How on earth have I never tried Pizza Daddy before? I was about to give up on my quest for the perfect rice ball. Other places just couldn't get it right, but Pizza Daddy absolutely nailed it. The peas, meat and rice on the inside was cooked to perfection and the outer part which is the crust of the rice ball combined with the amazing tomato sauce, ricotta and mozzarella cheese was heavenly and brought back happy childhood memories. With each bite, you can tell that love and high quality ingredients are used. We also ordered a vodka cheese pizzetta, which is a mini version of the regular size pie and is ideal for two people. This too was outstanding with a nice amount of cheese and vodka sauce and a wonderfully crispy crust. Delivery via Uber Eats was great and quick. Highly recommend. read more

See all

Ordered the pizza daddy for take out. Everything was ready by the time I arrived. The pie looked amazing and tasted great. Crust was still crispy even after a 15 minute drive. The pie was a little sweet, it's not like a typical pizza. All of the ingredients blended well together for a unique flavor. read more

Pizza Daddy - The 18" Pizza Daddy - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The Pepperoni Pizza, and Jamaican Beef Patties are The Best! I order from here many Times, and it's still Great!

Whenever we visit our cousins in Brooklyn, the first place we order food from in Pizza Daddy. We came into Bensonhurst last night and immediately reached for the phone to order. We got two pizzas, Margherita and traditional and a rice ball. The dough is soft and yet crunchy and so light. The sauce is sweet and the cheese is fantastic. Pizza Daddy for life baby! read more

Pizza Daddy - 18" Margherita - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

The calzone, chicken rustico hero and hangar steak hero from Pizza Daddy were delicious! Other places need to get on the same level of bread that this place uses because it is the best for a proper hero. Cannot beat the brick oven bread! The calzone was full of mozz and ricotta and the chicken rustico was loaded with grilled chicken, portobello mushrooms and provolone. The hangar steak hero was so flavorful and had plenty of steak, sauteed onions and mozz. Not one complaint at all about any of these items. Recommended for sure. read more

See all

Got here moments before closing 9:50 pm. Ordered the last Sicilian slice they had. Got my pizza in a bag, and left to my car that was on the corner. Opened the bag after sitting in the car, and my pizza was street cold. They should have just told me that the oven was shut down and not that warm, allowing me the option of having it or not, before selling me a cold slice of pizza. I mean cold. Won't be spending my money there again. Thanks Pizza Daddy, for treating me like an unwanted stepchild. read more

Amazing pizza! The crust was so thin & crispy. We got 4 slices: cheese, bbq chicken, supreme veggie & margarita Our fav was the bbq chicken & margarita. We will definitely be back & try the other topping slices! read more

Pizza Daddy - Clockwise: Bbq chicken, cheese, supreme veggie, margarita - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Pizza Daddy gets one star... the dough taste like rubber it was soft and didn't look or taste fully cooked ..I specifically asked for a crispy pie and received the total opposite and let's not talk about the extra chicken ...pizza taste like cheap $1.00 pizza... sorry the truth is hurtful read more

It's been five years since I last had Pizza Daddy, but the memory of their incredible pizza remains as vivid as ever. Even now, I find myself thinking about it, especially their unforgettable Chicken BBQ pizza. The Chicken BBQ pizza was always my go-to. The crust was consistently perfect, with a satisfying crunch that gave way to a soft, chewy interior. The BBQ sauce struck an ideal balance between tangy and sweet, blending seamlessly with the tender, juicy chicken. Every bite was a harmonious mix of smoky, savory, and sweet flavors, topped with just the right amount of gooey, melted cheese. The toppings were always fresh and plentiful. Red onions and cilantro added a delightful crunch and freshness that elevated the entire experience. It's the kind of pizza that stays with you, making you crave it long after the last slice is gone. Though I haven't been to Pizza Daddy in years, it remains the best pizza I've ever had. If you're in the area, do yourself a favor and try their Chicken BBQ pizza. It's a taste sensation that will leave a lasting impression. Son shit is fire dead ass I If you aint eating you stupid read more

Service is great and their pizza slaps! Love how these are one of the few pizzeria's that still honors a slice being equivalent to the price of a single fare metro card! I don't know why so many people are writing such harsh reviews for waiting on excellent pizza! It's the weekend guys and if it's busy of course you're going to have to wait! After reading the owner responses I respect the grind and the work they put in to serve our neighborhood. Thanks Joe! read more

Decent option if you happen to be craving pizza in the Bay Parkway area. I stopped by to pick up an online order of BBQ Chicken Pizzette (12") and Garlic Knots. Service was efficient as my order was ready to go by the time I arrived. If you are interested in dining in, this spot has window seating the front and table seating in the back. In terms of the food, the BBQ Chicken Pizzette was savory and delicious, and a good option for those who may be allergic to tomato-based sauces. The Garlic Knots had a strong garlic smell and taste to them without being overwhelmingly salty. read more

Pizza Daddy - BBQ chicken pizzette (12") and garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

To cut it short, Great pizza, Great service, and Great atmosphere! Have been coming here few days in a raw, I love it and my kids love it.

I had a couple of morning meetings at schools in the neighborhood and was hungry when they were over. I saw this place on my way to the BQE and stopped in for a couple of slices. When I walked in, shortly after Noon, it looked like they had just opened, as the place was dark with no customers. But, they were indeed open and ready to serve. I picked up a couple of slices to eat outside, since it was such a beautiful Autumn day. The slices were good, not great, but good. They were a bit smaller than I'm used to seeing, perhaps another COVID victim. The cheese to sauce ratio was fine. I just got the feeling there was somewhat too much oil on them, as the slices had that kind of aftertaste. I would return next time I'm around the area. read more

ANTONIO!!! MY GOODNESS!!! Your decision for me to order the Chicken Rustico wrap was a BLESSING to my taste buds. My goodness. If this Rustico wrap was personified I wouldn't be able to keep my hands to myself. I added bacon to the wrap so... SHORTY WAS HITTING THE SPOT. The pizza slices stayed INCREDIBLY HOT. I don't know what kind of stove magic you used to keep the pizza feeling like grandma took it right out but MAN OH MAN was it fresh. Jokes aside, I just want to express how grateful I am to your pizzaria. We've been served great food for several years and hope that you'll continue doing your best for many more to come. Bless! read more

Pizza Daddy - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I have been going to Pizza Daddy since they opened and I have NEVER had a bad meal from them. They are consistently excellent food, great service and and a large selection of options. Great place, can't say enough about it. read more

I order online from them a lot and they've only missed one soda so far which they brought it as a credit the next time. The salmon and it's sauce is amazing. Great service so far. read more

My mom loves this place ! It can't get any fresher than this, they pride themselves on fresh pizza and they always deliver what they promise ! I have no idea why people are leaving horrible reviews. They are know for their buffalo chicken pizza and it is a must get! My favorite part of pizza daddy is their crust! Ugh it is to die for and I am a pizza fanatic. A large half buffalo chicken and half pepperoni will be around 22$, I believe this is a pretty average price so no complaints about the price either ! read more

The food is very good quality and so is the service. I've had their pizza, plain BBQ chicken, Margherita and others. Pasta dishes are also good, meatballs are plump yet cooked well which a lot of places can't manage. Pesto sauce dish was newer and quite delicious. Baked ziti, stuffed shells and manicotti all recommended. Great place, good prices and excellent service read more

The reason for the one star is not because of the food, but of the customer service from the owner who needs I attitude adjustment. Food is delicious, one of the best in Brooklyn. read more

Horrible!!!! We have ordered from here before and it was good. But we will never order from here again. We ordered a grandma pie and it was full of huge chunks of onions. We also ordered a regular pie and the crust was terrible very lumpy and uneven. One side was very thick and the other was very thin. read more

Pizza Daddy - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Drove past Pizza Daddy a bunch of times & always wondered how their food tastes due to the nature of their eye catching name. It turns out that their food was exceptional. I ordered the Penne A'la vodka with grilled chicken which was super fresh. You can taste that the chicken had just came off the grill. YUM We sat upstairs which was comfy & had the servers deliver our food to us once it was ready. Don't have any complaints about this place :) read more

Pizza Daddy - Penne with Grilled chicken. - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Their pepperoni is very good; lots of pepperoni and very cheesy. Delivery was prompt too. What gives it an only 3-star rating is the Buffalo chicken. The chicken is not spicy enough and the dressing tastes like tartar sauce minus the pickles. C'mon guys, spring the extra dime on a $30 pizza and use Hidden Valley Ranch! Or better still, make your own. read more

Pizza Daddy - Half pepperoni, half Buffalo chicken. - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Excellent pizza! Such a great local spot. Highly recommend it. Bensonhurst has a lot of choices for pizza. This is one of the best around. read more

Came here the other day for a pizza and there was a wide range of choices. They had everything from sicilian to chicken marsala slice. The place is very clean too which is always a good sign I ordered the chicken marsala slice and I wouldnt say it tasted like marsala but rather a cheese slice with chicken and no sauce. The pizza was a little doughy but overall it was a serviceable slice. However, in brooklyn you can find better. I really enjoyed the grandma slice. The sauce was good and the crust was nicely cooked. That is why I bumped up the review to a 4 star. If you are hungry... this is a good spot for a slice. read more

Pizza Daddy - Chicken marsala slice... decent - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Literally, the worse customer service! I called to have a slice of pizza for pick up order. I work around the corner and couldn't leave my desk for very long. So I plan on grabbing the pizza quickly and rushing back to work. To my surprise the person who picked up the phone told me he WOULDN'T put my pizza to get heated in the oven because it's just a slice and I would have to wait for it to be heated when I arrived. Wow. That literally took me my surprise. That was horrible customer service, you just lost a customer due to their ignorance for not treating customers like customers. I purchase food from a pizza restaurant down the street and they gladly had my pizza warmed and ready when I got there. This place really need to rethink their strategy about customer service. It's simply not right! Might I add, the owner responded to my review with a defensive attitude and faulting the consumer (me) instead of trying to make it right. Mm, any-who. I will gladly take my business elsewhere and I feel complete satisfaction about writing this review! read more

Stupid staff service. We are ordered small grilled chicken pizza and medium alfredo spinach, but stupid guy bring to us two both large size. read more

40 min wait for a takeout. McDonald's is down the block. Less money and the same amount of attitude. Don't waste your time here. Update: 2 mins after the sentence above was posted, a worker decided to yell at me while I was still standing there. I come here every now and then to know that the "food is not microwaved." My one star came after that unnecessary comment when I asked how much longer our food would take. Don't promise 20 mins when it cannot be fulfilled; tell me 40 and I would've waited somewhere else. If the the guy who took our order was just as mean, I would've left it at a one-star rating. However, he was nice and not so "commentary." read more

Horrible customer service. Really rude people. I was ordering from there and I called to double check and the man literally no jokes screamed at me. Like why have a nice pizzería and have horrible customer. Here is a suggestion for the workers always be nice no matter how stressed you are and if you can't handle your job. LEAVE! I don't recommend this place. read more

Grabbed pizza here one night durin a walk w the family. Tried the grandma slice and it was not impressive. Ive had better pizza from my corner pizzeria. The pizza wasnt warm enough, cheese was not melted, and crust wasnt crunchy. In response to the comment below, i do not get nothin from Yelp except for email alerts for friend requests and msgs. I have somethin called a life, so when i do have down time, i do Yelp and hence, that is why i have an account. Instead of stating u guys will work on to improve ur pizza, u assume people get paid to review ur shop. Smh. read more

Pizza Daddy - First initial response from owner. I was gona edit my review to a 2 star being that the spot has nice decor until he did the next thing.. - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Can't miss the place located on Bay Blvd & 65th St. in Bensonhurst/Mapleton, Brooklyn. Their sign is huge and visible from a driving distance. Kudos to their brick oven pizza. Amazing grandma pizza. Place is clean and cozy. We got here by 7pm. Have luck trying to find a parking spot if coming by car. Must have been a busy night. We ordered take out that was fast, and ate it in the car. Over all, I'll come here again. read more

Pizza Daddy - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I live across the street and around the corner from this pizzaria. It opened up a couple of weeks ago and I've been eyeing it and meaning to check it out ever since but never really got around to it until today. What a shame because this place is awesome! The decore is very modern, clean, and pretty. There is a sitting area in a slightly elevated half of the restaurant. It looked nice and spacious but I was here to get something for dinner. When I first walked in the guy behind the counter greeted me and was very friendly. I took a menu and was looking it over. He offered to explain anything and told me that their special was a homemade lasagna which he would recommend as it was delicious with fresh mozarella and mini meatballs. It sounded too good to pass by, so that's what I got along with a large iced coffee. The lasagna (you can see my picture!) was as good as described. It took a bit of time and it was clear that it was made fresh. No regrets at all as it was amazing. Other things of note: they have a good selection on their menu in addition to just pizza and pasta: there are paninis, salads, calamari, buffalo wings, burger, wraps, and rolls. There was also this ceasar salad pizza that was sitting on the counter looking really tempting. Also they have Hale&Hearty soups (New England Clam Chowder! I don't know anywhere else in the neighborhood that has that!). So five stars because I support new businesses and this place has friendly employees, a good selection, and a clean and neat decore. Looking forward to seeing you again Pizza Daddy. read more

Pizza Daddy - Lasagna is delicious! - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

** 3.5 stars ** New pizza joint opened on the highly visible corner of Bay Parkway and 65th Street, still pending posting their full menu but they have pizza and calzones. Attractive, red-hued space with window bar-style seating and an elevated dining area, contemporary mosaic accents. Traditional order counter, pizzas on display behind glass. The igloo-like ovens are not traditionally looking nor obviously brick. Distinct cartoon logo and goofy name somewhat mismatched with the place. We ordered a pie topped with fresh mozzarella, basil, and tomatoes. Fifteen minutes later, we got the fresh pie and toted it down the block to try. Thin-crust, texture reminds me a bit of cornmeal but it isn't, just enough toppings to accent, good taste. Would prefer crispier crust. A solid pizza, and better than everything else in the neighborhood, besides Spumoni and haven't tried Europa's version. Not destination good, but an excellent addition to the neighborhood. Will update when they roll out the rest of their menu and have some time to warm up. read more

See all

Went in and ordered two sandwiches. Chicken cutlet parm and veal cutlet parm. I could not believe how bad they were. Hard, shredded when you bit into it, and you better have good teeth cause it was like chewing rubber. This place use to be good, sorry to say there not anymore. I just can't believe how downhill the quality of the food is. What happened to this place in the last two years. ???. I would never ever go back, unless your into rubber read more

I love a good decent Brooklyn pizza, however, Pizza Daddy didn't do it for me. I still think Di Fara's has the best pizza in the borough of Brooklyn. I heard L&B Spumoni is great too, but I haven't eaten there so I can't agree yet (until I try it). Pizza Daddy markets their pizzas as "brick oven", but I really did not taste the "brick oven" flavor. I was very disappointed. If you want brick oven pizzas, travel to Manhattan and visit Adrienne's Pizza Bar (that is the epitome of what a brick oven pizza should be). I understand that it is a recession, and businesses have to be a bit stingy. But don't be that stingy. The pizza did not have enough mozarella cheese and tomato sauce on it. Not to mention that the pizza bread itself was very thin, and not crunchy. Although Pizza Daddy didn't excite my tastebuds, it is way better than Torre's in the neighborhood. read more

He loves it when you call him big PI-zza, but Pizza Daddy will do. This loft-style modern pizzeria is situated on the busy intersection of Bay Pkwy and 65th street. You can't miss the animated signage outside. The branding is clever, the display is clean, well-lit, and plentiful, but at the end of the day every specialty slice tastes like an interpretation. When you're in Brooklyn, you especially want a smothered hearty slice which when you take a bite, has unmistakable flavor. Here the ingredients are held back; a light smattering of buffalo sauce, small diced chicken and dainty scallions adorn the surface for example. If your slice isn't dressed enough to mop up the extra rolling off with a piece of crust, there is something wrong. Nevertheless, priced reasonably at $3.50 for a special or $2.75 for a Neapolitan you get a decent slice with upscale ambiance. Sitting upstairs in their never-crowded dining area with large windows and two large TVs casually playing in the background makes taking a pause from all the Brooklyn outside a lot easier. read more

Who the hell taught these people how to make pizza ? I literally took a slice out of the box and rolled it like a rollatini. Pizza is supposed to make a crisp and snap sound when you fold it. If this is your idea of Brooklyn pizza shut the friggin place down. I'm embarrassed for you. OK first of all it was Friday night June 19th 2020 and I live six blocks away 11204. I have no idea why Yelp listed me from San Francisco. I'll say it again you have NO IDEA how to make a pizza. read more

Nice location. Everything looks new. Service was pretty quick even though they were busy. Friendly service. Good selection of pizza, wraps and heroes. Had their chicken parmigiana hero. Bread was nice and crispy and not soggy. Had a generous amount of chicken. It was not dry. Had a perfect amount of cheese and sauce. Better than your average corner pizza shop. Looking forward to trying their other stuff on the menu. read more

Pizza Daddy - Chicken parmigiana hero - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This place took over 1 hour for delivery and I was 3 blocks away. The pizza it self was a bit overpriced and somewhat tasteful but then my stomach felt like it was going to pop.. Add on..... Now you must be on something man, the pie wasn't that huge so relax, second of all I think me and friends all had something going on with our stomachs. Plus it took longer then an hour ... on top of that I told you to come to the 6th floor after I bused you in and still I had to come all the way down yeah .. You as an owner of a business talking to a customer like they are you friends and making the review look real here you go I actually I'm changing 2 stars from 3 because I didn't really see service in till you posted to the review. One more thing I said a BIT overpriced not OVERPRICED LIKE ITS A MILLION DOLLARS... read more

This place has the best salads always fresh. The best slices are the chicken bruschetta and Buffalo. It's family owned so support small business in this pandemic. It's hard to find parking it's a busy area but once u do enjoy great food. read more

Best pizza in all of Brooklyn. Love coming here for the food and company! The grilled chicken with garden salad, clam chowder soup, chicken parm, and fried calamari are my favorite from their kitchen. Definitely wish the location was closer to my home! read more