Although I haven't actually been there (yet), this might seem disingenuous, but I am from Long Island and I know what good Italian food looks like! I would be willing to bet the chicken parm is amazing, and Anthony is great! read more

Great Food, great place. Love his videos, fake reviews are not good, trying to hurt someone's business because you don't like the social media is stupidity. Just scroll away if you don't like them. read more

November 1, 2025, was the very first time I visited and dined at Phil's Pizza (only in) Syosset! I had the best time! From the time I walked in, I was so excited and captivated by the ambiance and the family-friendly environment. The food was excellent! I recognized Anthony behind the counter. I missed King Anthony :))) I did not hesitate to tell Anthony how much I appreciate his content and his great job promoting this restaurant. The night started out with us ordering wine, beer, and a victory slice of pizza. I had just run the Abbot Dash to the Finish Line in NYC (the shakeout before the NYC MARATHON), and I wanted to have my dinner in Long Island at Phil's. It was about 7 p.m., and we were lucky to get a table! I ordered the Porterhouse steak with broccoli rabe and potatoes! The restaurant is clean, and there are lots of families! Tells you how much people love this place and how well they dress for the occasion. Good job, both Anthony's, and thank you for your daily posts. I am coming to visit again very soon! Great food, great pizza, and an excellent menu! read more

Great food, awesome service, their videos on social media are a riot!!! 5 Stars!!!! Will definitely return read more

Best damn Pizza in NY. That Phil guy is a little mouthy but its raw and honest the way a boss running things should be. Can't help but respect it. Atmosphere is nice, no weird stares or idiots asking me ethnic questions its great. Visit Phil's if you want good pizza and a place to take a load off and forget your freakin' problems over pizza! This review is for you, Anthony and the trolls who keep review bombing you for no reason. read more

Pizza was good, I should have gone with the NY style slice over the Sicilian, but the hot honey on the angry grandma was fantastic. They actually sell that separately if you want to take some home. The real star here was the chocolate peanut butter pie....Fantastic dessert options. Vibe was okay but the service was great. read more

Phil's Pizzeria & Restaurant - Angry Grandma Slice, Grandma Pie, Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie - Italian Near Me - Syosset, New York

Love Phil's Pizza! I was first introduced in 2017 (before they were social media stars!) and have always made an effort to come back everything I visit the island! Love the Mac n Cheese Slice, Angry Grandma, Fig-get bout it!, Chicken Bacon Ranch, etc. Best pizza showcase in LI! And of course, their reels are hilarious!! read more

See all

Clean, great people, they know how to make pizza, and they are very entertaining as well. Can't wait to have my next Pie there read more

This place is AWESOME! The service is amazing, the food is fantastic and the restaurant is spotless! I highly recommend this restaurant! read more

I have not been there but planning to make the trip up from Philly hopefully soon. Love the videos!!!

Prices are extremely high. Food is okay. We have definitely have had better. Food was cold and just over all not worth the price.

At here last night after seeing funny TikTok posts. Great food and atmosphere. Funny dude

Was there last month and the food was excellent. We had the best fried calamari ,crisp and tender the way it should cooked The main entrees had good portions and we even had some left overs to take home The waitress was knowledgeable about the food and portions and guided us with ease. Definitely will be back and we are recommending this restaurant to all. read more

One of the greatest places that serves pizza, it's very tasty I loved it there Syosset New York baby Phil's Pizza!

I live in Arizona, and I was visiting a friend in New York, and he said, you have to try this pizzeria. It's my favorite, so we went to Phil's place. And oh, my God, the Pizza was off the hook, it was really good. I had one slice, and then I had to try the basic spaghetti and meatballs. The meatballs were some of the best I've ever had in my whole life. The sauce was flavorful balanced. It was just perfect, and I met that guy in the video, and he was the nicest person you would ever meet really good guy. And I asked him about his videos, and he said that is just to make people laugh. He's totally opposite of the video. What she is, I could say, first-hand he's a gentleman and a nice guy, and he runs a classy Italian style pizzeria. You people on Long Island are very lucky to have him. read more

This place is best of the best love the pizza there. Owner is always there very welcoming and making sure food is perfect and everyone is taken care of. read more

Excellent food and service!!! Anthony took a picture with us too! Fun time!!! His videos are hilarious read more

Phil's Pizzeria & Restaurant - Italian Near Me - Syosset, New York

Visiting a friend on Long Island and visited this business that has a large social media following. I enjoyed a couple of slices of NYC and found it to be very good. The service was prompt and quick as they reheated my slices. The store is clean and well maintained. Certainly if I return to LI I will visit again. read more

Food is so good! I go in my lunch hour to get pizza slices but have also had entrees after work. Everything's is fresh and flavorful! I wish I could go more often and his videos are funny! read more

I work down the block and this place has the best pizza and the best garlic knots. I love their veggie slice but i am OBSESSED with their fig slice. I highly recommend you try their famous fig slice. read more

Phil's Pizzeria & Restaurant - Italian Near Me - Syosset, New York

Outstanding . Great people and great food . Everyone in the family loves this place . Super clean .

Love not Phil cracks me up daily. Service is top of the line. Ambiance is perfect. Food looks yummy!

I love the manager, his videos are the best on the internet, open and honest, and for fun, says things people wish they can tell people, but it's all for fun and entertainment purposes, really people need to get a grip, if he was here in Henderson/Las Vegas I would frequent his place at least one a week, the man's been in business for years and obviously is making good pizza and other delicious delectables, bravo for him trying to break the monotony and do something different to entertain the people, if I am ever in that area of New Jersey I will definitely be eating at Phil's Pizzeria, God Bless You and your staff. read more

Well, I am finally able to review after Yelp had a hold on this account for a while. I just don't understand why people continue to do strange and harmful things to other people and businesses. Two stars... seriously? Now... down to business. My wife and I came here after watching [many] of their instagram reels. We just had to visit this place which is actually not far from me. Easy in and out right off of Jericho Tpke with plenty of parking in this very busy parking lot. We walked into a very busy restaurant with lots and lots of electricity in the air. People waiting and lots of food being served both at the tables and for take out. We walked to the front and give our name when I saw the counter that showd they currently have 103,000 followers on Instagram. This is what happens when you put out really good social media posts and engage your audience. People are just waiting for the new content to be posted. The place is extremely comfortable and welcoming. The team here is fantastic. Crazy busy and the wait staff are all so attentive to all the tables and what's happening around them. Everything they speak about in their ads always looks and sounds so good. We were going with our favorites tonight: Appetizers: - Baked Clams - EXCELLENT crispy toping with juicy clams that taste fantastic - Plane salad - cold and crisp, exactly how a salad should be served. DInner: - Grilled Chicken - Best grilled chicken ever. Not just a lttle salt, pepper then put on the stove, but marinated and perfectly grilled. Tasty, fresh and was served over a fabulous broccoli rabe. - Lasagna - my favorite of all time. A plateful of well cooked lasagna pasta, very delicious rich-tasty sauce with plenty of meat and cheese. (check out the pictures) Everything was just fantastic and we are looking forward to our return trip. We need to go through the menu here... So much to try. Too bad the limit is five stars... could definitely go higher! KUDOs to the team at Phil's Pizzeria & Restaurant read more

See all

Wife and I just got back from a trip back east. One leg of the trip was Cold Spring Harbor. Being so close to Phils, we had to stop in . I am a sucker for their online skits. Now I am a sucker for their pizza. Wife and I ordered a whole plain cheese to eat in. I feel, if a plain cheese can't make it, why bother to pile other crap on top of it. The plain was delicious The cheese and just right amount of sauce, and crust were perfect and flavorful. I wish I had pizza like this in california. Keep up your fun "commercials" read more

Amazing pizza! Hope to try it soon. Service was excellent, couldn't ask for a more engaging experience with a cynical twist. The place smells of culinary adventures. Nice, well lit atmosphere. Very clean. read more

Great atmosphere and service. Plenty of variety And I was hungry. Like I always am. Love their videos too. read more

Best slice in the city. Perfect for a quick lunch. Excellent service always. Funny online videos.

Pizza selection is insane. Not only does it look delicious you can't go wrong with any choice you make. Must tries are the stuffed eggplant pizza and spicy vodka. Dinner menu is just as filled with the classics along with special's. What tops it off the owner Anthony not only is he one of the nicest guy you'll ever meet but make you feel at home every time. Highly recommended read more

Ah love your videos! Wish pizza was this good everywhere. Won't regret a visit. I'm not a big social media guy! But some people deserve our appreciation of their charm! read more

Pizza was great , chicken parm is out of this world , great atmosphere , very clean restaurant Anthony is a great guy read more

what he does is a riot and it's all staged so it's not like he's really doing that to actual customers but it's a riot and it's when I get back to Long Island. I am definitely gonna check this restaurant out because of the pizzas that he has out there look delicious and his full menu looks even better. Keep doing it. read more

I was way out in Long Island to go to my car dealer for service so I said wait I'm pretty close to the famous Phil's Pizza .... Only in syosset ! I follow them on social media and the skits they do really attracted me to the place . I wanted to see the place in person and see the infamous "I'm not Phil" lol Anthony . I ordered a margherita slice and a chicken parm slice . First off the place is very nice clean and well laid out . They have a nice variety of pizzas and a huge menu ! Also the skits on social media are just that skits if you go there they are very polite and professional and detailed . So as far as the pizza I ordered I really enjoyed them both but prob the margherita a little more that's always my favorite style of pizza . The chicken parm slice was heavy and I got too full too quick . However both were really good and also wanna add the prices are very reasonable maybe even too low in my opinion. Next time I go back to the dealer over there I'll stop by to try other items . read more

See all

This place is incredible! Great service and Anthony is hysterical! Just look at that pizza.. doesn't it look delicious?

I love Phil's pizza.. when will he be coming to Stuart Florida? Love his videos .. how's your eggplant rollantini.. u make me wish I was Italian cept they usually have a mustache read more

Staff very friendly. Food always great! Everything always tastes fresh. Look forward to trying new items every time I go and am never disappointed read more

Outstanding pizza tremendous service Great food highly recommend By the way Great videos!! read more

Hilarious videos I never scroll past one. Wish I could visit in person. The food looks amazing

This is a great pizzeria. Perfect pizza, friendly, funny service, ice cold Pepsi. Also try the chicken parm. People who diss this restaurant are uninformed losers with no taste and I hope they die horrible deaths, and soon. read more

5 star service. clean service area. delivery was a bit slow but probably because they were busy and they are sofaking good.