Fully authentic Italian sandwiches bursting with flavors you may never had experienced before. These are not your typical Americanized Italian sandwiches using cold cuts. The flavor combinations with all the textural nuances throughout, mixed with exciting flavors you probably have never experienced, UNLESS you've traveled to Italy and the masterfully crafted bread will leave you in awe of how the transported you to their hearts while never leaving home. I cannot recommend them any harder than to not only say greatest sandwiches in Columbus, but greatest sandwiches I've ever had read more

When I tell you that this is hands down the best Italian focaccia sandwich in Ohio, I mean it. Always the best service, providing knowledge and a warm welcome. My kids love the decor, brightly colored umbrellas cover the ceilings. I love the handmade espresso cups that line the shelves. I recommend it to EVERYONE! The Il Top is my number one favorite because their house made pesto with the mortadella is to die for. Just go, and don't forget to grab a gelato and some wine on your way out. read more

We hit this place for a Friday afternoon lunch. Warmly greeted by the guy behind the counter who walked us through the menu. I have to be honest, I don't have a clear idea of what was on my sandwich but it was great. I ordered the Della Casa and it was solid. Not too filling but tasty and fresh. I'd come back to explore the menu and check out the gelato. read more

Piazza Pelino - Della Casa - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Piazza Pelino is an awesome authentic Italian shop with freshly made focaccia sandwiches, delicious homemade gelato, and a great wine selection! It's fun and inviting if you're eating in, and it's also great for picking up a sandwich, a loaf of focaccia or a scoop of gelato to go! They have so many great flavors of gelato and the staff is very friendly. The authentic canned sodas goes perfectly with the sandwiches as well! read more

Piazza Pelino - Raspberry sorbetto - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Cute little Italian sandwich and gelato stop in downtown Columbus. The focaccia bread is so fresh and delicious. Highly recommend the Della Casa or the Genovese for the non meat eaters. The place is very cute. Seating is limited so plan to take your sandwiches to go. The service is friendly and fun. Absolutely recommend for anyone looking for a "life changing sandwich" (my partners words). read more

I kept hearing about this place. And I figured it was just the usual hype. But it lives up to it. Shares the little lot with Lox, so, free parking in the Short North. The lot was almost full on a weekday, but you should usually be able to find spots at off times. Inside, it was steady, but not packed. Super friendly service. Order at the counter from a limited number of sandwiches. They all sounded good. I went with the prosciutto and fig. It was excellent: perfect bread, perfect fillings. Combined into a nicely balanced whole. And, not small, as I had feared. I got a limonata with it, very complementary and very good. I got some gelato after because of course; it was a hot day. You can have two flavors; I picked lemon and raspberry. The medium was plenty, overfilled with those. It was also good, maybe not amazing, but I'm spoiled- my uncle has an ice cream place and they make gelato among other things. Prices were reasonable for quality and quality. I'll be back to try several sandwiches. read more

This hidden gem is right next to The Lox and specializes in traditional Italian sandwiches, freshly baked focaccia, and homemade gelato. I've been here a few times now and it's always a treat. The staff is very pleasant and helpful, the food is delicious with ingredients imported from Italy, and the decor is relaxing. -- at Short North Arts District. read more

Piazza Pelino - Nduja and Doppel Espresso - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I have seen reels for Piazza Pelino on Instagram for a while now and finally had an opportunity to try it out. I am glad I did! The food is delicious! My sister and I split a sandwich but I could have easily eaten one all by myself. The flavors were amazing I didn't want to stop eating. I love that they use Italian flour and real ingredients in their food. The foccacia was delicious. We also tried two of the cookies. The almond cookie is a must try. I can't wait to go back and try the gelato. There are tables to sit inside. It is beautifully decorated inside with a small wine selection and some gifts you can buy. read more

Excellent sandwiches -- I admit that at first glance I was concerned they'd be overly bread heavy and lack flavor, but that was far from true. The focaccia bread is light and perfectly salty, the meats and spreads rich but not overwhelming. We got the Il Top and prosciutto e fichi and they perfectly complemented one another, with the top being more savory and the fichi sweet (because of the fig jam). We were so full we didn't try the gelato, but we've heard you can only find better in Italy. Service was quick, friendly, and attentive (I noticed the owner on site, which speaks to their attention to the place) and the decor is so whimsical and fun (umbrellas decorate the ceiling, cool finds from Italy, from wine to books to drinkware, are on sale on the walls). Definitely check it out! Next time we have guests in Columbus, we'll take them here. read more

See all

What a gem! I wanted to take my Italian wife to someplace cool on her birthday weekend trip and this did not disappoint. From the moment you walk in you are transported to Italy. The staff are amazing and friendly. I got the prosciutto e fiche. House made focaccia bread with prosciutto de Parma, soft cheese, fig jam, and a black garlic crema. I cannot describe what my brain went through after the first bite. It was pure Italian pride in a sandwich. They gave house made gelato as well. I had tiramisu and chocolate mixed. So rich and creamy. If you are anywhere close to this place do yourself a favor and stop! read more

Piazza Pelino - Such a beautiful interior - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Whats not to love? Homemade focaccia and homemade gelato, all under one roof....Sign me up. No bread brings me more joy than focaccia. It's a soft, chewy, fluffy labor of love. Piazza Pelino brings easily the best bread on the planet, freshly made daily, to the heart of Columbus. The Della Casa is a beautiful sandwich. Prosciutto and pesto never misses. Don't let the size fool you, these sandwiches are deceptively filling. The charm factor is absolutely off the charts here. It's the ceramic tile, the umbrellas, and the Italian music serenading in the background. I've been to my far share of sandwich shops in Italy over the past decade, and Piazza Pelino instantly transports me there....one of my life's happy places. read more

See all

This place is AMAZING! It smelled soooo good when I walked in. We got the Top & Fichi sandwiches- yummy. Loved the black truffle chips and the strawberry cheesecake with chocolate shavings was delish. The staff were great. Highly recommend read more

Piazza Pelino - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

There is truly nothing like an italian sandwhich with the highest quality ingredients! The Della Casa blew me away- it doesn't look like much but the focaccia, prosciutto, and stracciatella are top notch. It was the perfect amount! The calabrese was a bit of a letdown- it tasted like focaccia with tomatoes, which is technically what it is but we couldn't really tell there was nduja in there. For sandwiches that came to around $19 each after tip, it would be nice to be a tad more generous with the ingredients. It's cute in here and they have a nice shop as well, the wine selection looks great. I'm excited to come back to try the gelato! read more

See all

I saw someone review this place on social media and I had to check it out. It did not disappoint!!! I love that they have their own parking lot right outside the business so no need to worry about street parking. Once you're inside the shop, it's pretty spacious and it smells sooo good like fresh bread. They have several tables too. You can order at the counter and then pick where you'd like to sit. I don't remember the name of the sandwich I had but it had cheese, prosciutto, and pesto, and it was delicious. It was pretty big so I had to save some for later. I also tried the pistachio gelato and it was the best gelato I've ever had. read more

See all

Super cute sandwich shop that just opened next to Lox. Not a lot of seating inside but the tables are beautiful with the ceramic tiles. There's also a large selection of ceramic goods and other cute things inside in addition to the food! All their sandwiches looked amazing on the menu. We ended up trying a few - the Della Casa was a fav. The bread was super fresh with delish sea salt and the prosciutto was also so good. The gelato also looked amazing and we got to try the pistachio, which was so good. Overall, love this new sandwich shop and would definitely be back! read more

Piazza Pelino - Della Casa - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

A small place with crazy good sandwiches and gelato! If you value quality- then you'll love this place!! Order at the counter from friendly folks, seating options are cozy and its not too loud or trying too hard. A little taste of Italy like you would find at a walk up shop in Cinque Terra. read more

Piazza Pelino - Outside. Just off High Street, next to Lox, small parking lot in front. - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

A Culinary Gem in the Heart of Short North! Columbus, meet your new go-to spot for gourmet sandwiches --Piazza Pelino in the Short North! This place has already earned a permanent spot in my list of favorite eateries, and here's why: I had the pleasure of trying both the IL Top and Genovese sandwiches, and let me tell you, these are not just sandwiches--they are works of art. **IL Top Sandwich:** This masterpiece is a flavor explosion from the first bite. The IL Top features layers of thinly sliced, perfectly seasoned mortadella, rich, creamy burrata, and a delightful pistachio pesto that ties everything together. The focaccia, fresh from their bakery, is crisp on the outside with a soft, airy interior that soaks up the pesto without becoming soggy. It's balanced, it's savory, and it's absolutely addictive. Each bite transports you straight to an Italian piazza, with flavors so authentic you'd think you were dining under the Tuscan The ambiance at Piazza Pelino is just as impressive as the food. The decor is chic yet cozy, with a modern twist that pays homage to classic Italian eateries. The staff are incredibly welcoming, knowledgeable, and passionate about the menu--clearly proud to be part of such a stellar establishment. Piazza Pelino is more than just a restaurant; it's a dining destination. Whether you're a Columbus local or just passing through, this is a place you simply cannot miss. Trust me, one visit and you'll be planning your next meal here before you've even left the table. **Pro tip:** Go early because this place is bound to get popular fast. And don't forget to try one of their homemade desserts--they're the perfect ending to a perfect meal. Columbus, you've got yourself a new culinary star in Piazza Pelino. Five stars all the way! read more

Piazza Pelino - IL Top and Genovese - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

This place was on my list for a while and it did not disappoint! Cute interior and decor, definitely Instagram-friendly. I got the Della Casa which was delicious. The bread was super soft and all the ingredients tasted fresh. The sandwich was on the pricier end, but was a decent size. Overall would highly recommend, and looking forward to coming back to try the other sandwiches! read more

It's a cute Italian inspired restaurant in the downtown. Good thing is they have parking which might be a nightmare on weekends. I have had their gelato. They change their flavours often. I like their ricotta cheese flavour and tiramisu. The options are limited though. The staff is polite and courteous I had to edit my review. I tried their focaccia sandwiches. We have tried 2 different sandwiches and they are subpar for the price they are charging. There was nothing good about their sandwiches read more

Piazza Pelino - Italian - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Got around to trying this new gem in the short north! It so delicious and the atmosphere is warm and inviting. You can tell the ingredients are fresh and well thought out. The staff was super friendly. While it is a tad on the high price side, it's a nice place to treat yourself on occasion. One recommendation I do have for them (and I almost took one star off for this) is that the focaccia bread would have been better if it was slightly warmed. Mine came out relatively cold and when you combine cold bread with cold meats, cheese and speeds, you lose some contrast. Also, it's a jaw workout chewing cold focaccia. Overall, just an excellent place. read more

Piazza Pelino - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Finally a dream come true and home away from home! I've visited Italy a few times in my life, and have always loved those street focaccia sandwiches. I try to recreate at home, but not quite the same. I was thrilled to hear a place like this was coming. We split the Il Top and got a blood orange soda. Absolutely delicious! Their focaccia was perfectly moist and infused with the right amount and olive oil flavoring. High quality ingredients that are imported from Italy that warrant the cost. So worth it, and inside was lovely as well. Loved all the wine there along with the Italian specialty items! They also serve gelato which we got to sample. If we weren't so full we would've gotten that too. Their amaretto was to die for. We will definitely be back, great work on this place! Authenticity was definitely there. read more

Piazza Pelino - Il Top - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

This was a highly anticipated try for me, and I came ready!! We ordered the il top and Della casa, along with 2 scoops of gelato - coffee and chocolate First the aesthetic, so beautiful !! Love the umbrellas and all of the shelves to look at while you wait! So bright and welcoming inside we decided to sit down because of this. The food... WOW! The il top was so creamy with a sweet pistachio pesto YUM! Della casa had a fresh pesto, with a nice meaty bite of prosciutto. Now for the creamy smooth gelato, I will dream of it... the coffee was so rich not too much but enough to tickle your taste buds. Normally I am not a fan of chocolate but I'd come back for more. After looking at pics the price was a turn off, HOWEVER seeing how big these sandwiches were and tasting the quality of the ingredients I can easily justify it (despite the little bit of meat you get) I will be telling everyone I know to come get a tasty bite here, you won't be disappointed. The owners are always so sweet, and genuinely happy to help. The staff were kind, and educated on the menu. They were able to explain the ingredients and help us navigate the menu. I do plan to come back and eventually work my way through all of the items on the menu! What a great spot, job well done! read more

See all

Ok, 4 stars just because of the gelato. The focaccia was amazing and delicious. The sandwich (prosciutto e fichi) was just ok. It was too sweet for my tastes. The gelato was so amazing. We tried tiramisu and coffee, but all the flavors we sampled were delicious. And the umbrellas hanging in the cafe are so cute! read more

Piazza Pelino - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Ugh where to begin?! This place is so cute and the food is like a dream. It's simple, not heavy and made of the best materials. I got the il top and it was delightful, nutty, sweet, and simple read more

Piazza Pelino - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Great friendly service. Cute decor. Sandwich wasn't as great as I hoped but I think if you like simple bread heavy sandwiches you would enjoy it. I asked for extra meat because I worried there wouldn't be enough. Focaccia could be more flavorful. I wouldn't be back for the sandwich. The gelato was good, I wish it had stronger flavor on pistachio but it was very smooth and creamy. I would come back for another flavor of the gelato for sure. read more

Piazza Pelino - $17 Asked for extra meat so this is not the norm - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

I've had the privilege to travel to parts of the world in my life and it was here in Columbus, OH I discovered the BEST sandwich in my 62+ years!!! Amazing focaccia for the sandwiches and the Il Top was truly hands down the winner. The meats were super fresh and the pistachio crumbled a top the fillings - magnificent. Service was very helpful in picking the right sandwich. BRAVO! read more

This place has the BEST sandwiches in Columbus hands down. The homemade focaccia is wonderful, crispy crust with a fluffy chewy interior, high quality mortadella and prosciutto, and fresh pesto of various kinds. It's lovely. The cookies are also outstanding. Everything is just fantastic and I hope they stay open for a long long time. read more

This place is turning into one of my favorites in the city. The Prosiutto E Fichi is my current favorite. I also am a big fan of both Ricotta and Pistachio gelato. read more

Piazza Pelino - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

We got the Massimo and Della Casa sandwiches. They were both delicious. I love the prosciutto. And the different sauces / spreads on each sandwich were so good. One had pesto and fresh cheese while the other was a hazelnut and fig spread. Sooo good!!! And you could buy wine from Italy too. I'd love to check out there Wine tasting nights!!! read more

Tried a new place for date night! YUM. A little deli serving Italian sandwiches + gelato. All the sandwich ingredients are imported from Italia, except the focaccia, which was made TODAY. House-made gelato. Bellissimo! read more

See all

The GELATO was amazing! Creamy and smooth and not too sweet. I got half chocolate and half raspberry. My only complaint was having a petite little serving thing when what I really needed was a child's beach pail shovel. Probably saved me from having "too much" though... (whatever that means) Trapanese sandwich. Diced tomatoes, Pecorino Romano, provolone, almond slices, fresh basil. Focaccia was fresh and delicious! The ingredients were fresh and flavorful. Tried the packaged "Confetti Pelino" candied vanilla almonds. They're different from American candy, but in a good way. Crunchy shell, light vanilla taste. These are not chocolate, fyi. Full almond in the center, not sure if it's baked, boiled or raw. "Limonata soda" Italian lemon soda. What is this magic?! Not too sweet, very lemony, and refreshing. The restaurant is sizable and easily accessible off of High Street. It is well-decorated and very interesting to take in as you inhale your gelato. The prices are very reasonable for the quality of ingredients. The staff were really nice, but didn't explain much beyond me asking direct questions as to what things were. Most everything, (names, descriptions, etc) is written in Italian, and I don't know a lick of Italian, so there was a lot of "what is...?" read more

See all

Absolutely love this little short north gem! Reminds me of my visit to Italy when you would walk into a little store and they have the most amazing sandwiches displayed. And they taste as good as they look! read more

Come hungry and prepare to have a pricey lunch. With that being said, I would gladly do it again soon. Had the Della casa and tiramisu gelato. They were heaven and worth getting out of the office for lunch. Service was kind and quick. Helpful, attentive staff. Portion size of the focaccia bread was gigantic and flavorful with the right amount of sea salt on top. The sandwich didn't look to have a lot of meat inside but it was actually perfect. They had about 10 different flavors of gelato and the texture was flavorful and the perfect consistency. read more

See all

Honestly, what you get for bread spread cheese and very little meat is way overpriced. The focaccia isn't soft and all the different options and flavors should be discussed before purchasing because a lot of them have very strong flavors. We bought three and only liked one out of the three. We were a family of four and bought three sandwiches and four gelato and our bill was almost $100 with water. They do not provide any filtered water just tap water or you can buy water for six dollars. I'd give the gelato five stars hands-down, but the sandwiches in my opinion are incredibly overpriced and very skimpy on the ingredients that year essentially paying for read more

Piazza Pelino knows quality!!!The homemade focaccia loaded with olive oil and topped with salt crystals, freshly shaven Italian meats, decadent burrata, and garlicky, aromatic pesto shine with flavor and authenticity! They even have a pastry chef as part of their incredible team. We will definitely be back to try the gelato. We are thrilled this is in Columbus!! read more

Cute little store with amazing selection of gelato! Thank you to the kind lady who gave us samples to try and her recommendations.

Oh my gosh, these sandwiches are amazing!!! So fresh, the flavors complement each other so well. The people who work here are so nice. Will definitely be back!! read more

Excellent food and great service. Nick was a big help picking out our meals. Feels like a trip to Italy.

Got the Della Top - fantastic focaccia sandwich with just the right amount of stracciatella cheese and prosciutto

First off, the atmosphere was 10/10 (from the paintings on the walls to the gelato we came there for). We walked in 15 minutes before close and yet the staff was very welcoming and went above and beyond with helping us choose which gelato to get since all were so delicious! We didn't feel pressured to leave afterwards whatsoever! If you're ever in the area and are looking for a good gelato place this is THE ONE! read more