Tried for the first time. Definitely not a chain and they have the benefit of independence. The marinara sauce on both the meatball parmigiana and eggplant parmigiana was very tasty! The amount of Ricotta on the Eggplant parmigiana sandwich was more than generous. The staff is friendly and attentive. The only disappointment was the ratio of bread to meatballs on the meatball parmigiana sandwich as it was heavy on the bread and light on the meatballs. However, the meatballs were great. Suggest they enhance their website a bit, as it could use some more photos and/or menu descriptions (Ex. What are their World Famous Pepperoni & Cheese Bites? Didn't know what they were but likely would have ordered them with a bit more information). We will try the restaurant again and update the review. read more

Pizza Johny's - Meatball Parmigiana Sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Miami, Florida

This is my second time going to Pizza Johny's. I went the first time about 3 or 4 years ago and was extremely pleased with the pizza and taste. Don't know why it took me so long to go back. That won't happen again...I will def go back more often. The owner Johny is friendly and welcomes all of his customers and asks how their food was. I like that. He seems genuine and you can tell he takes pride in his restaurant and products. I'm glad the store has expanded to double the size. Now there is more seating. I ordered a plain slice and a meat spiral. They came out quickly, were fresh, and hot. Both tasted amazing! I wish I lived closer because I would go there at least once a week. I'm interested in trying a lot of other things on his menu. The menu has a lot to offer...more than what I can remember from 3 or 4 years ago. I will be a loyal customer to Pizza Johny's. Authentic! read more

Pizza Johny's - Meat Spiral and Cheese Slice. So good! - Pizza Near Me - Miami, Florida

See all

Food was great 5 cheese pizza has lots of flavor Mest lovers Pizza is perfect Cheesecake was good Next time I will order the triple chocolate cake Crust was on point Service was friendly and fast Ambiance is typical pizza restaurant with lots of pictures on the walls and NY ambiance. Johnny was there and he is super friendly. Give some tips to support and you will get a Happy Face on your pizza box I will definitely be back to Johnny's read more

Good NY style pizza, pasta dishes and sandwiches. Long counter and tables outside. Order at the counter and grab a table or spot on the counter. read more

Absolutely delicious! Pizza, pasta, & salads! Wow! You can't go wrong. A must try! The staff is welcoming and worth the wait. Very little seating but the food is worth standing by up and eat or taking home! A hidden gem! read more

I used to come here and enjoyed the pizza. Well, last few visits were terrible. I came in a few weeks ago, ordered a large pie and 2 slices of Sicilian. Saw the pizza maker put the Sicilian slices in the oven. Paid my order and NEW cashier gives me my order. I came home to a large pie and 2 regular slices. Called up immediately and was told I can have my Sicilian slices credited. Spoke with a thin tall manager showing him my receipt and he basically tells me it's not his problem. So, I happen to order more pies for my house, address my problem with the owner and he looks annoyed at me (as I have the order ready to show on my phone) and tells the cashier give it to her next time. He hid in the back and wouldn't come back out. Anyways, without telling my family my niece orders a Hawaiian pizza and it was a dumped can of pineapple on the pizza couldn't pick it up soggy! I will never do business with this place again! There are more pizza parlors in the area. 2 brothers and mikes pizza where you get great customer service and not a nasty attitude from the owner. If I order a product and I didn't get it and have proof, I should get it. NOT NEXT TIME! read more

Pizza is great, we get half cheese half pepperoni. We love their spaghetti carbonara with the melted cheese on top. And their pinwheels with pepperoni. We recommend this place. It's one of our favorite pizzas, especially if eaten right there. read more

Amazing authentic New York style pizza very kind staff, easy ordering, and fast service

I love pizza and this place reminded me of a small pizza joint in Battery Park NYC. I ordered two slices and a drink to go. Came out to be $9.00 w tip. Check out the check-in offer they have going before you place your order. The pizza was thin and crispy, just how i love it. The sauce was delicious with a hint of sweetness. No abundance of cheese on the pizza, which i love because too much cheese kills it for me. The place is small with a couple of hightop tables inside and a few outside as well. The decor reminded me of authentic nyc pizza places. The far right wall has picture frames of nyc skyline with a funny job application on the wall for wannabe gangsters to join the mob. Ha! Above all, the enployees taking your order are very courteous and friendly, which is always nice. Definitely i give this place 2 thumbs up. Love their pizza and will be returning. read more

See all

The grandma pie was the most delicious pizza I've ever had. Excellent! It has the cheese on bottom sauce on top very flavorful and cheesy.

We love Pizza Johnny's pizza! The crust is perfection. I tend to order to go because have had bad experiences with delivery drivers but nonetheless back to the food... the garlic rolls are so yummy and you can even order them stuffed with pepperonis. The pasta is decent shared the chicken alfredo. We love the deserts as well. This place can get busy over the weekends so be mindful of that, especially during dinner time. read more

Was in the mood for pizza and didn't want to drive out to my usual pizza place, so I decided to check if there were any local pizza shops near my place. Found Pizza Johnny's on Yelp and decided to give them a chance. I ordered delivery and received an email letting me know the pizza would be delivered in 60 minutes, however, it arrived in closer to 30 minutes, which was a nice surprise. Pizza arrived promptly and still piping hot. Very happy with the service and product. I think I found a new pizza place to order from, from now on! Seeing all the other food they offer on their Yelp page, I will definitely try some of their other Italian classics next time. read more

Great Italian food spot friendly attentive staff!! Kids loved the cheese pizza, spaghetti & meatballs...was nice to find what tasted like homemade food.. read more

Great food and customer service. We ordered from uber eats and unfortunately an uber driver that was our driver took our order so long story short our order was delayed but then Johny himself called my roommate and apologized, he rushed our order and even sent us complimentary dessert. The pizza was so cheesy and it was just amazing. It was thin was the perfect amount of sauce. Im not a fan of suer saucy pizza. We tired their Famous Pepperollies and it is a garlic roll with a slice or pepperoni inside. Overall the pizza was delicious and Johny was so sweet I would highly recommend this restaurant. With much foodie love, Chiqui linguine read more

See all

One of my top pizza spots in Miami! The Mac n cheese bites are SO FIRE! The garlic rolls are very refreshing, not too pungent and not dry at all. The staff here is very respectful. I'm unsure if the older guy is the owner but he makes you feel so welcomed once you come in. He's very honest on what you should try when you have a craving. Very sweet! The prices here are VERY reasonable. Such a great experience with great food. read more

Pizza Johny's - Pizza Near Me - Miami, Florida

This restaurant never disappoints. The service is impeccable, the staff is always nice and friendly, and especially the owner! We have tried just about everything on the menu, the appetizers- wings, pepperolies, garlic bread, mozzarella sticks, and the homemade tomato basil soup. The pastas- red, white, and pink sauce. The PIZZAS- YUM!!! All beyond delicious. I have no doubt that everything on the menu is great. We have very few things left to try. I highly recommend this restaurant. Almost forgot- for catering- very good pricing and you don't have to call a day in advance. Everyone compliments their food at our parties. read more

My husband and I drive 40 minutes to eat Pizza Johnys Sicilian pizza, always delicious, best in South Florida. And the people are always amazing! read more

Delicious Pizza! Great Customer Service, Provides Different Selections for Everyone in the Family! Staff was very friendly and humorous! They were pretty quick with bringing out appetizers. read more

Pizza Johny's - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Miami, Florida

See all

So I passed by today to because my pops was craving pizza. Noticed something different as soon as I walked inside ( I think this place is under new management ). The pizza tasted completely different.... ( lost my appetite after half of the fist slice) This was the closest thing to NY pizza I had in Kendal and now I must search for a new spot. Rating - 1-10 A struggling 2 To top it off as I got in my car I noticed that the guy at the register was zapping flies above the pizzas.... Bruhhhh. read more

Pizza Johny's - Bug zapper - Pizza Near Me - Miami, Florida

Very bad as of lately sauces tasteless rock.hard garlic bread which broke a tooth , onions in carbonara it has none , no ham too cream based sauce very watery doesnt stick to the pasta , Romano eggs make guancalle make the real.carbonara this is an american version . Ps workers hate cubans including the owner. read more

Pizza was extra cheesy which is not totally a bad thing but a little too much grease. The fettuccine with chicken had zero flavor which is definitely a never order again unless they change the recipe. My wife had the chicken parm and was pretty good. All that being said a 3 star is a fair rating. read more

The best of the best!! Great service amazing ingredients. I am willing to risk burns in my mouth for this amazing pie. I come here several times a month. Once you try pizza Johny's no other pizza will do. read more

Pizza Johny's - Classic pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Miami, Florida

I'm a recent transplant to the southern end of the county - by recent I mean 3 yrs now. In those 3 years I've been trying to find a good pizza place to replace my preferred spot located in the northern end of the county (easily 45 mins - 1 hr away). I haven't been successful and now approach each new pizza joint I try with apprehension and expect disappointment. Pizza Johny's delivers on what a NY style pizza is. The staff is ultra friendly - which isn't the case at many businesses (including my preferred pizza joint). The garlic rolls were fantastic! Very soft and flavorful - which apparently is difficult to find now. As for the pizza flavor - I would have preferred a slightly more robust or flavorful sauce. It was a bit bland for me - but I'm willing to give the place another try in the event for this was a one off. I'm really hoping this ends up being my go to place for when I want/need a pizza fix. I'd much rather drive 15 mins than 1 hr. read more

Pizza Johny's - Pepperoni 16" Cheese Pizza (Large) - Pizza Near Me - Miami, Florida

I love this place, thin pizza made with love, their pastas are also delicious. The people that work there are all nice and work fast. This is not a seat and eat place it's mostly to go, sometimes they have 2 high tops outside but I havent seem them in a long time. read more

When I crave pizza this is one of my favorite places to get my fix. Their pepperoni pizza is one of the best and if you are trying to be healthy they have amazing salads too. I've had the grilled chicken salad which is served with spinach, tomatoes, onions, and mozzarella. The other salad was served with breaded chicken, romaine, tomatoes,, onions, cranberries and goat cheese. Both salads were delicious. This is my go to when I want a New York Style pizza. read more

See all

Great pizza! Lots of options on the menu with great portions and fair prices. Consistently good!

We decided to order something local during the pandemic/quarantine and chose Pizza Johny's. Right off the bat the customer service was very good and friendly, they even called us when the food was about to be ready. The actual food was good, but definitely not what i expected. The chicken wings were very salty and the garlic rolls were drenched in oil. The Sicilian pizza was okay, a bit undercooked. What saved the whole experience was the meatball & ricotta pizza. I would come back just for that! I would give this place another try and would recommend it if you're around the area. It definitely beats a lot of commercial pizzas. read more

Pizza Johny's - Meatball & Ricotta pizza & 4 Meats Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Miami, Florida

See all

Everyone knows that pepperoni is my weakness. I had two of my friends rant and rave about this place so I had to pay them a visit to see what the buzz was all about Yes, it's totally authentic. It's like if I closed my eyes and opened them up whilst standing in Manhattan awaiting a solid slice from some highly esteemed pizzeria. By the way, their lasagna is out of this world. Aside from the dough being freshly made and baked with a robust portion of hearty marinara and fresh cheese spread above-they're truly ahead of their time. I love watching them spin the dough in the air as they keep the dough for the perfect pies they make. If your stomach doesn't creep up on you upon entry then the aroma will certainly get it started. Not only are the prices super attractive but the portions and quality are vastly a superior than what that price lands you elsewhere in Miami. It's authentic in every way and a total score when searching for pizza in the area. You aikoky can't go wrong! read more

Discovered this Jen out of luck just driving by, if your looking for that traditional NY pizza this is the place no imposters here solid to the core. There service is friendly and very helpful with suggestions. The interior takes you into NY as soon as you walk in and go's all the way inside. The pizza I ordered was just a little under cooked only reason for the four start rating to it to go so a few mins. in the oven solved it nothing serious maybe next time will ask for a little more crispy the rolls were on point with lots of garlic and cheese. There cheesecake was truly delight tasted home made. Very happy with my experience will be back for sure. read more

Really great pizza at a great price. Love the crust. Also they have great pasta dishes too. Very reasonable prices.

I've only ordered take out from here and the pizza is always great and so are the garlic rolls. On the phone, everyone has been friendly so far. read more

Best stromboli south of Philly! Service is always great. The pizzas are also delicious in the traditional New York style. But, in my opinion, the stromboli is the best bang for your buck. read more

16" Cheese Pizza (Large) half pepperoni half cheese and a tomato, spinach and bacon Stromboli.. let me tell y'all, y'all haven't lived if you haven't had food from johny... food is amazing I highly recommend.. if you want real pizza, johny is where you wanna go.. such a nice gentleman he is. read more

Pizza Johny's - 16" Cheese Pizza (Large) half pepperoni half cheese and a tomato, spinach and bacon Stromboli.. - Pizza Near Me - Miami, Florida

I have loved Pizza Johnny's for years but service has declined exponentially. I live less than 2 miles from the shop and last order waited THREE HOURS for delivery. Tossed it up to a fluke! Today, same experience and after 2 hours of no delivery and calling to check on order, we were told it had not left yet. I asked to cancel order and they said they would not do that! It is now 8:20pm and i am being forced to pay for a dinner i wont be able to eat and which wilk arrive cold...and the person answering the phone hung up on me. Sadly, Bye Pizza Johnny's! read more

Very disappointed with quality of food this time Delivery was quick but even the pizza was awful and onions were somehow pre cooked or it appears it was and soggy. read more

See all

Supper good old style pizza CLASSIC good with care and service Taste was amazing Chicken Wings was delicious read more

It's hard to find good NY style pizza in Miami. A few notable places have come and gone but Pizza Johny's beats them all. I'd be curious for Dave Portnoy to try a slice here. I think he'd judge it be very good and certainly the best in South Florida. There are other great pizza places in Miami. I can think of Steve's and Miami's Best right off the bat but they aren't really NY style. For that, you best bet is Pizza Johny's read more

I use to love this place and have been a patron for a very, very long time. Today was an indication of how low this establishment has gotten. I called ahead and ordered my food. The person confirmed and even wrote my name even though it was in the system. I even asked what I had last time and he seemed so confused that I just gave him my usual order. When I arrived and gave my name surprise, surprise they didn't have anything by that or my phone number. Everyone seemed super busy running around but there was nobody in the restaurant. The baker who may have recognized me and my frustration got in and tried to fix the thing only to tell the front desk lady to take my order again. She takes my order three times still very confused didn't know or maybe didn't want to be there in the first place. It is sad that this will be my last time ever going to Pizza Johnny's! It was a great establishment literally built on blood sweat and lots of tears (Johnny's tears) a lot were from his ex wives! So long Pizza Johnny! It was a great run! read more

This Jersey Girl gives Johnny's a 5 Stars rating! So glad I've found this truly authentic Pizzeria. Reminds me of home! Totally recommend! Zepoles like you've never had them in Florida. They make them on the spot. read more

See all

Having heard so many of my close friends rave about Pizza Johny's pies, I figured I'd finally give it a shot Saturday night. I picked up the phone and called ahead to place the order, which they gladly took over the phone. My drop dead gorgeous girlfriend & I opted to get the medium Prosciutto & Arugula Specialty Pizza alongside a half order of garlic rolls which came out to the total of $23.52. Once we arrived for pickup we were warmly greeted by the staff, adding more to the excitement I had to try the pizza. We waited a few more minutes before I heard "MR.!" followed by my name. My order was complete and prior to handing it over, the friendly staff member opened the order up to ensure I was satisfied with the order to which I was. After seeing the pizza, I could hardly contain my excitement any longer! The moment we got home, I slammed the movie on and grabbed a slice. At first I was in awe at the freshness from the ingredients, but very quickly after a few more bites in I became increasingly morbidly confused. It turns out that Prosciutto & Arugula Specialty Pizza uses an oil & herb base rather than the traditional tomato red sauce. This was pretty devastating for after two slices of the pie, I just couldn't bring myself to have another bite. Not to say the pizza was bad, it just felt like it was missing a crucial ingredient that without it, gave the pizza more a salad/sandwich feel rather than of a pizza lover's experience. Add to the fact that the rolls weren't as good as I've heard as it just felt like I was consuming more bread. Maybe my batch simply came out bad? Overall I was pretty disappointed, I really thought I was gonna enjoy my order as it was something unique I'd never tried before on a pizza, let alone been to the famous Pizza Johny's. Still the customer service was phenomenal, greeting each customer coming in as well as greeting the regulars by their names to add that family atmosphere to the store. Therefore, my recommendation is that for those of you whom have never been to pizza johny's I will strongly advise you to stick with the classics like the cheese or pepperoni pizzas to really be able to get a taste of Johny's cooking. As the great Gucci Mane once said, "If a man does not have sauce, then he is lost. But the same man can get lost in the sauce."Although I won't be back soon, I hope the next time I visit I'll be experiencing the latter rather than the former again. read more

See all