisket Grilled Cheese and it was also delicious! Yes, we tasted each other's food. The wait staff was super friendly and made our meal even more special. Thank you! The new owners have added their own touches which have updated the Red Horse and we were seated by the wall of desserts. So we had to have some Pie! Ban-offee (I hope I got that right) Their Banana Toffee creation was gorgeous to look at and even better to eat. Pretzels on the whipped cream was a bit surprising, but it worked! Over the years we have tried meals here with many different owners... Now this is the Best Ever! read more

Food is very good and well presented! Cozy atmosphere. We love to chill out and have a nice dinner here. Highly recommend.

Awesome food! We especially love the chicken pot pie! The fried green tomatoes are unique and delicious with a tomato strawberry jam, balsamic drizzle and dotted with a couple of fresh strawberries in a bed of greens. One family member raved about the pork chop with served with diced sweet potatoes. The service was friendly and prompt and the restaurant is casual and comfortable. read more

Great informal restaurant with darned good cooking and delicious desserts. Good menu, perfectly executed. My pork chop was sublime. The grilled cheese with brisket might have benefitted from more meat. Salads perfect. Great service. Did I mention the pies? Oh my. read more

The food was delicious. There was no wait when we got there. Service.Was wonderful, and I cannot wait until my next meal at this local secret. read more

We were on a triad trip along I-80 and if you have done it cross state you know it's full of either fast food or Subway.... Red Horse is just off I-80 and had excellent reviews, especially recently as it's been taken over by new management. Don't let the name fool you. It's not a bar with food, it's a nice historic restaurant with a bar attached to it. We stopped for lunch and it was excellent - their fried greed tomatoes were excellent - included strawberries & cream. Wife had a great Reuben & I had a salmon with a unique mustard sauce that was delicious. The locals love the place, and if you are driving along 80 you don't have to go all the way to State College and find parking to find a good spot for a great meal! read more

We went here to celebrate our PSU grad but had a very disappointing experience. Sadly, the waitstaff is really bringing down what could've been a much better review. The fresh cut fries, burgers, salads, cooked veggies were very good!!!! But the server wasn't friendly, didn't come to get the drink order for a long time, messed up 2 of the orders, brought appetizer salads with the main meals and could've said something to the graduate sitting in her cap and gown. I understand this business is under new management.... The food is great, now hire front of the house staff to meet this higher bar. read more

I had lunch today at the Red Horse Tavern with a friend who's vegetarian, so we went meatless. I had the Eggplant Bruschetta, which was amazing! It's not really a bruschetta, but more of an opened face fried eggplant sandwich. It was the best eggplant sandwich I've ever had. My friend had the Harvest Bowl, and it was really great, as well! We were both considering the roasted butternut squash salad, which sounded great too. I'm sure there meat sandwiches and entrees are great. The service was very friendly and the decor was charming. I'm looking forward to going back. read more