New Owner. Been eating here for years. Same great pizza. Prices have increased. Restaurant needs to be cleaned and then Refreshed! New Owner is sitting on a great pizza but not having a clean place to sell from hurts. I really hope to see success here! read more

For thin crust, without traveling to New Haven, this is the best mozzarella pizza around. The pie is cooked in a standard oven so its not wood or coal fired which is next level. This is thin crust, New Haven style. Good value. Not overpriced like the place 100 yards away! Great service. Eating in is nothing fancy but there are a few tables. For this style of pizza, and local to me, this is my first choice. read more

I'm writing a new review as we did give this place one more try and I am hoping the extremely rude man from earlier was just having a bad day and not always like that. The food is delicious and a great price, so for that reason they get four stars, but just barely due to the lack of good service but also the absence of horrible service, at least for now. Highly recommend the Italian dinners - they come with salad and bread and are easily 2-3 meals worth of food. read more

Pepperoni's is your basic pizza restaurant. The handmade dough is excellent (fermented over a couple of days) . It is solid reliable pizza and New York style. The grinders are decent and again exactly what you expect out of a Blodgett Pizza oven. Is this the best pizza around, well maybe not quite but is darned good and if you like classic pizza it is really good. I am not sure I would order much else from here other than pizzas , grinders and calzones. It is a small place and there isn't much of a kitchen. Salads are made with the veggies they use to build grinders. Nothing special but OK for a veggie fix. Ambiance not much. It is classic old school New England pizza parlor which has it is own charm. TV's frequently playing soccer and football (that is not the NFL). read more

Tried this place after searching for a thin crust, basic pizza. We were pleasantly surprised! I was a little skeptical when seeing a simple website that looked like it hasn't been updated in a while, and no online ordering or delivery service option (DoorDash, Grubhub, etc), but decided to kick it old school and call in an order. The prep time seemed a bit long for a random weeknight order, but was hot and ready when I arrived to pick up. The restaurant is small, no frills, just a counter with slices for sale and a few booths for seating. I ordered a large pizza with sausage & peppers on half and it was less than $20!! The pizza was great, excellent cheese pull and a nice crispy crust. Not greasy or oily and the sauce had good flavor. My belly and my wallet were satisfied! We will definitely return in the future! read more

Like always customer service is good The food was great I recommend it been going there for years

This little pizza place has the corner on the best crust for pizza in the Farmington Valley. Toppings cheese and of course a pepperoni version of their pizza is the go to order and it is uniformly excellent. As Dave Portnoy would say, it's easily an 8.5. read more

There are a lot of pizza places around Granby/Simsbury, and this is the very best if you like excellent New York style. We've been going there for a couple years, the pizzas are consistently great. Fresh ingredients. And the owner and others who work there are friendly and enthusiastic about serving up great pizza. read more

Thank you SO MUCH for adding cheese to the order with a dairy intolerance note and hiding it under the lettuce and mayo....but only on half a BLT? Not only that but only one melted slice when everything else was cold, Did you reuse bread from another sandwich? Did you forget it was labeled as NO DAIRY and were just too cheap to throw it away and remake it? Literally never again ordering takeout from this place again. This restaurant deserves no stars. read more

Quite good - have ordered a few times and impressions have been that all ingredients are fresh, cheese and dough not overly salty and the prices are reasonable. Recommended. read more

A friend ordered pizza from the next door pizza shop and I knew there was a better choice. Today I went to pepperonis and saw the sign for New York style pizza; and it was just that. Hot. Cheesy. Nice crunchy crust and Mama Mia the long thin point with the got drippy cheese. True comfort food. Love the pizzeria decor. The unicorn mural. The tables. Made this Nyack NY girl feel at home. read more

Pizza for delivery is fine, as are grinders and calzones. A solid go to for delivery. Until my last order. Pizza and chicken parm grinder were fine/average as usual. Ordered a small Greek salad and a large house salad. $13.00 later, this is what I got. Sad looking iceberg lettuce, and a few tomato skins and feta cheese on the greek salad. Before I posted this review, I called the owner, who told me - "most people don't want the Kalamata olives, onions, cucumbers and green peppers so we leave them off unless you ask for them". Huh? So I asked for a refund of the $13 for these salads and he asked me if I wanted to fight or get a free replacement salad. The pictures tell the tale. read more

Pepperoni's Pizza - Pepperoni's "salads". - Pizza Near Me - Simsbury, Connecticut

Luckily my mom found this place for my family when she moved up here a year ago. The pizza if fantastic! The crust is by far the best in this region and the cheese they use is fresh and tasty! My favorites are the regular cheese and the white pizza with ricotta added. When I bring my daughters friends their they always love it- Give it a try and I am sure you will love it too. read more

This is a family owned business. I travel a LOT - best calzone I have had. Friends had pizza and wings- all great. Portions huge - GO!

We stopped at Pepperoni's Pizza on the way back from a baseball game. The crust was crisp and buttery. MMMMMMM. Delicious. And the toppings were fresh, I don't think they came from a can, like others usually do. The owner is a great guy, genuinely friendly. LOVE THIS PLACE. read more

You want pizza? This is it. Old school and still bringing in the returning Brooklyn hipsters looking for food while visiting the parents. They have salads, calzones, subs and Italian entrees plus the soft drinks. Owner and staff always welcoming. Small eat-in area, pick up or delivery. read more

They do not offer life-changing pizza pies, but they are pizza pies nonetheless. Guys behind the counter were nice and quick about the service. Restaurant was relatively clean-ish. When you want a slice of pizza at 2am, this place gets it done! read more

Being a New Yorker, I'm a bit picky about pizza. Pepperoni's is a close as you are going to get to a New York thin crust pizza. Old school family owned pizza parlor that churns out consistent pies every time baked by the owner not a high school kid. Their pepperoni pizza is loaded with high quality slices, their mozzarella is the real deal, actually melts and doesn't reconstitute itself in 5 minutes like pretender pies do. My 15 year old even loves their Hawaiian pizza. The parlor is what a pizza place is supposed to be - a somewhat divey, hole in the wall (eat in if you want) in a strip center with guys in white T-shirts tossing pizza dough, moving pies from hot spot to hot spot in the giant pizza oven, sliding them into the box, expertly cutting them into 8 slices and handing you a great, fresh made pizza. We live 10 minutes away and the delivery is fast and always hot. read more

My family's family pizza in the area. It's quick and the employees are always friendly! The lasagna pizza is delicious! read more

Ever since they have been opened our company across the street couldn't get enough! We love the enthusiasm and family feeling they provide. Always happy with pizza, calzones and their salad! Quick delivery and tasted good. Can't go wrong! read more

Living in Simsbury, we miss classic thin crust New York City style pizza and this is the closest we have found. Nothing else around compares. read more

Closest thing to New York City pizza you can get up here. Quick delivery. We usually crisp it up in the oven a bit when it arrives and it's perfect. read more

I eat lunch here everyday I have off from work. They make really good grinders. I usually get the Turkey or Chicken Breast large grinder. On the weekends I have my kids, we always go here for lunch. Good people, friendly people. read more

Pepperonis is better than frank pepe's. The review itself should speak for how great the pie is. I recommend the cheese pizza the best one I've had in this area. Lunch special is the go to. 2 slices and a drink for 5 bucks. read more

Excellent Buff Chic salad. A tangy but friendly taste. Exceptional customer service. Meatball grinder was a delight. Clean restrooms. Great restaurant for the whole family. read more

I've had a few pizzas from this place. It's ok. Not a standout but it isn't bad. New York style pizza. A little greasy but it's nice they have a good selection of slices you can pick up for lunches. Not bad, not supreme. read more

I work at a company in Simsbury . We have been using pepperonis for a while because they deliver and options in Simsbury for delivery are limited. We will never use them again. We called in and we were giving our order, and the person on the phone started sighing each time we asked a question. After a few minutes he said "well it is lunchtime you know."so we asked him if he would rather have us call somewhere else. He said, "thank you." And he hung up. He lost over a $60 order today, and many more in the future. read more

Met a friend and tried Pepperoni's Pizza it last evening for the first and last time. He enjoyed his slice of cheese pizza. No so for my sausage grinder. (Iceberg salad was fresh although bleu cheese dressing was tasteless, lacking bleu cheese.) I've never been served a sausage grinder with crumbled -think pizza topping- sausage. I ate about half of each, that's all I could stomach. Young "cook" never heard of gloves or frequent hand washing; from cooking, to serving and working the cash drawer. Not even hand sanitizer (which could have at least added some flavor!) Yech. There were 3 open restaurants in the plaza, I picked the 1 I had never been to and lost. read more

They overcharged us and refused to re-check the order. The barbeque sauce on the bbq chicken pizza is pretty aweful, but the crust is better than some. We will not be returning which is too bad since we live right up the street. With all the pizza places near by you would think they'd try harder. read more

Always great food and service. Pizza is one of the better ones in the area. Meatballs on pizza or in sub are my personal favorite. Dinner combos are excellent as well as are calzones. One item I didn't like was scampi pizza as shrimp were too small for my taste. Nobody's perfect. Been coming here for 10 years with no plans to go elsewhere. read more

Nice people. Pizza was ok but didnt have much flavor. Crust was nice and soft but also bland.

We only order our pizza from Pepperonis. Salads and calzones are amazing as well.Service whether pick up or delivery always prompt!!!!!

I work in Simsbury and we have ordered delivery many times from Pepperoni's Pizza. The food is okay, not amazing, but okay and is priced very reasonably. We made a decent size delivery order and two out of the five items were wrong. When we called to have one of those items fixed all we got on the other end of the phone (from I believe the owner) was attitude and an argument. I consider myself to be a patient and understanding patron and I understand that orders to sometimes get mixed up and that is okay - mistakes happen, as long as you try to make it right to the best of your ability and not give attitude and ask us if we are trying to get something for free. Our work establishment will be no longer ordering from here and not because of the incorrect order, but instead for the complete lack of customer service and rudeness. read more

Pizza is pretty good to great but so-so in price. Order online a lot and the web site is horrible - please do something about it. But overall very friendly staff and good eats. Worth an order! read more

Very good food and friendly staff. Our regular pizza shop in Simsbury, they have slices for a quick lunch, great calzones, and is run by a nice family. read more