Pie Lady Cafe Photos
Business Info
Pie Lady Cafe Popular Desserts
PIE LADY CAFE ATMOSPHERE
You might also consider
More like Pie Lady Cafe
Recommended Reviews - Pie Lady Cafe
Start your review...
Reviews With Photos
I ordered a slice of coconut custard pie chocolate chip cookie peanut butter cookie sugar cookie pie lime pie. Let's start with the coconut custard. It was pretty thats what draw me in i got my feelings hurt because all though it was pretty it had no taste . The peanut butter cookie was the Star of the show my wife enjoyed her key lime pie
the banana french toast was AMAZINGGGGG. Service was a little bit slow on a saturday morning it was a bit busy which is understandable but we asked for the coffee menu but it never came. Our party had to ask another waiter for the menu and take our order other than that we do recommend the place. It's on a main st we didn't have any issues finding any parking and did a quick walk post breakfast.
This cute delicious little cafe in cozy little house building , one side being the restaurant and the other side being the bakery with a cafe and parking located in the back with few spots in the front , ugh loved it here ! Service was great , there is a bit of wait here but they have a little patio with chairs , tables , and blankets to stay warm . Got myself some coffee from the bakery while waiting . Ordered a basic egg plate with an apple pie once inside . Potatoes were amazing , egg was of course delicious , and turkey sausage was tasty. Apple pie I wish would have been warmed at first because that cold first bite was not it but the girlies were super sweet and warmed it up for me , so good , also it seems they made the whip cream in house . Overall a wonderful experience , will def be back when in the area !
Came here after the Scott Coffee Moorestown Rotary 8K for a post race meal. We were seated immediately outside on the porch which was perfect. Our server, Juliet, was very attentive and friendly. The owner, Christine McHale, gave us our food. We chatted with her for a little about the baked goods since my son is on the search for delicious cinnamon rolls and cookies. She came back out with crumb cake on the house. Awesome customer service. We did get a couple of the molasses cookies that were very good. Eat local!
Food: 5 stars Service: 3.5 stars My mom and I came here for the first time last weekend. Thankfully it wasn't too busy and there were seats available both inside and outside. We sat inside and our waitress was very friendly, but also very busy that it was hard to track her down. We had to remind her twice that we had no water. Our food was taking a very long time to arrive that she came around all tables offering a complimentary scone. She dropped it off and ran off without providing any napkins or utensils. We weren't able to choose the flavor, but received the butterscotch and it was SO good! Flaky, fragrant, sweet, delicious and huge! We didn't want to eat the entire scone or we would have no appetite for our main food. However, we waited close to 40min for our food to arrive so the scone was gone..I ordered the basic breakfast, which wasn't special at all and was indeed, basic. This is normally my go to breakfast item because I do like to see how restaurants prepare the potatoes, toast, etc. this was good but not a dish I would reorder. My mom ordered The Beast and that was a strong 10/10! After eating, we wanted to buy a pie to go. There were a ton of employees making coffee, but not one person acknowledged us for a while. Not even telling us that someone will be with us shortly. Finally a young girl helped us and we ordered a cherry almond pie and lemon blueberry scone, both were devoured in 2 days. One of the best pies I ever had! When we got home, we noticed our waitress charged us for the "complimentary scone." Food was amazing (minus the basic breakfast), but service was lacking a bit.
This place is interesting. Good service and good food but just takes forever. Idk why they don't get more help in the kitchen, someone said it's just one guy cooking back there but the time I came it was packed! I think I got my turkey sandwich after an hour of being there. My toddler's PB&J also took just as long and they told me 30 minutes after I ordered there's no more peanut butter. But then I couldn't be mad when I tasted my sandwich. Times are tough these days I get it. I'll just try to get take out next time.
This place was still crowded around 1 PM. Luckily my husband and I were seated right away. I ordered decaf cappuccino with cinnamon on top. The smell of the cinnamon was perfect for a cold fall day. It took quite a long time to get the food. My salad was huge, dressing was bland. My husband had breakfast burrito. It was ok, the filling didn't stay intact. I asked for pie selections and I was told that that there's one slice of pumpkin pie left so I asked for it to go. I was very disappointed not being able to try different kinds. I asked for the most popular scone and the waitress said it's the blueberry lemon. When I was leaving the dining area, I noticed that there's a store just for the baked goods. I saw more pumpkin pies, scones, and muffins. The scones are huge. Blueberry lemon had a lot of blueberries in it. Highly recommended. The pumpkin pie had a very good homemade crust and not too sweet. In summary, I would skip the restaurant and go straight to the bakery.
Still the best scones I've had. Stopped by here on our way to NYC and it's just as good as it was two years ago. This time, I was able to try the pies and got pumpkin and mixed berry. Top notch all around. And also tried the blueberry lemon scone and it was absolute heat. People were nice inside and it's still got that homey feel to it, like you are eating your grandmas food. Still packed like last time. Glad to have eaten here again.
Great local gem that's too easy to drive past. It's on Main St in Moorestown, so I recommend parking in a municipal lot. (Otherwise, there's metered street parking.) I've been here 3-4 times, and each time the food is excellent, fresh, homemade, and reasonably priced. The hardest part is deciding what to order. Decisions, decisions!
We went for lunch and dessert. Service from Brandon was excellent and the ambiance was pleasant. We ordered a chicken salad sandwich which was tasty and very filling. The vegetable wrap tasted good but didn't hold together as a sandwich and I requested they put it in bread. Pecan pie and whipped cream was the best and the key lime pie second best. To be honest, the crust was too thick to my liking in both of these pies but this is my personal preference. I prefer thin crust pizza too! I would definitely return and turn my friends on to this cute cafe and excellent bakery.
Best scones in South Jersey and it isn't even close! This place is always booming on Main Street Moorestown. Coffee is solid you can get free refills. Always go for a mug! Bakery side is always stocked with an abundance of pies, scones and muffins. Blueberry Lemon is by far the king of scone options. Not only the size but the soft crunchy texture they have it down to the tee. Icing on the top doesn't make it too sweet either. Other options come without glaze. They have two sides one to sit down and eat from a menu and the other side grab n go. Usually order from the grab n go side and have a seat outside. They finally opened on Wednesdays too which is a hug bonus! Lightens the heavy load from Thursday and gives a chance for a more lean, steady business model. Check this place out.
The Cafe is located in a retrofitted house, and feels just as cozy. There's inside and outside seating, and due to intermittent showers we ate inside. It can feel a little tight, but once you're eating you don't notice. Our waitress with really cool glasses was friendly, provided insights into the menu, and was backed up by her equally friendly fellow waitress. They seemed to all work really cohesively as a team. I ordered the breakfast sandwich with bacon on a roll. The eggs were cooked perfectly, and almost overflowing on the sandwich. There weren't any greasy butter remnants, and the cheese was gooey without the ooey overflowing. It was a master class in what a neat, tasty breakfast sandwich should be. The restroom is very clean, but the switch is higher up on the left side of the door than you may anticipate. I could not find the light in the dark... and then it took a moment to reopen the well sealed door from inside. Find the light switch before you close the door is what I'm saying. There is a shop on the opposite front door for pastries and pies!
5 months ago
Really cute sweet place and it was very cool to be there when it was also Moorestown's Christmas parade. The scone I had was fantastic. It was cranberry orange. I just wasn't super super impressed with the food. The server was wonderful. It was very crowded and busy yet. She still had a smile. I didn't like how crowded it was and how close to each other we were, but I think that's the nature of the venue read more
Charming, quaint restaurant with a wrap around porch and sidewalk seating perfect for dining outdoors on a nice day. Opted to takeout, and received great service at the separate bakery counter. Selected a breakfast sandwich with vegan sausage, pepper jack cheese, and a fried egg on a plain bagel which was really tasty. Tried an iced coffee and took a few scones to go, which weren't the best I ever had, but were good. I will most definitely return to sit and enjoy a meal. 8/10 read more
6 months ago
Really, really, really yummy quiche, avocado toast, and pie. Our waitress was super kind as well. Will definitely be back. And their iced lattes are delicious. read more
I ordered a slice of coconut custard pie chocolate chip cookie peanut butter cookie sugar cookie pie lime pie. Let's start with the coconut custard. It was pretty thats what draw me in i got my feelings hurt because all though it was pretty it had no taste . The peanut butter cookie was the Star of the show my wife enjoyed her key lime pie read more
the banana french toast was AMAZINGGGGG. Service was a little bit slow on a saturday morning it was a bit busy which is understandable but we asked for the coffee menu but it never came. Our party had to ask another waiter for the menu and take our order other than that we do recommend the place. It's on a main st we didn't have any issues finding any parking and did a quick walk post breakfast. read more
This cute delicious little cafe in cozy little house building , one side being the restaurant and the other side being the bakery with a cafe and parking located in the back with few spots in the front , ugh loved it here ! Service was great , there is a bit of wait here but they have a little patio with chairs , tables , and blankets to stay warm . Got myself some coffee from the bakery while waiting . Ordered a basic egg plate with an apple pie once inside . Potatoes were amazing , egg was of course delicious , and turkey sausage was tasty. Apple pie I wish would have been warmed at first because that cold first bite was not it but the girlies were super sweet and warmed it up for me , so good , also it seems they made the whip cream in house . Overall a wonderful experience , will def be back when in the area ! read more
11 months ago
Came here after the Scott Coffee Moorestown Rotary 8K for a post race meal. We were seated immediately outside on the porch which was perfect. Our server, Juliet, was very attentive and friendly. The owner, Christine McHale, gave us our food. We chatted with her for a little about the baked goods since my son is on the search for delicious cinnamon rolls and cookies. She came back out with crumb cake on the house. Awesome customer service. We did get a couple of the molasses cookies that were very good. Eat local! read more
2 years ago
Food: 5 stars Service: 3.5 stars My mom and I came here for the first time last weekend. Thankfully it wasn't too busy and there were seats available both inside and outside. We sat inside and our waitress was very friendly, but also very busy that it was hard to track her down. We had to remind her twice that we had no water. Our food was taking a very long time to arrive that she came around all tables offering a complimentary scone. She dropped it off and ran off without providing any napkins or utensils. We weren't able to choose the flavor, but received the butterscotch and it was SO good! Flaky, fragrant, sweet, delicious and huge! We didn't want to eat the entire scone or we would have no appetite for our main food. However, we waited close to 40min for our food to arrive so the scone was gone..I ordered the basic breakfast, which wasn't special at all and was indeed, basic. This is normally my go to breakfast item because I do like to see how restaurants prepare the potatoes, toast, etc. this was good but not a dish I would reorder. My mom ordered The Beast and that was a strong 10/10! After eating, we wanted to buy a pie to go. There were a ton of employees making coffee, but not one person acknowledged us for a while. Not even telling us that someone will be with us shortly. Finally a young girl helped us and we ordered a cherry almond pie and lemon blueberry scone, both were devoured in 2 days. One of the best pies I ever had! When we got home, we noticed our waitress charged us for the "complimentary scone." Food was amazing (minus the basic breakfast), but service was lacking a bit. read more
9 months ago
We have had two great experiences here so far! Staff is friendly and we love being able to sit and enjoy our breakfast outside. Food is delicious too! The cinnamon butter is so good and they have la columbe coffee which is another plus. read more
This place is interesting. Good service and good food but just takes forever. Idk why they don't get more help in the kitchen, someone said it's just one guy cooking back there but the time I came it was packed! I think I got my turkey sandwich after an hour of being there. My toddler's PB&J also took just as long and they told me 30 minutes after I ordered there's no more peanut butter. But then I couldn't be mad when I tasted my sandwich. Times are tough these days I get it. I'll just try to get take out next time. read more
2 months ago
This place was still crowded around 1 PM. Luckily my husband and I were seated right away. I ordered decaf cappuccino with cinnamon on top. The smell of the cinnamon was perfect for a cold fall day. It took quite a long time to get the food. My salad was huge, dressing was bland. My husband had breakfast burrito. It was ok, the filling didn't stay intact. I asked for pie selections and I was told that that there's one slice of pumpkin pie left so I asked for it to go. I was very disappointed not being able to try different kinds. I asked for the most popular scone and the waitress said it's the blueberry lemon. When I was leaving the dining area, I noticed that there's a store just for the baked goods. I saw more pumpkin pies, scones, and muffins. The scones are huge. Blueberry lemon had a lot of blueberries in it. Highly recommended. The pumpkin pie had a very good homemade crust and not too sweet. In summary, I would skip the restaurant and go straight to the bakery. read more
Still the best scones I've had. Stopped by here on our way to NYC and it's just as good as it was two years ago. This time, I was able to try the pies and got pumpkin and mixed berry. Top notch all around. And also tried the blueberry lemon scone and it was absolute heat. People were nice inside and it's still got that homey feel to it, like you are eating your grandmas food. Still packed like last time. Glad to have eaten here again. read more
Great local gem that's too easy to drive past. It's on Main St in Moorestown, so I recommend parking in a municipal lot. (Otherwise, there's metered street parking.) I've been here 3-4 times, and each time the food is excellent, fresh, homemade, and reasonably priced. The hardest part is deciding what to order. Decisions, decisions! read more
2 years ago
1 year ago
We went for lunch and dessert. Service from Brandon was excellent and the ambiance was pleasant. We ordered a chicken salad sandwich which was tasty and very filling. The vegetable wrap tasted good but didn't hold together as a sandwich and I requested they put it in bread. Pecan pie and whipped cream was the best and the key lime pie second best. To be honest, the crust was too thick to my liking in both of these pies but this is my personal preference. I prefer thin crust pizza too! I would definitely return and turn my friends on to this cute cafe and excellent bakery. read more
1 year ago
2 years ago
Best scones in South Jersey and it isn't even close! This place is always booming on Main Street Moorestown. Coffee is solid you can get free refills. Always go for a mug! Bakery side is always stocked with an abundance of pies, scones and muffins. Blueberry Lemon is by far the king of scone options. Not only the size but the soft crunchy texture they have it down to the tee. Icing on the top doesn't make it too sweet either. Other options come without glaze. They have two sides one to sit down and eat from a menu and the other side grab n go. Usually order from the grab n go side and have a seat outside. They finally opened on Wednesdays too which is a hug bonus! Lightens the heavy load from Thursday and gives a chance for a more lean, steady business model. Check this place out. read more
The Cafe is located in a retrofitted house, and feels just as cozy. There's inside and outside seating, and due to intermittent showers we ate inside. It can feel a little tight, but once you're eating you don't notice. Our waitress with really cool glasses was friendly, provided insights into the menu, and was backed up by her equally friendly fellow waitress. They seemed to all work really cohesively as a team. I ordered the breakfast sandwich with bacon on a roll. The eggs were cooked perfectly, and almost overflowing on the sandwich. There weren't any greasy butter remnants, and the cheese was gooey without the ooey overflowing. It was a master class in what a neat, tasty breakfast sandwich should be. The restroom is very clean, but the switch is higher up on the left side of the door than you may anticipate. I could not find the light in the dark... and then it took a moment to reopen the well sealed door from inside. Find the light switch before you close the door is what I'm saying. There is a shop on the opposite front door for pastries and pies! read more
Stopped in for breakfast/brunch on a Sunday morning. For two, it was around a 20 minute wait, but it was well worth it! The coffee was delicious, and the banana french toast was incredible and the portion was huge! Such an adorable spot. I will definitely be back! read more
1 year ago
7 months ago
2 years ago
Nestled in the heart of Main Street, come for the cozy atmosphere or the great food, or the friendly staff or for all three. A family friendly place to get really good brunch, try the lox eggs Benedict. Would highly recommend. read more
7 months ago
8 months ago
9 months ago
2 years ago
This is a charming breakfast spot! It can get busy, so making a reservation is a good idea. The staff work efficiently to keep the ordering process moving smoothly. The food is absolutely delicious. We tried the Red Eye based on a recommendation, and it didn't disappoint--the sausage was perfectly cooked and paired wonderfully with the aioli, hash browns, and egg. The sandwich was soft and flavorful, truly one of the best I've ever had. We also tried the Monte Cristo because the ingredients seemed like they'd go well together, and they absolutely did. The cinnamon on the sourdough, combined with the cheese, pork, and ham, created a tender and harmonious flavor. Both the outdoor and indoor seating areas are beautifully designed and add to the overall experience. read more
1 year ago
I went to the Pie Lady Cafe for breakfast back in December and completely forgot to write a review. Despite this delay, the Pie Lady Cafe unironically may have been the best meal I've ever had at a restaurant no exaggerations. I got water, black coffee, and the red EYE breakfast sandwich. The service was extremely friendly and fast and the coffee was very very good. The red EYE was so insanely good. Every single ingredient on the sandwich was done perfectly and the chili aioli on it was the thing that really wrapped it all together and made it perfect. The sandwich was huge and the price was extremely reasonable for the portion. Honestly I thought it was pretty cheap for the amount as I was stuffed afterwards. Not pictured here, but I also got a muffin to go fresh from the bakery and it was also amazing. The person I went with actually asked for jam/jelly for their toast and they brought out some of the best tasting jelly I've ever had. The restaurant also has an amazing and cozy atmosphere. I really do recommend the Pie Lady Cafe for anybody looking for a good meal that's reasonably priced with great service. I cannot wait to go back when I have the chance in the future! I can't express enough how amazing the meal was! read more
2 years ago
Great local spot for a large selection of scones, muffins, cookies, pies, bread and brunch. Two sides to this quaint little place, the bakery side and cafe side. The brunch selections are basic as well as unique. Be ready to wait on the weekend for a table. They have indoor and outdoor seating but not alot of tables. It is definitely worth the wait. Service is good but slow at times. It give you time to look at all the interesting artwork. Will be back! read more
3 years ago
Never tried Pie Lady Cafe in Moorestown NJ even though we driven by a plethora of times. For today's sampling we tried a blueberry lemon scone that was exemplary scrumptious. It was already warm so we had to eat that in the car for science sake. Perfection. Later in the day we had the rest. Butterscotch scone was also very good but did not touch the supremacy of that blueberry lemon. Coconut custard pie was good but the apple pie was stellar. Now that we know how good it is here we will certainly be by often. read more
10 months ago
11 months ago
2 years ago
This was an outstanding place! We had a really good waiter named Brendan and the food was absolutely fire! Also, there was a nice breakfast sandwich decoration with a bagel inside. This is written by a kid! read more
11 months ago
2 years ago
A high quality, delicious, and cheap breakfast/lunch small business with a cozy, fresh interior. Come for the laid back vibes, stay to sip your coffee and berry "corn." Everything is prepared to order, so it might be a bit slow, but the service is always so friendly. read more
4 years ago
On a short vacation, Pie Lady Cafe, was a total hit! The food was seasoned well and tasted delicious. The home fries are seasoned with rosemary, which caught me by surprise. That surprise ended up tasting really good . The cafe was short staff, but they still did an amazing job with the customers, being attentive, and making sure everything with the food was great. Thank You ! read more
2 years ago
Usually I would want to keep a place so amazing a secret, but I really do love this little café. The food is beyond amazing and always fresh. The scones, the pies and the fresh bread are always on point. The service is exponentially welcoming. They have blankets as you come in If you get a chill, you can also sit outside on the porch with a blanket when weather permits. The inside is charming but small so be patient. read more
Page 1 of 6
More info about Pie Lady Cafe
Ask the Community - Pie Lady Cafe
You might also consider
Why does Yelp recommend reviews?
9 reviews that are not currently recommended
The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.
11 years ago
3 years ago
14 years ago
15 years ago
5 years ago
4 years ago
5 years ago
9 years ago
11 years ago
Pie Lady Cafe - bakeries - Updated May 2026
Best of Moorestown
People found Pie Lady Cafe by searching for…
Breakfast & Brunch in Moorestown, New Jersey
Breakfast in Moorestown, New Jersey
Brunch in Moorestown, New Jersey
Donuts in Moorestown, New Jersey
Coffee Shop in Moorestown, New Jersey
Desserts in Moorestown, New Jersey
Bagels in Moorestown, New Jersey
Gluten Free Bakery in Moorestown, New Jersey
Vegan Bakery in Moorestown, New Jersey
Key Lime Pie in Moorestown, New Jersey
Apple Pie in Moorestown, New Jersey
Quiche in Moorestown, New Jersey
Cookies in Moorestown, New Jersey
Lemon Meringue Pie in Moorestown, New Jersey
Cheesesteaks in Moorestown, New Jersey
Sugar Free Bakeries in Moorestown, New Jersey
Pancakes in Moorestown, New Jersey
Breakfast Sandwich in Moorestown, New Jersey
Scones in Moorestown, New Jersey
Soup in Moorestown, New Jersey
Banana Cream Pie in Moorestown, New Jersey
Gluten Free Pie in Moorestown, New Jersey
Browse Nearby
BEST of Moorestown, New Jersey Restaurants near Pie Lady Cafe
BEST of Moorestown, New Jersey Coffee near Pie Lady Cafe
BEST of Moorestown, New Jersey Desserts near Pie Lady Cafe
BEST of Moorestown, New Jersey Breakfast near Pie Lady Cafe
BEST of Moorestown, New Jersey Things to Do near Pie Lady Cafe
BEST of Moorestown, New Jersey Parking near Pie Lady Cafe
BEST of Moorestown, New Jersey Cake near Pie Lady Cafe
BEST of Moorestown, New Jersey Shopping near Pie Lady Cafe
BEST of Moorestown, New Jersey Cupcakes near Pie Lady Cafe
BEST of Moorestown, New Jersey Thrift Stores near Pie Lady Cafe
