A group of us were enjoying drinks at nearby brewery's but needed something substantial... we found this great place. Walked in and immediately were seated. Server was friendly and took our drink order. I went with a shipyard draft IPA. Great tasting g beer. Had to order pizza here, I went with their build your own pie. You pick, size, dough, cheese , sauce and toppings. Small Beer 3 cheese Red Pepperoni Pizza was amazing, hot perfectly cooked read more

See all

I went stopped by to have some wings and a beer at the bar. I was delighted to find out that Miller High life is only $2 which may be the cheapest beer in Biddeford. I was the only one at the bar and there were about 4 tables. It did take a bit for the wings to come out, However there seemed to be tons of to go orders. The wings were very fresh and crispy. But $16 seemed like a lot for 10 wings. read more

Portland Pie - Honey BBQ Wings - Pizza Near Me - Biddeford, Maine

They have a good variety of beers both local and national. I had their mushroom and goat cheese pizza. Plenty of goat cheese, but the mushrooms got lost. Hubby had the brisket chili and it was really good. It came with what looked like 2 orders of tortilla chips. A few days later, we had a large pepperoni with fresh mozzarella and basil. I have found my new pizza love!! Huge pieces of pepperoni, slabs of mozzarella and delicious chunky red sauce. I will definitely be ordering that again! Four stars because of the mushroom pizza - pepperoni was 5 stars. read more

It was our first time there. We ordered the Burnt mountain pizza, Eastport pizza, Acadia sandwich, and brisket chili. All the food was excellent! The service was very attentive. The atmosphere was conducive for conversation. The establishment was very clean and comfortable. Overall, a great experience!! Definitely give them a visit. read more

This was my second time coming here and I can say a lot has changed. We went when there was about two or three other parties and service were still slow. The food was decent as you can see in the picture they burnt the bread crumbs. Sad. read more

Portland Pie - 10" Nor'Easter Buffalo Pizza, Cape Neddick 'Roni Mozzarella Baked Macaroni and Cheese - Pizza Near Me - Biddeford, Maine

Saw the bad reviews after we got here and have to say, that was not representative of our experience. We were greeted with smiles and our server, Gianna, was an absolute gem. She hustled, paid attention to small details (like remembering to add a line in my drink refill), and was very friendly. We tried the Parmesan Garlic wings and they were slightly over sauced - though that might be just a preference thing on our part. The pies were decently done, while not the absolute best, omg I would die if I didn't have it, pie - they have some creative offerings that were tasty and well prepared. The cook on the crust was perfection. So we'll done enough to warrant another trip in on those nights when I just do not want to cook. read more

See all

Ordered a pizza with beer dough yesterday. Had ordered a few weeks ago and was craving the same pizza! Unfortunately it was totally different. The crust was definitely pre-made. Prior pizza had totally different, definitely fresh, chewy, perfectly cooked crust! Very disappointed. Pizza was certainly edible but not up to par. On another note the Orchard salad and German pretzel were great! No more pizza at Portland Pie for me. read more

Worst pizza in the state. Had a pie from here once and never again. You're better off with frozen grocery store or Costco pizza.

Driver left on ground outside the door, never received text order was here and the driver never rang the doorbell. Food is now cold as it's 49 degrees outside. read more

If I could give it 0 stars, I would. We typically order from Ottos, but wanted to try Portland Pie just to change things up. What a bad idea. First, we ordered delivery at 4:53pm and it wasn't delivered until over TWO HOURS later! Second, the order was missing items (my kids vegetables and toppings for my pizza). Lastly, no apology. No explanation. The driver just made a joke and left. This place need some help. Not what it used to be. read more

Good pizza in Maine is hard to come, especially since I'm from CT and am very biased towards New Haven pizza but Portland Pie gets my seal of approval! I've been here a few times but finally am getting around to writing a review. The cheesy bread is an absolute must to get. I also really love their mashed potato pizza. You can also choose what flavor dough to get as well which I think is really unique. The garlic is my personal flavor. You honestly can't go wrong with any of their specialty pizzas. read more

Portland Pie - Margherita pizza - Pizza Near Me - Biddeford, Maine

Excellent pizza. Friendly bartender but didn't care for the steak sandwich. My bread was burnt. read more

Portland Pie - Shipyard Pumpkin Ale on draft. Yum. - Pizza Near Me - Biddeford, Maine

Food is very good and service is great, one thing rubbed me the wrong way, I had Diet Pepsi and asked for a refill then got the bill and was charged for 2 Diet Pepsi into a big deal but give me a heads up read more

Stopped by for drinks and apps. We had the Nachos and artichoke dip shared between 3 people. Plenty of food so we did not get an entree or pizza. Pizza nearby looked great. Our appetizers were very good. Only one server who waited on all tables near bar area and also bartended. It was busy. Not sure why this restaurant did not have more people on a Friday? He worked his butt off and was very friendly so that made up for the slower service we received. I will return to try the pizza. In the meantime, I recommend a visit if you are in the area! read more

See all

We purposely looked for a restaurant outside of the high priced options in Kennebunkport and landed on The Portland Pie Company. We sat at the bar and were immediately greeted by Kelsey. She has a nice energy and a knack for playing off the various patron personalities. My husband had the Downeast on a brioche bun with their chips. He was a happy camper. I had the Quinoa & Chicken salad served over a healthy bed of greens. I got the balsamic dressing on the side and didn't need it. The salad was fantastic. I wolfed it all down. read more

Okay for Maine pizza. Was made quick and good for pizza craving but not as great quality. Overall okay

If your bad review has to do with lack of staff, you should probably look around and realize it's a problem everywhere. They often have people covering the bar that aren't even allowed to pour beers because they're not of age and will grab a manager to do that... this is where we're at. That being said, you do need to know what's good here and what's bad. Salads - usually mediocre and not a good bet. As a wing fan, I also find theirs terrible, but last I checked they bake everything, no fryer. The pizza, some of the sandwiches, and even the burger are not bad at all. I appreciate that despite the lack of staff, they do their best to stay open afternoon hours. More than once I've tried to meet a friend at the brewery next door, but they aren't open yet, and we pop into Portland Pie instead and it's cool, the beer is fresh, the staff is friendly, and there's usually a game on. That's all I need! read more

horrible food, horrible service, not at the fault of the bartender but way under stafffed. I sat at the bar and barely got any service because management thinks it's a good idea for one bartender to take care of the bar and full bar area (ten tables) including food service. the bar tender did the best she possibly could have, she was sweet and professional but inevitably had to be everywhere at the same time which means no one got great service. management needs to step up and realize this will not help anyone. this leads to getting cold appetizers after waiting for almost 30 minutes and walking out before you order dinner. please reorganize and support your staff. read more

Ordered from here today since we work in the building. The Thai Chili Cauliflower sounded great! It was anything but great. It was soggy, burnt and gross. There was a huge pile of what appears to be burn breading in the corner of the take out container as well as all through the bottom. I assume they tossed this in the sauce and put the entire tinfoil maybe in the oven. Will never try this again. read more

Portland Pie - Thai Chili Cauliflower - Pizza Near Me - Biddeford, Maine

We went tonight and waited an hour and a half at our seats for no food to be delivered to our table. At this point we'd had it and walked out. I had to ask for water (again) after half an hour! Our table was so sticky everything stuck to it including my phone. I understand there's a shortage of help, but better organization is definitely needed at this restaurant. read more

Mixed thoughts. Warning! avoid delivery. Every time we have ordered delivery, it was a huge issue. Last night for example - ordered a steak salad and a sandwich at 830pm. We were told 45-60 mins for delivery. By 10 (when they close) still no order. I called and I was told they were short staffed and somehow, the order wasnt completed properly. They said they would "refire" the order and send out. I will say, the 2 employees I dealt with were very accommodating (Phil and Riley) and tried to make us happy, it was just another disappointment. $15 for a steak salad that was very pathetic (see photo). There was barely any steak, it was dry and over cooked as well as mostly gristle. The sandwich (Peaks Island) was soggy. It had obviously been sitting for a while...anyway, just another bad delivery service and the food wasnt even up to par, considering we had other good experiences with take-out and dine-in. On a precious delivery, the driver went to the wrong house and left. When we did finally get our order, the plastic wrapping was left on the pepperoni. So we had a pizza with melted plastic. Not great. They did comp it (as they should have) and delivered a plastic-free pie. Some positives-the beet salad is really good and there are several specialty pizzas we have liked. But it's been hit or miss some days. So we definitely wont make Portland Pie and choice in Biddeford any longer read more

Portland Pie - Pizza Near Me - Biddeford, Maine

See all

Very good gluten free calzone and the summer strawberry salad was amazing. Very friendly staff.

New to Biddeford! My boyfriend and I were craving pizza & I wanted to try out Portland Pie for my first time! It wasn't busy & we sat in the bar area. Kelsey waited on us & was our bartender this afternoon. She took a few minutes to get to us, however she was finishing up with a large party- so as a server myself (I get it). Her service was efficient & I like her taste. She was knowledgeable about the menu /drinks, and honest. We shared a Caesar salad in house & ordered pizzas to go. The salad took awhile to come out & wasn't hearty as I hoped. Was delicious- just wish there was more! Our pizzas were tasty! We ordered the Pawtuckaway 14" pizza & a margarita 16" pizza (they were both $22.99, Was told additional toppings are $2.25 each -for reference). Overall we got what we were craving & I'm excited to explore more of the menu. In the future I'd like to see more disclosure on pricing & when it's not busy - more efficient cook times! Apparently they also have a pretty sweet rewards program that I can't wait to benefit from! read more

Portland Pie - Pawtuckaway 14" pizza $22.99 - Pizza Near Me - Biddeford, Maine

See all

I called the Biddeford location to place a large pizza order for a visiting college team. The manager was very nice and extremely helpful. He took my payment via phone and arranged for the pizza to be delivered to the field where the team was playing. The pizza arrived right on time and everyone commented on how good it was. Very pleased with the whole experience! read more

Mid pandemic review time! Wife and I were in town for a short day, and opted for Portland Pie for lunch. We ordered 2 calzones to go. Service was pleasant, even though they were clearly understaffed (like everyone else!) The calzones were good. Not great, but solid. I think my only complaint is that they were very wet, and not cut at all. We didn't have utensils, and these were decidedly unwieldy to eat by hand. For me, half the point of a calzones is that it should not require a fork and knife. It's hand pizza, like how a British pastie is intended to be a hand held meat pie. Overall, I'll give Portland Pie a solid 4 stars. Decent enough, but with a little room for improvement. We'll try them again post-pandemic and see if it gets better! read more

Don't waste your money. Delivery was almost an hour late. The driver did not have the salad we ordered. He said he would bring it soon. Never showed up! Tried to call but they're not answering their phone. This place is terrible! I would give it zero stars but I had to pick one.., read more

Portland Pie is a staple I always come back to (I always recommend the Great Diamond pizza), but service wise (at the Biddo location) I will ALWAYS give the people who work here the benefit of the doubt. Every time we go, they seem super understaffed, but they still get shit done. If you're dining in, patience is key. The waitresses are always kind, but it has always taken some time for orders to be taken and food to come out. However, the food never disappoints. read more

Three year Yelp Elite reviewer here. If that means anything at all, consider yourself lucky to be trying Portland Pie. First, look at my profile picture. The first observation you'll make is that I like to eat - and it's solely due to my insatiable desire for pizza. I've had it all: New York Style, Chicago Style, Frozen, and all the other crappy styles in between. Portland Pie just blows away every other pizza. I liken their pizza to good sex. It's hot, moist, good any time of day, great the day after, and satisfying with every bite. But instead of getting pregnant, you'll get a big belly if you do it to often. In all seriousness, they have a great selection of creative pizza (including a design your own, if you want something straightforward), salads, and beer. Great atmosphere and a good time guaranteed. Pro Tip: parking is limited. Try using the free parking lot across the street. read more

Portland Pie - Menu Page 1 - Pizza Near Me - Biddeford, Maine

See all

Good pizza, try the Puckaway, outstanding! usually very good draft beer selections: Lunch, Swish, Substance, etc.

Absolutely love this place. I am originally from NY so sometimes it's hard to find pizza I like around here. I love to get the mashed potato pizza or Buffalo chicken pizza! Those are the best! read more

It started off fine with the host and server, this was a not a busy night when we came. Two other tables got sat after us, and we waited for about 35 minutes after our appetizer. During that 35 minutes, they were able to make three pizzas for one table & two pasta dishes for another table. THEN they were able to make a whole other pizza to correct someone else's pizza, before they brought out ours. We ended up getting our pizza to go, and left unhappy with our first experience. (Edit: Oh and they made our pizza wrong too!) read more

Ordered Large Cheese Pie. Was told be ready in 30 min. 45 min still not ready. Folks who ordered after me already got their order. Sorry but this is unfair. And this has to be managed more professionally Most likely not coming back read more

They cancelled our order 45 minutes after it was supposed to be delivered. Would not recommend.

We ordered pizza to-go one night during our vacation and this place did not disappoint! We are from New York, but unlike most New Yorkers who prefer the traditional NY style pizza, I LOVE pan pizza and this was some of the best I've ever had. The 3 cheese blend was phenomenal but so was the fresh mozz! We got 7 personal pizzas: bacon breakfast, veggie, pepperoni, Buffalo, cheese, sausage peppers and onions, Margherita + pepperoni and sausage. All of them were fantastic and perfect sized for one person or two depending on hunger level & desire to have leftovers. We ordered online which was very simple and easy and the food was ready when it said it would be! read more

I love pizza. Like, a little too much. Our family does pizza every Friday night and has for the past ten years. It's a thing for us. We missed our normal Friday night pizza so we decided to try a sit down place Saturday for lunch. The pizza here is very good. I love all the options, I love the specialty pizzas, there were a lot of unique food options. We got a seasonal pizza, BBQ Brisket and a half cheese half pepperoni (kids, that's a staple order). The BBQ Brisket pizza was good, but man the Brisket was not that good. It was very dry and lacked flavor. I have lived in the South for years, that is not how Brisket is done. However, the crust was awesome (we got beer crust for both pizzas). Our roasted brussel sprouts with garlic cream sauce was super good and one of my kids ate them, willingly, and loved them. So that's a win. Our waiter was not the most attentive. I was not very impressed with our service. I do not like getting to a point where I'm wondering where the waiter has gone. I am not picky, and am generally patient but that was definitely frustrating. The pizza was fantastic, the service was ehhh but I know we will try it again. I'll update as we continue to go. read more

I had ordered take-out a couple nights ago, and was unhappy with a couple things. I wrote a review about my experience. The owner then contacted me directly, and made it right. That means more to me than one off night the restaurant may have been having. Portland Pie Co. really care about there customers. The food is great too! read more

I've given a great review in the past but I honestly don't know what happened to this location in the last year. I decided to order delivery for the first time since I suffer from long term COVID, and getting out is hard/exhausting to do. I ordered my usual which is the arugula with 3 types of mushroom and goat cheese. I sat waiting with my phone for the call to tell me it's downstairs, or even a curtesy door bell ring. I had waited quite a while and still nothing. I get a text message from my neighbor downstairs who had come home from work, saying there was pizza left on the BOTTOM stair in front of the building. Her husband graciously brought it up for me but all the food was cold and the cheese was hardened by this time. WHY wasn't there a call or doorbell ring? In the past when I've ordered delivery, I received a call stating they're downstairs. Nothing this time. Do yourself a favor...order for pickup because delivery is lazy and has no care. read more

Portland Pie - Cauliflower crust pizza with arugula, vegan cheese, mushrooms, goat cheese and balsamic drizzle - Pizza Near Me - Biddeford, Maine

Rude staff that set unrealistic expectations. Put in a phone order, since the online app blows and they know our address and HOW MUCH WE ORDER FROM THEM, then asked about the status of our order. The girl that answered the phone was the rudest person I've ever dealt with in the service industry will never buy food from people that can't manage their employees not to mention having mediocre food. read more

Crickets...unsurprisingly haven't heard a peep. I stand by my earlier comments. Good luck Yelpers!

I have been to the Scarborough Portland Pie a couple of times and had a completely different experience. In Scarborough, the service is great and the food seems to be at another level to what we got in Biddeford. The pizza had barely ANY toppings on it and the service was so slow. There was hardly anyone dining in and they didn't have many people coming to pick up orders. There was no explanation for what was causing the delay. I asked if they were short staffed and the hostess said they weren't. The waitress we had was friendly but she was not around to offer refills, get us cutlery that was never placed on our table, to collect our check, etc. Overall we were really disappointed and won't be back. I couldn't recommend it, either. I hope something changes so the area doesn't lose what could perhaps be a great place. read more