This is like the pizza of my Pizza Hut-loving youth: puffy crust and piles of cheese.* I must be a bad foodie because I enjoy this more than subtle, authentic thin crust pizza with minimal toppings. Anyway, I could find no fault in my personal Deluxe pizza at a recent visit. Nice amount of sauce, generous toppings. I don't even feel bad for eating the whole thing. *If you were elementary-school age in the early 90s, remember that program where you got Pizza Hut coupons for reading books? As a nerdy kid who read a lot, I milked it for all it's worth. read more

Still sux. Was forced to choose this place again recently for a late night snack. Jeebus, their pizza is barely passable as food fit for human consumption. The absolute only thing they have going for them is they deliver later into the night than anybody else in town that I've found. read more

We go here for lunch as a staple in Milwaukee. The pizza even in the case is fresh hot and cheap. I've had the gyro pizza before. Well worth the $. Also the garlic yummy butter bread sticks are so good !!! My fiancé myself and one kid all ate there w 3 bottles of water for under $12! It's delish cheap n quick !!! Would like to try the ice cream sometime if im ever not stuffed from the pizza!!! read more

Pizza shuttle is delicious! Their thick crust is super scrumptious and the prices are good too. Plus they have ice cream!!! And in addition to delivering pizza they will also deliver deserts. Yasssss. read more

Dirt cheap food that's not half bad. Staff I encountered were nice and I found absent at the window straight away. Not a big fan of the crust but the slices are huge! Good stop for a cheap and fast piece of Zza. Parking sucks so try to not drive here. read more

Omg... I love you, Pizza Shuttle. Not only do you have AMAZING pizza, you also make a mean peanut butter shake. Thank you, thank you, thank you. read more

Pizza = + 1 Star (or less)... It's terrible.. so terrible. Pick up a piece, you'll see the thickest grease ring EVER. Bread sticks = + 1 star...They were good... but when someone asks for extra dipping sauce, don't give them only one [we clearly didn't get our extra sauce]... The place seems to cater to fattening food (deep fried green beans for God's sake). Don't skimp out on the one thing that someone asks for extra, that isn't fried. Delivery service to our hotel room at 2:30am = + 4 stars Total for 1 pizza & 1 order of bread sticks with a 2:30am delivery = $30. -2 stars... Wait. What? $30 for a large pizza ($8.99) and bread sticks (can't be more then $5). Ummmm, maybe I can't add, but something seems fishy about this. The feeling I had in the morning after eating your crappy ass pizza - 4 stars. Go to Ians... Wayyyyyyyy better! read more

When you walk into an establishment and find a "Late Night Hangover Menu" emblazoned on a chalkboard behind the counter, do you honestly expect world-class cuisine? If you do, you're in for a real disappointment. If you expect a place that caters to the tipsy crowd with food that's equal parts grease and fat and cheese and gluttony, then you're in for a treat. With realistic expectations, Pizza Shuttle can be a fun, quirky experience. I personally love pizza and bread sticks that are a little on the doughy side which the Pizza Shuttle has in spades. And, let's be honest, any meal that costs $3-5 is going to be a little on the crap side -- but that's what gives Pizza Shuttle it's charm. 2 people: 2 slices, 1 order of bread sticks, 2 sodas about $12 read more

Fun place to grab a slice and a beer! I'd recommend as a casual date destinations - really reasonable prices and fun things to see and do. Good pizza and the broasted chicken I purchased for my client was thoroughly enjoyed (I'm a vegetarian but she loved the chicken and the coleslaw A LOT). AND I was so impressed with the quality of service. Friendly and thoughtful - as I waited for the rest of my order staff offered to keep the items already up warm for me. read more

For all the times I've visited Pizza Shuttle over the years, I (like Rachel) am shocked I haven't written a review sooner. This place holds a certain nostalgia for me that brings back memories of driving over to the East Side during high school and chowing down on delicious pizza noms since there were few other options as an under-aged wanna-be gourmand. It would be impossible to tabulate the amount of their blue icees and bread-sticks I've ingested during my life. If I did, I'm sure it would horrify and depress me. That is not to say however, that those things weren't absolutely delicious. Sweet, sweet carbs! Pizza Shuttle really does serve that "late-night-drunk-and-hungry" demographic quite well. The after hours specials they have are awesome and super cheap. I've never ordered anything from them by delivery, so I can't speak to their service in that department. I will say though, as an adult I've changed my diet and am now a vegetarian with a gluten allergy. I recently stopped in with some friends the other night and I didn't realize how little they have that doesn't include either meat, breading or gluten of some type. Also, almost no healthy vegetarian-type things. I get that though. It's a pizza place. We're in Wisconsin where some people think if you're a vegetarian that means you can still eat meat in salads. I'd just love to see something I could order there besides french fries or ice cream. Not that either of those things are bad, but they get old quick. read more

After having what is supposedly "Milwaukee's best pizza" at Zaffiro's earlier today, and being disappointed with it....I was still in the mood for pizza. So I grabbed a couple slices for dinner. Pizza Shuttle pizza is better than Zaffiro's. Yeah, I said it. 2 slices for $4 and i'm out the door? Book it...done. Pan style pizza by the slice, good substance, a decent amount of cheese and I'm a happy camper. My pizza dreams haven't been crushed for the day. It might be called Pizza Shuttle, but they might as well call it.....Everything But the Kitchen Sink Shuttle. You want a gyro? They've got it. You want a burger? Sure why not. You want a shake and fish sandwich...knock yourself out. Now, I've had a fair amount of items on the menu to realize they should stick to pizza.....but for what it's worth...it's not the worst. read more

Great food! I love the delivery service. I just ordered food for the second day in a row. I'm waiting for my food now. Yesterday I had ordered Mac and cheese pizza, soup and the smoked Gouda poppers...all amazing. I ordered more soup today and ice cream due to me not feeling well. I would definitely order from here again if I came to Milwaukee again!! read more

Pizza Shuttle - Absolutely amazing!! Mac and cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

I'm only giving this 2 stars because my delivery came about 20 minutes before the scheduled time, and the delivery driver was really great. However, the actual quality of the pizza was definitely lacking, especially for how much I paid for one large sized pizza. The crust was completely burnt by the time I got it, and even though I paid for cheese, there was hardly any on there. Working in food service, I understand that things don't always come out perfectly, but that's why there needs to be some sort of quality control. I remember years ago, this used to be one of my favorite pizza places on the East Side, but recently, whenever I've made the mistake of going here, I've been severely disappointed. This was al just the delivery aspect of my experience. As far as the actual dine-in experience is concerned, I'm always surprised at how dirty the place seems, alongside counter attendants who occasionally seem to be a little high. Besides, the pizza I've gotten in the restaurant wasn't anything impressive either. Very disappointed. read more

God I love this place. I can't say I've ever had the pizza sober.. but my lord does it hit the fuckin spot. One time, we went out to dinner had some drinks and then went to Pizza Shuttle cuz I love this shit that much. The staff are surly as hell. the place is open super late, therefore after like 12midnight, you have to be frisked by TWO security guards to enter the place. Whatever, they can frisk me till the cows come home as long as I get some of that pizza. They also deliver late. Frisked. At a pizza place. read more

Was surprised! I was beginning to feel famished and decided to get a couple slices of pizza from one of the only places that does so in Milwaukee. When I went inside the establishment, they had slushie machines, ice cream, and even alcoholic drinks! My order was to go, but the atmosphere made me want to come back to dine!! HIGHLY RECOMMENDED from what I can tell. read more

I used to like their pizza. The establishment could have charm, but they need to lose the TVs so I don't have to put up with sports. This place recently seems to attract a bad crowd. Especially during the late hours. I came here the other day and asked for a pizza with different toppings on each half. They did a VERY sloppy job with this. There was significant topping "contamination" on either side. There was very very little pizza sauce, which is always a turnoff. And the cheese seemed like very poor quality. It just sort of fell off after the first bite from each slice. It was also way too stringy and didn't taste very good. Most egregious of all, they served me mozzarella sticks with COLD MARINARA SAUCE. That's absolutely inexcusable. If you can't be bothered to even microwave the stuff for ten seconds, you clearly don't give a crap about your customers. To say something positive, their ice cream rocks. But it's ridiculously bad for you! I don't plan on coming back here anytime soon. Which is a shame because I have fond memories of this place from years ago. read more

This review is based off of pizza shuttle's main dish: pizza. I have not tried their burgers, gyros, subs, or wraps. We walked in and ordered a thin, crispy large pizza up at the counter. If you are not familiar with Pizza Shuttle, as I wasn't, you order up at the counter and then sit down at wait for your order to be ready. For some reason we left a $5 tip unknowing that there is no service here. You pick up the food yourself at the counter & fill your own drinks "fountain-style". Our order was ready and we picked it up and sat back down. From the first bite I knew there was something off with the sauce... WEAK SAUCE! It was very non-flavorful & watered down. Ate one piece. If it weren't for the shuttle sticks I would have gone home hungry. With Chopstix right across the street, it seems that this section of Farewell breeds mediocre eating establishments. Side note: there is a friendly "old man bouncer" at the door if you are looking for small talk, otherwise, avoid this eatery. Another side note: I felt dizzy after eating this pizza. read more

Too much to drink+Pizza Shuttle=Perfect Combination Too little sleep+a ton of homework+Pizza Shuttle=A Great Threesome Too Lazy to Cook+Pizza Shuttle=A Match Made in Heaven Or, when all of the above equations don't apply, and your craving a guilty pleasure...or should I say greasy pleasure...Pizza Shuttle is for you. It is not a five star, but it's pretty good. And most importantly it's quick, consistent, and a Milwaukee hot spot that delivers. read more

Pizza shuttle is one of the restaurants that has a really good menu; you can find food like pizza, wings and full dinners. However, they need to work on their delivery service. I placed my ordered online because it's difficult to order when u call the restaurant they put you on hold for a long time and sometimes they forget you're still waiting. I got my receipt for my order online but I notice the tax on my check was 6.1 % instead of the 5.6% it was supposed to be. The total was $20.92 with the delivery charged included but when i got my food the total was $22.19. I was kind of mad because they were charging me more in taxes and all of a sudden my delivery charge was almost 2 dollars more. Menu Item Qty For $ $ x Qty B.A.R.T. Burger 1 Me $5.99 Appetizer Add-Ons (No Appetizer Add-On) Special Instructions: no tomatoes, no lettuce. Big Philly Burger 1 Me $5.99 Appetizer Add-Ons (No Appetizer Add-On) Soda [2 Liter] 1 Me $1.99 Soda (Pepsi) Funnel Fries [12pc] 1 Me $3.50 Funnel Fries Topping (Powdered Sugar) Subtotal: $17.47 Tax: (6.100%) $1.07 Delivery Fee: $2.38 Total: $20.92 Everything looked good except for the FUNNEL FRIES; we got 7 in the order of 12. This establishment is really mediocre when it comes down to service. This place is only good when you're so drunk and don't know what you're eating!!! read more

There are so many places I can think of to go for pizza in the city of Milwaukee. Pizza Shuttle is on the bottom of my list, yet they are hailed for having one of the better pizzas in the city. Not only can I tell you that the majority of the food here is bland and lackluster, but that the service I have received is generally quite bad, ranging from basic to horrendous. I can honestly say I think this establishment is a complete disaster, yet no one seems to notice or care. The pizza is spongey, greasy, and usually skimps on the sauce. I've tried the specialty pizzas before as well, but they pretty much taste exactly the way you'd expect them to. As far as appetizers go, the majority of it is fried and terrible for you (although I assume that's just supply and demand), and even if you wanted a "healthy" option, the ingredients to the salad are not fresh, and the amount of dressing you're allotted for an enormous portion of iceberg lettuce is laughable. Sure, it's nice that they offer and deliver ice cream treats, but you would think that such a popular venue would have the time, nay the intelligence, to update their list of treats they actually offer. I tried to order a Sprecher Orange Dream float from them three months ago. But they don't carry Orange Dream any more. So they send you Squirt instead. The price? Still $3.75. And it STILL says Orange Dream on the menu online. Oversight? Yup, and a pretty big one. However, one of the upsides to Pizza Shuttle is their hours - generally open very late for the drunk gourmands (or the better half of our fair city) looking for a greasy bite to eat. At that point, taste and basic common sense go out the window anyway, and even I will admit the joint has a plethora of dining options to please the palate of even the most wasted. But, in my sober opinion, the many options is what restaurants like Pizza Shuttle are doing wrong: they try and please everyone. So in the end, everything's just kind of bad instead of doing a few things really, really well. If you're a drunk college student, looking for a cheap, quick bite, or anyone on a budget with a general disregard to freshness or flavor, by all means, stop on by. But to me, Pizza Shuttle is like some sort of monster hybrid of Ma Fischer's, Pizza Hut, and Ed Debevick's. And if that doesn't freak you out, I don't know what will. read more

We go as a family to Milwaukee a few times per year. EVERY TRIP we order pizza shuttle to our hotel. The kids start talking about the pizza that they are going to choose this time while in the car on our way to Milwaukee. They make really good pizza and their prices are very fair. For us... a Family Tradition! 5 stars. PS.. after reading below it seems that it is viewed as an econ pizza place..I would not be able to speak to that. We always order the specialty pizza's on the high end of the menu. Never had a basic cheese or Pep pizza here. read more

Used to love this place until management went south. Beth with the purple hair, your attitude needs adjusting. Saw kids that my Friend knows and apparently, I can't make jokes with them. If she can't handle people being not completely sober on a Saturday night, then she can't handle managing the shuttle, period. The kids I joked with did not complain, but beth was totally rude and told me I should leave if I was harassing other customers. I harassed no-one, nobody complained, beth just got on a power trip. I've been going here FOR YEARS. The multiple people I was with felt this was a horrible experience because of beth, solely. If you want customer service, go elsewhere. Because Beth will ruin your night if she gets the chance; her agenda is getting rid of paying customers if they are not Her "ideal" customers. Sorry we had a joke, and Beth didn't liked it. What irks me the most was her poor attitude in approaching us. She was very unprofessional, and was in no way diplomatic. You're in a service industry, don't forget that. I will also note that all the "not recommended reviews" are worth reading. Clearly, I'm not the first to have a bad experience with the management. read more

I love their extensive menu. I can always find something I am in the mood for. The delivery is quick, and the staff friendly. The food is amazing. I particularly love the burgers. 5 stars for sure! read more

I love the place but their Sicilian style pizza is ALWAYS RAW IN THE MIDDLE! And they always have an attitude with you when you let them know this. It's like yo.... cook your pizza correctly read more

Pizza Shuttle - What kind of personal pepperoni pizza is this? So far they haven't answered me back - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

The best way to describe pizza shuttle is it is the ramen noodle of pizza. So if you prefer ramen noodles to a nice homemade chicken noodle soup, you actually might like this pizza. After I ate the pesto chicken pizza, I hate the shits for about two days. I possibly would give Pizza Shuttle another try if they upgraded quality of the dough and laid back on the grease. On a positive note, the delivery driver was cool as hell and our food was delivered incredibly fast. read more

I've been going her on and off for a few decades - went therea few weeks ago and got the 2 pizza with 2 soda cans deal. Normally they offer cups if you want to dine in; I asked for one cup and one can; the counter girl was super rude and said "we lose too much money on that so we don;t do that here!?!" Hope the 5c you saved was worth it! read more

Although Pizza Shuttle has an extensive menu, complete with various appetizers, sides, main dishes, and desserts, I like to stick to what they do best -- pizza. It's really hard to go wrong with Pizza Shuttle pizza. It's pricier than most of the national chains, but it's worth it for the quality of crust and the overall flavor. Our pizza of choice tends to be the pepperoni Sicilian ($11.58). It's a less greasy pizza and manages to hit the spot every time. And, you know, sometimes those greasy, original, hand-tossed pizzas are the best ones to have. Overall, we love Pizza Shuttle for its convenience. You can dine-in until 1 am daily or order delivery until 3 or 4 am throughout the week. You can get pizza by the slice or order a whole pie. They run lots of specials depending on the day and the time. They'll even deliver ice cream, sundaes, and milkshakes -- how great is that? College tip: If you've got an ID, you can get a large 1-topping pizza, four sodas, and a photobooth voucher for $9.99. Not a bad deal. read more

I was initially disappointed that this was not the Pizza place from Toy Story. But once I got past that I had a pretty good time. This was not the best or the worst pizza ive had in my entire life. But mind you I used to live under the stage at a Chuck E. Cheese (when it was Showbiz) so I have pretty high standards. Ok thats a lie, it was already Chuck E. Cheese... I dont remember the exact pizza I had because I was the opposite of not intoxicated. It was something involving cheese sauce chicken and spicy taste... Id say the pizza was a 3 out of 5 and the service was 6 out of 5 but the fact that buzz and woody werent there is a 1 out of 5 so without using my calculator I averaged that out to a 3 out of 5. I feel ok about that... Hey its better than Katy and Erika to the right gave them. Little overpriced. read more

Ehhhh... I live across the street and the only time I eat here is because I'm really too lazy to get something else. On the plus side, they have a HUGE menu. Pretty much any type of unhealthy food you'd ever want to eat is here. They also are open really late - which is convenient. On the negative side, I don't think they do ANYTHING that well. I'm partial to the calzones most of the time. The slices in the case are usually better than ordering an actual pizza, in my opinion. Not sure why, but that has been my experience. The people are usually nice enough that work there and the vibe is good... I just don't think the food is very good. read more

My experience here was okay. Came here after work one night, a little after midnight, and got a slice for two bucks. It was fine, pizza is pizza. Nothing incredible; just something when you have a craving that needs to be put to rest. The cashier was nice and the decor was pretty neat. The concept of the restaurant is awesome and I'd love to come back during normal/busier hours for an actual pizza to see how that plays out. Oh, and parking was sort of a hassle. There's a small lot underneath and that's it, from what I could tell. Otherwise, you're stuck searching on the street. read more

I can not believe the amount of good reviews for this place. I know that I am from Chicago and my standard of "good pizza" may be higher than the average Milwaukee local...but COME ON! As we arrived back to our hotel after a night of drinking, this menu was shoved into our hands by the front desk staff and we were just happy that someone would deliver us food at that hour of the night. We ran up to our room to order pizza and anxiously awaited the moment where we could devour a pie made of cheese and grease. When it got there (minus the beverages I ordered) we quickly dug in....and then just as quickly stopped eating. What WAS this? This pizza was the worst tasting pizza that I have ever had in my life. The worst part is that it wasn't even cheap pizza. You can get a $5 pizza from Little Ceasers if you are trying to save a buck and that is edible. But this pizza tasted like something that you would get from a gas station at best. I had fortunately ordered some garlic bread sticks that were very good and really the only thing I ate out of our order. You know that when you are drunk and there is pizza left that there is a problem. The menu had a large amount of other things and if I ever found myself in Milwaukee again, starving after everything else had closed I might order something other than pizza from this place - but I would never get pizza from here again. read more

I haven't had their pizza in a few years but I recall the Spaghetti and Meatball and the Mexican Pizza (with Jalepenos) was incredibly good. And ouch-spicy. With some of their unusual menu items a friend and I joked that their demographic probably includes both pregnant women and stoners. Indoors I scared people by playing choosing "Just One Fix" by Ministry on their jukebox on a Sunday afternoon. Evidently they had forgotten to turn it down from the night before. MUAH HA HA HA! My friend claimed he saw someone dive for the volume knob behind the counter. Also, their breadsticks and cheese dip was awesome. 2011 I just went for the first time in about eight years as I was visiting Milwaukee for a concert (Front Line Assembly). Wow, they've upgraded the decor, added a photo booth, some video games, and an internet jukebox. I wanted to play a song by the band I was seeing that night and checked the jukebox. They had one album by them - Milenium. There were families dining and a large group of kids so I sortof balked at playing that. I decided to play a cheesy inoffensive song first to test the volume. Choice? "Windy" by The Association. It was barely audible. I then chose the FLA song. It took some time but eventually played. It was a little louder but not enough to start a 3rd grade mosh pit. I winced when I realized that the song did have the "F" word in it (from a movie sample). I ordered a lot of food, ravioli, bosco sticks, a salad and bread sticks (came with the ravioli), All excellent. I couldn't eat it all so I saved it for after the concert. read more

Pizza Shuttle is a must when we go to Milwaukee, huge menu, great slices and wings, FREE Parking right under the restaurant which is great as parking is at a premium on Farwell. read more

A few years ago this place used to be great. Decent food with excellent delivery service. Although the pizza here is not outright bad, the service is horrible, delivery is horrible, and nearly every aspect of this place is disturbingly horrible. Each time you order delivery from here you are taking a gamble on actually getting your food. This has been happening with increased frequency. Its to the point now where I just won't chance it. Also don't expect anything but attitude and annoyance from anyone over there if you call to ask why your order is taking over 2 hours. The last time the woman on the phone actually shushed me! WTF?? Save yourself some frustration and go elsewhere. This place is just awful. read more

WOW!! I am so glad I placed an order through grubhub and my order never came. No one and I mean no one called me, I had to call grubhib and here my order was running late (aka lost/never rang it) This is shady a $15 credit doesn't cut it and grubhib ands insults the hungry peeps it left standing. I am new to MKE and this leaves a bad taste in my mouth, I should rinse it out with Brick3 read more

I love you and hate you, pizza shuttle. One day everything is immaculate and one day everything sucks. I have literally spent thousands of dollars at your establishment, so I speak with experience. In the last year, I feel like quality has taken A sad turn. Love the Detroit pizza, by the way. Tonight though, I ordered a pita, got a wrap. This is the second time that happened. Ordered a sprecher orange dream shake, got a can of orange crush and a cup of ice cream. Seemed a bit deceiving. I guess I should stick to their pizza. read more

In this Covid19 world I rate places different. It's kinda what places take it serious and what don't. Pizza shuttle has hand sanitizer out and the dining room set up well. But the line to pay is a mess. Where to stand in line is a mess. There are two squares on the ground but in this world you need to dumb it down for the people that don't understand there is a pandemic going on. Pizza shuttle is trying but since they don't tell guests where to line up. It turns into a small narrow box loaded with people. I will order delivery from them in the future. But until the pandemic is over. This is a scary place to line up unfortunately. read more

Go during lunch hours if you can! 10am-4:00pm. Each cheese slice is $0.99 and one topping $1.85 and 2 topping $2.10 best price per slice. However if your looking for more than just pizza I'd recommend going between 2pm-5pm. That's when it's half price appetizers and discounted hard drinks. (Happy hour) the sweetest time to go is between 2pm-4:00pm everything is on sale then. Dinner time it gets kind of expensive being $1.85 per cheese and 2.10 for 1 topping. read more

Late night drunk food? Check. Open when Classic Slice was closed for Labor Day? Check. Really it's one of the few places in town to get a slice. Pretty Good. But after this visit I realized all the other pizzas everyone ordered looked so much better and fresher. Next time I'm ordering a whole pizza and will deal with the leftovers. Also on my next visit: $2 photo booth. awww yeah. oh and contrary to the many votes against it: pizza shuttle does have beer! read more

I live practically across the street and pizza shuttle has never let me down. Big menu, cheap slices, good service. Solid pizza joint with everything you could ever want. Also, their sign is awesome and unique I love seeing it everyday ! read more