I went there last night to get my favorite sandwich, #9. Italian beef. Unfortunately, it will be my last time. Your prices have again went up! I paid 12 dollars for a sandwich and a soda no chips with a five dollar off coupon. If I didn't have the coupon it would've been $17. That is highway robbery and ridiculous! Your prices are so inflated, you will probably go out of business! It's unbelievable! And, you had 5 kids working with no customers. I guess that's why you inflate your prices to pay more labor, while they're on their phones, btw! There should never be more than three kids there at a time! You better check your competition they're all around $12 for a sandwich chips and a drink with tax! Get your head on straight before you lose your business! read more

Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe - Sandwiches Near Me - O'Fallon, Missouri

Pickleman's is always consistent and always delicious!! If you need a quick bite to eat this is a great spot for it. Don't forget to try the pickles ! Yum read more

We placed our order for pickup: two pizzas and an Italian beef sandwich. The pizzas are always delicious. The sandwich was disappointing: they forgot the spicy peppers. It was just a sad beef and bread sandwich and the jus didn't bring it to life. read more

First time here. Staff was great, friendly and helpful with menu items. My grandbabies loves the white cheddar Mac and cheese, they usually share but they both loved it so much we bought a second one and they ate that too! We got a #13 with peppers and mozzarella and it was excellent! One got the veggie and said it was great too, also got the BLTC and it was very good. They toast the bread and it melts cheese to perfection. Prices also seemed reasonable. We will definitely go back and try others! read more

Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe - Sandwiches Near Me - O'Fallon, Missouri

See all

Ordered for delivery and was not disappointed. Sandwich came warm and toasty and soup was on point. After putting my order in, within actual seconds the driver checked in and was waiting on my food. Jimmy John's got nothin' on Pickleman's super fast, just sayin' read more

Whenever I'm at my parent's house we will order from here, and have for many years. Food is always great and nice staff. I almost always get the buffalo chicken sandwich, but the pizzas and sides are super delicious too. Also extra bonus mom points that a few years ago when I asked if peanuts were in their cookie ingredients, they answered " no the owners have peanut allergies and don't have any peanuts in their stores at all"--so needless to say, we will be lifetime customers here! read more

Pickleman's really just gave my husband half a gherkin pickle. They did not care that they delivered this and said "that's what we have today" when we called for ask if it was a mistake. Comical compared to what they advertise! read more

Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe - What they advertise - Sandwiches Near Me - O'Fallon, Missouri

See all

Good soup and service and it does feel welcoming. Clean and we will try again because they have a few selections that sound interesting.

I'm here for work from California and I've eaten here three times so far for dinner! Love the sandwiches, the salads, and of course, the pickles! In California, a sandwich like this is $15! Super fresh & good portions! All three times the employees have been super friendly and courteous! Wish I could find these in California! read more

I have been very disappointed with my deliveries the last several times. They don't have the pick two offer anymore, my tomato soup has a layer of oil on top and was not edible and my sandwich was burnt. I feel they have gone downhill over the last several months. I used to love this place! It is one of the only places close to work that I can order from. I'm very upset. Update: I appreciate the prompt feedback from the owner. I will definitely give the business another go and update my review. Thank you, Caroline. Your commitment to your customers is great to see. read more

Excellent, well crafted sandwiches and a cheerful staff to complete the experience. My go to is the Italian and my wife loves the Cuban sandwiches. read more

This was my very first time coming to this restaurant and I was pleasantly surprised. I ordered a chicken caesar salad and a bowl of tomato soup. The salad was crisp and the croutons were crunchy and delicious, I liked the dressing as well. I enjoy a bowl of soup all year round and I was not disappointed with this soup, it was mouthwatering and I will have to go back and get some to store for later. The service was great, you come in and order and tell them what you want on the salad and the bowl of soup and they have all the items waiting for you with the cashier. Quick and easy process, I didnot feel like I was being rushed at all being my first time there. I like the way it was set up. You can eat in or either outside. I will definitely return! read more

it took over an hour for a delivery on a bowl of soup and half sandwich. When I contacted the store, no one answered. After multiple attempts i was finally connext to aman that was unprofessional and making excuses for the delay. it was a terrible experience. the delivery guy was not professional. Not a single apology for waiting an hour and 45 minutes for picture below. read more

Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe - Sandwiches Near Me - O'Fallon, Missouri

See all

I struggle with my review. My first trip here started with a request for Pastrami. It wasn't up on the menu at all, so I asked the counter for help. The puzzled response was "Past what???" How does one in the sandwich business not know one of the biggest classic meat choices available? That having been said, I later came back to enjoy a far more pedestrian ham and cheese sandwich. It fit the bill a lot better than other places around for sandwiches, but still seems like it's missing something. The people and the location are great. The food was mostly above average... but not exciting. The namesake choice, the pickle, seemed rather unremarkable, even more so with the wide variety of pickle choices in the greater area around the shop. Almost went with a 3 for dissing the pastrami.... but my scores are about the actual experience. read more

First time here and it was great! I ordered the broccoli cheese soup and club sandwich. The soup was so tasty and the sandwich was loaded with all the meats and veggies. Did not skimp on the ingredients. My hubs ordered the cuban sandwich, he said my sandwich is excellent! He also ordered the pulled pork mac n cheese and oh my gosh so very good. I don't usually eat mac & cheese but I asked for a bite and went back for a second bite. Yes, I did, it was just that delicious. The employees were very knowledgeable and personable, great interactions! And the store was so clean and inviting. We will definitely visit again. I can't wait to try their salads! We got our order to go and took it home and we're so hungry by the time we got home I forgot to take pictures. Next time I will. read more

Yummy bread! Food is good, service is fast and friendly! Tables were cleaned quickly too.

The food tasty as described, Absolutely delicious and should definitely check out if your looking for a great sandwich. Very fresh meats and cheeses, Ordered a roast beef and provolone with mac and cheese and it was the perfect amount to fill me up. Would highly recommend :) read more

Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe - Roast beef - Sandwiches Near Me - O'Fallon, Missouri

See all

First off, I was supposed to wait for my wife to go with me because we have passed it another of times since we moved here, but never stopped to try it! A few days ago, I was in the area and had an appointment close by and saw the restaurant just glaring at me, so I thought, what the heck, let's try it! I ordered the turkey melt sandwich, and it was very, very good! Toasted to perfection, the only way to eat a sandwich in my book, and I also ordered a bag of chips and a Pickleman's bottle of water! When I went to pay, the cookies were just too yummy to pass up, so I added one of those to my order also! I will definitely return, the restaurant was slow at the time I stopped by, and I ate in at a table, and hopefully the next time I bring my wife it won't be too crowded to get a table! read more

Always good, fresh sandwiches and great service. We get delivery from here fairly often and everything arrives as ordered and delicious. Keep up the good work! read more

the food was great and came out fast but the service was terrible. krista or kristyn (i can't recall her name) was extremely rude to us. we came in there for dinner at 9:00 PM and she was extremely rude and off putting. I love picklemans!!! It's great for late night food but that service makes me not want to return. read more

Second time here. It so clean and the employees are so helpful and nice. Janice is my favorite It's easy to order on the app. It took me 15 min and my order was done already. The soup was hot and I love the roll that comes with it. The new chips are amazing! read more

Pickleman's is one of those places, "I'd take it or leave it". I was a victim of their social media marketing when they followed me on Instagram, then they liked a few of my photos, and suddenly they stopped following me. Well played, guys. It worked. But I wasn't really that impressed. I've been to two different Pickleman's locations, and they were alright. It's always hard to keep in mind they are mostly a deli. The one thing that stands out in my mind is, while their sandwiches were good, Pickleman's doesn't offer any of them bigger than 6". Thought that was very strange. Yes, I was still hungry. I did have a couple slices of my nephew's pizza from here, and it was okay. Any place that has the "Coke Remix" machine (or whatever its really called) wins points with me. If a Pickleman's location opens up in my town, I won't get that excited though a lot of people may be. read more

The food tasted good, however the sandwich insides were a bit thin, meaning not much stuff for the price.

The one thing that has remained consistent: great food, great service and great people.

Always great!! Very quick, courteous and yummy! From pizza to soup to sa It's all good! read more

Thank god their food is good. Their delivery is just awful. I have ordered an Italian beef several times and every time, they forget the sauce that comes with the sandwich. Sometimes, they forget the peppers, too. Even when you leave a note, they still forget it. They don't really offer anything except to drive the sauce back to you. By then, your sandwich is cold. Management doesn't seem to care either. Really frustrated with their delivery service, so probably won't use them again. read more

I love this place! Over the past two years, Pickleman's has been our go to for a consistently tasty meal and this store, in particular, always delivers. Almost all of our meals have been delivered (one time in-store) and the food consistently arrives at the right temperature (hot meals are hot and cold meals are cold) and the ingredients are fresh and vibrant. Most important, the drivers are always professional and friendly! Nice job, Pickleman's next to Dierbergs on K, cheers! read more

Pickleman's is a regional chain with locations in Missouri, Kansas, Nebraska, and Arkansas. As "gourmet" in the name implies, it's several steps above Subway. Meats, for example, taste more deli-like than out of a plastic bag. Sandwiches, soups, salads, and pizza are made to order. A you-pick-two deal is a good value. My Italian sandwich was on the smallish size (slightly under 6 inches) but also didn't have an oversize baguette dominating the meat and cheese. It was delicious. The half romaine, half spinach salad was a nice portion by itself and fresh tasting. But, the potato chips I added--Deep River Rosemary and Olive Oil--wonderful! Don't skip the chips! Pickleman's lives up to its gourmet claim. read more

Placed an order right as they opened and had all 6 workers working on just my order. My bill was 110 bucks which is fine, idc at all about that. But they forgot, 8 pickles, garlic cheese bread, and 4 cookies. I drove it all the way out to my clinic in warrenton just to realize it. I called and asked them to bring it out and they refused and didn't even make it right with a refund or anything. I'm easy going but this was just weird as f*uck. You would think if someone spends that much money at your business you would at least make it right by the customer if there's such a large mistake haha read more

Have been here a few times, sandwiches and soups are always hot & delicious. Service is fast and the price is reasonable compared to subway/jimmy johns etc. read more

The food is always good and delivery always goes smoothly. Highly recommend placing an order.

Everything we've ordered from Picklemans has consistently been fresh and delicious accompanied with friendly service. We have take out from here about once a week. The pizzas are top notch (and we're pizza snobs so I don't say that lightly) and the sandwiches are awesome (I recommend the #11). We haven't tried their other offerings but judging by what we've tried so far I would imagine they're good. 10/10 recommend! read more

I placed an online order at the Ofallon MO store for delivery. Order was placed at 11:30 am and said it would be delivered at 11:58. It's now 12:23 and it still hasn't been delivered and no one is answering the phone. I checked my account and was charged for the order that it looks like I won't be receiving. Be careful ordering delivery from this location. read more

Food was warm and fresh! Delivered quickly and even earlier than anticipated. We've ordered from here several times and it's always been amazing! Will recommend and will return! read more

Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe - Italian Club - Sandwiches Near Me - O'Fallon, Missouri

The Best Italian beef sandwich and salad this side of St. Louis!!!! The staff was sooo friendly and helpful!! I will always go here . Food was excellent down to the last drop!!! Thank you guys ! read more

Always clean indoor restaurant, delicious food, courteous staff and spotless restrooms! Great Job!!!

Great sandwich, great service, fresh tea & lemonade, relaxing atmosphere and good mugs!

Manager or the owner are almost always there overseeing service which has been stellar for quite some time. Food wise it's ALWAYS good. Absolutely recommend read more

Great food! My favorite is the chicken salad sandwich! It is yummy! When I order my husband's lunch, I have to make sure and order for most of his coworkers, they all love the #11, an all Italian meat-sandwich! read more

Always good! Tried the Pizza for 1st time tonight. Very tasty. Even my wife who is very picky with her pizza loved it. Salads are always nice and fresh. Only 1 suggestion on the choice of Pizza toppings. Get some MUSHROOMS PLEASE!!!! Back in 17, I had their Southwest Salad Monday thru Friday for 3 months. That combined with a rigorous walking pace of 6-7 miles everyday helped me to lose 79 pounds. read more