Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Pinkerton's Bakery

    4.5 (25 reviews)
    Closed • Closed
    Updated 3 weeks ago

    Pinkerton's Bakery Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Pinkerton's Bakery

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Dennis G.

    This was awesome. I love art deco restorations and this building and decor are well maintained. Friendly folks there who take pride in their food. My daughter had an almond croissant that she loved. And I had one of the best egg sandwiches ever...fluffy eggs, cheese, some delicious garlic-tarragon mayo and homemade English muffin. And the coffee was excellent. GO THERE!!!

    Zingy: (Cross Between A Linzer & Other Goodness)
    Mercedes C.

    My Yelp friend, Jane D. recommended I check out this bakery in Kingston, NY. From the moment I peeked at their menu, I was totally into it. One item, in particular, practically called my name: the passion fruit meringue pie. If you know me, you know I'm a sucker for anything made with real passion fruit pulp. It's not just a flavor I enjoy- it's one I grew up with in my homeland. For me, it's nostalgic and joy all in one bite or drink. When I first visited, I was bummed to learn they were completely out of the passion fruit meringue. Still, I didn't leave empty-handed. I grabbed a few goodies to take home, including an apple+hibiscus pie slice that my husband devoured and something else. Fast forward to my recent second visit: this time, I called ahead to make sure they had their famous passion fruit meringue and they did! I also picked up the veggie quiche slice which although had a nice list of veggies, they seemed to be resting on top only and not mixed throughout. It was also very eggy and maybe just a smidge of cheese. Then I finally got my hands on a mini passion fruit pie. As soon as I sliced it open at home, I caught a whiff and there it was. That distinct, tangy-sweet smell that took me straight back home. The meringue was cloud-like with the right touch of sweetness and perfectly browned on top. Just one bite and I was hooked. That lush, silky passion fruit center was rich, tangy and excellent. Everything I wanted. But something made me pause and started to wonder- was the curd made with gelatin? If you know me, I don't eat pork or any of its by-products. So I called and my heart sank when I was told it contains gelatin. As much as I loved that first bite of the passion fruit meringue pie, I couldn't eat the rest. The pie delivered everything I wanted flavor-wise, but pork/gelatin/lard haven't been part of my dietary lifestyle since my teens. And in their menu, gelatin isn't even listed in the pie description. If they made a gelatin-free version. I'd be the first in line.

    Passion fruit meringue
    Jacklyn K.

    I'll start with the most important information- the passion fruit meringue pie is one of the best things I've ever eaten!!!! If you visit Pinkerton's, this is a MUST ORDER. It is verrrryyy pricey but the quality is unmatched in the area. As a boulangerie snob, the croissants also stood out harsh critique. Textures, flavors and freshness all on point. The staff were friendly and welcoming. This spot is unassuming from the outside but top notch!!

    Mud Pie
    Hem B.

    James Beard award winning chef in the Outstanding Pastry Chef category, Angela Pinkerton, moves back to the East Coast to open the eponymously named Pinkerton's in a converted Gulf Oil station. Che figo, Italian for "That's so cool." I hesitated to write this review but after trying a few of her creations, I can emphatically state, she's the real deal! Although I took pictures of some baked goods and desserts, I've only tried two - a plain croissant and a slice of the passionfruit meringue pie. If someone can make pastry that is crunchy, chewy, yet light, airy and delicate at the same time, out of five ingredients, that's accomplishing something. That croissant was something. I know it's such a cliche but the passion fruit meringue pie was the best I've ever had. Seriously. Each layer (graham cracker crust, custard, passion fruit curd, bayleaf meringue) is very good on its own but the combination of crunch, sweet, tart, and slightly exotic/unfamiliar (passion fruit and bay leaf) tastes and textures altogether...redefined what a pie can be for me. I'll admit I'm having a moment here, fanboying on pastry and desserts, of all things. I haven't even tried the chocolate croissant, apple, quince & cheese danish, or the mud pie yet because it would be too much of a good thing. I recommend you try it for yourself. If you have the time/interest, here's a wonderful article: https://hudsonvalleyone.com/2024/11/22/pinkertons-formerly-pie-society-of-berkeley-takes-over-cake-box-in-kingston/

    English muffin and egg sandwich with bacon
    Bob P.

    Delicious English muffin and egg sandwich. Very, very friendly people behind the counter. Highly, highly recommended.

    Jason B.

    The much anticipated Pinkerton's (8 Fair St) is now open. Angela Pinkerton, former pastry chef from 11 Madison Park (3 Michelin Star), made her way to Kingston via San Francisco. Taking over the old school gas station space that was Cake Box for over 30 years. We are not talking old school Italian or German bakeries like Diesings. Think Dominque Ansel or whichever hip bakery in Manhattan is doing some laminated croissant riff and pies with strange herbs and fruits. Even uttering the words 11 Madison Park, raises the bar so high, I don't know how they could live up to the expectations. I've been to Pinkerton's twice to try an array of pastries. The owners are super pleasant and easy to talk to. Nate's laid back California vibes and tattoos are a welcoming ice breaker from the stuffy over the top pastry case. I've had the passion fruit meringue ($8), apple pie ($6.50), quince and cheese danish, mud pie with coffee and hazelnuts ($8), croissant, jalapeno monkey bread, and a pecan sticky bun also an array of cookies from chocolate chip($3.50), pecan snowballs, and ginger yuzu snaps. The croissant was perfection. The delicate layers of crunch wrapped around the buttery pillowy insides. The only other croissant to challenge its throne locally would be from the Bartlett House in Ghent. Chocolate chip cookie was thin with lots of crunch. It still had some soft spots in the middle and a healthy dose of salt on top. The Passion fruit meringue was the one I was looking forward to the most. I much prefer the bright zing of the passion fruit to the sourness of a lemon. One bite and im confused. Why does this have the slightest hint of thanksgiving? It was next to the turkey pot pie in the cooler? After asking Nate, I realize I didn't read the fine print and it has a bayleaf cream. Why? The quince danish has herbs on top also. The danish is out of this world with the same crunchy lightness and butteriness of the croissant. The apple, quince, and cheese filling is delightful but bam Thanksgiving once again. The Mud Pie is over the top deep rich chocolate with coffee in the background making it deeper with brownie pieces on top. I'd say a mix bag for me but the flavors might work for you. Rosemary, sage, thyme, basil or any random herbs can stay on the savory side of my meal. To each their own. Overly complicating ingredients to sound trendy or fancy doesn't always work. These profiles didn't work for me but man was that croissant top tier . Above Photography https://www.instagram.com/b.overly_delicious/-- in Kingston.

    See all

    6 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    30 days ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 months ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 1
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 10
    Thanks 4
    Love this 11
    Oh no 1

    10 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    11 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 months ago

    Life-changing passionfruit meringue pie. Best croissant in town. So lucky to have them!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 3
    Oh no 2
    Photo of Bob P.
    9
    62
    17

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of June M.
    0
    184
    5

    1 year ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Tasty cookies and pastries and the coffee ain't bad either. The building is also iconic.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 4
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    BEC & iced chai - easy 10/10. This is delicious. Seriously good. Cool interior, friendly staff, quick service. So worth it.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Lil Z.
    1
    10
    3

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Sooo yum, loved the croissant especially. Cute space, good pastries, nice staff. Loveeeed it.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    Ask the Community - Pinkerton's Bakery

    You might also consider

    Rough Draft Bar & Books - No books were harmed.
    -W.Shakespeare 
 "The need for mystery is greater than the need for an answer"
    -Ken Kesey

    Rough Draft Bar & Books

    4.6(191 reviews)
    0.8 mi
    •$$

    My wife has found her new absolute favorite bookstore! I think it is an incredibly thought out and…read moreperfectly executed bookstore meets bar meets cafe. We were about an hour away where this is typically around 5 hours away so knew we needed to check it out being so close. Snagged street parking easily and even just the vibes of the outside started off our experience so nicely. Located at what is dubbed Four Corners that is I believe the only remaining intersection in the US that has pre-revolutionary stone houses on all 4 corners. Such an amazing sight to see the old architecture. Rough Draft has utilized the space so perfectly. Worth visiting even if you are looking to just browse. I highly recommend trying a coffee or tea drink to start your day though and a baked good. If those aren't your cup of tea grab a beer or wine then. My wife got an Iced Mocha and loved it. I went with one of their current specials, "I Know What You Did Last S'more". It was so good but was unique compared to a typical s'more coffee drink since it had espresso and smoked black tea. I also had a chocolate croissant while my wife had a maple palmier and we enjoyed both. We snagged some window seats and it was the perfect way to enjoy the drinks and baked goods. My wife loved browsing the books and thought it had so many unique books she hadn't seen at other bookstores. Which it really is more than just a bookstore with the cafe and bar vibes! Highly recommend everyone check it out, if you can. We look forward to coming back!

    I have so many good things to say, where do I even start?!…read more First of all, this book and bar spot is absolutely beautiful. It's located on such a charming street, and stepping inside felt like walking into an elevated Barnes & Noble straight out of a Harry Potter movie. There are endless shelves of books across every genre, cozy seating throughout, and the perfect atmosphere to spend hours browsing or reading. The coffee was just as wonderful as the space. I wasn't sure what to order, so the barista recommended a drink and was incredibly accommodating with my many requests. I can't have too much milk or syrup, so I basically gave them a complicated custom order, and they made it exactly to my liking without hesitation. I also ended up buying one of the chocolate bars they had at the counter and turns out it was $20!!!! As a tourist, I had no idea it was a well known local chocolate brand with a factory nearby, so that was a fun surprise. This is the kind of place that makes you want to slow down. I'd love to come back, grab a coffee, spend the entire afternoon reading, and just soak in the comforting smell of books and fresh coffee. Such a cozy, magical spot that's well worth visiting!

    Photos
    Rough Draft Bar & Books
    Rough Draft Bar & Books - Clever display

    Clever display

    Rough Draft Bar & Books - The bar

    See all

    The bar

    Village Coffee and Goods - Lentil Burger! A delight.

    Village Coffee and Goods

    4.3(127 reviews)
    0.6 mi
    •$$

    Village Coffee was the best coffee I found in the surrounding area. The espresso is excellent, with…read morereal attention to detail, and the breakfast sandwiches are OUTSTANDING. I went three times during my visit and had a different sandwich two times...both were incredible. I also really loved the music they play, which gives the whole place such a great atmosphere. Village itself has a small amount of seating, while Little Village has much more room to settle in, plus Wi-Fi if you want to stay awhile. Great coffee, great food, great music. I'd absolutely make this a regular stop anytime I'm in Kingston.

    Tiny spot on the corner of a street by the railroad. If you don't know about this place you are…read moreunlikely to find it. I must warn you, don't walk in hungry. The smell inside will have you drooling harder than a boxer puppy smelling a pizza. Unfortunately I forgot to save the photo I took of the delicious display of pastries. That display certainly hooked me. Came in for coffee walked out with delightful bites I couldn't wait to dig into. One of which was a strawberry danish. That crust was amazingly light and flakey. Layered strawberries, center with a little cream and that cream topped off with some lemony drizzle. Oh just pure goodness. Prices VERY reasonable. Coffee is outstanding. Desserts are dangerous. You will want to say "One of each please" and you won't regret a thing.

    Photos
    Village Coffee and Goods
    Village Coffee and Goods - Cortado in little mug by local pottery shop

    Cortado in little mug by local pottery shop

    Village Coffee and Goods

    See all

    Uptown Coffee

    Uptown Coffee

    3.7(49 reviews)
    0.6 mi
    •$

    When I entered there were two people chatting with the barista (owner?) and I was hard pressed to…read moreorder. They were discussing football very strenuously. Little options: no decaf, only one alternative milk choice. I opted for the mocha and I will say it was delicious. I ordered a small and was given a large cup but she explained she ran out of small cups so it's a small size in a large cup. Not an issue, but all of it together left an unpleasant taste. Mocha was yummy, but not sure it was tasty enough for me to return to this unwelcoming space.

    I walked in with no one else in the place. There was no music and one person at the counter on her…read morephone. I asked for a bowl and she very abruptly expressed that she was only doing a limited menu today, no bowls. She could make an egg and cheese sandwhich and it would be 10 minutes. I said I was willing to come back and ordered the sandwhich. As I stepped away, I watched the woman behind the counter go back to her phone. No wonder the place is always empty. There was NOTHING welcoming about the experience. If I wasn't so darn hungry, I would have said "forget it." The sandwhich itself was really good, and a great price (compared to the rest of uptown Kingston), which I appreciated. She thanked me for coming back for the sandwhich and that was that. Really too bad the place isn't more welcoming. They'd have more customers from nearby offices, I'm sure.

    Photos
    Uptown Coffee
    Uptown Coffee
    Uptown Coffee - Round room

    See all

    Round room

    Deising's Bakery - Pound of cookies

    Deising's Bakery

    3.7(193 reviews)
    0.9 mi
    •$$

    After having lunch at a nearby restaurant, we saved room for dessert because we had seen this nice…read morebakery on our way through town. Very clean inside and beautiful display cases make you want to eat everything in sight. We opted for some cookies and a couple of pastries to take home. We also got a couple of cannolis because- well, because. Plenty of parking in the area in a Sunday afternoon and when we entered there were only a few customers but when we were leaving after having checked out, the place really got a rush. Some tables and a diner type counter allow you to have some of your goodies inside while there are also tables on the outside. Prices were very reasonable and I was surprised at the final tally for all of what we bought. The staff were really friendly and most importantly helpful in making choices. They offered best sellers and personal favorites. Of course, they have some beautiful cupcakes and pies and cannolis as well as homemade sweets for the kids. ( Big and small kids). Well worth the visit to grab a coffee and treat yourself to very good and fresh baked goods.

    Generally their baked goods are terrific, yet this last time-- very tasteless. The cupcakes were…read morestale and felt like biting into saw dust; the mocha "thing" was creamed to the hilt but didn't taste like anything-- 'cause tasteless and the napoleon was sugared to the hilt. We actually contributed these items to the garbage bin. A waste of $$, time --and attempted use of taste buds!! So out of character! What's up Deisings??

    Photos
    Deising's Bakery - Too funny

    Too funny

    Deising's Bakery - Starting off the meal with some Pecan French Toast

    Starting off the meal with some Pecan French Toast

    Deising's Bakery - Yumm-o

    See all

    Yumm-o

    Calcutta Kitchens - Raagda Pattice

    Calcutta Kitchens

    4.1(24 reviews)
    0.8 mi

    Ulster County used to be my home and I've noticed Calcutta Kitchens during my travels through…read moreKingston. It's one of the businesses on that stretch of Broadway to endure while others have changed hands. So the other day, I decided to take a peek inside and find out what's for lunch. Chicken Vindaloo. There was also a vegetarian option. Each cost $15. The vindaloo was really delicious. I could smell it as soon as I walked in. The location is both a gift shop/ market and restaurant. There's dry goods and ready-made foods for sale on the shelves as well as brightly hand-painted gifts such as food storage containers and kitchen towels.I bought both as gifts for friends. I also got an order of vindaloo to eat-in along with unsweetened ice tea. The meal was delicious. The business owner is gracious and helpful. Her ready-made lunches are served in what look to be attractive eco- friendly paper containers. When I let her know that I couldn't finish my meal, she smiled and said," I'll give you a cover for the container so you can take it home." The cover fit perfectly and was secure. I let her know that I'd be returning for lunch and shopping another time.

    Such a shame that a place like this has so much potential but the owner can ruin its vibe. It's not…read moremy first encounter with her. All my experiences with her have left me with a bad taste in my mouth and I have overlooked it until recently. She's not nice, she tries to be pleasant but comes off insincere. Recently I spent almost $100 there and ate there. The meals come with a very small/trial size condiment/chutney that holds maybe a tbsp of content. I asked for another one and she was hesitant, she told me that I could buy them and pointed to a shelf. Seriously, I couldn't believe it! I asked again and she reluctantly gave me a different condiment babbling about how there are different ones. Nm that I just spent a lot of money for mediocre food! The frozen butternut squash and lemongrass was very watery and lacked flavor. I used it as a broth that's how watery it was. The hot chai was bland and watery with no taste of spices. The chicken curry was decent but again lacked depth of flavor and was on the watery side. It's very sad bc I like Indian food and want to support local businesses but not when you're treated like this esp by the owner who is very cheap and unpleasant. Food has gone downhill and watering everything down to cut costs doesn't help. And it's way overpriced like other reviewers state.

    Photos
    Calcutta Kitchens - Interior

    Interior

    Calcutta Kitchens - The menu was on display.

    The menu was on display.

    Calcutta Kitchens

    See all

    Fantzye Bagels

    Fantzye Bagels

    3.9(34 reviews)
    1.0 mi

    Coming from nyc I was not phased by the pricing as most patrons seem to be on yelp. Listen. This…read morebagel was AMAZING. I got a rosemary salt bagel with cream cheese, greens, and shiitake mushrooms. So glad I ordered this although I was not sure what to order because the menu had many unique, delicious sounding bagels. The bagel was made with great attention to detail! The shiitakes were cooked with butter and salt. The greens tasted lemony. Everything complimented one another very well. The bagel was a little tough but everything was so delicious. The iced mint latte was cooling and refreshing. Also incredibly unique. This was delicious and I'd eat here again if I were to return to Kingston!

    Sourdough bagels! Yessss finally someone is doing these. Doing them well. Ordered the whitefish…read morebagel and the shitake mushroom one. White fish bagel - came in a container split in half. Loaded with whitefish and a heaping mound of micro greens and dill covering a layer of cucumbers. Bagel was oh so perfectly airy and had that sourdough flavor. If it wasn't for the hair I found on it 3/4 of the way eating it I would give this place a 5 star. But hey stuff happens Shitake mushroom bagel - wrapped like a regular bagel. Excellent schmear and a great amount of mushrooms. Really stands out as a unique bagel. Prices are pretty high. Is it worth the price? Eh not so sure about that but it is definitely delicious and worth a try

    Photos
    Fantzye Bagels - Frontal

    Frontal

    Fantzye Bagels - The Big Lox

    The Big Lox

    Fantzye Bagels - Cortado

    See all

    Cortado

    Restaurant Kinsley - Stay Crispy: (W/ Gochujang Dip)

    Restaurant Kinsley

    3.9(105 reviews)
    0.7 mi
    •$$$

    Since hubs was in the area he had noticed Restaurant Kingsley and coordinated with me so we could…read moregrab early dinner nearby after I got out of school. This whole time, I really thought this place was inside a cozy hotel about 2 blocks over. Guess you learn something new every day. We pulled up on a Thurs. around 4 with no res. and got seated real quick. Restaurant K. is airy, chic and gives a relaxed vibe. The menu is on the smaller side, but honestly, there's something for every eating style. We kept things light instead of diving into something heavy. Our spring greens salad was really good: hefty mound of mixed greens, lima beans, string beans and a hint of dill to make everything pop. Hubs had the double-stacked burger with white cheddar on a potato bun and loved it. I had high hopes for the hush puppies because they sounded amazing on paper- but they were doughy than corny and threw me off. Then came dessert. Again- sounded great on paper. It kinda feels like desserts get a "reinvented" treatment here(?). For instance, the strawberry shortcake was deconstructed: a few chunks of white cake, some diced strawberries and whipped cream. Totally unexpected. I ordered the 'Fun-Fetti Dunkaroos' with madeleines because they caught my eye, but they're smaller than standard. The food isn't bad at all. We were just caught off guard by how some of our selections were prepped. What really saved the evening were the cocktails. They were beautifully made and had a lot of strength. No watered-down nonsense here! Plus, our server Karina(?) was super sweet. I asked if I could try the passion fruit purée to see if it was the real deal for one of the cocktails I ordered and she brought me a little sample. Passed the test!

    We love stopping for a mid day beverage on hot summer days. Perfect spot for people watching and…read morepost-farmers market hang. Service is friendly brunch has been decent! We mostly stop for a sip!

    Photos
    Restaurant Kinsley - Loving Out Loud

    Loving Out Loud

    Restaurant Kinsley - Dig In: (Hubs' Double Patty+Cheddar+Pickles) He Liked It

    Dig In: (Hubs' Double Patty+Cheddar+Pickles) He Liked It

    Restaurant Kinsley - Gin & Tonic Kind Of Evening: (Hubs' "Supersonic")

    See all

    Gin & Tonic Kind Of Evening: (Hubs' "Supersonic")

    Pinkerton's Bakery - bakeries - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...