3/20/25 Ate List: Chicken Ranchero Pizza - 6.8 Meat Lovers Pizza - 7.1 We are a Pizza Fiesta house. LOVE this pizza. It's the perfect drunk slice. It's an amazing, not too greasy sober slice. Hell, there's a strong possibility we'll be having some after our wedding. Tried the Chicken Ranchero because it was popular on Postmates. It's solid. Very unique taste. Not good enough to exchange for a more standard pie but if you're looking for one to "switch it up" this one will do it. The Meat Lovers was better in our mind. Not better than your standard cheese or Pepperoni but still good. Just flagging one thing, might not usually get called out - dont order their small Pizzas. Pay the couple extra bucks, get a pizza that's more normal size. Paying $40 for these two smalls which were smaller than most frozen Pizzas was jarring. Highly recommend that you don't put yourself through that. read more

Pizza Fiesta - Meat Lovers Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

Reasonable neighborhood pizza. Nothing to write home about. The online ordering process was perfectly reasonable and used a fairly standard platform. The staff were all friendly and easy to work with. The vegetable pizza was a nice baseline option, and I added banana peppers. I highly recommend requesting additional sauce on the side. The crust was fine. They were clearly hand tossing dough in the back of the kitchen, but this isn't a long ferment situation. This is crust that offers a sufficient substrate and nothing more. There was some browning, but it's not clear that the oven was particularly hot. This was more of a "put the pizza on a conveyer belt" type operation, rather than a ripping hot brick oven operation. Even so, it was fine. The Greek salad was a salad. Nothing to write home about. The iceberg lettuce was. The red onions were fresh. The croutons were a little excessive. I'm not actually sure why they didn't close the deal and add banana peppers and tomatoes. Also, canned black olives rather than anything remotely Greek. All told, the pizza did its job. The salad did its job. Perfectly serviceable pizza, but there are better options around. read more

See all

Great place and was open late. It was $5 per topping which is crazy. I like the way the pizza was cooked, but I usually like more char. read more

Pizza Fiesta - The outside! - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

Walked in and ordered our pizza, which was ready in about 10 minutes. It was served fresh from the oven and was delicious - crust was great, sauce is flavorful and the cheese is stringy! There are tables and chairs for those who wish to dine in and plenty of take out business too. read more

Pizza Fiesta - Medium Meatball pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

My sister ordered 2x 12 PC Fiesta Wings on penn avenue and the wings were overcooked and dry. We were very disappointed in the quality. read more

Pizza Fiesta - 12 PC Fiesta Wings - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

A gem of a place in an area with a lot of great options. Food (5/5): This is the perfect pizza for parties and large group gatherings. Good balance of sauce and cheese. A little on the greasy side if you get pepperoni. The 2 provided ranch cups is a great bonus and the quality is similar to Eat'n Park (for you Yinzers). Service (5/5): I got takeout so there was little interaction. I requested for the pizza to be ready at a certain time and it was. The staff were friendly and helpful in providing me plates and napkins. Price (4/5): I'd recommend the coupons to get a deal. Otherwise, it's not the cheapest pizza, but it's hard to get a large 1-topping for $10 anymore. read more

Pizza Fiesta - Half pepperoni, half cheese with provided ranch cup - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

This is my go to Pizza Fiesta spot especially during First Fridays on Penn Ave. The Buffalo Chicken pizza is my favorite and I've devoured a personal size one by myself once. The fries on top of them and the spiciness of the sauce is everything I could want and more. This pizza alone keeps me coming back. The location is convenient and the staff are patient. read more

Pizza Fiesta - Buffalo Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

very rude and I placed a order waited 2 hours and never got a pizza and got hang up on I called back to store and they did not even place the order and again this pizza place hang up on me and there vary dirty and place pizza in the trunk of the car im not getting this pizza ever again don't order here pizza is not good read more

I got the chicken tenders platter it was really good and came out fast. The staff was all super nice and the place was cool and clean. I love that it's open late. read more

See all

Best Pizza and Gyros in the East End. Very prompt delivery service Big variety menu and great Cheescakes. Brintell St. Stanton Heights read more

Pizza was pretty decent. The crust did taste a little cardboard like but the flavor was good. I would order it again. read more

Pizza Fiesta - An empty pizza box - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

When looking for some simple but reliable pizza or similar Italian American items, give Pizza Fiesta a try. They are quick and efficient with their services. Tonight, I ordered something simple: just the spinach and feta Fiesta rolls. Every order of the rolls comes with 8 of them. They are also served with ranch and tomato sauce free of charge. Price wise, it was a little on the expensive size, even when considering the portion (which was moderately large but not outstanding). The flavors, though, were quite good. These rolls were crispier than I had expected. There were slightly charred bits of cheese on the ends, which I loved. Plus the extra little cheese on top always adds a nice touch. It's filled decently enough and you can taste the feta. Spinach tasted frozen, though. Dough was great - soft on the inside, fluffy, and a nice outer shell. All in all, I can't complain about this place. It's a nice pizza shop that's undoubtedly convenient. The Fiesta rolls (especially the spinach and feta) are pretty good. 3.7/5 read more

Pizza Fiesta - Spinach and feta Fiesta rolls - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

Fast service. Great selection of foods. I had a great salad. Crispy fresh lettuce , ripe tomatoes, crisp cucumber slices , croutons , red onion and the house made Italian dressing is delish. Clean inside , friendly employees. Cool atmosphere. read more

It's consistent, nothing too fancy but nothing unexpected. A tad pricey but, hey, supply chain. So, to use the word "generic" may come off as a dig. It is exactly what you imagine when you think of pizza in its basic element. There is nothing that really gimmicky or unique about it. It's just "pizza" and I actually like it. read more

I'm from New York and this is the rudest I've ever been treated at a pizza shop...the pizza is good but the service is trash

I'm really surprised how great this place is. It's like a hidden gem I'd never paid attention to. They have an extensive menu but it's not too much. Some places have crazy menus that read like novels. It's nice to have a decent variety at a pizza shop. We had an Italian hoagie, gyro and fries. Really tasty with fresh ingredients. Specials are cheap and lots of food. There's a small dining area that's decorated with black and white framed prints, modern tables and chairs and nice flooring. Staff are super friendly. Will be back soon. read more

Pizza Fiesta - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

This is 'utility' food...you order it cause you're hungry, not for the refinement is the cuisine....I get that. They seem nice delivery was prompt! However The picture of their gyro has hand sliced gyro meat, and the gyro I got had that frozen pre-sliced crap. I just can't give three or four stars to a place that has a misleading picture of one of its dishes is all. Oh, and it ain't cheap. read more

Pizza Fiesta - Gyro - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Too notch pizza in pgh. Never soggy, hot, flavorful pizza. The offered menu choice options are a go to without needing to pay by the topping (unless you want to). chicken ranchero is where it's at people (but they're all good) . I've ordered dozens of times. read more

Mildly hole-in-the-wall feel concealing the many culinary delights offered by one of the most convenient junk food lunch stops in Pittsburgh's Garfield neighborhood. Has an overhead map of Italy as the sole decoration - which is odd because the staff here come from a variety of ethnic and national backgrounds, none of them Italian. That said, you can definitely hear a variety of accents and languages from the kitchen, a testament to the city of Pittsburgh's diversity. If you have traveled a lot, you might meet someone from a country you have been to behind the counter and have a chance to practice whatever rusty language skills you developed abroad. The people who work here are nice and incredibly patient, and some of the dishes are quite creative for an establishment that otherwise doesn't look like much. The seafood pizza is fun and can be ordered with potato wedges as a topping (highly recommend doing so) and the lunch specials are an amazing deal: if you do go for the weekday lunch specials, you can get the most bang for your buck out of a single pizza slice (which is quite large) with a side of fries and a beverage of your choice. read more

Best ranch in the city! Pizza was great and service was excellent. They were super nice and helpful. Will be back :)

Great Pizza, I ordered the veggies pizza and made it last for 3 days. I will tell everyone to definitely give Pizza Fiesta a try. I look forward to another order and many more. Thanks Guyz read more

This is definitely my new favorite pizza shop! It was sooo easy to order & because i did order online it came with free breadsticks! No other pizza shop has a special like this. The food was exceptional also. Will definitely be ordering again. I ordered a 16" pizza , Italian Hoagie , 12pc Wings & got breadsticks free from ordering online. Here's read more

Pizza Fiesta - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

I'll update later... But amazing experience, super nice family, almost ruined by some rude Karen (Keith) customer.

I would really like this review to go VIRAL because they delivered something that was so much more than a pizza, it was a gift to my soul sister from afar. I live in NYC and wanted to do something special for my friend's birthday and asked (pleaded) that they help me do something creative with the pie. They DID NOT DISAPPOINT!!! Pizza Fiesta not only wrote "Happy Birthday" beautifully in the box, but they made the pizza into the shape of a heart, and lined the edges with pepperoni. IT WAS A GOSH DARN WORK OF ART!!! My friend was thrilled to say the least, not to mention she said it was delicious. It's people like the workers at Pizza Fiesta who are the unsung heroes of the food industry. They do things out of the kindness of their hearts while also delivering quality. A million thanks to Pizza Fiesta for saving the day!!!! read more

Pizza Fiesta - Huge thanks to those who work at Pizza Fiesta for making my friend's birthday SO SPECIAL!!! - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Service is always short and rude, but the food is fire so I don't even care. Cashier once rolled her eyes at me even but I still tip (very important) and always come back read more

I'm not sure how this place is rated 4.1 stars on google but man was I disappointed with my 5 cheese pizza. The only reason it was semi-tasteful was because of the ranch sauce and I typically never eat pizza with ranch. The feta cheese was almost rubbery and unappetizing. read more

Pizza Fiesta - a half eaten pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

April 12 9pm .. Welp. Let's just say this is the worst pizza place I've ever come across.. they charged me 60$ for one pizza. The girl seemed new so we said ok no biggy just refund it and charge me for the 1 large pizza we ordered. Got home . Completely wrong pizza. I called in to speak with the manager . She said i was wrong that i ordered "half pepperoni half sausage half mushroom. I said mam , there's only 2 half's in a pizza and I'm not sure why you're yelling at me when there's nothing correct on this pizza that I've now paid 80$ dollars for !!!! She said she'd refund me and it NEVER GOT REFUNDED.. yelling at customers for your mistake is not a good look. We tipped big because we do understand mistakes. Please take your business else where people read more

This is by far one of the best thin crust pizzas I've ever had! I'm a New Yorker but let me tell you Brooklyn might have to start calling these guys for tips because everything about it was immaculate. Seriously, if you're looking for a good slice in Pittsburgh this is the place to stop. read more

Pizza Fiesta - Deliciousness. - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Okay, so where do I start???? I thought long and hard about leaving this review but concern over safety and health comes first nowadays. So here we go................... I had fiesta once before and it was good enough to try it again. I ordered online and went into pick up my hoagie. When I went in the first thing I noticed was that there were five employees working. Two of which had masks on the correct way and two that had masks on over their mouths but not the nose. I commented to the man helping me at the counter about that and he immediately defended his lack of any mask at all due to his asthma. Correct me if I'm wrong which I am not, if you have asthma you should be wearing a mask as a precaution for your safety. Here is one of the reasons I am writing this review..... HE IS THE GM OF THE STORE!!! A place where food is made and prepared and out in the open!!! The second reason is that the woman that started to prepare my food was one that had her nose exposed!!! I noticed and mentioned that to the GM. He did tell her to put her mask on. I then watched to my already confused and disgusted horror that she stopped touching my food and pushed her mask on but still left her nose exposed!!!!! But what was really nasty is that the gloves she had on went from my food to her mask back to my food!!!!!??????? I told him there was no way I was going to eat that!!! The GM was flustered and said he would make a new hoagie for me. I told him just forget it and give me a refund. He did apologize. But at that point it was a lot, not a little too late!!! So here are my legit concerns. If your leader has no mask and is not following CDC/government guidelines why should the employees??? No sanitizer of any sort at all for customers. The one pen out for customers was just that, ONE pen. It's safe to say that one pen has not and will not be sanitized for each use. I am not some freak about this Covid thing but really??? Come on pizza fiesta!!! Think twice about giving them your business based on this honest and factual review. If they don't follow simple and common sense health safety what makes you think they are washing their hands and always wearing gloves??? The owner should be appalled and if this is allowed then he or she may already know proper health procedures aren't being followed. It all starts at the top and you lead by example. I have been in the food industry for years and I know this to be a huge breach in food safety, CDC, OSHA, and the health department. It should be noted that the GM knows who I am as I signed up online with fiesta. So I am hopeful that the owner follows up before I call the health department. EWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! read more

Dank piksa and fast af boiiiiii. I eats it hella times and it's always gnaaaaaar ‍‍‍‍ read more

After hours of misfortune, this was the only place we found open at 8:00 on a Friday in COVID times. We ended up in Pittsburgh while traveling for job interviews and were not expecting every one of our recommended spots to be closed. The hotel desk offered this and 2 other pizza restaurants (both closed at 8pm) and Dominos (hard no). So Pizza Fiesta it was. It's a solid pick. We ordered pizza with pepperoni and sausage. The edges of the pepperoni were slightly crisped to perfection without burning the cheese. Flavorful and fast delivery through Doordash. It's not a gourmet pizza kitchen or anything but it's perfect for a late night meal or post drinking! read more

Botched pizza served by an extremely rude and aggressive lady. there was a puddle of grease over the whole pizza like nothing I've ever seen before. There's no way she could have looked at that and thought it was acceptable and together with her attitude I wonder if she did it on purpose. I got napkins to soak it all up but the pizza underneath was no good because the cheese was hard and thick and nothing would stay together, it was just a sloppy mess. when I showed it to her she was already hyped up to fight me which seems to confirms she was being hateful giving me the pizza like that. I threw the rest in the dumpster. be careful when you enter this place. read more

Pizza Fiesta - This wasn't long after the pizza was made..... falling apart and disgusting. - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

I live above this pizza shop. My landlord is the owner of the pizza shop as well. I could be starving and still not eat this pizza. If you don't eat it when it's hot it turns rubbery and completely un-edible. Our hallway has had an on and off leak for three years that has now turned into a mold situation that our landlord has refused to address or fix. If he's like that with an apartment where three young kids live, I'm afraid to see what happens behind the scenes at the pizza shop where food is served. read more

I hate to give a review after ordering one thing and having it delivered, however; I've had so many bad experiences with pizza shops around me, that I'm excited to finally find a place close to my apartment that delivers a good quality pizza. The pizza had a great flavor, the cheese tasted fresh and the ranch dipping sauce was great. The prices are so affordable and the pizza is high quality. I've now found the ONLY place I will be ordering pizza from in the future. read more

New pizza, burgers, gyros, and other comfort good spot opened about a year and a half about by a nice family from Kyrgyzstan. They have lunch specials and are one of the latest places still open of you're on Penn after a show, gallery opening during Unblurred, or other event. If you become a regular, they'll even occasionally share Boortsog and other Kyrgyzstan dishes that the staff each together with you :) read more

Pizza Fiesta - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

This place has absolutely the best pizza you will find anywhere in Pittsburgh! They're also open late everyday for late night munchies. Don't go anywhere else. read more

Staff was hard-working and nice, restaurant is super clean and aesthetically pleasing. Pizza was cheap and fantastic, and anytime I'm in garfield, I would definitely eat here again!! read more

We were staying at the Sheraton in Station Square. This pizza was the one that delivered to us. We got two large pepperoni pizzas. They were delicious they came with ranch inside the box and I was confused but once I tried it with the pizza it was delicious. A great drunk food for the end of our night. Will definitely be ordering again when we come back read more

It pains me to say that I can no longer recommend Pizza Fiesta. Living a block from this shop, I ordered nearly every week the past few months for their reasonable prices, unique buffalo sauce, and complimentary breadsticks with every order 10 bucks and up. And up until now, it had been pretty great. Recently though, this place has taken a nosedive. Smaller portions, no more complimentary breadsticks, and horribly rude staff. I will say that their buffalo chicken hoagie was one of my favorite in the area but I just can't bring myself to frequent this pizza shop any longer until they reevaluate their attitude towards customers. read more

They did an excellent job love the names and desperation of the communitu and legal action keep on doing what is best for ur exsquisit resturuant and community get together location Much love, Bizett read more