I had originally given a low 1 star rating because the service didn't exist at the time I visited. However, I recently had dinner and drinks there and it may have been the best burger of my life (I got the Kobe burger with sweat potato fries). I don't usually over eat but I ate my entire meal and the service was very intuitive. I would recommend for sure, the food quality is 5 stars in my opinion, atmosphere was charming and service was attentive. read more

So we were seated at a table outside last night. We sat for 20 minutes and not one server came to our table to even say hello, much less bring us water. There were 5 servers outside and it wasn't an apparently busy time. What a shame that we had to walk out. Think twice before going here- at least have a backup plan. read more

This review is overdue, but we have been to Prime a few times and have had a consistent positive experience. The burgers are out of this world, and other food selections are good too (love the brussell sprout app). Great service, as we have only encountered the most welcoming and friendly people. It's a good crowd too, mixed with families, small gatherings of all ages. Great bar service too! read more

I have ordered kobe beef burger medium rare with lettuce and tomato and crispy onions on a side. The price for the burger about $ 25. It was a take out. I got overcooked, dry, not even close to Kobe beef burger without lettuce and tomato with a ring of raw blue onion on a side. After one bite it went in a garbage, on a top of loosing 25 bucks, I have stomach ache today as the result of that one bite. If you ordering a take out, do yourself a favor, and open the box and see what they packed. Very disappointed. Wanted to help a local business but no more. There is no excuse for food poisoning people. The bar was empty on Sunday night. If you cannot get an order to strait , you should not be in the business. I could order a burger for a fraction of the price and much better burger and more important closer to my home.Shame on you Prime Burger Bar for ripping off people. read more

Went last night. Was a little busy than I'd like given covid but they did have tables nicely spaced out and barriers which I appreciated. Our server was great. Super helpful and nice. Food we had was bomb. Our meal consisted of fried calamari, giant pretzel(they not kidding when they say giant, it feeds 4) burgers, yummy truffle fries, and the grilled chicken flatbread. All that food and my kids still had room for dessert which they spilt. Absolutely loved the purple rain margarita. If your a fan a coconut, this drink is a must. I'd definitely come back. read more

Make your own burger kind of place. It was decently cooked but didn't knock out of the park. Big menu so I look forward to trying other things next time. Honestly nothing to write home about but i have taken to yelp to document my restaurant visits It's a nice place to hang out as employees are nice and do not make you feel rushed to leave. Clean interior which is appreciated especially with COVID. Hopefully they keep it up! read more

This is truly a fantastic local spot to visit, mostly because of the friendly and attentive service of their employees. Specifically, Tatum has been one of the main reasons my friends and I keep coming back. I highly recommend coming down! read more

Had there Ribeye sandwich with col slaw, it was very good. I recommend this bar restaurant to everyone who's in the area.

This was my first experience at Prime Burger Bar and I can easily say this is some of the best service I have ever received while sitting at a bar. Tatum was one of the friendliest and most attentive/professional bartenders I've ever had! Looking forward to coming back for some great food, drinks, and even better company. -Jay read more

Perfect local spot! The service is marvelous & the menu is incredible. I recommend the warm lobster role with summer ale. For dessert a fancy sundae is a must. Will certainly be back numerous times. read more

Nice spot for a casual dinner. We sampled the Poutine and the Fried Sprouts. Burgers were yummy and all the ingredients were fresh. The brownie sundae was enormous and delish! We shared it between 4 of us and still couldn't finish it. Overall, a very good experience and I would definitely recommend you give this place a try! read more

Very loud. Lots of kids. Service not great. Food good. Fries taste weird. Ambiance tight tables , very loud.

Awesome tasting burger. I've been in search of a great burger where my travels take me around the country. I trust the Yelp community and this was no exception. If you want a great tasting well seasoned combination of meat between some buns try this place. You won't be disappointed!! read more

Tried to eat here but apparently everyone got there at the same time and after the hostess spend 10 minutes decided how she could see us at the 20 open tables inside and out it was going to be a 30 minute wait. Nope. Not going to stand there watching open tables for 30 minutes. No wonder why the restaurant business is failing. read more

Perfect burger. Juicy and delicious. Our "go to" place for burgers. Always a hit. The wait staff is exceptional . Courteous and friendly. Looking forward to trying one of the scrumptious , mountainous desserts. read more

Food isn't anything special here. I always think the fries have a weird oil taste. We were charged $1 more on everything we ordered versus what the menu price was and on top of that they charge a CC fee. Not worth arguing over a couple of dollars but also not worth coming back. read more

I think we found our replacement for all our regular burger places that closed from COVID! PERFECTLY cooked medium rare (worth the wait) huge burger on a luscious bun. My one complaint is that they doused it in sauce, but that's an easy fix in the future by asking for sauce on the side. Took a bit for service, but the bartender noticed and jumped on it. Comped us a beer for the trouble. Class act! Very excited to go here again. read more

The food is delicious and the service is good. Hefty portions and great variety!we have eaten here several times and we're never disappointed. read more

First time there today and we will be back! Delicious! I had the Kobe burger and could only eat 1/2 it was so big. read more

Ordered a couple warm lobster rolls, the feta watermelon salad and the classic poutine for delivery. The food here is a little pricey but the quality of food makes it worth it. I can't wait to try their burgers! read more

Food is pretty bland unfortunately. I heard such rave reviews and it was really just ok. I was let down by it. The service was good. Not sure if I'd bother returning. read more

Prime Burger Bar - Chicken sandwich - Burgers Near Me - Commack, New York

YUM! Had a lovely time trying out this spot. The servers were friendly, attentive and great with recommendations. They have a wide range on their menu, so everyone will be able to find something whether a snack with a drink or a full on burger. There are so many DELICIOUS apps from fried brussel sprouts (get them well done!) to PB&J wings! There are plenty of entrees including insane burgers, salads and mac n cheese. We tried the Buffalo Mac and were quite happy with the flavorful creamy dish! The actual burger patty in the steakhouse burger was absolutely delicious, they even mix steak into the blend! And don't forget to leave space fo dessert, they have DECKED out milkshakes, which is the perfect sweet treat to end the meal. Definetly would go back, just for that BOMB burger blend! read more

My wife and I took the family which included my son and his wife and their two sons. First, got to say, great hamburgers. You get to choose the meat. How neat is that? Plus, choose the rolls. The beer selection is great. Four of us had beers (free tastes,which I always appreciate). Our grandsons had chocolate milks and the waitress brought them, unasked, refills. Service was great. When my wife and I are back in town visiting the kids- we will be back. read more

Second time here at Prime Burger Bar. Staff was friendly and place was very clean. Had the TexMex Salad, which was awesome! Many flavors and textures! My new favorite! read more

Went there for lunch with my father. Service was great. Burgers were very good, a bit greasy. As with most food these days it was a bit expensive. Would go back again. read more

What a disaster! We waited an hour for food to arrive. We were told a manager would come over. No food. No manager. No thank you!! I have never experienced such poor service in my life. Why go here when there are a million burger places around? read more

I've had their Kobe burger several times during quarantine, via DoorDash. It is BY FAR the best burger of all the possible burgers in my ordering radius. Simple, meaty, well-cooked. Perfectly (lightly) seasoned...nothing to mask with over-seasoning. The meat speaks for itself. An entire meal even without a bun. The fries are fresh and hand-cut and delicious. The Bavarian pretzel is so big I can never even finish half of it because the burger fills me up so much. I look forward to trying other menu items, but for now I'll stick to what I know I can't go wrong with. read more

Food was good. Just got a plain grilled cheese nothing on it and it came with fries. The only thing that threw me off was that it came to $16 and change for a grilled cheese sandwich read more

Delicious burgers. Sooooo many options. The only reason it's not 5 stars is that the service can be suspect.

Tried this place multiple times. Want it to be good because Commack needs a good burger place. Temperature on the burgers are inconsistent. Sometimes good other times over done. If your going to name the place burger bar cooking to proper temperature shouldn't be an issue. Hopefully they can get this fixed. read more

We got two different burgers my wife had I and both were cooked to perfection. Medium and juicy as hell! The hand cut fries were also perfect. Not salty at all! We sat at the bar with a really great bartender nicole. She was kind, courteous and very knowledgeable about everything on the menu. Worth every Penny. read more

I have to say the food is delicious and we believe we are pretty snobby when it comes to burgers because we have tried so many places all over NY. We were happy to learn that same owners of NY burger bar are now near our part of town and although when we walked in there was a bit of wait and it seemed the hostess needed some help figuring things out (kinks when u first open) and when we were seated the waitress didn't see our table in the corner and we had to ask for her to come in (again opening kinks) but with the manager buying us a round (omg the ketucky bourbon ale is awesome) and the food being so delicious it was all worth the wait! We will be dining and hanging there again! read more

Tried Prime burger for the first time recently. Heard good things from a few ppl so we decided to give it a shot. Didn't have time to sit down so we did take out. A bunch of apps. The boneless bites were 8 embarrassing small pieces( almost like m&ms). Sliders were alright ( overcooked on one). The only positive was the pretzel. Won't be back. read more

Came here for my daughter's birthday and ordered five perfectly cooked burgers and delicious fries. Service was excellent, we will definitely be coming back read more

Prime Burger Bar - Perfectly cooked proprietary blend burger with crispy bacon and whipped goat cheese. Excellent service and delicious food - Burgers Near Me - Commack, New York

Really wanted to enjoy this place - Was so excited to see a new hot spot in town. First off, we ordered a flight of beer that 3 out of the 4 were watered down and the last good glass was broken. The beers i chose were beers i normally drink so i noticed the difference in taste immediately. The bacon on the burger was raw. The fries were the last of the batch, i don't even think i had a full fry in the mix. That being said, the bleu cheese was delicious and the overall burger was decent. Unfortunately wouldn't come back. read more

I was expecting a little more from this place I think but I did still enjoy it. The drinks were good and the food was pretty good. Not a big enough variety but it worked. I got the burger with pulled pork and the sweet potato fries with marshmallow dip which was really good. It is a place I'd go again but I'm not dying to go back anytime soon. read more

Food was very good but their tipping policy is ridiculous. Take care of your peops, dear owner and get them tips! Being able to use a gift card and or a credit card should be allowed without an additional charge to the customer. There is a cost to doing business and your staff shouldn't be paying the price. read more

Great food with outdoor seating and entertainment! Definitely recommend and the staff was so kind. Had the seasonal summer menu and I'm definitely going back for their year round menu, it was hard to decide what to get. I got the lobster grilled cheese with a lobster bisque and it was wonderful. read more

I had the Great South Bay burger. Amazing! My wife made her own burger. Everything was seasoned well and delicious. We love the garlic aioli that came with the fries, and so did our five year old son. We can't wait to order from here again! So good! read more

I had very high expectations for this place. It's always packed and reviews are great. I ordered the ultimate grilled cheese, my husband got the drunken goat burger. Neither were as advertised. Grilled cheese: "Tomato jam" was chopped tomatoes, "onion straws" were sauteed onions. Everything was smothered in brown gravy. Burger: not sure if it was the correct one as "candied bacon" was simply bacon, barely any goat cheese, and "cabernet sauce" was brown gravy. 2 stars bc my kids' kids meals were correct, the waitress was sweet, and the live music entertained my 3 yo. And...toilet seat completely broken in ladies bathroom. Sadly we won't be back. read more