We had dinner last night here, for a friend's birthday. They were very accommodating, and let us change our reservation time to an hour earlier than what we expected. The ambience was that of a typical hibachi restaurant. We were sat almost instantly at a hibachi grill, with two other people. The staff were over pretty quickly, and took our drink orders. I would say, our hibachi chef wasn't the most extravagant. He did the usual things you would expect, but he wasn't very talkative, and didn't get us really engaged. The food was really good though. I got the hibachi steak and chicken with the vegetables and double fried rice. Getting double rice, gave a boatload of rice. Both the chicken and steak were cooked well, and had good flavor to them. I really liked the vegetables, because they weren't cooked too much, and still had a crunch to them. I also ordered a Philadelphia roll, which was presented really well, and tasted very fresh. Definitely will be coming back here in the future for dinner! read more

Disappointing in too many ways. Mule drink tasted bad and little liquor. Soup was mediocre, salad mostly iceberg with questionable dressing. Fried rice no better than supermarket. Beef and chicken seemed to have flavor but not very tender. Veggies sat on the grill the longest but very crunchy and not very hot. Disappointing and all about the chef's show. read more

I went with family on a Tuesday night for hibachi, to me, it seemed quite busy. I'd suggest reservations no matter what size your party is. We were seated quickly at our time. My sister asked for a specific chef, the hostess told us they don't take requests but "they'd try their best." They did not try. Just say he wi not be available at the time of your reservation so we can manage our expectations. Our chef was fine. He did some tricks but otherwise was not very engaging, other chefs definitely put on more of a show. I had chicken and it seemed a little bit tough, not very juicy but I ate all of it, luckily there was sauce to dip it in because it needed it. Our server was okay. I understand things need to be timed, she was not overly friendly at all. We all ordered drinks she did come by and ask if we needed more drinks, my brother was ready for another but my sister and I were working on ours and we would have ordered another but we were mostly through our dinner before we saw her again and by that time we had waited so long it wasn't worth it. Our waters were never refilled. There's not a huge dessert selection but that was never offered to us. The chef we would have liked to have had was cooking for the other half of the table right before we were leaving. He was so funny. Those people got a much better experienced than we did. Of course I'll be back but I won't expect a super fun experience with fantastic food. I'll manage my expectations. read more

See all

So sad with this experience! Wanted to love it here, but service was SO lacking. Our server came over 15 min after we were seated, and didn't come back until bringing the check. My husband did not get the correct order, and it just was not a great experience. read more

We had such a great dining experience. Had a reservation at 7pm for a party of 8 to celebrate my friend's birthday. Our table was ready and we were seated promptly. Highly recommend Chef Freddy, he elevated our dining experience and had a great sense of humor! The food was delicious! Not one complaint from our party. Our other server was very attentive and she kept the drinks coming. Hibachi is such a unique experience. read more

See all

Didn't get chef for 40 minutes and was very annoying and pissed me off super bad. Never coming here again read more

Plum Garden - Japanese Near Me - Pittsford, New York

Confusing menu, couldn't order exactly what we wanted, long wait and the server was wearing plastic gloves the entire 1.5 hours we were there and they were filthy. Not worth the money, nearly $80 for what you see here read more

Plum Garden - Japanese Near Me - Pittsford, New York

Came in with a party of 8 for a 6:00 reservation took about 5 minutes to sits us down. No big deal took Our orders very quick and then the waiting game started order drinks and food all at once and did not see our drinks till we said something about it 20 minutes drinks finally showed up. Then almost another 15 minutes and still no person cooking. We finally get up to leave and all Of the sudden now he is about to walk in walked out the door at close to 7 read more

Went to celebrate a birthday AND anniversary. Made reservations the day prior for 6:30 for hibachi. We didn't get seated until 7:20! Apologies from the young hostess, but no offer of a drink while we waited or anything. Turns out they are short on hibachi chefs. Well then don't take so many reservations. The chef was great and very entertaining. The food was just okay. Not as good as previous visits. At $25-$38/meal it should be better than okay. Especially when you're tacking on 18% automatically for gratuity and not honoring the reservation time. Sadly that'll be our last visit. read more

Freddy was great! He had some great jokes and definitely made mine and my girlfriends night. What a great guy! Food was awesome!

Very disappointing experience. This was a first experience for our grand children and it was not as expected. Poor service, waiting on tables all around while we could not even get water. Our chef did not do any of the tricks the other chefs were doing, but what I found most disturbing was he was using the spatula to put grime down a chute and then using the same spatula on our food preparing it. He got the spatula right up to the kids mouths for the rice balls and did not do any egg tricks. He didn't even have a chef hat in he had a baseball cap. The chef sneezed and turned away as he did wiped his nose on his sleeve and continues to prepare our food. The meals were not served together. First steak was served to my son and he ordered filet mignon an up charge. When I pointed it out that the other woman got my sons steak he simply said oh sorry. The scallops and lobster were last to be served by then my rice was cold. Terrible service, and not a good experience. read more

First time at this location for hibachi. Came on a weekend early dinner hours so it wasn't that busy. They sat us right away and we were even able to do hibachi with just two people, it was nice but I do recommend with more people. Fun to see others reactions during the cooking show. We had a great chef who was talkative and funny, gave us extra food it seemed cause he did forget an item at the end but included it after we started eating. Food was very flavorful and I had left overs a few times. read more

Food is always consistently well made. Hibachi chefs are fun to watch. Some funnier than others, but always a good time.

We went to Plum Garden to celebrate our daughter's birthday and were a party of five. Our reservation was at 7pm and we were seated fairly promptly. We had an incredible evening and both the service and food were fantastic! I had the Sukiaki Steak Dinner, a thinner cut of steak served with soup, salad, rice and vegetables. 2 people in our party had the chicken, the others.. shrimp and steak. Everything was tremendous and we had plenty left to enjoy the next day. I would definitely recommend dining here if you find yourself in the Pittsford area and craving delicious Japanese Cuisine. read more

See all

We have been going to Plum Garden since the kids were babies and my son turned 30 today and asked to go for his birthday dinner. It's been about 10 years since we've been, but have gotten take out fried rice over the years. It was fun and food was great, as we all remembered. Service was attentive and our chef was entertaining, engaging and cooked us a great meal. One of our memories was having enough to have leftovers for lunch the next day, and the portions did not disappoint. Everyone had leftovers! Well done Plum Garden. We won't wait so long next time. read more

See all

Stopped in the other night with some friends for dinner after work. We went for the Hibachi experience which was fun, scary, and delicious, lol. There is a regular seating area too, where you can just order off the menu, fyi. The cook was entertaining, and very experienced. I was a little nervous with the hot fire, and the knives moving so fast, but was great. We had shrimp, chicken, and steak with vegetables, all were fresh, hot and delicious, oh and the fried rice was phenomenal! Was a little pricey, but well worth the experience, and I took home leftovers and some sushi to go, will definitely be back. read more

See all

Enjoyed a lovely post-spa dinner last night at Plum Garden! I had been a number of times before for birthdays and celebrations, and this review is only for hibachi as I have never tried their sushi (mainly because I've heard it's....um...just not very good.) Thing 1: the chefs here are inconsistent in terms of entertainment value. The chef at the table next to us was super outgoing and fun, whereas our chef was 100000% miserable throughout the meal. Doesn't make a huge difference to me since I'm in it for the grub, but if a first timers experience was with this chef they would probably assess the hibachi experience as hella lame. Not even an onion volcano?! Come on man! The food is always perfectly fine and filled with butter and served with haste. Their ginger dressing is my absolute least favorite of all the Japanese places in town as it is the most watery. I tend to go with the hibachi chicken but you can't really go wrong with any of the proteins as they are mass prepared on the reg and super consistent. Overall a finer place to enjoy hibachi and a fun moment with family! read more

Always like it here , been going for generations now! Special place !!!!!!!!! Celebrated an important event here , nice ice breaker read more

Great time having lunch on a weekday. Good serving based on the price. Big serving. Accomodating service. Big space. Pittsford Plaza parking space. Clean and good spacing. We ordered Shumai,Tempura appetizer, japanese soda,green tea, buckwheat noodle soup, chicken teryaki bento. Looks like big sashimi and sushi bar, teppanyaki style on the other area. Playing oriental music for good ambience. Arigato gozaimasu! read more

See all

This was our first time back to Plum Garden in 20 years! The staff was pleasant and the chef that served us was wonderful. He entertained, while serving up a great meal for us. Portions were more than generous- with lots of leftovers, which lasted us a few days. It was certainly an experience and a bit pricey, so it might be a special occasion kind of place for us in the future. We enjoyed it! read more

Plum Garden - a plate of food on a table - Japanese Near Me - Pittsford, New York

See all

My friend and I went here for lunch and the experience was great. Our service was very well paced, the food was great and the prices were reasonable. 10/10 read more

Good food and service! Make a reservation in advance for big parties. We were a table of 9 and had a reservation for 7:00 pm on a Saturday so it was pretty busy. We only waited 15 minutes for the table. We got drinks right away and the chef joined us about 10 minutes later. Portions were fantastic and we got soup and salad to start. Steak and shrimp were excellent. The fried rice was great! They accommodated our 2 Gluten Free people by making all the dishes with GF soy sauce , which made our folks feel included in the meal and you couldn't taste any difference. The only down side was that we brought an ice cream cake for my daughter's birthday from Wegmans and the waitress put the cake on the table with some paper plates, plastic forks and a steak knife. for us to serve ourselves. I understood it fine- we didn't buy their dessert, so why should they serve us outside food? I get it. But then the check came - they added the gratuity to the bill, which again, is acceptable for a large party, but when I gave her my credit card, she came back with the check and it had an ADDITIONAL gratuity suggested where you add the total to sign. I already was paying the included gratuity, but if I wasn't paying attention, I would have added an additional 18% to the total ON TOP of the included gratuity I was automatically charged'. I was pissed! I mean, if she can out and served our birthday cake, maybe I would give her an extra $10. But on a $350 bill, she got a $56 tip and wanted more than $60 on top???? I would eat here again, but READ THE BILL before signing!!!! read more

We went to Plum Garden for a Friday night dinner, since they are now offering the option to dine-in. Given the recent lift on Covid dining restrictions, I was surprised that it wasn't very busy at all. We opted out of doing the whole hibachi experience and got a booth in the dinning room. The service was prompt, all of the staff was very friendly, and they were diligent with the Covid guidelines (masks, shields, plexiglass, hand sanitizer, etc...). We ordered some edamame as an appetizer and I got a hot tea to drink. For our entrees, I ordered a couple of sushi rolls (The Miami Beach Roll and the Philadelphia Roll) and my date ordered the chicken hibachi dinner. The edamame was good and exactly what we were looking for, not sure how you could screw up edamame anyways. I really enjoyed both of the rolls that I ordered, especially the Miami Beach Roll. The seafood was fresh and there was a lot of flavor in both. The chicken hibachi left us with both positive and negative takeaways. The soup and salad were very standard with other hibachi restaurants and we enjoyed them both. The negative was that the chicken wasn't super flavorful and I think it was slightly over cooked. The rice on the other hand was the best part of the dish and was very very flavorful. Not to mention they gave enough chicken and rice for about 3 meals. Overall it was a great night out and I will be back. The only negatives were that the chicken wasn't the best and for the quality of food, price was a little on the high side. With that being said, there were some great flavors in the other items, the staff was excellent, and the portions were extremely generous. read more

Plum Garden - Chicken Hibachi (Top), Edamame (Middle), and Miami Beach Roll + Philadelphia Roll (Bottom) - Japanese Near Me - Pittsford, New York

Very fresh sushi & sashimi with generous portions. we stop in here every chance we get. I've not had the hibachi but expect it to also be top class. read more

I had lunch with a friend at Plum Garden yesterday. Neither of us had eaten there in a few years, but both remembered it as a good restaurant. Our experience was quite the opposite. The waitress came to take our order, never gave us napkins or chopsticks, delivered the food and never returned to the table except to leave the bill. The food was cold, tasteless and unappealing. We had to find someone to pay at the register. They were not busy. There was only one other table with customers during the time we were there. We will never go there again and would not recommend this restaurant. read more

Wife and I both had filet mignon, was awesome. Best hibachi table in Rochester area, eat here about once a month

The service and our experience here was very bad. After waiting for an hour we continued to sit at our table with other guests as our station sat empty without a chef. Then we all got to witness the table that sat a half hour after us cheer as their chef came out. We canceled our order and left after that. My child was very hungry and we didn't want to wait any longer. We left to eat else where, therefore I cannot review the food. I will try a different Hibachi restaurant next time. read more

Seated right away. Excellent service. My hubs and I started with a local IPA beer and a house white wine. Our meal started with salad and miso soup - best we have had at any local Japanese restaurant Our appetizer was the shumai (shrimp dumpling/ 6 pieces) - excellent flavor & texture. Then we ordered sushi tempura for 2 with shrimp. Stunning presentation, plentiful & delish! Hot tip: Order "Spicy Mayo" on the side! Happy anniversary to us read more

Plum Garden - Sushi Tempura for 2 with shrimp - Japanese Near Me - Pittsford, New York

Going downhill..! Been going for the past 10 years. There was hardly anyone in the restaurant & very few workers . Appeared to be debris on the hibachi grill. The food tasted ok but 3 out of 5 of us were sick later on. Not great at all. Not sure what is up . Ugh . read more

Overall meh experience at a premium price. The atmosphere and service were good but nothing to write home about. Of the several dishes we tried I can honestly say that the food was average at best. Specifically, the tofu was chewy and unappetizing and the tempura was at best okay... Considering the very high price for lunch and mediocre quality I doubt we will be returning... However, it wasn't so horrible that I would dissuade anyone from giving it a try. Your tastes may be different than ours. read more

If I could have given a negative rating I would but here is the 1 undeserving star. Waitress was rude! Food was beyond horrible. I think the broth came from a dirty toilet or old sink water. When I told the waitress the soup was horrible I still had to pay for it...half of it. I refused to order anything else. My husband had the steak that he said tasted old and later that night he had an upset stomach. Please do not eat here. read more

This is my family's favorite hibachi restaurant. We believe their rice has the most flavor compared to other similar restaurants. We also love their mustard and ginger dipping sauces. Also the salad and soup are delicious additions to the meal. The chef is always fun and talented. The only negative is that you will leave smelling like food from the cooking but it's worth it. read more

If I could give a ZERO stars I would. One of the worst dining experiences I have ever had. Service was beyond terrible and they seemed to be running around like chickens with their heads cut off. We made a reservation for 7:00. Waited for over an hour before they finally sat us.Their excuse was that EVERYONE had a reservation at the same exact time. WOULD NOT RECOMMEND unless you have a whole day to waste. read more

My daughter has a holiday birthday so on the 23rd we are hibachi dinner for 18 as the whole family is in town! It's always fun and the chefs make it a great time! We end of with two chefs back to back so a little lag between meals for safety but we get a great show twice! I have the chicken and shrimp and my husband the filet and scallops. The fish is fresh and meat cooked perfectly - my dad likes it very rare - so a true test if his is right! We have attended just our family and it's fun to meet other people at the table. read more

This restaurant was awful. I truly don't want to hurt it, but I don't remember the last time I had such a terrible meal. This was my first visit, and a friend invited me because she remembered it as being a lovely restaurant. The server who waited on us was extremely negative, hurried us along, although there were only a couple of tables in the entire place taken, and didn't stay nearby long enough to explain a single thing on the menu. The restaurant could use a renovation, it has a very negative smell to it when you come in the front door. The restroom had aluminum foil holding the toilet together (it was broken). I ordered a combo plate but the waitress never told us anything at all about the food that was on it. It did come with miso soup and the soup tasted like somebody had squeezed out a dirty sponge. I am not exaggerating, I'm sorry to say. I don't know what the waitress's problem was, but she acted like she was aggravated to even be there. We did not do or say anything to CAU her to treat us as she did. It was a total disappointment from start to finish: no ambiance, abominable service, and food that I took home and threw out. read more

I do not recommend plum garden to anyone for your safety stay away especially if you have any allergies they do not take it seriously they find it as a joke and then they mock you. we ordered three hibachi dinners that totaled $111 I requested that the steak and chicken be made separately from the chicken and shrimp due to the allergic reaction my sister has towards shellfish. I also asked that it be packaged separately as well. when we arrived it had not been packaged separately everything was together. I complained and the lady at the counter said there's nothing that we can do and took the food back, she was upset and walked towards the area of the kitchen. Something was telling me to just leave, but I was Hungry! I went out and I told my sister and she said wow that's disappointing she said well let's see if they can remake it over again I went inside and ask to speak to a manager and requested it be remade and I'll pay for the other two dinners she said...OK....we'll make it over and we will do it right now ....so I waited and I waited about 20 minutes before that dinner came back out again. I gave my sister her dinner in her hand and I put the other two that contain the shrimp in the trunk and we drove back to Gates at this time it was really late, I text my husband and told him to come outside because we were going to go home and eat dinner FYI we live in Henrietta. Are you guys still with me! We finally make it home. Dinner is cold by now we began to eat our dinner and as we were eating I noticed that the shrimp was not deveined so that was absolutely disgusting. I called my sister and asked her how was her meal and she said because it was so late she decided not eat and she'll eat it tomorrow. well Sunday rolls around and of course we're in church all day and on Sunday's we go to dinner after church like we normally do so that means she still did not eat her dinner from Saturday. Monday rolls around and I receive a call and a text and guess what guys read the text below This was done deliberately and it was wicked and it's unfortunate that people live in a world where they think this is ok. knowing you Deliberately tried to harm someone. With two little shrimp covered with chicken vegetables and steak knowing the customer was allergic to it is a wicked and Hateful act. Eat at your own risk ! I just want to let you know if you eat at Slum Garden I just want to make sure you are aware of the type of people you are dealing with and that is preparing your food. read more

Plum Garden - This is how Plum Garden treats its customers - Japanese Near Me - Pittsford, New York

Plum Garden is our weekend go-to spot for sushi, sake, and conversation between a few coworkers and I. We are always content with our sushi and service, so this time we wanted to switch it up and try out the hibachi that everyone raves about. My colleague and I ordered the steak hibaichi, served medium. It comes with the usual soup, salad, veggies, and fried rice. Kudos to the rice not being super soy-salty! We were served a great abundance of that. I couldn't finish it all. The soup and veggies were good, but not memorable. That's fine, I'm a carnivore, gimme the steak! Anyways, at one point my coworker and I noticed the steak was a perfect medium point where it's dark pink in the middle, and well cooked around each slice's circumference. I was praying in my head that I would get it that way, but alas, the chef kept cooking and we both go it well done. The steak was pretty much tasted like a chewy sirloin. I guess I'll shoot for the filet mignon next time? That's only a $3 difference. I'll be honest: I never took hibachi seriously when it comes to cuisine. I admire the skill, technique, and entertainment of the the craft but I consider it the same as flare bar-tending. I would not order a cocktail with flare and expect it to be the best I ever had. Was the meal good? Sure. Did my hibachi experience stand out from all others? Not really... I give this place 4 stars because I like the sushi here so much. The service is always pleasant and the prices are fair. Having an overcooked steak isn't a deal breaker for me; I have yet to experience a hibachi meal that truly gives me a medium or medium-rare cooked meat. But when I do... read more

Plum Garden - Meat on deck - Japanese Near Me - Pittsford, New York

See all

I used to be in Rochester for school. I still remember going to Plum garden whenever I had a reason to celebrate. After about two decades, I finally had another chance to dine at Plum Garden. It was as pleasant as ever. It reminded me how much I missed this place. The food is delicious, the price is reasonable and the service is fantastic. During my visit I picked simple but delicious sio may appetizer, followed by some cut of sashimi and salmon bento. I couldn't be happier. After more than two decades, Plum Garden is more than just another restaurant. It's a Rochester institution. Fantastic! Keep up the good work! read more

See all

So much fun. First time taking our kids and they LOVED it. Food was really good and we left more than enough for lunch the next day.

Five Facts About Our Trip To Plum Garden: 1. If I had known sake bombs were that cheap, I would've taken 2-7 more. 2. Our hibachi chef looked exactly like Manny Pacquiao. 3. Even after I specifically asked her not to embarrass me, my wife STILL couldn't catch a rice ball in her mouth. Right to the forehead, every time. 4. You better believe I got an onion volcano. 5. True to hibachi restaurant form, they use way too much salt and butter, and everything tastes good as a result. They also give you entirely too much food, which makes for excellent leftovers the next day. read more

Plum Garden - Onion volcano. - Japanese Near Me - Pittsford, New York

See all