Amazed at the positive reviews here. The women that work here were obnoxious. The prices imo are a tad overpriced. The pluses: 1. Bathroom was clean 2. On a scale of 1-10 for taste (with 10 being the highest), this is a 7. Good but not amazing in a city that is known for having great pizza. Other negatives: Bathroom although clean, did not have the paper shield thing. It baffles me why NY doesn't seem to have these at many establishments. No credit cards if something is under $10. read more

So, I took my daughter to Pizza Plus today, we usually get delivery, but decided to eat in today...Nice place to eat, pizza is excellent! We got mozzarella sticks , which were yummy, and the baked ziti which was tasty as well..Staff are all friendly..Definitely recommend!! read more

See all

Stopped in here on the way to the airport. What a great way to end my Big Apple adventure! Didn't think I was that hungry.. But the sandwich I ordered was too delicious to abandon. The sandwich was the one with pesto, thickly sliced Roma tomatoes and slices of baby mozzarella. The waiter mistakenly told me that the sandwich would be served warm and it wasn't. At first I thought that this would be disappointing but it was really much better this way.. Even two and a half weeks later, I am still salivating at the idea of this sandwich. The server was nice but a little too laid back for my liking. I'd recommend not checking this place out if you are in a rush. My husband got two slices of sausage and pepperoni pizza. Seeing as how he is the size of a lumberjack and felt comfortably full, I think it's safe to say that their slices are a good portion. He is a meat lover and was content with the amount of meat. Two thumbs up! read more

Pizza Plus - Front of the restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Yummy margarita pie!!!! Fresh and crunchy, just the way I like my pizza. The free bread that came with it was tasty! Pasta lunch specials were the perfect size. Our waitress was super friendly. Sit outside for the beautiful summer weather!! No complaints, must try!!! read more

Pizza Plus - Small margarita pie - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

My favorite restaurant in Brooklyn since childhood. I literally could sit and eat like 25 of their buffalo wings (ordered with the sauce on the side, so they're even MORE crunchy!) without taking a breath. I've been hoarding little takeout containers of the buffalo sauce in my refrigerator every time I order from them. The dinner rolls are to die for, and the Margherita pizza is a family favorite at my house. I grew up coming here with my grandmother for their linguini with white clam sauce, and my current favorite pasta dish is the linguini and broccoli with garlic and oil. It's so good you don't even need to add a protein to it. I'll take some pictures the next time I go (which will definitely be soon) though the food doesn't last long on the table. Also, cute little trivia cards on the tables! A+ for Pizza Plus. read more

The best chicken Parmesan I've ever tasted the pizza is great especially their sausage and pepper pizza that's their specialty and meatballs are out of this world the service is phenomenal the owners a gentleman they treat you like family me and my family come here at least three times a month ever since the pandemic we've been just ordering from them trying to support a local place read more

The best margarita pizza i ever had. The crust and the sauce is what stands out. Not too thick or thin...just perfect read more

Pizza Plus - Margarita with mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Food is always good. Vegan pizza is the draw for my daughter who has food allergies. Nice to have a pizza restaurant that can accommodate her. read more

My family ordered two pizza pies one regular one they call a white pie and a bowl of soup. We waited over an hour and a half for the delivery. Needless to say the pies and soup was cold,and for the price we paid for the food we were deeply disappointed. I think my family will choose a different pizza parlor the next time we crave pizza !!! read more

I've been here a couple of times the past two years. I've also had their food from a catered event before as well. The service has always been friendly and very accommodating. You can just order food to go or sit down and have waiter service. Their portions are pretty big for the price! I've never paid $8~ for a spinach roll before but this was HUGE. Wish I took a picture. My friends love their sandwiches and salads as well. Their hot food from the catered trays were good as well. Enjoyed the penne all's vodka and chicken parm very much. read more

Pizza plus has fantastic pizza & is in a great location! I love grabbing a couple of slices on my way home from the subway. Prices recently went up a tiny bit, but they're still a great deal. The eggplant parm hero is easily a meal for two, it's hefty & delish! Great service, and an absolutely amazing staff. Everyone there is always happy to see you & extremely polite. read more

Always great. Appreciate the hard work to make everything delicious especially in such a challenging time.

I am a very picky Italian food eater. I LOVE their pastas! The pizza is good, too. Not the best in the area but definitely worth trying. Really solid pasta and chicken dishes though. Chicken quality is high. read more

My husband and I dropped by on a weekday after seeing their lunch specials posted outside. The Fettucine Alfredo with Shrimp was really good. The shrimp was fresh and meaty. It was even sort of Lobster-like tasting. We also ordered the Broccoli Rabe which was tasty sauteed with garlic and oil. Would definitely drop by for lunch again. read more

There is a very nice, slightly older woman here who wears large glasses. If she is working behind the counter, she will make sure your experience is very pleasant. If she is not here, however, your experience will suffer. Pick up orders get sent out for delivery, delivery orders go to the wrong address, and the guys behind the counter take out their frustration on the customers - if something goes wrong, it's obviously the customer's fault. So, do yourself a favor. Before going in, take a look through the window to be sure the nice woman with glasses is there. If she's not there, go somewhere else. read more

Great food Great service A family style pizza restaurant with tables. We really enjoyed our pizza, salad and soup. They have a large menu. read more

I think an hour and a half wait for delivery when the restaurant estimated fifteen to twenty minutes on Seamless Web is unreasonable and more so when the nature of ordering via Seamless Web forces one to pre-pay the tip, an injury compounded ten-fold by hot salad and cold, overcooked pasta. read more

Came in from walking around on an extremely muggy and hot Saturday in Park Slope. My wife and I were a bunch of sweaty hungry yelpers looking for some grub. She had been here once and said I needed to check it out. The interior of this place was very welcoming. It is like a big country style kitchen mixed with hip Brooklyn style. The brick wall really makes the place look great in my opinion. The lady behind the counter was like a mother welcoming her kids in from a day outside playing. She had big smile and said take a seat and lets get you some drinks to cool down. The waitress came over and took our drink order. Quickly returned with them and then took our order. I got the pasta tortellini with sausage and marinara sauce. My wife got the baked ziti. It was a lunch special, so each meal was only $4.95!!!! Thats insane since it included a soda for me...my wife added a $1 to her meal and got a snapple. That my friends is a cheapo meal in Park Slope. I was a little hesitant about what was about to come out for under 5 bucks. The waitress placed a bowl of warm bread on the table and my wife, the bread expert, grabbed a roll, sliced it open and slathered on that butter so quickly because she was starving. She bit into it and gave me the "mmmmm" seal of approval. Trust me she is my yelp sidekick when it comes to breads and pastries, since she makes her own of both and knows her stuff. So our meals came out and they were decent, if not generous, portions for again such a cheap price. My pasta was good, bot great, but definitely not bad at all. Very tasty, just didnt blow my mind...but then again its simply a pasta meal with sauce. The sauce was sweet and I like them sometimes so that was good too and the sausages were a nice addition to this already good meal. My wife's ziti was very good and honestly when I go back will probably order that instead. They have a bunch of items to choose from on the lunch special menu from raviolis to spaghetti with brocolli and oil to many other great looking meals. 12-3 for the specials, but they do have so much more on the menu from great looking pizzas to delicious looking desserts. They boast "the best cheesecake in the world", but since I was seriously stuffed I never made it that far. Our 2 big meals, 1 snapple and 2 sodas came to $12.33 including tax. Low price, good meal and I will definitely be back to taste some more of this attractive joint on 7th avenue. Oh and the air conditioner is amazing...so go for the cool air...stay for the delicious food. read more

Not only is this place a vegan-pizza wonderland (with soy cheese, soy pepperoni and sausauge, too) but their topping options are amazing. Broccoli-rabe, eggplant, zuchinni, roasted peppers!! Ask for extra sauce though, it's amazing and you'll want to sip it with a straw. read more

Do NOT ask for meat on half to accommodate your vegetarian partner, it upsets the owner, might just be the pizza man but is a total d-bag! Not surprising place was empty on a Friday night with him in charge. A block away the cheap ass joint was jumping and has no problem with special order. NEVER AGAIN! read more

Currently munching on some Pizza Plus dishes while watching the Mets v. Minnesota Twins game. Ordering delivery, they deliver to Prospect Heights Woo!, we opted for their small whole wheat pizza and a grilled chicken sandwich with lettuce and tomato. The pizza is standard. Nothing amazing about their classic cheese with whole wheat crust but still good. Their grilled chicken sandwich is better than many I've had before. The chicken is moist, not dried out, like many restaurants. Delivery took about an hour and the woman who took my phone order called to let me know the delivery was on the way. Definitely a plus. read more

I went to Pizza Plus for the first time tonight - my friend had been there before - and we both thoroughly enjoyed eating here. It is a nice casual place to have dinner. We split a 12" Margherita pizza. The crust was just about perfect and the fresh basil and Mozzarella cheese were very flavorful. We wanted to try their salad of the day but because they had run out of dressing, we opted to share a Caesar salad with grilled chicken. The grilled chicken was excellent but we would have preferred a tastier lettuce than iceberg and the dressing was much too thick. Adding a serving spatular for the pizza and serving utensils for the salad would have been appreciated. Our server was very nice and checked to be sure our waters stayed full which is something I personally always appreciate. Prices were reasonable to the Slope. So overall, this is a restaurant I would be happy to frequent again! read more

Sometimes you don't need a fancy coal-oven artisan pizza. Sometimes you just want damn good pizza. And that is why I love Pizza Plus! Prices are insanely reasonable (small pie starts at $6.50) and they do that pie very well. (I'm partial to the simple glory that is pepperoni and black olives) The dining room is bright, clean and airy with lots of locals coming in and out, some just to say "hi." The proprietors are super friendly, and were very apologetic the one time our pie was later than usual. It was uber-busy and I could tell they were stressing, so no worries on our part. Only one note of caution: the infamous spawn of indulgent Park Slope parents can be pretty loud during weekends, so be warned! We've been hit with thrown crayons before (without an apology by the parent, but that's another story...) so we tend to take it to go and eat in the comfort of our couch. read more

To the Sloper on a budget- If you just can't live without your brunch even though you're not sure who you are going to make rent, Pizza Plus has a hidden gem of a brunch on the cheap- They have a pizza they call "The Continental"- three cheeses, egg, bacon and onion. My wife and I split a small one and a side of mozzarella and tomato, and the entire bill with tip was under $20. The pizza was really tasty, too. They may not be expensive, but they also don't skimp on the ingredients. And as far as pizza places in Brooklyn go, this one has one of the nicer decors in the area. read more

The 5 stars may be due to the fact we came in here starving after waiting 40 some minutes for food that never came (boo hooked on 12th!). We were greeted, sat, and fed within about 10 minutes of arriving. Regardless, the pizza was good and all the folks working were really nice. 5/7, would eat here again. read more

Tl;dr: This is the best tasting pizza for delivery. Two points distinguish this pizza joint from any other pizza joint in the area: tasty crust and fast delivery. I've stuck to simple pies with one or two toppings. They have always delivered in less than an hour a smoking hot pizza. The sauce is on the sweeter side and the cheese is plentiful with just enough toppings. Not too much and not too skimpy. But the most satisfying thing about their pizza is surprisingly the crust. Most pizza joints in the area have crusts that are bland and dry. I don't know what they do with their crusts but I hope they never change their recipe. Their crust has a soft and nearly buttery flavor and I love it. read more

Great local restaurant. Owners very friendly to neighbor hood residents as well as regular customers.

Not so good, anymore. I don't get it. Went there pre-renovation and it was awesome - crisp crust, good sauce with nice garlic flavor, quality cheese. Came back post-renovation, and it was like pizza branded as New York Pizza found in a strip-mall in Ohio - thickish chewy crust with ketchupy sauce. The cheese was still good, but whatever. Post-renovation, I crossed over to Smiling Pizza. It's the best slice place around, and since my babela no longer wanted to share a pie at Pizza Plus, I was left alone. Sigh. read more

Great gluten free pizza! I had two options-small + large, which is fantastic. I ordered the large and it was delivered in less than 30 minutes. The crust was great + the sauce and cheese were also fabulous. I'd definitely eat here again. I also think its great that they have whole wheat and vegan options-very accommodating! read more

We're in Brooklyn for a week and we ended up at Pizza Plus one night because we were too tired to go anywhere else. The pizza ended up being so good that we came back a second time and ordered the same thing. The crust is crisp and the sauce tastes very fresh. The owner was there the first time we went, and greeted several people by name. Must be a neighborhood favorite - deservedly so. read more

Lets start by saying the pizza is good no complaints. My issue.... I ordered a pizza delivery and within 10 minutes it was at my door. I thought wow that was quick and then I opened the box, and there was the disappointment. A warm pie at best, probably meant for someone else who didn't show up and now sitting on my kitchen table. Not what i was expecting and very disappointing Bad business practice. The moral of the story. The counter person saved a pie today and lost a customer forever. read more

YUMMY VEGAN PIZZA! I like mine with extra cheese and vegan pepperoni. Pizza Plus uses Follow Your Heart Cheese on their pizza. Personally, when we bought Follow Your Heart cheese to use at home is was so gross but Pizza Plus uses magic to make it taste wonderful. They also make vegan calzones that are to die for. Just ask them what is vegan on the menu and they will help you out. The staff is very approachable and the lady that rings up your price (older lady that smiles alot) is so kind and friendly; She always strikes up a conversation and is always in the best of moods. They do delivery, pick up, and indoor dining. I usually pick-up but the pizzeria is a really good place to stay and eat in too. read more

Delicious vegan cheese pizza. Excellent customer service. I love this place. Only downside is that you have to order a whole vegan pie, you can't just get an individual slice. Highly recommend to any vegan looking for their Brooklyn pizza joint... Vegan Calzones are also great and very filling. Quick delivery service to Windsor Terrace. read more

When I found out this place made vegan pizza I had to try it. Having recently gone vegan I thought takeout pizza would be out of the question. The pie took about 20 minutes to come out but it was worth it. I twas delicious, savory and a little on the spicy side. The crust was thin and really crispy, maybe too crispy because when I would take a bite it would break off in sharp edged pieces and scrape the roof of my mouth. After the pizza was done I had a really, really, sore mouth. I took home the leftovers to freeze and I had it for lunch the next day. It's so great to have pizza with "cheese" that doesn't leave my face smelling like vomit. Me and a friend would call it "Pizza face." I can't wait to go back to have pizza without the "pizza face." read more

Pizza Plus - vegan pepperoni pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

When you're a vegan and craving no-fuss pizza, this is an excellent place to come. The sauce is light and fresh, and they are generous with the cheese. read more

Not a fan. I stopped off midday today for a pedestrian emergency slice of cheese pizza, and I was woefully under impressed. The cheese didn't taste overly fresh, and I found the crust to be substandard. But Christy's right: The mushrooms are fresh. While I waited for my slice to warm, the fellow behind the counter was opening some new boxes of the little grey fungi. read more

While 30-40 min seemed like a longass time to wait for a pizza...they were actually on time. The stuffed pizza - 11 veggies and cheeeeeeese - ate more like a calzone that was more actual food-like than most pizza-place goodies. That being said, I reeeeeally wish Peppino's was open on Mondays.... read more

Best way to spend a late Spring Friday: Order a large whole wheat with vegan cheese, broccoli rabe, fresh garlic and many, many beers. Sit outside with a decent conversationalist. Eat, eat, eat. (The vegan pizza here is the best I've had and I've had lots. I'll give them five stars once they become a 100% vegan pizza parlor.) read more

I've eaten here twice, and both times have been absolute torture. This is not because of the food, but the obnoxious screaming children. It's as though parents think that this place is fair game for yelling, drooling, and touching random strangers. Control your children, people! Ahem. Back to the review. The pizza itself wasn't bad, but it also wasn't extraordinary. Next time I'll definitely try the soy pepperoni and have that pizza delivered! read more

I visited Pizza Plus for the first time a few weeks ago because my boyfriend and I were caught in a torrential downpour whilst looking for a place to grab some dinner. I'm already in love with this place! It's clean, the staff is incredibly friendly (this IS Brooklyn, after all), and the food is great--what more could you ask for? The Trivial Pursuit cards on the tables are a great touch. Even though the food may take a while (they're almost always swamped with customers and deliveries,) the cards provide a good diversion. I'm a fan of pizza with mushrooms and I recommend trying the garlic bread if you're a hungry group. read more