This place is bigger than it looks inside. It's spacious and they have a beautiful fireplace. Food was decent, prices ok, leaning towards expensive for a diner and server was friendly. read more

Premier Diner - Fireplace - Diners Near Me - Commack, New York

This diner does get pretty busy, but the atmosphere is great. Not a lot of kids screaming. First things first, the coffee was good. Your standard coffee. I like the fact they have a person specifically to serve coffee to everybody that has a cup. The service was very good as well. The waitress Vikki did a great job. They're very quick to give you your food and water first. My friend had the bruschetta avocado toast. I had the avocado, cheddar, and tomato omelette with home fries. 1. The bruschetta avocado toast: They're too generous with the balsamic glaze. They need to lighten it up so you can enjoy the rest of the ingredients. Anything balsamic is typically a strong flavor as a small amount. The avocado, mozzarella and tomato are too heavy for the bread. They should try a more sturdy bread like sourdough to keep it up. The bread they currently use will just break apart. 2. My avocado, cheddar and tomato omelette w/ home fries: The home fries had some good flavor, but could've been better. The potatoes were cut like coins for the most part and I think that kills most of the home fries experience. Usually something like this is diced up to give an evenly crisp and cooked experience. All I really got was flimsy potato coins with some crisp here and there. Which led to the potatoes being soft and dull. It should've been pressed down onto more to give a more crisp flavor and texture. The omelette was pretty good. At certain points it seemed like the avocado was not ripe enough to cook with. It had a similar taste to steamed unseasoned broccoli, then at other portions of the omelette, it seems fine. The cheddar used lacked a bit taste. Overall, it was still good experience. The people are considerate and friendly. I also think they should bring the food out when it's a bit hotter. I'm not saying I need it to burn my mouth, but I don't want room temperature food that is slightly on the warm side. read more

I have gone several times, the food is always delicious (breakfast, lunch and dinner), the service is great and the ambiance is great because it has a modern , comfortable and fun feel. This diner never disappoints and is great at accommodating small and large groups. read more

Love a Long Island diner, but prices don't match the quality! My friends and I grabbed dinner at Premier on a Wednesday night. There was no wait and service was fast/efficient! The menu is expansive and has everything you could want! I ordered the Tomato Mozzarella Panini and Curly Fries. The fries were flavorful and crispy! The sandwich was mid -- the tomatoes were overly soggy and the cheese wasn't melted enough. For $21, I expected better. I did enjoy the side of pickles and coleslaw! read more

Premier Diner - Tomatoes & Fresh Mozzarella Panini - Diners Near Me - Commack, New York

Premier Diner has top-tier service, menu options, fresh ingredients, and modern decor. The prices are pretty steep, although the portions are large. I'd recommend splitting plates. All of the servers had a good sense of humor and welcoming attitude. The parking lot spots can feel limited at popular meal times but there is free 2-hour customer parking. The restaurant is ADA accessible. read more

See all

Went out shopping & was hungry so tried this local Diner in Commack. The staff were friendly, the food was good & the portions were huge! The place was packed but service was nice & fast. read more

Premier Diner - Exterior - Diners Near Me - Commack, New York

See all

Food is average and not that good. I ordered the French toast with scrambled eggs. The French toast was drenched in butter (not disclosed on the menu). In addition the French toast was burnt in my opinion. The eggs tasted like old hotel eggs. In addition I ordered a Turkey Bacon cheese omelette. The server did not writing our orders down but instead try to memorize it. When it arrived the omelette had Turkey and Regular bacon. In addition I asked for fries with the omelette but received potatoes hash. Service was very slow So we didn't even bother to say anything. The diner is clean but the menus were very dirty. read more

A great diner that I will definitely be coming back to. A lot of options to choose from. I ordered the Jack Daniel's burger and it was well cooked and delicious. Service was great and I loved how the place had retractable windows so you could be sitting inside but also out at the same time - a great touch. read more

Oh yea, nothing beats a Long Island diner. The menu is huge. They start you oit with a bowl of pickles and a bowl of coleslaw. We went with th burger deluxe plate. Fries were crisp, onion rings huge and a burger done perfectly medium rare. We really should try something else on the menu but can't live without the burger. read more

Our waiter, Nicos, was wonderful, friendly, attentive, and made the experience even better. The menu truly has everything and then some. Prices are slightly on the higher side, but it's completely justified because the portions are huge. The atmosphere is super cozy, the food comes out incredibly fast, and having a full liquor license is a major plus. The Irish coffee is absolutely to die for. I seriously wish we had a place like this in Florida! read more

Premier Diner - Meals/ FRONT Grilled Cheese w Fries - BACK Chicken Cordon Bleu Panini - Diners Near Me - Commack, New York

See all

Your typical Diner, its clean, plenty of seating, ( booths & Tables), plenty of room if you come with younger children, location is a plus, plenty of parking. Good if you want a quick breakfast or lunch and not in the mood for anything else.. Very attentive service, prices can range on the higher end but really nothing to complain about, they do have a huge menu. read more

I'm only being so critical because of the price. In no world should a mediocre diner burger and a sub-par salad cost 30+ dollars. The place was popping on Sunday afternoon, so I guess some people are willing to pay. I'll give them the classic diner atmosphere, but that's about it. Our waitress was a little detached/disdaining, but I genuinely don't judge because I would be too. Service was fast, but the food was undeniably disappointing. The salad was a deceivingly large mound of iceberg lettuce, and the balsamic dressing was just objectively bad. To add chicken was an additional 9.25; shrimp would've been an addition 16/17! Although the protein comes on a quite generous side plate to my surprise, the chicken was considerably greasy and chewy. The burgers/turkey burger seemed better, but not by a long shot. Overall, it's just hard for me to find a reason to support this place. read more

See all

There's nothing better than a classic diner! The vibes were just as you'd expect, with traditional booths. When we sat down at our table, they gave us a plate of beets... an interesting choice of appetizer, but I didn't hate it. They've got all the usuals here. I'd recommend sticking with burgers, sandwiches, or breakfast dishes, since those always seem to be solid. I got the corned beef sandwich and I was very happy with it! The side of coleslaw and pickles also hit the spot. I'd be more than happy to dine here again! read more

See all

Your typical local diner, nothing special but I'm sure it's the heart of many locals around. Decent food, nice waiters, nothing much to complain or commend about. Great for quick casual bites if you're around the area as an alternative to fast food but definitely not a place I'd doll up for. read more

Busy diner, great service and delicious food! I got the turkey burger with cheddar cheese with fries and it was fresh and very tasty! read more

Premier Diner - Turkey Burger Deluxe with Cheddar Cheese - Diners Near Me - Commack, New York

Most importantly, their bloody Mary is great. Just celery and a slice of lime, no bells and whistles necessary. The drink was solid and tasty. And it's a Thursday around 1:00pm and this place is PACKED! Business speaks for itself and anyplace this busy at an off time is doing something right. Take my comments with a grain of salt. The food was normal. Decent bacon, eggs cooked a perfect over medium, crispy toast. Definitely nothing to complain about, but nothing to rave about (other than the bloody Mary!). But the entertainment! It made my $45 breakfast worth it. The waitresses are a hoot! They kibbutz among one another about crazy customers and other staff. They say all the right server things, but with an attitude of resigned disdain. They carry searing hot plates stacked up their forearms, and put your plate down without any "it's hot" warning because they could stick their arms in a blast furnace and come out unscathed. If you go into the experience as though it's participatory dinner theater, it's a great show. If you are unable to suspend disbelief during your meal, I'm not sure you'll be happy with the service. Expensive, though. No any one item seemed outrageous, but the items seem structured to require ordering a side of something to get all of what you would get at a different restaurant for the one item price. That said, tip well and be safe. read more

Amazing food and Skylar, my server, was beyond exceptional. Special shout out to the owner who went out of his way to bend the menu and fix me exactly what I needed with my food allergies. Thano you read more

"Premier Diner" is more like a premier truckstop. Don't waste your money. I ordered a simple mushroom American cheese omelette with a side of sausage and french fries. What I got was reheated food. The french fries tasted stale and lukewarm, the sausage definitely look like it was microwaved, - the casing was wrinkly instead of tight and robust. The actual omelette itself was very good, along with the toast. Thought about returning the food or even just walking out when they served me the food, but I was too hungry after a 13-hour shift, so I ate what I could and left the rest behind. Absolutely the worst $30 I ever spent in a diner. Then I figured I would mention it to a manager upfront, but he did not say one word to me as I was paying the bill NOT. ONE. WORD. I most certainly will not go back to that truckstop. The only bonus: The service was fast and kind. I'd say I would come back just based on the service, but no one goes to a diner purely for the service. read more

We stopped in the other day for the first time and walked out. The prices are totally off the wall. $$31+ for an open face Sandwich? $21+ for chicken salad? Give me a break. We went to a diner in Woodbury and had prices more reasonable like $13 for a sandwich. read more

The French onion soup was beyond delicious and came out still sizzling!! So buyers beware to take your time not to burn yourself on that Oort gooey toasted cheese - it was not overly salty as I find most French onion soups can be. Recommend 100%. After that I tried a Greek salad which was plentiful With feta - bring on the cheese .. their homemade Greek dressing was what elevated this salad I ate every single piece of lettuce tomato cucumber and olive - it was delicious. I ordered the ginger salmon with was served with roasted sweet potato and pineapple with a ginger glaze - and opted to have it with rice and a mashed turnip. The rice was good and had a bit of peas and veggies in it elevating it a bit. The turnips were prepared with cinnamon to make it sweet and very reminiscent of the holidays - but the best part of the meal was the salmon itself. Cooked to perfection and a very generous portion I took about half or more Home with me. Just enough to save room for Oreo cake I chose for dessert. It was very good but very sweet as your could imagine - I also boxed up half of the cake as their pastries are all made in house and MASSIVE. I always saw premier diner being very busy whenever I passed by and I'm glad I took the time to see what the buzz was all about it was a step above any old diner and really packed a punch when it came to the food, taste - and portion size. There was quite a few dishes in the menu that I couldn't find online so keep In mind there's more than just sandwiches and breakfast foods. Their specials were plentiful and could cater to anyone's cravings be it fish chicken pork beef pasta or classic authentic Greek. Stop by premier diner and you don't be disappointed! read more

See all

I have been coming here since I was a baby with my grandma and cousins. I absolutely love this diner. Food is good and so is service.

This place was really good. We got seated very fast even though it's busy there's a lot of seating. In the photo I had the western omelette with whole wheat toast and home fries was very good very filling brought some food home. We also had The challah French toast with egg sausage and home fries. definitely will be coming back! read more

Premier Diner - Diners Near Me - Commack, New York

We left without eating! After getting a blessing of " You are Cancer Free and Cured'" My wife and I were looking to celebrate at the diner which is conveniently located next store to MSK'S Commack facility. The Premiet Diner was packed, it was prime dinner hour and we were seated and after a brief waiting period, the waiter ( who never smiled) took our drink order and basically never returned? Actually he did bring our beverages over to us after about a ten minute wait and as he seemed totally preoccupied with the larger party directly across from us, he threw us a bunch of straws when we flagged him down as he hurriedly took our dinner order, but we had a couple if questions regarding same, he said he would inquire and basically, never returned! A beautiful diner with high prices and management that doesn't seem to care too much when we voiced our displeasure about a waiter who couldn't care less..never again! read more

The Premier Diner is the premier diner! See what I did there? We absolutely love coming here for dinner - it's been around forever, and so have many of the staff, and you can really feel it. They treat everyone like regulars and I always feel like I'm sitting down for a big family meal together with all of the other customers. I love that they serve a chick pea salad as a starter instead of bread - this gluten free babe loves legumes! Best things on the menu: Burgers, chicken fingers, beef barley soup, dessert. Some of the big chicken entrees are great too. Don't order: the salads. They need to improve their salad game. The Mexican salad was OK, but the chef salad was an insult to chef salads everywhere. Like a big slab of rolled up meat on top of a sad bed of iceberg. I could barely eat it. No one really goes to diners for salads, so I'll take the L on ordering it at all - but sometimes you just want a salad to go along with the delicious masterpiece that is the beef barley soup, y'know? I'll keep going to this place forever even if they don't fix their salad issues. It's the feeling of the place, the service, the honest-to-goodness diner vibes. I just love it. Don't miss out. read more

Premier Diner is my favorite! Great location, huge menu, food is good, staff is nice, but their prices have gotten so outrageous whether you eat breakfast, lunch or dinner. It's pure greed! Sadly, we can't afford to come here anymore! read more

Still the best diner in the area. Stand by the front desk for ten minutes and you'll get a snapshot of just how many regulars this diner has, and surely it's no surprise by the level of service and number of options. They did a nice job with the recent renovation of the inside, replete with a small expansion into the parking lot and windowed garage doors that swing open on pleasant evenings so one whole side of the building can enjoy dining alfresco. The rest of this review is a love letter to beef barley, the Saturday soup du jour. Beef barley is the moon to my stars and the best soup I've ever had. When with family on Saturday's, it's our anchor meal--we come in just for the beef barley. When ladled from the bottom, a bowl has big chunks of beef with a really thick and flavorful broth. I'd only ask for (1) less onions, (2) making it a daily option (since it's better than chicken noodle), and (3) another bowl. Lots of solid options at this diner. Please bring back the wiggle cake and refresh your salad options! read more

Premier Diner - More beef barley Soup Du Jour - Diners Near Me - Commack, New York

See all

What I like is that you get seated quickly and the wait staff is great. Food is typical diner fare however the price tag is is far from what you'd expect in a diner. I'd like to say the price you pay is worth it, but there's nothing special about the experience that I can feel good about paying close to 50% more than any other local diner. read more

By far one of the most expensive menus I've ever seen and I understand diners are charging more these days, but this place has some set of b*lls. For example, they charged $25 for an avocado BLT with fries. The food isn't even that good. Go somewhere else-- your stomach and wallet will thank you. read more

This diner is another one of my go-to diners whenever I'm in the area. You always know what to expect with great quality food, and the service is always excellent. Very enjoyable experience, and you can't go wrong with ordering breakfast. read more

My sister lives in Commack and I have driven past this diner for the last 13 years and never went in , and the last few months I have been here multiple times for breakfast. Wow ... what a great place . The meals are massive , the staff is so friendly, the seating is more then comfortable and the food is definitely great . I would recommend this place to anyone for breakfast!!! They have a huge parking lot with plenty of spaces . During COVID in the summer they have a huge tent outside which is great to eat under . Go and eat there you will not be disappointed. read more

Premier Diner - Menu - Diners Near Me - Commack, New York

I've only been to one or two other diners on Long Island so it's premature for me to call the Premier Diner the best. But I can certainly say that we had a great time here and a terrific meal. Thank you to my friend Art P. who chose it for our meet up. Busy at lunchtime on a weekend, there was a hostess taking names and organizing who was next. Tables didn't sit dirty for long after guests departed before they were turned over and a new party was ready to be sat down. We were warmly greeted (even though our party wasn't complete!) and drinks were fetched. It was a short wait. The menu is huge with everything served all day. You want pancakes for lunch? Burgers? Spaghetti? It's all there. But I still chose the classic diner meal: a sliced turkey club sandwich. It arrived quickly. No skimping here, this is a lot of food. One very large sandwich with a thick pile of turkey, lettuce, tomato and bacon. Quartered and then buried under french fries. The turkey was a little dry, so mayo was provided. As well, I requested onion rings instead of fries, so our waitress went and got the rings. Other than these two small bumps, perfect. Not cheap by any means, but a big portion so there's some value here. The restaurant was packed, busy and not quiet. But despite every table being filled, it wasn't loud and it wasn't rowdy. It was fun, friendly and delicious. This place is a classic New York diner. [Review 15110 overall, 612 of 2021, number 184 in New York.] read more

See all

Well the fries where ok they where burned and grill cheese I would say I come back ever once in a while too read more

My husband and I went last night for dinner. He ordered a burger which was almost raw when he bit into it. Waiter offered to get him a new burger. He comes back with the same burger recooked with my husband's bite marks in it. We were horrified. That is poor food handling and made me wonder what other bad food handling practices they do. We will never be back. read more

Bacon was a pile of grease stuck together horrible did not eat it home fries was somewhat eatable, staff not that friendly

Food was amazing ... best salad ever, the service was fast and friendly. Everything was hot and ready fast.

Best breakfast on Long Island! Consistently! Best pancakes hands down. I love their Santorini omelette. Great burgers and salads too read more

Premier Diner is a pretty solid Long Island Diner, we've been coming here for years. Right off the L.I.E, it's a home run hit for everyone. Spending a day with my sister in law and her family, we have plenty of mouths to feed. It's late and no one feels like cooking. Someone screams lets go to "The Diner"! Off we go to Premier Diner. This diner is perfect because my little niece can order pancakes on a Sunday night, the kids order hamburgers and I can order Souvlaki that's cooked so perfect it would make my Greek Granny proud. Lotsa harsh reviews, they're opened all hours and the food is pretty good. Come on down and try it for yourself! read more

Food was awful. Two Jack Daniel's chicken sandwiches both dry and overcooked. Cheese was barely melted. Chicken parmigiana hero - chicken had that weird, rubbery texture. Burger asked for medium rare. It was well done and like eating a hockey puck. Fried chicken was greasy and not even crispy and the Caesar salad had lettuce that was brown around the edges. Fries soggy. BLT had one strip of bacon and food was barely lukewarm. Service was terrible. Older woman with dark hair. Asked three times for waters to be refilled. Waitress never refilled. Never checked to see if we needed anything. Charges us for an extra $25 meal we didn't order. Food is outrageously overpriced. Went to pay up front the guy took the check and money, handed me my change, with no thank you or how was everything. It's loud and too bright and bathroom was dirty. Never again. read more

Another delicious luncheon and a great return after this Covid blah blah. My wife head the spinach greek salad, I ordered the gyro deluxe....so excited, I didn't take pics, sorry. Carla our waitress was excited to have customers and showed great appreciation. Her service was excellent! read more

Premier Diner - The outdoor dining area, very nice - Diners Near Me - Commack, New York

The burger was mushy and disgusting. The service was slow and the prices are very expensive.