Got a large meat lovers pizza, and it was hearty and delicious! It had plenty of toppings and was definitely filling. We also picked up a dozen wings, which came with a large side of blue cheese. From calling in and placing our order to picking it up, the customer service was amazing. We only waited about 15 minutes, and everything was hot, fresh, and delicious! Also the restaurant was clean and in an easy to access location. We were visiting from out of town and would 100% come back the next time we're in town! Highly recommend! read more

Solid NY Pizza. You know it's good pizza when the plain cheese pizza is better than what is normally available. Grabbed a pie on our way into town and was so happy we did. It's a small place with some tables to sit down. When I called the order in they were really considerate to make sure it was hot and fresh when we picked it up. read more

This is an amazing staff with exceptional food! I was greeted as soon as I walked in the door! I received the absolute best customer service from start to finish! Super clean restroom! You can watch them make your meal with the open kitchen view from multiple tables inside the restaurant. This is the locally owned and operated restaurant that I enjoy supporting! read more

See all

My family and I wanted some good New York pizza while visiting Ithaca. We chose well by choosing Sal's Pizzeria on Fulton. The pizza was delicious. The staff were friendly. read more

Sal's Pizzeria - 12" Meat lovers pizza - Pizza Near Me - Ithaca, New York

The service was amazing and the food is the best we have had in Ithaca over the last 2 weeks. We had 6 kids with us and the service and food the kids had also was amazing. Thank you so much for a wonderful dinner read more

Great pies, lowkey spot. Maybe 5-7 tables and cold beer on tap. Parking available too. This is one of those hole in the wall spots that has an incredibly good pizza. They offer delivery so support local. 10/10 - will be back! read more

Sal's Pizzeria - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Ithaca, New York

See all

This friendly pizza place was a stop on my way home. The staff were attentive and kind, everything I look for in a local restaurant. I ordered a large veggie pizza which was packed with tasty sauce, cheese and, of course, veggies! The only reason I gave it 3 stars is because of the price. Over $31 for the pizza only and that was the cash discount! read more

Sal's pizza, pasta, and deserts are the best!!! Always drive from Tucson AZ to get this incredible food ! Sal"s team is MVP , Super Bowl, and Stanley cup winners in our books! Highly recommend you visit!!! read more

I came here two times now, and plan on stopping by again. Good pizzeria considering the location, it is in Ithaca of course. First time I got a chicken parm hero, and second time I got the lasagna. The hero was probably the best I've had in Ithaca. They use Ithaca Bakery bread which makes all the difference! The lasagna was a bit bland on the meat, but as you can see the cheese is definitely there. Small sized pizzeria, with about a dozen tables. Nevertheless, it feels satisfying. The staff are really great, they check-in on you, refill water, and, in my case, bring more sauce. read more

Sal's Pizzeria - Homemade Lasagna - Pizza Near Me - Ithaca, New York

See all

This is one of my favorite fast food restaurants! The food is fresh and delicious! The owners and workers are very friendly and respectful to their customers. I highly recommend Sal's Pizzeria! The hot wings are the best around here! My family from Florida wanted to just buy the sauce to take back with them! read more

Sal's was the place to go to have a great meal back in the 70&80 on North meadow Street it was a fantastic pizza and home cooked meals sorry but today the quality is not there the pizza is so thin everything slides off and the toppings are very few and the prices have gotten ridiculous I miss sal read more

A solid pizza from a long established pizza restaurant in Ithaca. We placed an order for a large with 1/2 cheese and 1/2 sausage. The red sauce and crust where good. The side with cheese was chewy and had a good flavor. The side with sausage in my opinion was a bit sparse. In addition to the few pieces of sausage it had a powdery cheese type substance sprinkled across the top. I can't say if it added to it or not. It was ok. We were hungry and it satisfied our hunger. With other options in Ithaca I would choose another pizza option. read more

Sals has been an Ithaca favorite for as long as I've known. My old employer loved getting Sals every year. Fast forward to 2024 - I ordered a small cheese pizza for my spouse, it was great. I also ordered boneless garbage wings and they literally made her physically sick. Incase anyone wants to research me, I have never discarded a wing in my life, and these "wings" made me sick to my stomach a day later. I also ordered traditional wings, and you can see by the picture, these are ugly AF! Is this the result of new ownership? Please, let me know. read more

Sal's Pizzeria - chicken wings in sauce - Pizza Near Me - Ithaca, New York

No place fancy but the meatball parm was great ! The service excellent. I would go again if in Ithaca.

Clean, friendly spot with good homemade food. Right across from Agway on your way to Weggies. Stop by and visit the original Roma pizza ovens! read more

Sal's Pizzeria - Cheese slice - Pizza Near Me - Ithaca, New York

Great Pizza. The slices aren't even but great place. The service is nice with the great cooks. read more

By far some of the worst pizza I have had. The mozzarella was probably the worst quality and had a bizarre consistency. The pizza itself was greasy with absolutely no flavor, and pricy for what you get. The picture shows the glop of food you get for $24. Inside of the restaurante is pretty disgusting as well. Also the inside has no menu and subpar costumer service. Not a stop if you are in Ithaca! read more

Sal's Pizzeria - Sal 's Special - Pizza Near Me - Ithaca, New York

This place has their shit squared away. While other restaurants are slammed because they can't handle even a quarter of their restaurant filled, Sal's cranks out high quality food quickly. They serve some decent beers and the staff is amazing. No sitting around while confused staff members argue over which table they don't have to wait on, or orders lost because of bumbling. Food comes out piping hot because they have a real oven. Not like the average restaurant nowadays that uses an Easy bake oven powered by a 40 watt lightbulb which is why it takes and hour and half to cook the food and comes to your table luke warm at best. If you are in the area check this place out and you won't be disappointed. read more

Got to go pizza. Solids pie. Crust cooked great a long with a great tasting sauce. Great service. read more

Sal's Pizzeria - Slice - Pizza Near Me - Ithaca, New York

Our favorite thick-crust style pizza in Ithaca. Ithaca does not truly have the quality of pizza you'll find in New York City or New Jersey. But we're generally happy enough with this pizza compared to most local options. Once our pizza wasn't quite done and the cheese slid around on the crust in the car (we finished it in our oven). I showed a photo to them on next visit and they gave a small discount on our next order. While not such a big issue, they have actually never once cut the pizza into anything resembling equal sized slices, which is a source of mild amusement for us every time we order. read more

Definitely a go to place for me when I am craving pizza and chicken wings! I love their chicken wing pizza with their signature "garbage" sauce! All I can say is ahhh-mazing! you should give this pizza place a try and you won't regret it! read more

Best pizza and wings in town. I also recommend the chicken parm, Greek salad and antipasto

The food is always great and everyone that works there is friendly and outgoing! Our favorite pizza and Italian specialty dinners in Ithaca! read more

Top notch ! From the service to the food . Do not sleep on Sals I recommend the wings: mild garlic parm , cheese bread and the pizza Thank me later read more

Solid pizza white or red, good smattering of toppings, and one of the few places that would deliver out to us. Order the wings well done, better for travel that way. read more

Delicious pizza, and well priced too! I'd be willing to drive back from Buffalo just for the pizza! read more

Sal's Pizzeria - CNY has the best pizza, after NYC - Pizza Near Me - Ithaca, New York

Stopped by this afternoon for a slice. Always delicious and so nice to be served so sweetly with smiles to go with hot pizza fresh from the oven. I love this place and the people who keep it so enjoyable. Friendly, relaxed no rush atmosphere! My companion who is new to ithaca was very impressed. read more

Highly recommend the pizza joint. Veggie Pizza was amazing with mushroom substituted by pineapple. It was spectacular. Well done Pesto pizza with Jalapeños, green pepper and onion was outstanding. Best I have every had. The place is clean. The helper who took care of us was very accommodating with our needs and last minute request placed after the order. Orange cream drink is something new I tried and enjoyed it. read more

In town for a basketball game and wanted to try a local place. Pizza was excellent. Big slices! Service was good as well.

Horrible experience owner way very rude under cooked pizza save your time and go someplace Else read more

Sal's is easily the best pizza place in Ithaca and it's not even close. The service is always quick and friendly. The pizza is always fresh, the cheese always beautifully melted, and the dough/sauce/cheese ratio always perfect. This house only orders pizza from Sal's. read more

This place is awesome! Great real NY style pizza, the best in Ithaca! There is a medical mask clinic, sewing masks for the local hospital, and these guys donated lunch 2 days a week for the duration! Really generous and I'm sure much appreciated. Whenever I'm in Ithaca this is my pizza of choice!!!!!!!!! read more

Delicious. Recommended by Hotel staff were we staying for the night and delivered to hotel. Yummy lasagna French bread and salad. Large portions and shareable for two. Michael and Jackie Eastern Shore Virginia read more

Honestly I want to give this place more stars because their pizza just looked about as close as I was gonna get to Jersey in Ithaca and it didn't even taste half bad. The flavors were all there but I just can't explain what it was about the crust. It was chewy. Like really tough to bite into. You wound up taking half the cheese with you on the first bite just fighting to break the dough. Ugh. So disappointed. Onto the next pizza joint. read more

Sal's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Ithaca, New York

Great little pizza place with delicious, cheesy, pizza. My girlfriend and I came here and immediately felt at home. We ordered at the counter but our food was delivered straight to our table, and our server checked up on us while we were eating. Pleasantly surprised by such nice, caring service. The food was also delicious--piping hot Hawaiian pizza served in a timely fashion and delicious, classic buffalo wings. Definitely one of my favorite pizza spots in Ithaca. read more

Ordered Antipasto with italian dressing, which should be olive oil and herbs and spices. Instead the italian dressing was that horrible cheap chemical stuff that you find at the salad bar of a chineese buffet. I put my finger in the dressing and my finger indent remained after i removed it. A good home made italian dressing is part of the signature of an italian restaurant, not a cost cutting opportunity. read more

On vacation in Ithaca and spent at least 45 minutes looking at menus and reading reviews before settling in Sal's. We tried the Sal's Special and were very disappointed. It was a very bland pizza and had the most unflavorful sauce I've ever had. The only positive of the pizza was it's crust, which had a great texture and was nice and chewy. The crust earned them the second star. There are times when you have a pizza that you aren't too happy with, but think you'd give them another try someday. That is not the case for this joint. Once was enough. read more

Best pizza in town right now. The women doing the cooking are an Impressive team.Great

I like it here, and I'd go back. It has the feel of a true family place. The slices weren't huge, but they were served nice and hot. Lots of cheese, and relatively high-quality ingredients. $2.75 for a cheese slice. They have beer on tap, which is a nice feature for a pizza place. read more

Since I ordered on the phone, this is a review of their delivery, not the restaurant itself. I was in the mood for pizza but had a fair amount of work to do so I decided to go for a delivery instead. There are a few places within walking distance of where I live but the reviews aren't great and I figured I could get those any time, like when I'm walking home from class. So I decided to call for a delivery from this place. I went for one of their specials, a large pizza and an order of chicken wings. Of course, I didn't intend to eat it all in one sitting, but with all the homework and football this weekend, I figured I could spread it out over several meals. The pizza ended up lasting me for five meals. Call it disgusting, but I'm a lazy grad student who didn't feel like going grocery shopping this weekend. You do get a little tired of pizza after the third one, but at least the pizza quality didn't go down with microwaving. Chicken wings were pretty tasty. I actually enjoyed them a bit more than the pizza. But I didn't get a lot of blue cheese with it and you run low by the last few wings, and to be honest they weren't that big. As for the pizza, the cheese and sauce were great and there was a good amount of both. However, I wasn't a fan of the crust, which was really tough to chew despite being delivered fresh. They said they would deliver within half an hour, but it ended up being closer to 45 minutes. Not sure if it was because the driver had difficulty finding parking near my area or if it just took them that long to get my order together. Decent pizza overall but I think next time I'll just step outside and get a pizza slice nearby instead of just ordering a crapload all at once. read more