I have never had an order here delivered or picked up that was correct. Something is always missing or not done correctly. The receipt is as long as CVS and clearly spells out the order so there is no excuse. The wings are good. My son likes them with curly fries which were ordered but not in our pile of boxes. I ordered the steak and cheese added onion and lettuce and got steak and cheese. We had two burgers and two chicken sandwiches which had the most customization and were made correctly. The prices are a bit high for the size of portions and the fact that things we ordered and paid for weren't included in the order. This was a birthday dinner for my son. It probably will be the last order for me from here or Iron Horse Pub. (Same place) read more

People’s Choice - Giant chicken grinder with lettuce - Pizza Near Me - Simsbury, Connecticut

Late on a Sunday so decided to get two orders of burgers and fries for my kid and I and it was TERRIBLE!! The burger was so overcooked and burnt and crispy and it tasted like the grill. This should have never made it onto the bun and I can't believe I took as many bites as I did. My kids was the same way. Look at the picture to see just how black it was. Couldn't Finnish it. May be my last time going there ever. It's always hit or miss and this was a HUGE MISS! read more

People’s Choice - Burnt to a crisp burger - Pizza Near Me - Simsbury, Connecticut

So this weekend has been a takeout weekend for me, my nephew really wanted People's Choice Pizza so I decided hey why not and I was actually very pleasantly surprised. We just ordered an extra large cheese pan pizza that is one with the thicker crust I usually go for the New York style but the kids wanted pan and again I was very impressed. The crust was thick and fluffy there was just enough sauce and the cheese was nice and cheesy without being too much cheese. We did order delivery and it was here in a timely manner the delivery woman was very nice. The price they charge for for an extra large pizza you can't go wrong and it came with 24 slices you definitely can't go wrong with that. I know there's a lot of fancy pizza places in my area but I have to say People's Choice was right up there with half of them and I was very impressed so I do recommend this Pizza House. read more

People’s Choice - a box of pizza - Pizza Near Me - Simsbury, Connecticut

Critiquing a food delivery during a pandemic seems like an ultimate "First World Problem", but I'll be fair and balanced and give People's Choice credit for the things they did exceptionally well. We ordered a ton of stuff for delivery today to get us through the weekend, $64 dollars worth (including tip) to be exact. For that $64 we got a medium pizza, eight wings, a Chef Salad, a whole ham and cheese grinder, a side of curly fries, and a whole Italian Combo grinder. Things That Went Really Well 1) Their delivery website rocks! It is super easy to use and lets you customize things to the nth degree. As an example, you can deselect anything on their list of "standard" grinder toppings, add on a big choice of extra toppings, and even select hot or cold as an option. 2) Besides food, they also deliver a big variety of grocery items and household goods at fair prices. So if you need TP, paper towels, vinyl gloves, sanitizing wipes, milk, eggs, ground beef, or even beer and canned cocktails, Peoples Choice can hook you up. 3) Their website said the food would be here in 30 minutes, and sonuva gun, they were right on time. 4) Their delivery menu has a terrific variety of options starting with starters or sides like skins, fries, and rings, lots of salads, pasta or seafood dinners, two kinds of pizza (Original Pan or NY thin crust), calzones, strombolis, wings, chicken sandwiches, burgers, cheese-steaks, and quite a few wraps and grinders. That's a pretty deep menu. 5) Their Chef Salad was excellent! The medium size for $8.75 was plenty for two to share and included very generous portions of good roast beef and turkey over lettuce, tomato, green pepper, cukes and cheese. 6) Our Whole size Grinders were big, and it was cool to see that they even had a bigger size named Giant! They ran $8.75 for the Ham and Cheese and $11 for the Italian (I added on some options). We had half of each grinder for lunch, and the other half is set for tomorrow. They were massive portions and a pretty good value. Things With Improvement Opportunities 1) We ordered from People's Choice because they popped a flyer in our mailbox 3 days ago. The flyer included a code (DM7445) that was supposed to apply a $5 discount if you ordered before August 31, 2020. When I ordered, the discount code was rejected, so I went without it and made a comment in the general comments field. It yielded no reply in my order, no peace offering, it was just ignored. That was disappointing. 2) Our NY Style medium hamburger pizza was kind of average. The crust was OK, but the sauce and cheese were inferior to so many other local sources. 3) Particularly galling was the sliced hot pepper on my grinder that included a big hard stem. https://www.yelp.com/user_local_photos?select=FHITocHWx9Yjt6qrKgTM1w&userid=cVrM2BvOvPV0Vi_rC8kepQ How anyone could have the indifference to put this on a sandwich is beyond me. 4) Our side of curly fries was a hefty $3.75 for the very small portion we received. 5) The ham on my Italian grinder just wasn't very good. It was tough and a bit stringy, definitely low on the old quality meter, which is bizarre because the roast beef and turkey in our salad were excellent. read more

See all

I've never eaten in their establishment so this review is for delivery. I LOVE their pizza! The pan style crust has some crunch to it, not just doughy. One of my favorite things and I judge a good pie is the sauce. Gotta have a good sauce! Zesty, slightly sweet, flavorful. This place has great sauce! I've ordered the wings as well. They have like 10 different flavors I think. The insane Buffalo is just that, a volcano in your mouth. I like the garlic Parmesan although sometimes they could be a little more coated. I recommend this place for a Friday night or a Monday night, whenever you want a good slice! read more

See all

We ordered the pizza to be lightly baked! This delivery was borderline burnt! This wasn't the first time that our orders have been "over- cooked"! read more

People’s Choice - Delivered "lightly baked" ordered pizza - Pizza Near Me - Simsbury, Connecticut

We have ordered numerous times from People's Choice and have been happy with food and service. Our usual is pizza and wings. Unfortunately, we had a terrible customer service experience this evening and will no longer be customers. We placed an order for a pizza and wings. Wings to be Buffalo style with extra sauce on the side. When delivered the wings were plain with all the sauce on the side. The wings were over cooked and terrible. When we called back to provide this feedback, we were advised that they would replace the wings for us. After 90 minutes we called back to check on the status of the replaced wings. Turns out that because we ordered the sauce on the side (which we did not) that the wings can't be replaced. They asked if we wanted a refund, which we accepted, but we're really disappointed with the whole interaction. read more

People’s Choice - Terrible wings - Pizza Near Me - Simsbury, Connecticut

$44 for turkey and Italian combo grinder with tip..the problem is all bread and lettuce! Biggest ripoff! Ruined my son and I night in. Rocky movies and grinder turned into Rocky and lettuce read more

People’s Choice - Pizza Near Me - Simsbury, Connecticut

See all

Peoples Choice is offering basic toiletries for sale at cost it looks like. As well as sanitizing wipes. The only reason my family has access to sanitation is this pizza place; because our inhuman townspeople take more than they need for themselves. Thank you for doing the right thing in a world of so much wrong right now. Total redemption read more

You know what...I rarely log in to this account anymore. But, I feel like People's deserves better than a 2 star rating so I'm logging in to help them out. Ordered for the first time tonight and the food arrived hot, fresh, and was really pretty tasty. Got a pizza and some garlic knots and the pie looked great on opening it and was just as good to actually eat it. Same for the knots. Was it the best food I've ever had? No. But for what I ordered at around 8 or 9 on a Thursday night when I didn't feel like going out and grabbing something it was just about as close to great as I could get and it got here within 15 minutes of the estimated time on ordering. No complaints from me. Washed it down with a nice fresh NEIPA and it was a nice meal. Will certainly order again. read more

Super good pizza, both large and personal size. We get a cheese and pepperoni once a week to share while going to trivia next door. They're always super consistent and everything holds well on the pie when eating! I see they have delivery cars too but we've never called it in, but just another perk to add to the list. read more

. We don't go Into the restaurant but we do frequently have it delivered. I know with this you are not getting it at its prime. Even with this we had been happy with our food and really enjoyed the Pizza and grinders. Unfortunately it seems as of late the quality has gone down. Not with the product itself but in the preparation. We have regularly gotten burnt food....last order was our fried dough this order was our Motz. Stix...when you paying 9$ for 5 pieces you would hope they at least still had some cheese in them. read more

People’s Choice - a half eaten piece of food - Pizza Near Me - Simsbury, Connecticut

See all

We have been ordering from People's choice since we moved to Simsbury in 2005. Food is decent, sometimes hit or miss, but we generally enjoyed it- our kids really love the pizza. Our most recent experience was our last. Upon opening the box of delivered chicken tenders, we found a small bandaid inside. Beyond gross. I reached out to the restaurant, and the manager was apologetic and offered us new food (no thanks) and a refund of the chicken. Unfortunately, we won't order from this restaurant ever again. read more

People’s Choice - Pizza Near Me - Simsbury, Connecticut

Ordered online At 7:21pm. Showed up to pick up a x large pepperoni pizza at 7:35 and it hadn't even been put in oven yet. There was 1 table occupied in entire restaurant and 8 people in bar. There were a lot of delivery orders but it still should not take 50 minutes to get 1 pepperoni pizza. It makes it worse when I can see horseplay in the kitchen area, and all the servers are standing around eating or rolling silverware. I LOVE the pizza from here but this was a terrible experience. When I finally asked for my pizza it was brought right out to me and was no longer hot, so I don't even know how long it was sitting, waiting to be brought out. Very dissatisfied with the level of service. read more

People’s Choice - Pizza Near Me - Simsbury, Connecticut

Horrible customer service. Asked employee who answered the phone for a manager and he said no because they were in the middle of a rush. Didn't offer a call back or anything. Typical simsbury punk snob a-hole. This conversation happened 10 minutes before this post. When you ask for a manager, you get a manager. How busy you are means nothing to a customer. Maybe now a manager will care...but probably not. Stay away from this place. Better service and definitely better pizza elsewhere. read more

Very excited to see they had a gluten free pizza option. EXTREMELY disappointed when the pizza arrived with BREADED chicken on it. When I called they confirmed the chicken was NOT gluten free and that the did have grilled chicken, but I needed to request it! What's the point of ordering a GF pizza if it's going to be topped with Gluten? No offer of a refund or new . read more

The worst pizza in the area, comparable to most chain pizza joints. I'll only order if: a) I'm desperate b) they have a good coupon. There's just too many better places to get a pizza in Simsbury read more

The guy on the phone gave unbelievable sass and when I ordered 12 chicken tenders, I received 5 disgusting buffalo wings. read more

People’s Choice - Pizza Near Me - Simsbury, Connecticut

See all

We are very accustomed to ordering from the Unionville location, but have had the opportunity recently to try Simsbury. The do a very good job. Food is about the same, pizza cooked the same way and nice and hot when delivered. I will return read more

People’s Choice - Hamburg bacon and heavy sauce! Awesome - Pizza Near Me - Simsbury, Connecticut

Very disappointing. My roommate was sick for the entire day upon eating one of their "phillly cheese steak subs." While ordering on the phone the clerk asked if we wanted a "small" or "giant," completely disregarding the "whole" portion of their menu. Up charging without providing the options is absolutely ridiculous. read more

I've been getting delivery from People's Choice in Simsbury since their inception. Maybe at least 20 years. This place has gone downhill fryer than a Jamaican bobsledder. The delivery costs are ridiculous. They totally ignore the customizations you make to your order. Today is the 4th time I've ordered a whole turkey grinder HEATED with extra tomatoes and extra mayo. They failed to HEAT it. Its inedible. And the last 3x they did not add extra tomatoes or extra mayo. Fuckin $17+ for a shitty grinder. Everyone should boycott this place. read more

Meatball grinder was awful. Chunks of something clear and hard in the meatballs. The guy working who took the order I paid for it with was really nice. The staff is the only thing this place has going for it by a long shot. read more

What a disaster! First, we placed our order online like we always do. We recently moved so we made sure to enter our updated street address 40 minutes later we get an irate call from the delivery person saying she's been banging on the door and no one is answering which was odd since. No one knocked on our door. We informed her she went to wrong address. Upon delivery, She informed us that we put in the wrong address which we know wasn't the class. Also odd considering the email confirmation shows our new address. To top it most, one of our pizzas was made incorrectly. These long time People'a Choice customers are looking for a new pizza place. read more

Consistently terrible stay away. I wish I could post this review without writing more because it's honestly not even worth my time. Expensive + cheap. read more

So, we moved to Simsbury about 12 years ago. People's Choice was recommended, so we gave them a shot. I have to say for the last 12 years they're okay, as far as pizza places go. (It helps that they are the ONLY place in town - that we've found anyway - that actually delivers. No one else does. If anyone knows of another place that delivers in Simsbury, I'm all ears.) I'm giving the place 2 stars because, in the past 12 years, they've been an okay place to get food from. However, I had the worst experience I've ever had with any restaurant the night before last. I ordered dinner via their online service (as I do - because it's nice to just do it all in one shot and have it show up - the online service worked well up until the other night.) After waiting for an hour, I called to see where our order was. I ended up speaking to a very nervous girl who wasn't sure what to say. She asked for the manager to me speak to me, but the manager refused. So I had to sit there and listen to the girl be an intermediary between the manager (who I could hear speaking in the background) and me as to what had happened, instead of just speaking to me directly. The girl asked me to place the order online again, but my payment for the original order had already gone through (I could see the charge on my bank account online), and I didn't want to have to pay for the order *twice*. At the end of this conversation, the manager basically told the girl to tell me that they needed to call the company that handles the website to find out what happened, and then they would issue me a refund (as I'd already paid), and then she hung up. I assumed this meant they were going to deliver the food? I don't know but I called back to ask if the food was coming, or if I needed to go somewhere else for dinner. I was told that they still needed to call the company and find out what had happened, but they were going to send the food (which, how that was possible if they never got the order, and she wouldn't take it from me verbally, I don't know), and it would be at my house in 30 minutes. Then she hung up. After 30 minutes, the food was still not here. After 45 minutes, I called to find out if it was coming, or what (at this point, my husband is amazed at my patience, and my kids are "starving"), and she said it was on the way. 5 minutes later the driver showed up with our food. Now, I get a mistake was made. It happens. But the manager refused to speak to me; they didn't let me know what was going on; and even after waiting over 2 hours (and 3 phone calls) between the time I placed the order and actually receiving the food, we weren't even offered a coupon, or a refund - or even just a basic apology for what had happened. It's now 2 days later, and I still haven't gotten an apology (even though they took down my name and number at the first phone call "to keep me updated"). As of right now, the refund that was offered during the first call still has yet to be issued. So I'm REALLY glad I didn't place the order again to pay for it a second time, as they had suggested. So I guess I'll say the food is okay - has been for 12 years - the kids really like the wings (although if you don't order them "well done" they will arrive still pink in the middle) - but they are the ONLY place in town that delivers. Because of this entire issue - and honestly, even just a quick phone call to simply apologize would have been enough to satisfy me, but I guess the manager can't even be bothered - we're just not going to order from here ever again. If the kids want pizza, I guess I'll just be making it myself. read more

Ordered two pizzas tonight. Ordered online at 4:30 pm for a delivery at 6:00pm. Driver showed up at 6:45 and pizza was cold.

Pizza Medium is Ridiculously Small for the Price.....Ordered half bacon (barely put any on) and half cheese....The cheese is not normal mozzarella more like ricotta and the garlic over powers any flavor and the edges were all over cooked, was thin crust although!!! $26 with tax and delivery for something worth $5.99 read more

I dined here a couple days ago and I will definitely be coming back! Great food and even better service. I can't wait to recommend this quaint dinning establishment to my friends! The sweetest young lady served us and tended to our every need. Highly recommend!! read more

The People need to have their right to vote revoked if this is in fact their Choice. Quite simply, the last resort for pizza in the area. They stay open later than everyone else so if you have a late night craving go for it. I would recommend ordering something other than pizza though. Also they are cheap so if you are on a budget consider it but i would almost rather eat PBJ sandwiches instead. read more

Our family LOVES their pizzas! And we have eaten dozens of them over the past few years. People's makes both New York Thin and New England Crust (thicker). Half of our family prefers the thin, half prefers the thicker. Having lived in NYC, I can attest that the NY thin crust is true to form. There are a variety of specialty and signature pizza's. The signature "Lasagna Pizza" (ricotta, sliced meatball, marinara, mozzarella) is the most delicious pizza I have EVER tasted! I get it on the thicker crust and it's my go-to pizza, consistently delicious every time! Equally amazing, that my son and husband devour, is the signature "Piggly Wiggly Pizza" (like a meat lovers -it has pepperoni, bacon, sausage, mozzarella). We have ordered this adding meatball to it - even better! What we like most about People's pizzas, is that they're generous with their toppings, they cover the entire pizza. We have another son who is a finicky eater and he consistently enjoys the signature "Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza" (hamburger, bacon, tomato, mozzarella). He also says their burgers are excellent, served on a thick brioche bun, that he orders with curly fries. We can also give a nod to the calzones - they are yummy! People's has excellent carry out prices and specials. We utilize delivery frequently, and it has ALWAYS been as stated, usually faster than expected, always within 1/2 hour of placing a large order during dinner time - even in inclement weather! Furthermore, I've interacted with several different drivers -they've always been courteous and the food arrives HOT! People's is conveniently located on Iron Horse Blvd., directly across the street from the park and performing arts center in Simsbury. You can bring your little one(s) to the park and then walk over to People's for lunch or dinner. During the summer months when concerts occur at the outdoor Performing Arts Center, you can either pick up food and carry it over to take in some music or attend the concert and cross the street for a casual, impeccably clean atmosphere to enjoy pizzas, grinders, burgers, wraps, salads, or simply to have a drink. I highly recommend People's, whether you want to order online and have your food delivered to your home for free, carry out, or dine in. read more

Ordered online tonight. Pizza was very good. Wings were undercooked although I ordered well done. I also ordered blue cheese and that was not delivered. When I called the shop I was told they could send a delivery of blue cheese in 20-30 minutes. Really People!!!! read more

I don't want to be mean and only really like to write positive reviews- but maybe it'll help them improve? (thinking positively). The pizza is bland and the crust is not crisp. I'm just not a fan. (sorry) read more

The food was OK but the service was poor. We asked for our food to be delivered at 8:30 and they arrived at 8:10. My family was not home and by the time they got here it was cold. The wife was not amused! read more

People's Choice holds the not-so-coveted distinction of being the only pizza I've ever thrown out.

We just moved to Simsbury and People's Choice was recommended to us. We've had the pizza delivered twice, as well as chicken tenders, fries and onion rings. Both times the delivery time was less than anticipated, roughly 30 minutes. The food came well prepared, hot, and tasty. It's one of the only places to deliver pizza within a good amount of time in the area. read more

I ordered two simple items, wings and a grinder for pick-up and I was waiting in the restaurant for over 50 minutes. Absolutely ridiculous.

Ordered food for delivery was a horrible mistake, I'm going to say it was not the drivers fault. The person at the store gave the driver not only the wrong address, but the wrong phone number. So when they called to let us know they were outside, btw there was no car out front and it was the restaurant that call from an unknown number. The poor driver went back. We called looking for our food and the guy started blaming us that we didn't answer the phone when delivery was there, which it was not. Long store short I called them back when the driver just drove by our house while my father was standing out side waiting. After he called me back saying that we are banned from ordering from them for bring difficult. P.S. the pizza we order was not cooked, it was doughy. read more

Pretty much your basic late-night pizza place. That is to say there's no real good reason to order from them unless everything else is closed. The pizza pretty meh. The wings are decent, and well, everything else is pretty much the same as the pizza; good enough. I just got a "Philly Cheese Steak" for $11.00, and it was just some shaved steak on a grinder roll with mayonnaise. No onions or peppers, no flavor, and I'm not really sure there was any cheese on it. Pretty much the same as a $3.00 frozen-in-a-box-from-the-supermarket sandwich with a fresh bun. read more

Admittedly I haven't eaten here in years, so it doesn't really seem fair to leave a review. But the intense mediocrity that I remember does seem to warrant it. My friends used to get People's Choice all the time (the one saving grace is that they deliver), so I've had it dozens of times. It's not the worst pizza I've ever had- hence the two stars, but it's not something to seek out. read more

I love this place - it's affordable and I'm not sure of there is a new owner or something but the quality has improved over the last year or so. The remodel turned out very nice too so you can sit down and eat at the restaurant now. Keep up the great work! read more