We love Pielands! The pepperoni, garlic white, and veggie (Farmers Market) pizzas are all incredible. The staff is friendly and the atmosphere is very family friendly. Definitely check it out! read more

Staff were extremely rude; owner is defensive rather than helpful, food is overpriced and there are so many good pizza places in Atlanta so pick a better place because this isn't it. read more

Overpriced disappointing food! This was the second time I got food from here. I tried to give Pielands a second chance after being disappointed the first time but it got even worse. I ordered food for delivery and it came 30 minutes late. It seems like my food wasn't made until the driver arrived to the restaurant. I got the limited time chicken, bacon, ranch pizza. It barely had any cheese or chicken on it. I didn't taste or see any ranch on it. The buffalo wings were soggy by the time I got them. Won't be coming back here. I paid $45 for bad food. I could've paid less than $20 for dominoes which would've tasted better. read more

See all

The place was pretty busy as it was a Friday evening. Most people were ordering to go as it has a very small dining area and it's pretty much set up for takeout. I ordered the farmers market pizza to go. I called them to ask if it was possible to add garlic because on the website it says "No additional toppings". They checked and decided that request was an ok. I was disappointed that it was an additional $3.99 for fresh garlic yet I honestly couldn't find nor taste the garlic that much after biting into it, but such as it is. The pizza tasted very fresh with all of the veggies and there was a sweetness about it that complemented it very well. I'm not sure if it was the tomatoes that were sweet, but I did like the flavor. Unfortunately, the crust was a little overdone for my liking. I think this was just the luck of the draw. I'll try again next time and I'm not adding the charge of the sprinkles of garlic. I'll just put it on myself when I get home. Lol read more

See all

I don't like posting poor reviews but, for safety, I feel the public should be aware. Our pizza appeared to be undercooked. We tried it anyway and immediately experienced an awful case of food poisoning. We were up all night in pain and discomfort. Stuck in the bathroom, my wife was vomiting so much her nose started bleeding. I hope for the publics safety, this restaurant's health standards improve. read more

The service ok pizza was good the sauce also good the dough also nice and chewy could have used a little more garlic love garlic the guy that took my order friendly but the rest of the staff no hello the vibe from the staff not friendly Good pizza reminds me of home read more

Pielands Sub & Slice - Cheese slice - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

Hmmm, wish I loved it but I didn't hate it! The service was friendly over the phone and in person. Ordered the Italian Stallion and buffalo wings. The pizza was generous in size and the toppings portions were fair, but I think what was lacking is flavor. The crust needed more oil/butter plus herbs and salt - but the dough was actually great and tasted fresh. The toppings tasted fresh and high quality as well, but nothing stood out. 6.5/10 Also glad to report the wings were good. The buffalo sauce definitely has a kick and the wings are meaty, juicy, and cooked well. But if you don't like meaty wings, keep that in mind. Overall, my rating is just because I'm not sure if I'd recommend Pielands. When I pay a premium for pizza ($30+) I expect something special and/or to be blown away. This wasn't my experience but it also wasn't disappointing - which is a relief. I'd like to see this place get better! read more

Hi everyone! It's been a minute since I posted a review. One, the restaurant industry is not as interesting as it use to be! However, I came across a little gem! Pier and is a throw back to the pizza places on the corner in Pittsburgh! The pizza crust is actually a wonderful texture, and there are many toppings to choose from. The super cool thing is you can buy it by the slice!! For us real connoisseurs of pizza, this is heaven! Think of all the slices to try! The sandwiches were also a great treat! I love bread, and sweetheart, the bread is to die for! The salads are delicious, the calzone has just enough filling, so you're not just eating dough. I could keep going... oh, the Garlic Parmesan wings !! All I can say is this spot was a wonderful experience. Thank you Alex ,for being so pleasant If you've never been, it's worth the trip! read more

As far as I'm concerned, my search for Atlanta's best gluten-free pizza is over. I was heartened by the praise of Pielands' GF crust and found them to be overwhelmingly correct. On the menu, the sole GF offering is in the form of a square personal pan size, and it includes one topping. Additional toppings can be added for a charge (though celiac diners beware: none of the toppings are safe). I wasn't sold on the look of things when the pie first came out since it looked heavily browned and burnt, but the taste was outstanding. The sauce is sweet in a recognizably NY-style, with a crust that I wouldn't have known was gluten-free if I hadn't ordered it myself. It was crispy with good chew, and the Italian sausage I'd chosen as my topping was savory without being too salty. My husband ordered two grandma slices from the ready pans, and I'm afraid he was less than enthused with his choices. Both of his slices were floppy and oily. After tasting mine, my non-GF husband remarked that he should've ordered one for himself too. We both loved the chef's salad, which was a healthy serving and surprisingly robust with toppings like olives, tomatoes, cucumbers, cubed cheese, sliced salami, pickled onions, and pickled peppers. It was a riot of colors in a bowl and a great starter for our meal. Service at the counter was brisk and business-like, though they were happy to answer whatever questions we had about the menu. They bring the food to your table (which has a dedicated pizza stand! I love little details like these), but you bus your own tray and trash afterwards. Inside, the restaurant has a casual, retro dive-bar feel, with 80s tunes (at least while I was there) and even a Ms. Pacman game machine in the corner. There are a few tables for dining in, and several tables out on the sidewalk for those who prefer to eat outdoors. read more

See all

I recently tried their limited-edition barbecue pizza, and it was absolutely amazing. The flavors were perfectly balanced with the tangy barbecue sauce, fresh toppings, and that signature crust that Pieland does so well. I honestly hope they bring this one back because it was unforgettable. I enjoy coming here and the service is always great. If you're a pizza lover in Atlanta, Pieland is a must-visit--you won't regret it! read more

Pielands Sub & Slice - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

So this place is kind of tucked away but it's in the open if that makes sense. If you don't know where you're going you may not even see it. But it is a good gem and the neighborhood. It's located in the Virginia Highlands area and that area maybe small but it's very walkable. I came on Wednesday and they had dollar wing night. If you know how much wings cost in Atlanta, it's definitely worth it lol. I talked to the guys there, a couple of them, they were actually pretty cool. So we were their favors were and told me what they didn't necessarily like, since I was a first-timer. We are good conversation. They were just generally and genuinely decent when it came to conversation so I appreciate the customer service. There is indoor and outdoor seating and a TV you want to watch something. Didn't know what the weather is like, you may want to sit outside but at the same time it was too hot, you may not want to lol. But at least it's an option. I tried the garlic parmesan wings, I tried the lemon pepper wings, and I got a pepperoni slice as well as the pizza of the day (green granny). Also got a couple of garlic knots as well, just because. The parm wings were drenched in garlic parm and they were really good. The lemon pepper wings were okay, kind of like a lemon pepper semi wet. Comparing it to the level of wetness from the garlic parm (as you can see in the pics, its definitely a difference). But they were still good. The green granny was okay, if you like pesto. I was not sure what I expected, but it was the special pizza of the day so I went for it. The pepperoni slice was huge and had a good taste to it, the pepperoni that they used set it off. The garlic knots, I probably would not get again. They came out pretty hard and they were not worth the chewing (considering it was bread). Maybe this was an off batch, but still. Even in the pic, you can see them be a bit on the overcooked side. Overall, I would go back for another one of the Wednesday specials, it was well worth the money. read more

See all

Service is fine but the food is so inconsistent and I just had the worst meatball sub of my life, and that includes going through college. The meatballs had no flavor (have you heard of salt?) and the second meatball almost broke my tooth it was so dry. No marinara sauce. Seriously, come on. I'm nauseous from that sub. Pretty annoying because I'm walking distance but I'm done with this place. The pizzas can be good but not worth it. Sometimes they hold back on the toppings and I don't think they clean their ovens because the semolina flour at the bottom of the pizza is usually burnt. read more

I saw this place today looking for something to eat. Parking was amazing and wasn't bad at all. I order the pepperoni slice. It was really good and the crust was great on its on. The young lady at the counter who took our order was really polite and helpful. The seating area was open. A lot of room. read more

See all

I came back for a second time after a previously mediocre experience and boy was it a lot better and so good pizza-wise. We ordered to-go and on a weeknight and pick up was easy. Service was really great as our pizza was ready but they mentioned the garlic knots were still being warmed up - no biggie at all. The pizza was super good and hot. The toppings you definitely could tell were fresh. The garlic knots I still found to be lackluster and just doughy and a rather crispy near burnt bottom. With so many items on the many, next time I would opt to try another app to see! Would come back again to try another pizza or grab a slice to-go! read more

Pielands Sub & Slice - Italian Stallion 16" - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

So happy they have a yummy gluten free pizza crust! Even happier it's not thin and hard like a piece of cardboard. You can deck it out with the toppings you like. Staff has always been nice as well. read more

I'm so glad I tried this place. I just randomly decided that I wanted pizza. So I looked on Yelp and found this place. TikTok also highly recommended this place. So I got in the car and went there. Staff was friendly, and helpful. I didn't realize that they only have certain pizzas available for slices. So I settled on pepperoni and a white slice of pizza. It is fair to note that they also have sandwiches and appetizers available. I got two huge slices and it cost me $9. You cannot be that. And I am grateful bc the slices ended up being both lunch and dinner. So again, I was very happy with the price. It was nice to sit in the car, people watch in Virginia Highland and enjoy a hot slice of pizza. Small things in life :) Definitely worth coming back for. Grade: A read more

See all

Card only payments but 3% card processing fee? Just raise your prices 3%. Unavoidable fees are ridiculous. Otherwise, food is good and recommended. Always able to find a seat. Good selection of beverages. read more

First time going here. I'm normally disappointed by the food in Atlanta but this is honestly one of the best pizza spots that I've been to. Very delicious, the pizza is very flavorful read more

Pielands Sub & Slice - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

The pizza is really good. I usually like meat on my pizza, beef and black olives, but I'm trying to ease my way into a lifestyle of not having to have "meat" with every meal including pizza. And the Noni was my go to. I did not miss not having beef. The pizza was really good. The service was good too. Definitely a gem in the VA-Highland neighborhood. I see why it's so popular. read more

Pielands Sub & Slice - The Noni - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

Pielands was just ok. They have a great marketing team that really pushes the restaurant but I wasn't really impressed. I had two slices one was a garden one which was good I loved the fresh veggies. And then a buffalo chicken one which was not to my liking. I don't want to dog the place it's ok but I'm in no rush to go back. read more

The pizza was okay at best. Service was swift and courteous. The decor felt like a scene in 'Stranger Things'. read more

See all

Food safety issues here!! I wish I had read the reviews on here before ordering. Similar to another customer, my pizza was undercooked, it was basically gooey dough with sauce and cheese. I only managed to eat one slice and am really regretting spending any money on this place. I ordered chicken wings too, but was also only able to eat one of those because it tasted terrible. This place is not only a giant waste of money, but also a food safety concern, beware!! read more

Came to Pielands for the first time on a Sunday night. I have to agree with nearly all of the other reviews - while the food is great, the restaurant itself is pretty chaotic and disorganized. The staff were clearly overwhelmed at all of the uber eats / to go orders on top of dine in customers. As a result, the dining area was not clean and there was a long line of stressed out customers waiting to place their dine in order. While I did enjoy the pizza, I'll probably stick to visiting on a quieter day of the week until the restaurant is a bit more organized and has a better system in play. read more

See all

Service was good and pizza ok. But upset with policy of location. Understand from manager, who was very nice, that owners have multiple locations. They do not accept cash but charge 3% to use credit card . Understand policy of charging fir credit card use but then you should accept cash payments. Feel this is a terribly unfair policy . read more

See all

Best pizza around and very kind staff. Tonight I went in and got the Noni with half pepporni and loved it. Each time I go I try a different pizza and so far all great. Shout out to the super nice staff tonight - 12/5/24. read more

Came here for dinner with my family. It was busy when we got there but we were able to order in a few minutes. We got the cheesy bread and the Piedmont Pep. There was seating available because it seemed most orders were takeout. We had to wait about 20-30 minutes for our cheesy bread to come out. It was piping hot when we got it and it was delicious! Our pizza came out a few minutes later and that was also very hot. The pizza was ok to me. the crust tasted good but it didn't hold the sauce, cheese, and pepperoni very well because it mostly just slid off when you try to bite it. The flavor was good though, had a nice little kick to it. The staff was working hard! The seating area was pretty dirty. so we just cleaned the table ourselves and they didn't have any clean cups the first 20 minutes we were there. We had to go back to the counter to re-ask for cups. Overall it was an ok place. Update: Management reached out to me and was very nice and accommodating! read more

See all

When visiting Atlanta, we stopped here for a quick lunch while in Virginia-Highland. The reviews were good and quick New York style pizza seemed like a great option! I was not overly impressed. The cashier/hostess was friendly upon arrival. We placed our order and found a nice table in the window. The pizza did not impress. It wasn't bad but it wasn't good. It didn't taste super fresh, and it was a little too saucy in my opinion. The inside was a little grimey, but it was decorated cute with bright colors and retro-accents. Service was great, but food was mediocre. Great location! read more

Pielands Sub & Slice - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

For sure the best pizza that I have had in Atlanta. Service was great, Flavor was immaculate, and the ingredients were fresh. We went with the square pie called "The Noni". I can't wait to bring a pie home for my family. This was everything. Please make the drive and check them out. I also love that they have pizza specials through the week, the sale slices and alcohol for the adults. It's a win, win! read more

Pielands Sub & Slice - The Noni pie - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

Pielands is absolutely hands down the best pizza in Atlanta, period! Recently, I ordered the 'Nonie' pizza pie and added two optional toppings for a friend and myself. It was so delicious!! The toppings are FRESH! And that is a part of why it makes it different. I picked the pizza up on a Sunday about 30 minutes before they were scheduled to close. When I arrived, you may expect to find a bunch of employees ready to go home, but what I found was probably the friendliest end of day staff that you could hire. And I was handed my pie by someone who had a huge smile on his face as if he knew how much I was going to enjoy this pizza pie. It makes all the difference in the world when you run into nice people who are friendly and happy and when you have a great product, you have a great experience. I did not eat in as I was taking it out to bring home, but the location is always clean and a well planned layout makes for a convenient eat in location as well. Pielands is doing it right!! Next up I want to try their subs!! read more

Heard about this spot on TikTok of all places. Since we live here, we decided to check it out. Very VERY good pie!!! We had the half Margherita half pepperoni and it was delicious. The garlic knots we do soft on the inside and had the perfect amount of seasonings. Next time we go I want to try the dirty bird. Service was fast, food was hot! read more

Pielands Sub & Slice - Garlic knots! Sooooo so good! And I'm picky about garlic knots, having been in Chicago for work so many times. - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

We love this neighborhood gem. Kid friendly complete w. a fun Pac-Man machine! Food is awesome. Note that the large salads can feed more than 2 as advertised - always have leftovers and it's great read more

One of the best Italian sandwiches I've had in Atlanta. Honest price. Looking forward to continuing to support this local business

Cute little pizza place. Pretty spacious, phenomenal staff. Everyone there was so friendly. Parking can be limited in this area, especially during the weekends. Restaurant is in a busy area with intricate stores - love it! Can make a nice afternoon outing. Had their single slice of cheese pizza and two orders of the garlic knots. Arrived when they pulled out a new cheese pizza from the oven. Cheese pizza was amazing. Thin and crispy crust, homemade sauce, Brooklyn-style pizza. Had a little oregano in the pizza. Garlic knots were too greasy for me and didn't have enough garlic (lacked flavor). Overall, I am for sure going back for more of their cheese pizza. read more

See all

Being from New Jersey I wanted to like this sooooo bad!!! It was terrible all bread and not much of anything else. Ive tried sandwiches all over Atlanta and this just wasnt what i expected after looking at the other pics and reviews. I dont even do reviews but i had too with this disappointment. Went back spoke with management. They refunded me and gave me a coupon and it was with no hassle.. I will go back and try the pizza read more

Pielands Sub & Slice - Turkey and cheese - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

Big, juicy, succulent wings! Always cooked to perfection. I have to highlight their dough recipe. The pizza, calzone, garlic knots are chrewy and tasty. Caring and attentive staff. Everything I've had so far has been delicious read more

If you enjoy a flavorless, reheated, lukewarm, limp, overpriced slice of pizza, this place is for you!

SOOOO good. Probably the best pizza I've had in Atlanta. The staff is super friendly and funny and you can tell they genuinely like their jobs. The garlic knots are great, they make a homemade caesar dressing which was delicious and one of the best spicy pizzas I've had (the piedmont pep). The bathrooms are cute with the pizza collage wall paper and they have a Ms.PAC-MAN arcade game. read more

See all

I found this gem on Instagram and I'm happy I did. Visited this place on a Thursday evening and I key gem is to order ahead of your doing take it out. I've been looking for pizza places that remind me of home (NJ) since moving to GA and I think I've found it. To me, it's about the Cheese, sauce and bread and they nailed it. You have good pizza without having good cheese! It's a small pizza shop with a few indoor tables, outside tables and a PAC Man machine! They also offer spirits and wine!!!! We ordered the baked garlic parm wings with a meatezza pizza and garlic cheese bread. I give it all 5 stars. Remember I said order ahead if your doing take out. They were quite busy this evening and a little backed up but I love how it was an all teams on deck kind of situation. The way they pumped out orders smoothly and efficiently was admirable. While waiting the cashier did offer a complimentary fountain drink since they were backed up, which is a nice gesture. Back to the food. It was delicious! The wings were delicious. I thought I would miss the fried aspect of the wings but truly enjoyed the level of depth baking adds to the wings. There was a perfect balance of garlic, oil and parm. The cheese bread was my highlight. The amount of cheese was perfect and I loved how the cheese pulled! Good quality. The pizza was delicious as well and Fresh. I give this place a 10 out of 10 read more

See all

We came to Pielands on a whim and was pleased with our experience. First off, Tommy's service was absolutely great! From the time we stepped foot into the restaurant, to the time we left. We kept it simple and ordered cheese pizzas and a cold beer. The pizza was so good and hot that I ordered 2 more slices for the road! They also have everything you need e.g., parmesan, oregano, crushed pepper, garlic. I plan to return! read more

Pielands Sub & Slice - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia

See all

That salad tho. Hear me out. I know this is a pizza place. And the pizza is solid. (Pro tip: order a whole pie. They are infinitely better. The Noni is THE way to go there). Now back to the salad. The Chopped Salad is just an all-around, classic pizza joint beast of a salad. It is THE perfect pizza place salad. Crunchy romaine lettuce--none of that slimy, purple chef-y lettuce--and piled with salami, tomatoes, peppers, pickled onions, and those croutons! It can easily feed two and is loaded with ALL the good things. And the house dressing? :: chef's kiss:: read more

Pielands Sub & Slice - Chopped Salad - Pizza Near Me - Atlanta, Georgia