So let me start this review by saying I have never been a huge fan of Pickleman's. I only ever had them catered in to work events and they were very lackluster, basic sandwiches. However, when I tried them for myself outside of catering, I actually was semi pleasantly surprised with the options on offer. Yes, they do have those basic sandwiches that were catered in (if you like that, I mean) - but they also have a lot of other items you can add onto sandwiches when you order for yourself. I tried the BBQ Pulled Pork sandwich, and added mayo and black olives, and removed the onions. It was actually pretty delicious, but still kind of basic when compared to other sandwich shops in town (Potbelly is my favorite of the similar ones to Pickleman's) I also ordered the BBQ Pulled Pork Mac and Cheese (I know, more pulled pork??). It was alright, but was cold when I got it home, so maybe the container they put it in doesn't retain heat so well. Basic Mac and cheese with a tiny bit of pulled pork on top and bbq sauce. If you couldn't tell, I ordered a few side things in case the sandwich was gross. I also grabbed the Broccoli Cheese soup. Now, when it comes to broccoli cheese soups, the one I measure them all against is the Panera one that comes in a bread bowl. And this was nothing compared to that. Kind of bland and also cold. Now I know you're saying "couldn't you just heat up these cold items?" And to that I say "I shouldn't have to do that, when I literally live a block from the store!" The one bright spot was that the cookies I ordered I ordered were actually pretty good - soft, flavorful, and pretty inexpensive. I would get those again, but not much else from Pickleman's. read more

See all

Fresh made to order salads and sandwiches. Friendly helpful service. We went at an off hour so not many people but plenty of seating. The room was a little chilly for the kind of day we were having , maybe the staff needed it cooler. Our salads were delicious and the soup hit the spot. We left quite satisfied. A tiny bit pricey but good food. Give them a try. read more

Yum! Everything always fresh and love the giardiniera to add to my sandwich. Wish there was a store closer to me in Iowa. Friendly staff. Just go there! read more

I decided to pick up my order. It was very easy to navigate the site to place my order. It was ready to go quickly. I loved the veggie sandwich on warm, toasted wheat bread. The toasting added crunch and flavor. I had the pick 2 with a veggie sandwich and garden salad. The sandwich was the perfect size for me but people with a bigger appetite would probably be disappointed. The salad was a generous size and standard, although you can change it up with toppings. Inside was clean and colorful. The workers were quick and friendly. This is a great place for lunch. read more

Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe - Cookies! - Sandwiches Near Me - Omaha, Nebraska

See all

Unbelievably LOUD rap style music!! Could not even carry on a conversation! They could not even hear our orders very well, so mistakes were made and we were overcharged and did not receive what we ordered. Sandwiches did not have very much meat on them and were missing bacon. WE will not be back! read more

We used Picklemans for our Pickleball tournament! Was a HUGE hit! Picklemans is very quality and timely. They did amazing for catering. read more

Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe - Sandwiches Near Me - Omaha, Nebraska

Delicious sandwiches and salads. The people working there were super nice and friendly. The Aladdin soundtrack was bumping when we walked in and had us singing. Will definitely return the next time we're in Omaha. read more

Great team and service!!! The team is so friendly and the food is amazingly consistent!

I've truly never indulged in something greater. The #11 Italian club is to die for. The combination of salami, cappicola, and pepperoni is extravagant. Adding pickles and banana peppers is the way to go. If you order this sandwich you surely won't be disappointed!!! Jimmy John's could never. read more

Food was very solid for a fast casual restaurant. Kids had pep pizza and kids meal. Both enjoyed the food. The kids meal was a little small for my ten year old, but would have been fine for my youngest. Service was slow, but clean restaurant. read more

I had time in between meetings so I stopped into picklemans to grab a healthyish bite to eat. There were ample staff members who were very friendly helping me. I ordered a pick two and rather satisfied with the portion size though the walnut cran salad lacked something. The Italian club was incredible. I'm still thinking about it today. Would definitely return here. read more

See all

Oh my gosh, it was our first time at this location and we are blown away with the service. I had the buffalo chicken sandwich in their lettuce wrap (they didn't have a gluten free bread or wrap option), and my husband had the chicken salad sandwich. We both loved our sandwiches. The icing on the cake was the service. Every employee was smiling in the middle of a busy lunch rush, and when our toddler ran up to the counter pointing at the cookies, they gave him one! Literally can't wait to come back. read more

One of my favorite fresh sandwich places. I really like their broccoli cheese soup. I probably been eating here for about 20 years.

Food was delicious. We ordered carry out. The Au Jus and Italian beef were still hot when we got home. The salad was almost too big to finish. Good food for the price! read more

I had such a great experience at Pickleman's last week! Despite being a very busy lunch hour, the staff was beyond friendly and upbeat! I ordered the chicken asiago sandwich with the broccoli cheese soup. My sandwich and soup were hot and perfectly delicious, and they even threw in a cookie for me! read more

Thank you so much Pickleman's for coming to our rescue of getting 40 sandwiches together within an hour for our church luncheon! Thank you for being very prompt and courteous! This was a first time eating from here and it was so very good! Everyone loved the sandwiches. We will definitely be eating here again! read more

You can't beat Pickleman's for soup and salad. The avo-cobb is great, and is always made fresh! Friendly staff and customized orders from their user-friendly app make this place a go-to favorite for me! read more

Sandwiches and salads, pizza and Pickles. Can't beat it, they also play great music! And don't forget the cookies made on site! Mmmmm

Solid place to grab a soup, salad, sandwich, or flat bread for lunch. They have quite a few options to choose from and the food has been consistently good whether you eat in or takeout. Service is pretty typical for a deli type of restaurant and the dining room is pretty clean with plenty of tables. read more

I used to be a fan of your AvoCobb salad but lately I have found little avocado in your AvoCobb salad. Perhaps you should take the "Avo" out of your salad name and just call it Cobb salad with an occasional avocado if you have enough supply. 1 slice of avocado doesnt make the salad justice. read more

Great sandwich! I had the turkey and I'm going back again for the Asiago chicken sandwich. Very friendly and helpful crew on 114th & Dodge! read more

My salad was so good this is the best place to get a salad you're full beyond full they give you everything you want even if you request extras what a great place to eat it's my favorite read more

I have ordered Pickleman's for the last 6+ years and they have always been great - staff and food. May have been an issue with drink not being delivered here and there but driver always is so apologetic and offers to run back and grab it. The food and customer service earned the 5 stars from me read more

NOT IMPRESSED with the service and food I just got at Picklemans. Stood at the counter for 5 mins without so much as an acknowledgement or a "be with you in a minute". When I was waited on, I ordered the Turkey bacon club lettuce wrap. I was asked if I wanted it toasted, which doesn't make sense with a lettuce wrap, so I said no. Wasn't asked what I wanted for condiments so I assumed, based on what's listed on the menu, that it would have provolone cheese, tomato, and mayo. I got home to open up a lettuce wrap with uncooked bacon, and Turkey. That's it. Nothing else. No mayo, cheese, or tomato. I had to microwave my bacon, and add my own condiments. Waste of money. read more

Thrilled to have Pickleman's in the 114th/Dodge neighborhood. One thing that the workers of Old Mill/Miracle Hills area love is a lunchtime sandwich stop. Many will be excited to see the "now open" flags out on 114th street. A few things make for a great 114th street sandwich stop. 1- Convenient and ample parking: it can be scarce south of Dodge, but Pickleman's has a big lot! 2- Efficient layout: well done on the simple - but thoughtful - design that will process a busy lunch-time crowd while not harshing a guest's vibe. 3- Quality food & choices: If you like other Pickleman's you'll love this one too. I had the chipotle chicken sandwich (has become my favorite toasted sandwich now that the Quizno's chicken carbonara is nowhere to be found). I took the good advice of my sandwich man and added some of their spicy pepper blend - no regrets! Transformed a former print shop space into a gourmet sandwich shop in one of the busiest lunch districts in town. Awesome! read more

Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe - Sandwiches Near Me - Omaha, Nebraska

See all

I enjoy going to Pickleman's cafe for their fresh food. It is a difficult choice between the sandwich or the salad. Both have crisp veggies and meat if you choose. My favorite is the freshly baked cookies! Each time I visit Pickleman's on 114th & Dodge Street the dining room is clean and the employees uniforms are neat. You can tell that the staff are happy from the smile's on their face. By the way, I hear they have good pizza I just haven't had the chance to try it yet. I recommend stopping by Pickleman's gourmet cafe the next time you are in the area. It will be worth your time! read more

First the bad news. It was by far the smallest sub that I have ever had. It was also fairly expensive given its size. That's it for the bad news. There was a lot of good stuff though. First, and most important, is that the Italian club sandwich that I had was one of the best ones that I have ever had. It was loaded with flavorful quality meat and dressed perfectly. The slightly toasted bread was very good. I would not even change anything about how they dressed it. I also had a bowl of the broccoli cheese soup. It was thick, flavorful and loaded with broccoli. I only had to add a little salt to make it perfect. I really like it served this way. Most places make it way too salty and you just can not fix that. Bottom line, the service was good, the place was clean and the food was great. A little expensive for how much you get, but when it is this good, it is well worth it in my book. I will be coming back to try more of the menu items.The only reason that I did not give them a 5 star rating was the size of my sandwich. read more

Had a class for work near by so decided to stop here on the way home . I always tend to look at the menu online before I go anywhere so that way I am not standing there staring at the board while the employees stare at me waiting for my order . Walked in knowing what I wanted , quick glance at the board to make sure the names haven't changed and placed order . The employee taking the order and one putting Ingredients on were not either friendly or unfriendly , short and to the point . The associate who was taking the money was very nice and we held a conversation while the sandwich was being prepped . Now for the sandwich ,, toasted bread and higher quality meat then most places . Lacking some flavor when it comes to the seasoning but it was "clean " tasting ( not full of preservatives ) . Strangely I liked my 2nd 1/2 of the sandwich better then the 1st . It feels odd to say this but I almost felt she gave me the wrong sandwich when I first started eating it . I ordered the hodgepodge which has salami, capicola , turkey and ham and I did not taste the salami or capicola at all . I started to feel maybe I ordered wrong but when I got to the 2nd 1/2 of the sandwich I definitely noticed it on there . I don't know how they cut the meat , they don't let u see that . ( that doesn't bug me so much but I love other places where they cut the meat in front of you and let you watch ) , I Almost felt she forgot and just didn't put everything on the entire thing . Would I go back ? Probably if I was in the neighborhood and wanted a sandwich but would not "crave it ". read more

Why do they bother giving you the option to customize your order if they literally never read the order and mess it up every single time I order delivery? Ask for no tomato, no mayo, add ranch on a sandwich. Guess what I got...mayo and tomato and no ranch. Ask for regular ranch on your salad...they give you spicy ranch instead. My order has never been right, not once. Call to have them fix it and guess what? You get to wait for a driver...worst service ever. Do not recommend their delivery service at all! Food may be good if they can ever hire people who can read and get your order correct. read more

Love their chicken salad sandwich! They have speedy online ordering and very polite employees!

Nice soup, sandwich & personal pizza shop. Order at the counter & they toast your sandwich as you move down the assembly line. Staff very friendly & helpful. Moderately priced. Vegetarian choices. They deliver as well. read more

See all

Delish tomato basil soup that comes with toasted roll. Added an order of cheese bread and I was in heaven (it looked better than the grilled cheese but I have never tried that). Ordered online and it was ready in 10 minutes. Great meal that warmed me up! read more

We are fans! We were told to stop in as we drove thru Omaha & this location was easy access from 680. Awesome food, friendly service & quick turn around from online ordering. 6 meals were delicious & well-priced! Thank you for the pickle too! read more

I was in a city, walking around with my grandmother and we both got hungry. I looked on my phone for food places near where I was and I saw Pickleman's. We went inside, the service was great but my meatball sub was extremely spicy. read more

I had the fish and fries meal which came with a small little cop of fresh coleslaw. The fish was amazing, it fillets from catfish and was the flackies freshest tasting cat fish I have had in a long time and the fries are hand cut just like momma used to make! The prices are higher but if you are getting fresh for midwest seafood it's worth it really want to check out their crab legs next! read more

We started going to Pickleman's a lot after my son got to try their sandwich because the soccer camp he was at provided them for lunch one day. We like Pickleman's because they have so many different options of sandwiches, pizzas, salads, and soups to choose from! They use the best ingredients and I love the taste of the sandwich after the are toasted. I usually get the Veggie. It is really really yummy. We also always get their chocolate chip cookies. They are scratch made daily so they are always good when we get them. I also always get an iced tea from there which I am unsure if they make there or not, but it is still good. It doesn't come from the soda machine, so it may be made there. If you have not tried Pickleman's before, you should at least give them a try. They are really good and the people who work there are usually very friendly. They also do delivery and you can order online too. read more

Just ordered for the first time here. The club sandwich was amazing and the cranberry walnut salad was fresh. Will be ordering again soon. Friendly deliver person! Thank you I also want to add that Lucas is a great guy. Nice representative of your company. read more

Got the bbq chicken sandwich and my wife got broccoli cheese soup. Good sandwich I enjoyed the bbq sauce they use. Soup tasted like it should and the piece of bread if came with was fantastic ! read more

I made my first stop here for lunch today, and came away impressed. Great bread, lots of choices, and nice environment. I ordered half sandwich, broccoli &cheese soup, pickle spear and a drink. Same as lunch special at Little King. The food here is much fresher and better made, but $3 more than Little King. So the value is a little off. Restaurant is nicely laid out, with most booths having USB ports, which is a nice touch. Staff was friendly and quick. Lots of sandwich shops on 114th and Dodge, but Picklemann's will make a strong run for top dog. We'll be back, frequently. read more

First time trying Pickleman's and delivery at that. I ordered online and it was a breeze, the ease of the entire website and ordering process made the whole process much better. I ordered the buffalo chicken salad and a meatball sub. Estimated delivery was 45 min. My food arrived right on time. I live in the back of an apartment complex that is more like a maze than an apartment complex and it was dark out so the drivers visibility of the tiny apartment numbers was extremely limited. He had to call to find out where I was and was very pleasant. My sub was pretty good; I will probably order something else next time though and it was still warm so that's a plus! The salad was by far by favorite buffalo chicken salad. The right amount of dressing and some healthy looking veggies. Safe to say I will be ordering again! You team rocks keep up the good work. read more