Came here on pi day to try their franken-pie. I loved being able to try a bunch of different flavors in one. All the flavors were so delicious! My partner and I almost devoured the whole thing in one sitting. I'm not up in the area often, but definitely want to stop by again for some of their other baked goods! There are a couple of tables so you could eat your food there. Bathroom is clean as well. read more

Pinkerton's Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Kingston, New York

See all

This was awesome. I love art deco restorations and this building and decor are well maintained. Friendly folks there who take pride in their food. My daughter had an almond croissant that she loved. And I had one of the best egg sandwiches ever...fluffy eggs, cheese, some delicious garlic-tarragon mayo and homemade English muffin. And the coffee was excellent. GO THERE!!! read more

See all

Great sandwiches, great treats, and great people. These negative reviews are asinine. I can't wait to go back! #EatingOutwithBrianRicci read more

Pinkerton's Bakery - Passion fruit Meringue Pie - Bakeries Near Me - Kingston, New York

My Yelp friend, Jane D. recommended I check out this bakery in Kingston, NY. From the moment I peeked at their menu, I was totally into it. One item, in particular, practically called my name: the passion fruit meringue pie. If you know me, you know I'm a sucker for anything made with real passion fruit pulp. It's not just a flavor I enjoy- it's one I grew up with in my homeland. For me, it's nostalgic and joy all in one bite or drink. When I first visited, I was bummed to learn they were completely out of the passion fruit meringue. Still, I didn't leave empty-handed. I grabbed a few goodies to take home, including an apple+hibiscus pie slice that my husband devoured and something else. Fast forward to my recent second visit: this time, I called ahead to make sure they had their famous passion fruit meringue and they did! I also picked up the veggie quiche slice which although had a nice list of veggies, they seemed to be resting on top only and not mixed throughout. It was also very eggy and maybe just a smidge of cheese. Then I finally got my hands on a mini passion fruit pie. As soon as I sliced it open at home, I caught a whiff and there it was. That distinct, tangy-sweet smell that took me straight back home. The meringue was cloud-like with the right touch of sweetness and perfectly browned on top. Just one bite and I was hooked. That lush, silky passion fruit center was rich, tangy and excellent. Everything I wanted. But something made me pause and started to wonder- was the curd made with gelatin? If you know me, I don't eat pork or any of its by-products. So I called and my heart sank when I was told it contains gelatin. As much as I loved that first bite of the passion fruit meringue pie, I couldn't eat the rest. The pie delivered everything I wanted flavor-wise, but pork/gelatin/lard haven't been part of my dietary lifestyle since my teens. And in their menu, gelatin isn't even listed in the pie description. If they made a gelatin-free version. I'd be the first in line. read more

See all

I'll start with the most important information- the passion fruit meringue pie is one of the best things I've ever eaten!!!! If you visit Pinkerton's, this is a MUST ORDER. It is verrrryyy pricey but the quality is unmatched in the area. As a boulangerie snob, the croissants also stood out harsh critique. Textures, flavors and freshness all on point. The staff were friendly and welcoming. This spot is unassuming from the outside but top notch!! read more

Pinkerton's Bakery - Passion fruit meringue - Bakeries Near Me - Kingston, New York

Wow! What a bakery! So my husband was hungry so we went to this Italian deli in Kingston. He told me to check the reviews on a bakery across the street (which was vegan- no thanks), so Pinkerton's came up next. I went in and found all the reviews about Angela Pinkerton and what an amazing pastry chef she is. Well, they weren't lying! I had THE BEST croissant of my life- I was able to peel back each amazing layer. My husband got a plum and apple hand held pie which was soooooooooo good as well. We are going to Quebec next week to find the best croissant and all we had to do is come to Pinkerton's in Kingston! Their staff is friendly and warm and the place is adorable outside and inside. I told my husband it's a good thing we don't live that close because it would be dangerous. . DEFINITELY come here- it's amazing! read more

Pinkerton's is doing things right! Housemade English muffins - yum! Looking forward to the passion fruit meringue pie! The wallpaper in the bathroom - nice touch and I need some! Friendly service and the space is cute and ever so tidy! Thanks! read more

James Beard award winning chef in the Outstanding Pastry Chef category, Angela Pinkerton, moves back to the East Coast to open the eponymously named Pinkerton's in a converted Gulf Oil station. Che figo, Italian for "That's so cool." I hesitated to write this review but after trying a few of her creations, I can emphatically state, she's the real deal! Although I took pictures of some baked goods and desserts, I've only tried two - a plain croissant and a slice of the passionfruit meringue pie. If someone can make pastry that is crunchy, chewy, yet light, airy and delicate at the same time, out of five ingredients, that's accomplishing something. That croissant was something. I know it's such a cliche but the passion fruit meringue pie was the best I've ever had. Seriously. Each layer (graham cracker crust, custard, passion fruit curd, bayleaf meringue) is very good on its own but the combination of crunch, sweet, tart, and slightly exotic/unfamiliar (passion fruit and bay leaf) tastes and textures altogether...redefined what a pie can be for me. I'll admit I'm having a moment here, fanboying on pastry and desserts, of all things. I haven't even tried the chocolate croissant, apple, quince & cheese danish, or the mud pie yet because it would be too much of a good thing. I recommend you try it for yourself. If you have the time/interest, here's a wonderful article: https://hudsonvalleyone.com/2024/11/22/pinkertons-formerly-pie-society-of-berkeley-takes-over-cake-box-in-kingston/ read more

See all

Delicious English muffin and egg sandwich. Very, very friendly people behind the counter. Highly, highly recommended. read more

Pinkerton's Bakery - English muffin and egg sandwich with bacon - Bakeries Near Me - Kingston, New York

The passion fruit pie is absolutely divine, and their holiday customer service regarding an accidentally sold pre-order was above and beyond. Will definitely be returning. And telling others to do the same. read more

I was in the area today and decided to do what I usually do, google bakeries. I bought the cherry almond crostata, which I have just found out is an Italian version of a tart. It's almond past with cherries and I thought it was delicious. I had no idea what a crostata was but it looked good. Well, It looked like a tart but the sign said "crostata". The almond paste was yummy and nothing about the tart was too sweet. It was just right, including the crust. And I'm picky about crusts. The man who waited on me was very personable and friendly. I see from reviews here that this is a new bakery owned by a well known pastry chef. I'm in the area once in a while for hiking and general exploring and would love to return and try other choices on their menu. They also have breakfast and other items along with pastries, pies, and cakes. read more

Tasty cookies and pastries and the coffee ain't bad either. The building is also iconic.

stopped by this morning for the first time. hardly anything in the cases I was looking to bring something to work for everyone to enjoy for breakfast. I was told they didn't have anything and maybe I could try Deisings. As I was walking out an employee very sarcastically yelled "goodbye have a nice day". Don't waste your time stopping. Have never seen a bakery like that. read more

The much anticipated Pinkerton's (8 Fair St) is now open. Angela Pinkerton, former pastry chef from 11 Madison Park (3 Michelin Star), made her way to Kingston via San Francisco. Taking over the old school gas station space that was Cake Box for over 30 years. We are not talking old school Italian or German bakeries like Diesings. Think Dominque Ansel or whichever hip bakery in Manhattan is doing some laminated croissant riff and pies with strange herbs and fruits. Even uttering the words 11 Madison Park, raises the bar so high, I don't know how they could live up to the expectations. I've been to Pinkerton's twice to try an array of pastries. The owners are super pleasant and easy to talk to. Nate's laid back California vibes and tattoos are a welcoming ice breaker from the stuffy over the top pastry case. I've had the passion fruit meringue ($8), apple pie ($6.50), quince and cheese danish, mud pie with coffee and hazelnuts ($8), croissant, jalapeno monkey bread, and a pecan sticky bun also an array of cookies from chocolate chip($3.50), pecan snowballs, and ginger yuzu snaps. The croissant was perfection. The delicate layers of crunch wrapped around the buttery pillowy insides. The only other croissant to challenge its throne locally would be from the Bartlett House in Ghent. Chocolate chip cookie was thin with lots of crunch. It still had some soft spots in the middle and a healthy dose of salt on top. The Passion fruit meringue was the one I was looking forward to the most. I much prefer the bright zing of the passion fruit to the sourness of a lemon. One bite and im confused. Why does this have the slightest hint of thanksgiving? It was next to the turkey pot pie in the cooler? After asking Nate, I realize I didn't read the fine print and it has a bayleaf cream. Why? The quince danish has herbs on top also. The danish is out of this world with the same crunchy lightness and butteriness of the croissant. The apple, quince, and cheese filling is delightful but bam Thanksgiving once again. The Mud Pie is over the top deep rich chocolate with coffee in the background making it deeper with brownie pieces on top. I'd say a mix bag for me but the flavors might work for you. Rosemary, sage, thyme, basil or any random herbs can stay on the savory side of my meal. To each their own. Overly complicating ingredients to sound trendy or fancy doesn't always work. These profiles didn't work for me but man was that croissant top tier . Above Photography https://www.instagram.com/b.overly_delicious/-- in Kingston. read more

See all

BEC & iced chai - easy 10/10. This is delicious. Seriously good. Cool interior, friendly staff, quick service. So worth it.

Kingston is so lucky to have this award-winning chef Pinkerton open her bakery Café here. She's brought her experience from both coasts to the Hudson River Valley i made from and very unique. You won't be disappointed.!! The ambience and staff are very down home and welcoming read more

See all

Delicious fresh baked pastries, cookies and the best Chicken Pot Pie! We had lunch in the cute little cafe area. So many delicious options we had to take some home. read more

I'm so thrilled that they are so close to my house maybe about 3 miles away. The current scones are the best I've ever had in my life. I have shared them now multiple times and everyone just freaks out at how delicious and wonderful they are. I went in on Sunday 4/13/25 to pick up some scones to share and a cake/pie to take to a party. I ended up getting the passionfruit meringue, not only was this the prettiest pie, but it was just spectacularly delicious Everyone I shared it with was just blown away!! . Good job well done so happy to have you in the neighborhood.! read more

Sooo yum, loved the croissant especially. Cute space, good pastries, nice staff. Loveeeed it.

The bakery seems fine but there is no flexibility on breakfast sandwiches. Their English muffins leave much to be desired. Worse I've ever had, but they have good croissants. I was on my way to play golf and stopped to pick up a quick breakfast sandwich. I asked for an egg and cheeses on a croissant at which I was advised I couldn't get that because egg and cheese sandwich is only served on an English muffin. The guy even advised me it was unhealthy to serve it on a croissant which flabbergasted me. WTF. I was actually looking forward to the egg and cheese sandwich on a croissant which I only do occasionally but got nothing. They have croissants, eggs and cheese but I was forced into either one of their less than desirable English muffins or nothing. I found this totally absurd. I live around the corner from this bakery and frequented the Cake box that was the prior establishments. I. Was looking forward to a new experience but got this absurdity so have not returned. read more

Simply the best upstate bakery.. no its not the donuts you grew up with in Mapleton, NJ.. This is a legit 11 Madison park pastry chef who happens to live (and thank the lord cook) upstate.... Everything is beyond.. please don't order the fruit pie by the slice as they may run out before I arrive! read more

This place is so good, it's both a blessing and a curse. I will be increasing my cardio so I can eat whatever the chef makes. To wit: jalapeño monkey bread, apple turnover, tiramisu, a slice of Boston cream cake, lovely little ricciarelli. Everything was fantastic. I went in not knowing anything abt pedigree (EMP wow)...but good on Kingston for having this level of food here. Can't wait to try the chicken pot pie, the flaky looking croissants and everything else. read more

I saw so many nice pictures of what looked like nice baked goods so since I'm a fan of bakeries I thought I'd stop by. When I got to the counter and was ready to pay for what I ordered the man at the register was so aggressive when I asked a question that I practically ran out of there and decided not to go back ever. read more