As someone who is very picky when it comes to her pizza, Pontillo's is my favorite place in Cortland! Their pizza is always good, and my family and I are also fans of their fried cauliflower, onion petals, fries, and mozzarella sticks. The price is usually pretty reasonable, but there are definitely some things that are a bit pricier than I'd like to pay. Their staff is also usually pretty nice. I've never sat to eat, but there is plenty of space. It seems like it would be a charming place to grab a bite if you have time, but they are always punctual when we are getting food to go. read more

Meatball Ricottaroni was delicious & hearty. Pizza Crust was so good & crunchy. I ate all my crust. Not sure if I ever did before! The Pizza tastes fresh & homemade. The meatballs were crumbled & was full of flavor. I will definitely be ordering the fried Cauliflower. The breading was crunchy and the cauliflower was cooked to perfection. They have a really nice helpful staff. Oh yeah... even the Ranch was one of my favorites read more

Pontillo's Pizzeria - Meatball Ricottaroni; Mozzarella cheese, Meatball Ricotta cheese and Pepperoni Large - Pizza Near Me - Cortland, New York

See all

Chicken and veal parmesan dinners are great, as are the meatballs. We think the wings are the best in the area, and are certainly the biggest. We've always received friendly and competent table service when dining in and nice people on the phone when calling for delivery. The pizza is either very good-to-great, or burned or needing more sauce and toppings, so we've found that it's best to eat in than roll the dice on delivery. Friday fish special is great, and burgers are very good. We live close by, so it's a great place to be on a cold winter night, and is our go-to for meeting friends for dinner. read more

Great food of all choices a typical Italian restaurant with great service and reasonable prices. Small but a nice restaurant for lunch pr dinner, me personally I love the pizza . read more

Clean establishment staff is kind of rude price for a 6 " sub is completely outrageous 12$ not acceptable for skimpy meat proportions. Not definitely not recommend or returning read more

Over-priced and the woman who owns it and the store next to it is extremely difficult and rude...such a shame...used to love this place

As always the food sucked and the staff worse, I have been a customer of Pontillo's since 1987 When Ron Constatino ran it and yes, he ran a great establishment . and now ever since Pim is hardly there the place sucks. Jeff is joke too busy ripping folks off with that idiotic store next door. I usually call for pick-ups and the first thing the workers do is want you to tip them...FOR A PICK-UP. anyway I finally had it with this no-account shit show. Hollywood or Brix from now on oh yeah maybe you should get a (manager) with higher than a 5th grade education!! Farewell Pontillo's read more

Order a cheese pizza and an order of medium heat well done wings and it was very good. Their subs are very good as well

Order the wings. I have never left a review before, but this place should be #1 on the Yelp list of best wings in the county. read more

I had my meal delivered to my home. Delivery time was quick, and driver very courteous. I ordered the Buffalo chicken salad which I've had in the restaurant when I've dined in. Disappointed with my delivery. Large salad with mostly iceberg lettuce and tons of tomatoes. I counted the pieces of chicken..6 sliced up pieces! So much pepperoni it should be renamed pepperoni salad! Won't order again for delivery read more

The chicken sub arrived soaked in ranch. Could not eat. No wing sauce. The portofino roll was soaked in grease. Called about the sub and was told I had to bring it back to get a refund. I offered to email a photo and they accepted. I'm not sure if I will actually get a refund. Either way I am never going back. read more

Stop here once in awhile , should stop more. Always very clean and food and service is top notch. Big parking lot give it a try ! read more

See all

Good, good local joint. Friendly service plus tasty pizza and sandwiches. What no to like?

my family goes to pontillos a lot and we enjoy a lot off the menu. we tried ordering for delivery for a pizza, fries, and a hot sub. After an hour and a half for delivery without prior warning, all our food was stone cold. Don't order food for delivery. read more

Came and dined in because I was wanting some chicken parmigiana and it just so happened that they have it for the Thursday special. For $11.25 you get Chicken Parmigiana, salad, garlic knots and pasta. It came out hot and was excellent in flavor and portion. Instead of a typical dessert, I finished the meal off with a slice of cheese pizza which was excellent. Will definitely be back before I leave town in a couple weeks. Service was excellent and this while being very busy with takeout portion of the restaurant at 4:30. read more

If you order anything extra (specifically chicken) for an outrageous price, plan on being ripped off every single time. You'll never see extra, ever but be charged through the roof for it! Entirety of their Italian menu is jar sauce garbage with small serving sizes. They even screw up basic salads. Best bet - pizza and wings. Only. Get your drinks much cheaper, literally, anywhere else. read more

Pretty good pizza, not my favorite, but still yummy. Their garlic pizza was a little dry but the pepperoni with red sauce was really good. I love that they have a convenient order online option. Plus they are one of the few options in Cortland on a Monday. Their service is always quick and kind, and the building looks great! read more

Parking right off the street, quick service, delicious pizza. Good experience. Will be back on our next visit to the area.

I have been there a few times. I stopped by on Tuesday the 29th. I ordered the portifino loaded and 10 wings with Yorba sauce. The service there was excellent and very friendly. The Yorba (bbq garlic) was very good. Nice and tasty. The portifino was new for me. Loved it thank you love this place read more

I'm in town for a night and thought I'd order pizza from a local joint instead of supporting the pizza hut or domino's franchise so I decided to call up this place, and ordered a Medium Pizza with Pepperoni and Mushrooms. The pizza was tasteless! it's like they forgot to put tomato sauce on it! It was sloppily made and lacked tomato sauce, if this was a "special" pizza then I've totally missed the point. Stick with Domino's or Pizza Hut while you're in town. -Uploaded a photo "lacking tomato sauce" for reference. read more

Pontillo's Pizzeria - lacking the tomato sauce - Pizza Near Me - Cortland, New York

Have ordered takeout for 20 yrs after the remodel it has taken a turn for the worse . Every order in the last 9 months were either not what they say a lot of things left out . Usually they would give a credit . Lately in the last 2 months the person taking the order has it wrong and you don't know until delivery . Then as your setting up dinner you realize the order is completely wrong I called told them they said they would make it right send pizza back waited 45 min brought the right one and the onions and peppers just thrown on uncooked . Horrible food they want to make you feel like you messed up and argue when food is horrible . Too bad used to be great read more

It has been a while since I have ordered from Pontillo's, but I used to order from there at least 3 times a month. I moved from downtown Cortland out towards Homer, so I have been getting pizza and wings for other places. I decided that I wanted to get a pizza and wings from there Friday night. I called about 4:15 and placed an order for a large pizza - pepperoni, mushrooms, and hot peppers and 20 wings - 1/2 medium, 1/2 hot. I asked that the order be ready for pick up at 5:30 and they said no problem. I get there at 4:28 wings are done, pizza is still in the oven. I pay for everything and they say they will bring the pizza to the car when it is done. Pizza doesn't make it out to the car until close to 5:40. Drive home, open the box and look at the pizza and you can tell something is not right. Most of the toppings slid to one side on the pizza, and it is shiny. I took a spoon and gently redistributed the cheese and topping and came up with a spoon full of grease. I understand there will be some grease on a pizza, especially from pepperoni, but this was a whole spoon full, and there was lots more. One bite of the pizza and the grease was not the only problem. The crust tasted stale. It wasn't chewy or hard, it was like flavorless, charred cardboard. This is a pizza I used to love and eat all the time and was looking forward to getting. Such a massive disappointment. The wings were no better. My kids ate the medium ones, my wife and I ate a few of the hot wings. They were over cooked - not extra crispy to make sure they were done - over cooked and dried out, and sauced with a hot sauce that only had heat, there was no actual flavor to it. read more

This is my go to local restaurant with friends or family. I highly recommend the wings, the large antipasto (serves 4) and especially their made to order homemade pizza. Portions are generous and daily specials include all u can eat pasta and a bountiful veal parm. The service is friendly and very accommodating. read more

The wings here are HORRID. I ordered a large order of garlic wings and they were horrible. The wings were rubbery and raw. I couldn't even take a second bite. The bone is dark so you can tell they're frozen. Wouldn't ever recommend the chicken wings to anyone, YOU WILL GET SICK. Pizza is half decent, Brix is better if you're looking for pizza in Cortland. Lucky to get 2 stars. However, the customer service is A1. read more

Stopped for a quick slice and soda at lunch. Friendly staff and great pizza(CBR)! Would def go back!!

They've always had the best wings in town in my opinion. The pizza is always good and I'm rarely disappointed. It's a Cortland landmark.

Just to be fair, I'm tight on giving out stars. Also, I'm picky on my Italian food. That being said, bear in mind that this could be more like a 3.5 to 4 if reviewed by anyone else. This place is good value and welcoming for students and families. Food is decent but not top notch for what it is. Portions are big for what they charge -- especially their dinner specials. One thing to note: their veal is NOT cutlet. I think that is something the staff has to learn to tell their customers when asked. I should've mentioned at the time but I didn't want to insult the nice server. My fault! read more

The orders are always messed up. Instead of being able to order food as you like they tell you what comes on the food and act put out when you ask for customized order. This used to be one of the best establishments in the area to get quality food from. The food is much less then satisfactory and the employees are equally as bad. I don't know if they're deaf or just plain stupid. Then when it's all said and done and you get home, your missing items you ordered and paid for!!!! Worst place in town!!!! Cortland has a desperate need for fine dining with excellent service! read more

First of all I called for a delivery because I only live right around the block usually it takes max 20 mins to get here this time I only ordered Mozzarella sticks and they told me " about a hour and a half " really? Are you guys being serious then I asked for a extra side or marinara sauce and she said " you should've said something sooner because I already did the order" with a attitude. Never ordering from here again and tell me how "8.99" for mozzarella sticks turns out to be $15? No way the tax is that much I didn't even give a tip either nor does it cost any money to deliver I hope this makes you guys so somewhere else because this is disgusting. And then they got here and there wasn't even any sauce!! Lmao this is ridiculous read more

Ordered pizza and garlic knots from here tonight. Called to place the order and I asked how many garlic knots were in their appetizer, the woman on the phone said 5, but we received 4 old and dry garlic knots. Missing one, they had no flavor at all, no moisture to them, and were so hard and chewy we figured they were at least a day or more old, not fresh. The pizza was so dense (in a bad way) and the cheese on the pizza tasted fake and the amount of grease on the pizza was very unappetizing. Overall, really disappointing quality of food going out to customers during a time like this when ordering out is a privilege many people aren't getting right now. read more

Pontillo's Pizzeria - Greasy pizza (yes it has pepperoni but I've never seen a pepperoni pizza with THIS much grease) - Pizza Near Me - Cortland, New York

See all

I'm not sure what is happening to this place, but it has gone down hill so fast. We ordered delivery the other night, food took an hour and 20 minutes to be delivered and everything was cold...and I mean COLD. We called and were simply told "sorry, by whoever answered the phone. We have had several bad experiences in the last year and that was it for us. Jeff and Brian have really lost control of their establishment. So sad. They went from one of the best to probably one of the worst in Cortland. read more

Okay food, worst service ever. Staff are all incompetent and rude. My order of a cheeseburger and fries TO ACROSS THE STREET took over an hour to arrive. Called twice to ask about when it would be here and the staff were incredibly rude and sarcastic. Will not be giving them my service in the future. read more

Complete garbage. Pizza sucks, the only thing good is the chicken Parmesan.Dont waste your time, just go to rexs pasta

Food and service was good. Homemade Italian dressing and sauce! Wings were hot and delicious!

In a word....horrible I ordered stuffed shells and there was very little cheese in them. The pasta was undercooked and the sauce tasted worse than canned sauce. I was extremely disappointed and would have had a better meal if I bought canned pasta. Do yourself a favor and go to the Hollywood restaurant and if your doing delivery go for Pudgies. They don't have pasta but their food is good read more

I expect more from dinner service. We often order pizza for delivery and it's pretty good. However the rest of the food leaves something to be desired. The garlic knots were hard as a rock- I think the other food could be a bit better. We'll still get pizza delivered though. read more

Pontillo's Pizzeria - Stuffed shells - Pizza Near Me - Cortland, New York

See all

Pizza was good! But it was the hot wings that caught my attention. Coming from Buffalo, I have to say their wings is something. The sauce was what's expected but their control on the cooking are worth mention. It's not just crispy on the outside, but juicy in the inside. The crispness of the wings you would expect inside to be dry but no. Great job. read more

Ordered subs from there tonight and they were not good at all. Turkey sub order was completely wrong. Chicken finger sub had no lettuce no cheese. Roll was soggy and disgusting. The hot sub that was supposed to be sausage parm and the sausage was overcooked and chewy to eat. Too much sauce that made the roll soggy and disgusting, Very disappointed and will not be returning. The person taking my order over the phone constantly repeated that my phone was "beeping" out and my order was not right. Used to enjoy getting pizza and subs from here but as of late have been very disappointed!! So sad Pontillo's!! read more

Rude experience, went in for two slices and the cook complains and acts like I'm ordering 40 whole pizzas. Puts the slices in the oven for 2 seconds and slaps them face down in the box. I recommend any other place in Cortland for pizza, even little Caesars for a quality slice and some good service. To rate it like El presidente "One bite everyone knows the rules...4.3". read more

I ordered a medium buffalo chicken pie... they served us a cheese pie with buffalo sauce on it...... it had not one bit of chicken on it. I believe that they think buffalo chicken pizza consists of chicken wing dip smeared over a piece of dough. Go to spedinis or a pizza more instead save your money. Order anything but pizza if you come here. read more

Pontillo's Pizzeria - Buffalo chicken pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cortland, New York