Pizza is amazing! Their food quite frankly for a delivery service is great. Love the portions as well. The delivery staff is great and very friendly especially if you are a "regular". Cant really comment on the actual restaurant portion because Ive never sat down and ate there but if you want a decent pie, this is the place for it. read more

I'm a VERY picky pizza person. I could eat pizza every single day of the week. I live very close to this pizza shop and I love their garlic knots! I usually order for delivery, and I usually get my order within 40 min of me calling. The only complaint I have is that sometimes when I call, I am on hold for EVER. I do understand I may call during some busy times as well so thats a factor. but I will say, I love the knots as well as their pizza! read more

Great pizza, good service and really nice pizza spot in Brooklyn to dine in.

Decent pizza try the BBQ chicken and chicken roll. Uses really good fresh food. The women on the register is really nice. Whenever I order I ask for her everyone else just seem to mess up my order. Overall great place and order from them now read more

Great pizzeria! I order frequently from this place during lunch break. Their pizza has wonderful thin crusts and their salads are fresh. The staff are always nice and friendly, regardless of how busy it gets sometimes. The batter on the onion rings and fries are perfect and coated well. My co-workers always order the chicken caesar and spinach alfredo slices. Will definitely be coming back for more! read more

One of our favorite pizza joints in the neighborhood. We love the pizza there, specifically their grandma slices. Pasta is top notch. Our kids love their penne vodka and the Spaghetti with Meatballs. Takeout is quick and their dining space very cozy. We've had big parties come to set up for family dinner and they were so great about it. read more

Their pizzas made with exquisite taste! The place look amazing btw. Great food, great peaple, great service, one word describes them GREAT.

Have been coming here for a little while on fairly regular basis. The pizza is consistently good. Its thinner crust and not oily at all. Really good pizza and they have decent variety. read more

This restaurant is what I like to call dressed to impress!! The place looks absolutely beautiful and that's exactly how the food tastes too! I grew up in Brooklyn and when I was out there visiting friends they brought me to this new amazing pizza place. I have missed that perfectly cooked, home-style, Brooklyn pizza and this place hit that right on the head. I am going to visit my friends more often just so we can go to this place! It's a great environment and an amazing mouthful! read more

We love pizza daddy. Bring our out of town friends here for a great dinner. Big portions. Friendly service. Latest favorite is the meatball parm hero. Kids live the spicy wings and cheese pizza. The sons are great at providing customer service. read more

Really good pizza. I live a few blocks away and passed by all the time however the name was off-putting (I guess with pizzerias you are guaranteed credibility if the business has an Italian name lol). I decided to stop in about 3 weeks ago on a random day and I was impressed. I went in almost everyday soon after. So far I've tried their chicken cutlet slice, grandma, grandpa, chicken bruschetta, ham and pineapple, the spinach alfredo, pepperoni/sausage (meatball?), and the chicken parm. All were delicious. I also believe the sauce is missing a pinch of or an extra pinch of something. It's certainly tomatoe-y though. So far: - Generous on sauce (I'm a sauce girl). - The specialty slices are hearty and thick so you get your money's worth. They don't skimp on toppings - The crust is delicious. It's soft and doughy/bouncy but still have crunch. It doesn't get soggy and limp when you reheat it in a microwave Again, really good pizza but I have to deduct one star for something others have pointed out: the temperature of the food. I thought it was just me but the pizza isn't very hot when they heat it. I ordered a chicken parm and again, it wasn't very hot so it's not just the pizza. Not sure why this is. Maybe I should let them know I'm not in a rush and they could leave it in for longer. Very interested in trying their other items. read more

The Employees are amazing! The enviroment is so cozy and relaxing. I order almost every week and sit down and enjoy the view from the upstairs. read more

These guy have out done themselves when it come down to it specialty slices are amazing I would recommend this place to anyone

I usually order the pizza daddy pizza the special pizza at that they make its great! It like a hamburger on a pizza with mozzarella! Also, the dissert with pasta and nutella is great and savory! read more

Pizza Daddy is an excellent start up pizzeria. With the basics: pizza was tasty, fresh, and crisp. Continuing on - the heroes were also very good (especially the sausage and peppers, as well as the chicken parmigiana. The staff were kind and courteous and the dine-in area was clean, unlike many other pizzerias in the area. read more

just ok. i mean it has all the makings of greatness. Original Italian recipes that somehow are getting watered down into a plain tasting everything. from the grandma slice which just lacks that special grandma taste. We ate the vodka sauce just eh. Pizza delight dessert was basically not edible (we think they made it wrong). Fried raviolis no good, soft, couldnt eat them either. They do a nice job and seem to really care so I am still giving them 4 stars and ill order again but, they have work to do. How can anyone say that their sauces are tasty? read more

Staffs were not really that friendly but I went here because of the pizza so I don't really care as long as you'll give me a slice of pizza. The best spinach pizza I've ever had. Because of their spinach pizza, it made me love more the flavor and now it's my most favorite pizza. It's creamy and cheesy! read more

This family owned pizzeria is absolutely gorgeous! An amazing atmosphere. The pizza is delicious and also, garlic knots are out of this world. The specialty pies are awesome! My family loved it and my twin daughters couldn't stop saying I want pizza from pizza daddy! Dont miss out on a pizza daddy experience! read more

I know it is wrong but I had no interest in trying this place because I didn't like the name. I didn't think you could get good pizza from a place that sounded more like a pizza chain than a neighborhood pizza place. About a week ago, I was hungry and tired and walking home from the train. I didn't want to detour to find food so I stopped in and got a slice. It was good! I tried a different slice a few days later and that was also good. A few days after that, I convinced my husband we should order delivery from Pizza Daddy. At first, I thought something was wrong with my pepperoni roll. I couldn't figure out why it seemed so different from all the other pepperoni rolls that I've eaten. Then I realized the problem was that it was so fresh and I am used to dried out, reheated Pepperoni Rolls. Wow, there are so many bad pizza places that it's gotten to the point where fresh and delicious seems weird to me. We also got mozzarella sticks and a shrimp cocktail. All were good. We'll be ordering from Pizza Daddy from now on. read more

There are many options to choose from. I ended up getting the Buffalo chicken with scallions and ranch slice. It was delicious! The crust was crunchy and the flavors were undescribable. I will come back and try the others. The staff were very nice and welcoming. read more

Pizza Daddy - Buffalo chicken with scallions and ranch. $3.51 - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

It's a crime to come to Bensonhurst and NOT come here and try the Buffalo Chicken pizza.

Pizza is not fantastic - but their entree's and pasta are to die for! GET THE ALFREDO! read more

We came here a lot since we live around the neighborhood. However, food quality and services going downhill compared to when they first started. First of all don't expect much service here. They wouldn't greet you whenever you enter unless you open your mouth and order something. Or the boss wouldn't even look at you. Second of all the food quality is getting worst than they first started like mentioned before, What I mean is we went there when it first open it was okay but recently pizza always not heat up at all. Also we always asked for extra sauce with their signature pizza "Big Daddy" but often time is like we am the homeless begging for some changes on the street. What really get us out of this place is there is couple times we send the kids to order and always end up disappointed. Is rather they being cheap on the sauce or pizza are burned. Sometimes they over charged the kids. I mean come on are you taking advantage of the kids because they don't know better?? Anyway if you looking for some quick pizza and don't mind service and quality be my quest. But if you looking for good quality food and service AVOID this place. read more

I went there. I was so impressed by the place nice people , had a plain slice and it was good but the lasagna was HORRiBLE. Omg that's a disgrace to the Lasagna society. The " Lasagna" had mini meatballs made of pedigree or I don't know what hell of Lasagdog was. Thats not beef. So if you are Muslim. Forgetta about it. read more

I come here a couple times a month on my way home to grab a quick slice. Their pizza is really great. The people are super nice and the kitchen and dining areas are so clean (you can see the kitchen from a little window). I love this place and I am picky about my pizza. read more

An excellent White Pizza. I have tried grilled chicken with arugula salad and It was delicious. California chicken whole wheat wrap is delicious as well. They signature lentil soup cannot be found anywhere else. I saw how they scrub down their kitchen. I am an extremely sensitive eater. Easily get food poisoned, but never got food poised from this place. Clean and tasty place! read more

I am from New Jersey and was in brooklyn with friends, when we were looking for a place to eat, we found this great Italian pizza restaurant on the corner of 65th street and bay parkway, their pizza was one of best I've tasted in a long time, we all enjoyed the pleasant atmosphere with the window bar-style seating and an elevated dining area, I only wish one would opened up in New Jersey real soon. read more

i don't see how anyone can give this place negatives, my experiences have been all good so far, eating at the counting and ordering delivery. Their regular pie gives you one of the best classic Brooklyn slices, and the Margherita is very nice brick oven style with fresh mozzarella and basil. The servers and pizza guys have all been really nice every time I have stopped in. read more

Finally a good place to eat pizza in my neighborhood...best brick oven pizza I have had in a while. Pizza was fresh and even warm after my 5 block walk home with it. The restaurant itself is great, very clean inside, will absolutely order again! read more

Atmosphere is pretty nice, but pizza.. there's way better out there. Its not a true authentic "Brick Oven". There was a group of us, we ordered diet dr. pepper. the guy says OK no wait, I'm waiting on a coca cola shipment, than asked for mineral water, i get Poland spring. i said this is not mineral water, "no we are all out". Some soda spilled, the owner or whomever came over nasty as hell as if she bit into a lemon is wiping it up, and as much as we apologized she had a stone face and if looks could kill! BAD FOR BUSINESS!. But we stayed because we really wanted to try the pizza, nothing to brag about! read more

Food is really good but the people that work there are disgustingly RUDE. They need to work on their hospitality . If you don't mind attitudes then surely try their food . read more

This place is great came in ordered some rolls and pizza and let me tell you delicious every time and what a show the works do they work very hard and at the same time keep there cool and is exciting to watch them work I will defiantly be trying kitchen food soon. read more

So I place an order at 543 pm on a Wednesday, 2 whole pies. Now pizza daddy is on bay pkwy and 65th street. I am located on 14th and 65. So after the gentlemen on the phone tells us a half hour, I call back at 645... 1 hour and 2 minutes later. The guy tells me that there is no way that he told us a half hour.and that the food hasn't even left yet. Now this isn't the first time we ordered from them, but he proceeds to tell me that we are really out of the way... don't you think you should have said that before you told us 30 minutes? How about every other time it's not an issue. Now I have 4 kids starving and it's one of their birthdays, and all I get from them is we are liars.. no way I said 30 minutes. Your company is a joke, your customer service skills are horrible you definately lost customers. Thanks for ruining a kids party read more

Had at my friends house and I thought it was awesome. Nice thin crust. Great sauce and flavor. Not too salty like the other places. I will def go back. read more

Best pizza! I LOVE their Margarita pie! Delivery is always fast. Staff is great, never had an issue. Haven't tried much else here, but based on other reviews it seems all their food is great. read more

olive pizza was very salty. good customer service nice place but not somewhere I will go again.

I called inn to make an order for pickup and when i got there 10-15m later and asked about it, he said they will start making it now....WTF!!!!!! I called in advance on purpose!!! Food here is good, but customer service is horrible. read more

Only went in because my 7 year old likes this place. Walked in, three guys standing around, no greetings, no smiles. There was basically no service. But the place is nice. Sorry but i would expect better from a place that just opened. What a waste. Youre in bensonhurst, not cobble hill or park slope, please hire new staff! Ill just stick with l&b and pizza wagon. read more

This place is horrible I order a small order, I took me more than 30 mins to wait. Will never come back at all. The owner doesn't respect customer at all. I will never come back. Only a few people waiting, they don't have enough people working at all. This place is all mess. Don't go to this place guys. U will see what I am talking about it u ready go. read more

Pizza Daddy was just as expected....Delicious!!! I brought my two little boys there and they loved it. They usually eat a slice each but we easily finished a large pie. The decor was top of the line modern. Didn't expect a pizza place to look so nice. The family that owns it.......well lets just say "That's Italian". Excellent pizza and looking forward to more dishes. read more