Ralph's Pizza is an absolute gem. Hands down the best veggie pizza I've ever had--piping hot, perfectly cooked, and you can taste the difference because they roast the vegetables before they go on the pie. Total game changer. The slices are insane, and the grandma pie is equally incredible--crispy, flavorful, and done just right. Honestly, this is the best pizza I've had on Long Island. Must try. Do not sleep on this place. read more

After a long scary evening at Bayville Scream park I took the kids over to Ralph's since they wanted pizza. This was our first time there and the workers was very nice to me and the kids. Pizza was nice and fresh. Fruit punch was also very good. Inside had a nice Italian feel and a lot of seating available. I would definitely recommend if you are out in Bayville area. read more

See all

Been ordering here consistently, and spreading the word about how good the food has become w/new ownership. Recent order had a little mistep, charged just over $30 bucks for a regular pie w/chicken cutlet topping. Could have just ordered a specialty pie on the menu for $25. Wasn't told that one specific topping would be an extra $10 on a $17 large pie. Inquired about it during pickup, they didn't seem interested. If were on the menu, it wouldn't be a surprise. Next time I'll just confirm the cost. Otherwise, I don't think you can find a better Sicilian pie in the area, it's always delicious, sauce & dough is just right; rolls & heros are fantastic as well. Order ahead bc they always make the pies fresh; takes 15-20 minutes which is great for a hot & fresh pie. read more

Ralph's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bayville, New York

E X C E L L E N T Everything a local pizza place should be, friendly, tasty from the slice, to the pasta dishes, at fair prices. Honoring the original owner, Ralph read more

Can't believe I've lived one town over for so many years and never stepped foot in Ralph's. Great food, good portions and a very friendly staff. Can't wait to come back. read more

See all

I have lived in the area for several years and tried Ralphs Pizza when I first moved. It wasn't good, so I never went back. I was a big fan of Mario's and would always go there. However, Marios has been lacking lately. The prices for a regular pie are out of control! So, we decided to give Ralphs a shot. Well, I was shocked because the food was delicious! They changed owners, and it shows! They are so polite and friendly, and the pizza is delicious. I once ordered a pie with four different special slices on the pie, and they accommodated me. The prices are REASONABLE! You get what you pay for and I appreciate that they didn't just up the prices to ridiculous amounts. I will be going back, and sadly, Marios has lost my business and is a thing of the past in my eyes...... read more

I stopped in for some slices. The staff is great. Everything looked delicious. The chipotle slice was amazing. I definitely will be back.

Have been hearing around town that the specialty slices at Ralph's (under the new owners) are great and they really are amazing. So this past week (Christmas '24) we had occasion to order trays of food and decided to try Ralph's. They were a total success - perfectly prepared and delicious! Everyone at this party was very impressed as were we. Chicken francese is pictured here - it was very tender and a real treat. Eggplant Rolatini and chicken marsala were also wonderful. And last but not least the bread that was included -- you know the bread that in most places is disappointing with takeout-- Ralph's bread was absolutely addicting! Not traditional Italian bread but really satisfying and even served cold it was gone in an instant. So a big thank you to the staff at Ralph's including the very talented chef for helping to make our holiday party a success! read more

Ralph's Pizza - Tray of Ralph's Chicken Francese - Pizza Near Me - Bayville, New York

I love this place so much. Their pizza is unmatched. The best dough, the best sauce and theirs special slices are incredible!!! Their pasta and chicken dishes are amazing as well. I eat here way to other, but it's just so good I can't help it. The work staff is also so nice which makes going there even better. read more

Best fast casual italian spot in bayville. Our family goes every Friday to eat in or take out and the food always hits. Staff are super friendly, attentive and always go out of their way to accommodate our large group. We've tried almost everything on the menu and haven't been disappointed yet. Some of their best dishes are the chicken or shrimp paesano, eggplant Parmesan and fusilli Al paillard. You also can't go wrong with any of their slices or the calzone!! read more

Came in and stood at the door waiting to be seated. And waited. And waited. Disorganized. Seating was all over the place. Had one of those makeshift dividers closed in my face to close off the "dining" area as opposed to the "takeout" area. Servers were rude. Counter staff was rude. Fries were okay. Penne slice was dry. read more

Ralph's Pizza - Sicilians and penne slice - Pizza Near Me - Bayville, New York

See all

Loved the pizza - best pizza in the world! It was perfect for me - I ordered a regular slice and a Margherita slice - crunchy crust, delicious sauce, cheese cooked well (not gooey) and all cooked to perfection! Loved the pizza - wish I didn't live 4 hours away from my favorite pizza spot. All the specialty pizzas - Marsala, sweet n spicy chicken, etc. and other menu items looked amazing as well! Staff were friendly & welcoming. Thanks Ralph's! read more

Recently moved to Bayville from Brooklyn last summer , my son's missed our local pizzeria Fabio's . Well I can say we've all become big fans of Ralph's , it's walking distance from our house. The food is fast, takeout is very reliable, and very tasty. A nice, convenient, and consistent local establishment #Recommended read more

Ralph's is a family favorite in our house. They are accommodating, very friendly, the food is very tasty and there always seems to be a steady flow of people in the restaurant. Eating in is just as delightful as take out. I have been telling everyone about the eggplant pizza...it's out of this world!!! I always order at least one slice on top of my ordered food to bring home and heat up later. read more

Ordered 4 slices of pizza for $45!! Mind you the 3 pepperoni slices were tinier than frozen pizza from the supermarket. And were burnt and most likely just re-heated already burnt! Not sure what a house slice is, but when we asked to have a bigger slice like the ones up front, they told us they couldn't do it. I don't like to throw this out there casually, but this is definitely a townie ass establishment that's not even hiding their racism. No thank you!! read more

Best pizza restaurant in the area. Reasonable prices and good service. Nice view of Long Island sound.

Omg I'm in heaven came here last night with 4 friends ordered 2 pies each and everyone of us said this an amazing pizza. Highly recommend will definitely return read more

Very good clams. I can tell are fresh I used to be a clammer and they shells were still dark a sign of very fresh clams. Love the pizza and food. read more

Great food, great pizza! Love this gem in Bayville. Definitely will be coming back here again and again.

Stopped by here a week ago and had a couple of Grandpa slices and they were delicious. Before I wrote a review I wanted to stop by again and make sure it was not a fluke. So I had a couple of Grandpa slices today and they were even better than first time. And, they were the two best slices of pizza I have had on Long Island in a long long time. The fellas behind the counter were very courteous and friendly. They thanked me for coming by and said to come back again. I will of course be back! I do not know how the restaurant food is - I will make an effort to get out there for dinner one night - but I can not recommend the Grandpa slices high enough. If you are ever in the area of want to take a ride, grab a couple of Grandpa slices and sit outside and enjoy the view. The view is almost as good as the pizza!! If I lived in Bayville I would be here all the time. I look forward to my next visit. read more

go take the drive to Bayville NY Long Island is beautiful and known for its beaches ...Bayville is small town long Island lovely sound beaches and there is this little strip of eateries and a amusement arcade and there is Ralphs its been here a very long time I used to come here as a kid ...and yes indeed Ralphs was here so lets talk Pizza its worth the trip from my home in Syosset because good pizza is hard to come by Ralphs is old school its not fancy its just good order at the counter friendly guys working there many pizzas to choose from white, baked ziti, buffalo chicken, sicilian my favorite and do not remember the name ... but its crispy thin crust with sauce no cheese square style its SO good and I mean really good finish off that yummy slice with a fresh cannoli you will very happy read more

Ralph's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bayville, New York

See all

Gave this a try, new owners! I loved the pizza and the eggplant parm. So good and worth the trip to Bayville!

If you haven't had Ralph's in a while then I highly recommend you do! They're recently under new ownership and it's delicious. Very friendly service. I definitely recommend the Chicken Romano ( my new favorite dish) and the Rigatoni Fiorentine ( my ultimate go to). read more

Having moved away from NY to the south I always crave NY pizza whenever I'm up there. Tried Ralph's on a recent visit I found their pizza excellent. I'm a cheese person type of guy and it was delicious. read more

This place is terrible ! Ordered a pizza and a lobster ravioli. First of all, the pizza was oily, most likely because of cheap cheese they must have used. Second, the lobster ravioli tasted like what I imagine a gym sock would taste like. The smell was horrific all together. When I confronted the owner about the food, he got nasty and refused to refund my money. I just read that this place has four violations. How are they still open? read more

A No Brainer! This place went way beyond my expectations. My wife and I stopped by for a slice and stayed for dinner in their formal sit down area (I still got the buffalo slice :-)). The staff was some of the nicest people I have ever met. Helpful with the menu options and checking in on us throughout the evening. The menu options were plentiful and prices were a steal...especially for the area! Stop in for a quick slice or sit down in the formal area for a full service...no decision is a bad one here. The food here is made to order and you can taste that in every bite. We had a few items, including seafood and poultry. I heard from a couple sitting next to us that the clams are the best dish on the menu. I cannot wait to bring back others to this restaurant. I can't imagine the wait in the summer and urge you to stop by now. Anyone reviewing less than a full five stars is insane. If you want good food at a great price served by nice people in a clean neat environment...come here! read more

Ralph's Pizza - Fried Calamari - Pizza Near Me - Bayville, New York

See all

Just came back from Ralph's, having satisfied my semi monthly craving for their eggplant marinara pizza. It's hands down my favorite although their veggie pizza is a solid runner up. Their entrees are great too. If you're in the mood for more than a quick bite, the grilled balsamic chicken with sautéed vegetables is delicious, especially when you want to go lighter on the carbs. My husband alternates between their spaghetti with white clam sauce and the rigatoni Fiorentina (another of my go-to's). My cousin loves their shrimp in white wine but she's not a garlic fan so they make it without, and it still tastes great. Follow all that up with a fresh filled cannoli and you can't go wrong. They're trying to make their mark in a community that still reveres the former owners and I think they're holding their own with the quality of their entrees. read more

This place is a staple of Bayville. Recently changed owners and the plain slice is still great Zero flop, 7.4 I recommend plain or pepperoni read more

I ordered a mushroom pizza and what I got appeared to be half mushroom with all the mushrooms on a few slices. I asked the guy at the counter where my mushrooms were and he looked at the pie and said wow, I don't know. Another employee walked over to inquire about my problem and I said where are the mushrooms and she said did you order a half mushroom and I said no. Then the owner came over and rudely said what the problem with the pizza. Once again I said where are the mushrooms and he rudely and arrogantly said that they were under the cheese and started pointing obnoxious closely to touching the pizza where he felt the mushrooms were. Ralph's isn't a good enough restaurant to be so rude and arrogant when a customer addresses poor customer service. I will never eat there again and spend the extra 10 minutes in the car to go to Glen Cove for some quality Italian food. read more

Ralph's Pizza - Disgraceful customer service! When I asked where the mushrooms were the owner rudely snapped at me that they're there. So Rude! Never Again! - Pizza Near Me - Bayville, New York

During our summer visits to the beach at Bayville, we always make time at the end of the day to go to Ralph's for Pizza. From the regular to the specialty slices the taste is super and the crust is usually nice and crispy so it doesnt fall apart. This past weekend we trekked from Syosset to Bayville to partake in the pizza..,.a trip well worthwhile. We have eaten at all the local pizza palors, but Ralph's on the Sound has it all! read more

Ralph's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bayville, New York

Unless you want to wait 1.5 hrs for a cold pizza, DO NOT order delivery from Ralph's. very Disappointing.

REALLY $7.60 FOR A BEER everyone's struggling and you RIP off hospital people! So disheartened. Then a young lady says " you shouldn't drink"! Really read more

This restaurant is outstanding! The food here was amazing. I had the plain and margarita pizza along with the lobster ravioli. My family and I couldn't get enough of it. You can tell they use Fresh cheese on the pizzas with a homemade sauce. The lobster ravioli is to die for. All of the food was at a reasonable price. Will definitely be coming here again. This restaurant gets a well deserved 5 stars. read more

Service and food is great, good vibes and nice view of the beach. Authentic Italian food, highly recommend the baked clams and veal chop. Seems like it's family owned and operated. Great spot to take your family out once a week. Highly recommend. read more

Ralph's Pizza - a pizza with tomatoes and mozzarella - Pizza Near Me - Bayville, New York

Food is quite good. The reason I'm giving it 4 stars and not 5 cuz it's the only pizza place I know that charge tax on a slice and charge you service charge for using a credit card. So you better use cash but prepare to pay taxes on everything. read more

This place was nothing what I expected. I ordered a cheese burger, they gave me one of them thin pattys i hate when restaurants do that, the fries where straight out a bag snd they are very over priced. I wouldn't recommend this place. read more

Delicious! We picked up food to go and walked across the street to eat at the benches overlooking the water. Food was ready quickly and was delicious. read more

Ralph's Pizza - Stuffed shells - Pizza Near Me - Bayville, New York

I love Ralph's! living in bayville, there aren't many options when it comes to fast food or delivery. Ive lived in many different locations however, and I will say that Ralph's is up there with some of the best pizza I've ever had - u may say "well u need to try some other pizzas." Well I have. Plenty. Their pizza is only amazing though, when it's not overcooked. Every now and again you'll get an overcooked pizza from here which sucks but it happens from time to time at every pizzeria in the world so can't really fault them there. Their shrimp and eggplant parmesean heros are bomb Mac and cheese balls are just ridiculously delicious. I haven't tried everything on their menu bc I would just make my own pasta at home but for a regular pie, or heroes they hit the spot almost always. And the Mac and cheese balls u just have to try. Sometimes staff can be a little more friendly but I get it! Not everyone is always rosey and peachy. All good overall in that department as well. read more

The new owners of Ralph's Pizzeria and Restaurant have redecorated but stlll offer some of Long Island best Pizza, pasta, meatballs and fabulous house made Italian pastries . Their luscious cannoli are made by the "gods" ! read more

See all

Ive had numerous different pastas from this location and they all have been amazing ! The pizzas are to die for