Talenti's

Grabbed breakfast at this store. Because we are still in this pandemic we were required to wear a…read moremask before entering. Bayville Deli makes amazing sandwiches. They make sandwiches to order. And the soft rolls they have are awesome! They carry sodas, water, tea, and other essentials. Not a lot of room when you have to social distance but it was worth the wait! Wish I had time to try their pizza. I'm sure it's great.

When I was young, I used to go goto Bayville a lot. They had an excellent arcade, for those who…read moreremember. So being back in town, I decided to try some eating. "Bayville Deli & Pizzeria" is a combo, you don't hear about a lot. Pizza, deli are two different businesses, and for good reason. It's not easy to mix. Inside it's a decent size. It's a bit dated, but I love that it offers seating for guest. At the counter, the staff were very friendly. They took my order and went to work. Once I got it, I sat down to eat. However, when you want an egg sandwich, you expect a couple things. For starters, cheese should be melted. Second, they should add more ketchup when you ask. So my experience was underwhelming. I wish it could have been better. I love Bayville, but some parts are not always how we remember.

Bacon, Egg & Cheese sandwich

See all

Bayville Meat Center

4.7(15 reviews)

1.5 mi

Awesome local butcher in Bayville , very interesting sausages , great beef /variety of cuts ,…read morepoultry and phenomenal fried chicken, sandwiches. One really cool product they offer is B.A.R.F Dog food (Biologically Appropriate Raw Food ) at a super reasonable price . Well worth a trip from all local towns along the North Shore of Long Island . Awesome local business to have in Bayville, local and family owned always a great combination Fantastic service in an old school butcher shop with some new twists

Got a Pork Cutlet Pasquale which consisted of fried hot cherry peppers with garlic. Also got a Ed's…read morecheesesteak which consisted of sirloin, caramelized onions and American cheese. Cute store.

Interior

See all

Interior

Harborside Delicatessen

3.3(38 reviews)

3.5 mi

Visit Date: June 5, 2022…read more I came here with my boyfriend for breakfast. He knows Oyster Bay very well so he suggested this place for breakfast. I got the same sandwich he did except without bacon since I'm a vegetarian. I had eggs, cheese, and a hashbrown on a roll with hot sauce and ketchup. Carb overload but that's how I've been living lately. The sandwich was delicious. I felt like I was eating a better version of a McDonald's breakfast sandwich. It was crunchy because of the hashbrowns with a nice extra salt flavor which mixed well with the ketchup and hot sauce, I felt like they complimented each other. The coffee was also good! Definitely a good deli to visit for breakfast!

Storefront restaurant with a huge menu. Tough choice what to order…read more I opted for Panini Italiano, ham cappicola, genoa salami, mortadella, provolone cheese, with sun dried tomatoes, spinach and red onions, very good. My wife chose the Fried Eggplant panini with roasted peppers and feta cheese. her complaint was that the eggplant was dry.

Harborside Deli now serves Crepes for breakfast

Harborside Delicatessen

See all

Food Basket

3.4(9 reviews)

0.2 mi

This is a great market for dry goods -- boxed crackers and cookies, beverages and other misc stuff…read moreas well as dairy (milk, yogurt, cream, etc.) -- but beware anything involving refrigerated proteins (steak, chicken, fish) and the deli counter. Not only are these items mediocre at best, any savings you'll achieve will be negated when you throw away your inedible food. Buyer beware.

The supermarket is not very far from my aunt house. I just want to buy some fruit to bring with me…read moreon the beach. There are a plenty of food over there, line is not long at that time, and I can ask any staff for the items I'm looking for.

See all

Country Plaza Delicatessen

3.7(49 reviews)

2.6 mi

There is in fact, nothing in the world better than a great deli sandwich. I am often a creature of…read morehabit and don't stray too far from what I've decided is the perfect sandwich. I got that same sandwich from Country Plaza (aka Million Dollar Deli) and it was great. A fantastic lunch and just want I wanted. I ordered a turkey and roast beef with everything (simple but fantastic) and like I said, it was a great sandwich. You order via text and then they'll call you if they have any questions about it. Wait time was pretty short and everyone loved their food. This was my first time eating here because I was just passing through the area, but this is a regular spot for the folks I was eating with. Apparently Million Dollar Deli is more than just a nickname and I am a little sad I don't get to stop in more often.

9 dollar BEC and it was special in any way. A desplay of…read moreshrinkflation and inflation at its finest.

Organic chopped salads

Gourmet sándwiches

See all

Chopped salads

Sweet Tomato

3.9(183 reviews)

3.4 mi

Love this mom and pop food shop! They have great sandwiches, salads, cookies, smoothies, and soups…read more This is not a typical restaurant like other reviewers have pointed out. There is no free water and one has to make a purchase for a water bottle from the fridge. Inside is cozy with a few small tables and what looks like a recycled pew used as a bench. There's a small "help yourself after paying" hot coffee station. Alongside the counter to the register one can see all of the amazing soups kept warm/hot! The ones that I have tried so far and love are: Hungarian Mushroom, Turkey Chili, Brown Lentil, Chicken Noodle, etc. Someone mentioned that the lobster bisque changed, but I can't eat shellfish so I wouldn't have any opinion there. The bathroom door is opposite the end of the bench and it smells like a bathroom. I have never had such an off putting experience there. It was as expected. A lot of things people don't know is that they can ask or make a suggestion instead of assuming that the bathroom is always nasty. One also doesn't know what the person before them did in there. It's wrong to assume that the staff handling the food would constantly be checking the bathroom. A little ask or suggestion can go a long way. During the weekends, OB events, and summer days the line can go out the door and the wait can be long, but everything is worthwhile as all of the non-soups are made to order! Happy eats !

Completely unexpected. Hubby wanted to have a quick lunch so we stopped in here. There is seating…read moreand at about 1ish during the week, it was busy but not packed. They have a nice half and half deal with half a wrap/sandwich and a cup of soup. Hubby and dad each got that, one with clam chowder, the other tomato soup. I tried some of both. I don't usually like tomato anything but this soup was GOOD! Especially dipping a piece of bread and eating the soaked piece. The clam chowder was also yummy. I ordered the Waldorf chicken salad wrap which was just the right amount of all flavors and textures. I felt healthy eating it but was also very full after. The interior decor is not fancy but inviting for a local town restaurant. So glad we tried this place!

Vodka Wrap

See all

Locust Valley Deli

3.4(22 reviews)

2.7 mi

•$$$

The only place that serves something by 5:30 am. Got bagels and spread tea and coffee for those…read morevery early commuters. It's enough to tie me over to the next meal. Don't expect decor or smiley services so early. Get what I need and get going. There is one small table if u do want to sit down

They were a great spot up until about the time they renovated the inside. Service has gone…read moredownhill significantly. Not only are the new workers slower, but they don't seem to know how to make decent food. I've had an iced coffee which was like warm with 3 small ice cubes, the Fairway wrap which was missing lettuce and had two small slices of roast beef (it was primarily bread the size of a taquito) and most recently a bagel with cream cheese that had basically basically no cream cheese whatsoever. After so many tries I have to give up until something changes

Try the Seasoned Grilled Chicken and soup special

Seasoned, Roasted Chicken with vegetable soup is a house favorite

See all

Our fries are simply awesome

Locust Valley Market

3.6(18 reviews)

2.3 mi

•$$$

First and most importantly, Locust Valley Market is a cut above in so many ways, but today I would…read morelike to share my experience with two individuals who work in the deli/catering department. I spoke with Dave and Roseanne who took my order, and gave advice regarding my order. On several occasions, they have prepared wraps for our gatherings. The wraps have been delicious, always fresh, and beautifully presented. Thank you Dave and Rosanne for the time you spent with me, the advice given, and your kindness.

Locust Valley Market had Bell n Evan's turkey on sale so I decided to go in and check them out. So…read moreglad I did. Not only was staff attentive friendly and willing to help. But they have a butcher on site who butterflied my turkey. Meat selection was wonderful, produce was fresh and their shelves were stocked. Didn't have to go anywhere else. Got everything on my list. If you're in the area or just want to check out the quaint village there are plenty of great restaurants and shops to explore too.

See all

Ralph's Pizza

3.9(111 reviews)

0.2 mi

Haven't been back to this place in years, when i heard they had new owners I wanted to try the…read morefood. The new owners are definitely an improvement. They fixed up the place quite a bit but still had a nice casual vibe. I found the pizza and food better than what it used to be. The pizza was savory and crispy and the fried calamari was cooked perfectly. The service was great, even though the place was packed the waitress took the time to make sure we were taken care of and as always, you cant beat the view here. The shop is accross the street from Ransom beach, on the long island sound and if you get there at the right time you can have a spectacular view of the sunset while enjoying really good food! They also have alot of specialty slices that i will definetly try next time i go there.

Ralph's Pizza is an absolute gem. Hands down the best veggie pizza I've ever had--piping hot,…read moreperfectly cooked, and you can taste the difference because they roast the vegetables before they go on the pie. Total game changer. The slices are insane, and the grandma pie is equally incredible--crispy, flavorful, and done just right. Honestly, this is the best pizza I've had on Long Island. Must try. Do not sleep on this place.

See all

Sunset by the window

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

4 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Brian B.

8 years ago

I'd give more stars if yelp allowed it. Don't listen to the negativity I just read here. Those two must have gone somewhere else. Great food prepared by great people. Best around by a long shot. Damn good coffee too! Been a loyal customer since they opened up, and I'm happy to support this hardworking guy and his staff. read more

Danielle G.

7 years ago

Beat deli ever the food is always fresh and I wouldn't go anywhere else. Always a pleasure going in and fun love live love

Joseph H.

9 years ago

Great new Deli in Bayville. Have tried a few of the dishes they have and have been happy every time.

Cos C.

6 years ago

You will never in your life find a better bacon egg and cheese than this place here.

Talenti's - delis - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Bayville, New York Coffee near Talenti's

BEST of Bayville, New York Things to Do near Talenti's

BEST of Bayville, New York Restaurants near Talenti's

BEST of Bayville, New York Breakfast near Talenti's

BEST of Bayville, New York Desserts near Talenti's

BEST of Bayville, New York Sandwiches near Talenti's

BEST of Bayville, New York Parking near Talenti's

BEST of Bayville, New York Thrift Stores near Talenti's

BEST of Bayville, New York Shopping near Talenti's

BEST of Bayville, New York Lunch near Talenti's

Best of Bayville

Things to do in Bayville

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Talenti's also viewed

New Country Deli

3.4

(25 reviews)

This place has the best coffee, along with delicious sandwiches and heroes…read more I would absolutely stop in again. Daily soup specials and the prices are within reason. I would definitely try the Tsunami Pastrami. Again, the coffee is really good...

So, a co-worker went to get breakfast for the office. Didn't know he was going to this place, or i…read morewould have said no thanks. im good. So my order was LIGHTLY TOASTED SCOOPED OUT EGG BAGEL WITH A LITTLE BIT OF BUTTER.. What I got was a scooped bagel with a whole stick of butter..Butter leaked on other orders, leaked thru wax paper wrap, all over my juice, my desk. I had to squeeze the butter out like a wet sponge. I ate 1 half only to take my vitamins without getting sick and threw rest in the trash. Lightly butter or even just saying butter doesn't mean a stick of butter..

Parkway Deli & Catering

3.9

(106 reviews)

3:5 stars Ordered a…read morehero here and it was pretty big which was great to see. It was a chicken cutlet (chopped) with cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato and some salad dressing (I forgot). I would say that it was overly sauced which made it really messy to eat. Price was great for the size. The only issue is that there were a lot of flies around which gave me the icks. That's never a good sign.

I got a delivery via Uber Eats and let's just say i won't be ordering from here anytime soon.read more

Bae's Village Deli

4.2

(9 reviews)

Cute interior. Friendly service. Very quick. They have everything you need from sunscreen, to bug…read morespray, to ice cream, to beer, to yummy sandwiches! Great local deli.

This place is the best the food and iced coffee is so good and it's low price!! Everybody who works…read morethere is so nice I can't get enough

Kitchen Kabaret

3.3

(229 reviews)

Beautiful place for a fast and delicious meal or, to take out the most incredible meals and or…read moreingredients. My favorite is the stuffed garlic nut. Sometimes I travel 30 miles just for that! Good service, clean place.

WARNING: Extremely disappointing and potentially unsafe experience…read more I rarely leave reviews like this, but people need to be aware of what I experienced at this deli. I bought the cocktail shrimp ($12 for half a pound) and was shocked. The shrimp had a greenish discoloration on the sides, was extremely stringy, and had an off smell. It did NOT look or taste fresh and honestly raised serious concerns about quality and storage. When bringing it to the attention of the cashier she replied "Ella no quiere". Bringing it to another person attention "what happened" Ella no quiere again. It's not that I don't want it. It was disgusting they were selling green shrimp. The gentleman at the counter was very sweet, but even if he gave me a fresh one, it would've been from the same green, stringy batch regardless. They should absolutely not be serving this especially on the Fourth of July. I also tried the lobster salad ($22 for a small half pound), which was basically mayonnaise with corn and celery and only a few tiny pieces of lobster. nowhere near worth the price. The chicken salad ($12.99) was even worse. It was oily, unappetizing, and looked like it had been sitting out for a long time. Easily the worst chicken salad I've ever had. Look at that oil! Overall, everything I purchased felt low quality and questionable in freshness. I was genuinely disgusted and surprised a place like this would sell products in this condition. I would strongly caution others before buying seafood or prepared foods here. I will not be returning.

Manor Delicatessen

3.9

(94 reviews)

Quality sandwiches. Different than any other sandwich shops. The people there dress classy in white…read moreshirt and black pants. Something very different than most delis

I haven't been in this establishment but I had my coworker pick me up a wrap and it was delicious…read more I got the heartburn which is hot pastrami, corned beef and Cole slaw. They packed it with lots of meat *pause*. Expect to be full after eating this wrap. I'll definitely visit this deli when I get a chance. I'm pretty impressed with the food quality and size for the price. Excellent!!

House of Heros

4.3

(110 reviews)

House of Heros totally lives up to the hype. We were super excited to try their sandwiches (well,…read morein our case wraps because of a corn allergy), and it definitely did not disappoint!!! The Godzilla (crispy pork, cabbage/carrot slaw, with tonkatsu sauce) was packed with thin slices of perfectly fried pork. The tonkotsu sauce was slightly sweet and tangy, and the carrot and cabbage slaw was very complementary to the plethora of pork. The only change I would make next time is perhaps adding some onions (personal preference) and ask for some extra sauce. The Crispy Cuban was also fantastic spin to the classic. Again, packed with crispy pork, the sandwich was then filled with the perfect amount of ham, melty Swiss, and mustard. Nothing felt heavy. I wish I had seen the list of sides before we ordered. The homemade tater tots look amazing. Before we left, my boyfriend and I grabbed a menu and have decided to check off each one we order every week go. You can bet we will be returning soon!

BEC on a wrap was ok this Friday . The bacon was overly crispy and some pieces seemed burnt…read more The coffee was delicious as usual. Service was good.

Meadowbrook Deli

5.0

(6 reviews)

The Deli was recently renovated; it is clean and well stocked with expanded varieties of drinks and…read moresnacks. The new owners still take pick-up orders over the phone, and continues to keep the overall transaction quick and easy! Edit: as of September 2025, they have Lottery.

What a great deli. They have a ton of different type of sandwiches. I had a chicken salad…read moresandwich. It was great. It was not drowning in mayonnaise. The people there were very friendly. It is on the way to the beach. The prices are great. Great place to get food before going to the beach.

East Norwich Delicatessen

3.7

(19 reviews)

I think this place just became one of my favorite delis on long island. I travel all over long…read moreisland for work so I stop at a lot of delis. I have now been here 3 times and every time have had one of the best sandwiches ever. The food is so fresh, but more importantly the bread has been fresh every time. So many delis serve hard bread that has been sitting out all day. Not this place. Bread is always soft. I will be coming back very often. I can't believe the other reviews ratings, but they are older reviews so maybe the place has changed.

Excellent BES missed my egg sandwich nothing beats a great Long Island BEC this place doesn't…read moredisappoint!! Moved upstate nothing beats coming home especially for a good breakfast sandwich

Pastrami Express

4.6

(205 reviews)

The Reuben Pastrami sandwich was one of the best pastrami sandwiches I have ever had. Bread was…read moretoasted perfectly, pastrami was full of flavor! The knish also was to die for!!! Even the pickles were great! Can't wait to have it again!!!

Still the best place around for a piled high authentic pastrami sandwich!…read moreI feel like Express is a hidden local secret. Fresh, tasty pastrami. All the sides are great. To stay or to go, best place in town for Pastrami!!

Henry's Confectionary

3.5

(98 reviews)