Stumbled upon this gem of a place yesterday and was genuinely impressed from start to finish. The food was absolutely delicious -- the pretzel bites arrived hot and fresh, the meatloaf was hearty and comforting, and the green beans were cooked to absolute perfection. The shepherd's pie was another standout, cozy, flavorful, and wonderfully filling. And do not skip the bread pudding -- it was absolutely amazing and the perfect sweet finish to the meal. The only negative was our booth: right in front of the door, so every time it opened (and it was often), we got blasted with cold air. Next time we'll sit further in or upstairs. If you're running around Old Saybrook and need a quick, hearty meal, this is the place to be. read more

We made our first visit here several days ago, dropping in for a midday lunch on a pretty crowded Sunday. With some good and some not-so good, we concluded that we aren't likely to return -- in spite of the really yummy tartar sauce (more on that in a moment). Penny Lane is a bit of an English Pub-style restaurant on two levels. We ate upstairs since the lower level was filled (steps, no elevator that we saw). Service was slow to nonexistent. It took us ten minutes to get recognized by a server who asked if we wanted something to drink and took another five minutes to get it. After we ordered we waited 25 minutes to get our food. We got no drink refills. Maybe service is better in the first floor? Ah, the food. Fish and Chips is essentially pub food, so that's what we got. The crust was light and buttery, quite good. The fish was utterly without any sort of flavor, as bland as could be imagined in your worst imagining. The tartar sauce was super good, but it just couldn't disguise the fact that the fish was tasteless. We also tried the poached egg and corned beef hash, which was ok though the hash was kind ... well, and of a hash, unremarkable at best. Conclusion: There was little that was appealing in our experience. Oh yeah, another ten minutes to get our bill... a long afternoon. read more

See all

Good pub. Decent food. Great service. Judging by some other reviews, I think we hit it just right and they weren't too busy for lunch on a Saturday. The bar seating was full, but we got right in upstairs at a cozy larger dining room. Service was excellent, professional, and did a great job. The menu was attractive. Lots of different drinks, classic pub food, your typical burgers, and fish and chips kinda stuff. But also a lot of other goodies too. I had the BBQ pulled pork sandwich with fries. It tasted good, the brioche roll was very fresh. I could have been seasoned more. I wasn't wow'd by it, but it was good. Fries were average, but tasted ok. I think the pricing was reasonable. I would definitely give Penny Lane Pub another try. I'm guessing though in the summer this place is tough to get into, just the vibe I got. read more

The food was good however the price we were charged was not what was on the menu. I got the Salmon Burger which was 19$ on the menu but was changed 22$. This was the same for all the items my party ordered and not just the burger. read more

This is a VERY busy place on Main in Old Saybrook. The staff and food were great. The noise level was a little much. Conversation across the table required yelling. read more

They allow pets in their small outdoor patio space. It was shaded by the building which was lovely on a hot day. Looking over the main street of shops was also a delight. The server brought a water bowl for my pet and was attentive throughout the meal. They had a lamb burger special that I ordered, but they ended up being out. I ordered the crab cake sandwich as a back up. The sandwich was okay, a little disappointing. It was on the dry side. I also ordered a slice of cheesecake for desert. It was tasty. The sites of the street were relaxing but the food wasn't out of this world with flavor. read more

Hadn't been here for a number of years, so we thought we'd give it a try for dinner on St Paddy's day. My corned beef reuben was OK, with the beef being nicely lean. I would recommend serving the sandwich on a good marble rye instead of the seeded rye, but they may have been trying to keep with Irish tradition. My wife chose the Irish beef stew, which, unfortunately, had a number of sinewy chewy pieces, which I certainly wouldn't expect for $25.00 stew dish. Typically two reasons for this, the beef was either undercooked or of poorer quality cut. Service was very good for a busy night, so no issue there. All in all, we're glad we tried it again after a long absence, but we wouldn't rush right back there. read more

We had a couple beers and wines and a pulled pork quesadilla that was tremendous! The bartender on a Sunday afternoon could not have been more pleasant! The ambiance is quaint and comfortable. Prices are reasonable and it is very clean. Great spot! I would definitely return and try more of their menu! read more

See all

We have been to Penny Lane twice recently and have had really great meals both times. The jerk shrimp plate (salad) was just full of things I love: brussel sprouts, goat cheese, butternut squash etc... And the hubby had the short rib pasta special which had a really nice gravy. They have seating on the first and second floor with a bar area as well. They recommend making a reservation and they make that pretty easy, I'm sure they get busier in the summer than these winter months. Definitely recommend and we'll be going back. read more

Penny Lane Pub - Short rib special - American Near Me - Old Saybrook, Connecticut

See all

Food is good, but service was horrible. We had to wait for drinks, ask multiple times for a specials menu (each time we asked was like it was the first time she heard it), one place setting for a table of four, they brought a shareable appetizer with no plates, brought food then didn't see server again for about 30 minutes( never checked on food). There are so many better places to spend your money in Old Saybrook. read more

I will start by saying the food was delicious and somewhat reasonably priced. Atmosphere was lovely, no issues there. Service was poor, as in, it took forever to get our drinks - but that is not the worst part. Let me ask you this... When you go out to dinner, spending your hard earned dollars to escape from cooking and cleaning, do you really want someone's politics in your face? I'm not going to reveal which side - right or left - the server leaned. It's irrelevant. My point is this: our waitress wore very large earrings that CLEARLY advocated for a specific political position. For me, eating out is to take me away from the stress of our divided nation, not immerse me in a stranger's opinion. I suppose if you are in agreement with the server's position, perhaps it won't bother you. But even then... no politics at dinner!! Give it a rest already, I just want to relax. I won't risk this happening again; I'll eat elsewhere until PLP creates a wait staff dress code. read more

Great place. I have dined here many times over the years. It's consistently good. Even catered events are well done. Nice atmosphere. Delicious Brussels sprouts app. I always enjoy this establishment. read more

I really like this place. The food is great and so are the drinks. I had the impossible burger and the Brussels sprouts and they were both really good. I appreciate the veggie options. My friend had the lam burger and loved it. It can get busy on weekends so keep that in mind but street parking is easily accessible. read more

Service poor (2) - very confused servers - one friendly but confused about everything - the other indifferent - as if it was an effort to serve us - 2 of our party of 4 thought the food was good (cob salad and hanger steak) - other 2 poor to average (fish and chips - average and steak au poivre poor). Food (3). Ran out of water. Forgot to bring beer and then brought a second one which belonged to another table. Late with second glass of wine. Will not be going back. Best part walking to Ben and Jerry's for ice cream. read more

Great pub. Great service. Everything we ordered was great. The clam chowder, hanger steak cooked perfect. Def hit this place up when in town. read more

Everything about this little pub was great. Bartender was very helpful with ordering. The spinach artichoke dip was fabulous. Highly recommend. read more

Clam chowder is good, Ruben was sad , fish and chips OK. Wish this neighborhood place was kick asss read more

Penny Lane Pub - My sad Ruben - American Near Me - Old Saybrook, Connecticut

What an awesome pub. Great good with enjoyable company at the bar. Chowder is filling! Just how I like it. Had bacon in it which was a first for me but only really noticed it my first bite. Bison burger was medium rare and on point. Had half of it for leftovers this morning and looking forward to trying the carrot cake tonight for dessert. read more

Penny Lane Pub - Chowder - American Near Me - Old Saybrook, Connecticut

See all

Went for brunch which offered a lovely brunch menu along with a specials menu and the regular menu! There was a margarita drink special for cinco de mayo and it was really good. We tried the California Benny and the avocado omelette - both were so yummy and perfectly cooked. The hash browns were well seasoned and the side salad was super fresh. The server was very nice and helpful and we loved the cozy dining room atmosphere. read more

See all

Food was excellent. We had the Bacon Burger and the Montréal steak. Fries are unfortunately not gluten free but staff ass knowledgeable and helpful. read more

Overall. Enjoyed it. Like the upstairs seating area. Beer Selection was good, and the Guiness pour right on. Pricing was good. The only drawback - Fish and chips. The fish was soggy. Need a hotter, longer and cleaner deep fat fry. read more

Stopped for lunch on our way from Boston to NJ. Food was awesome, service was pleasant and attentive and we had enough to take with us for snacks. read more

I grew up in Old Saybrook and every time I visit, I make it a point to come for legitimately the BEST spinach and artichoke dip I've ever had. It is located right on main Street in the style of an English pub. The menu has changed over the years and it's definitely not cheap, but the food is always great and the staff is wonderful. They also have a decent drink menu with local beers. We prefer sitting in the giant booths downstairs that can fit 6-8 people. It's also one of the few spots you can get peppermint ice cream year round. read more

See all

BLT s if Not to finest fish & chowders come for supper early if you can ; it can get crowed ;it's so good you ll be happy you did outside too some summer eves worked out too great beverages ! read more

Good selection of wholesome food. Great service. Fast and courteous. Nice place - clean and organized.

The food was great! Awesome service! The backyard patio was awesome for my kids to run around and they loved drawing on the chalk wall! 10/10 read more

Penny Lane Pub - Awesome beer flight! - American Near Me - Old Saybrook, Connecticut

Brian is an awesome Bartender ! We love going there because of him and the food is great and staff is very friendly ! Best place in Old Saybrook ! read more

I had lunch here today with a friend, and I have to say that both of us were very disappointed in the crabcakes. The drinks were OK and the pretzel bites were very good, the dips could have had more bite. read more

This was literally the best damn burger of my life. So juicy, fresh and delicious as were the sweet potato fries. And don't get me started on the aïoli dipping sauce. OMG. The staff were super friendly, welcoming and very on point. Awesome vibe here as well. read more

Penny Lane Pub - The best damn burger of my life. It's so juicy and delicious and the aïoli sauce...OMG. - American Near Me - Old Saybrook, Connecticut

Awesome little Tavern/Pub located right on the Main Street of Old Saybrook! Has a great casual friendly pub vibe! Cute smaller L shaped bar area with seating for about 10 ppl. 2 large flat screen tvs with a variety of current sports & tv programs. There's bar height tables and 2 & 4 tops scattered throughout the main level with a spacious open Dining area upstairs also. The staff here are great: Courteous, knowledgeable, friendly, efficient & helpful. They have a VERY good well rounded cocktail, wine, beer, cider & NA drinks menu. The menus is equally as well rounded: a variety of great appetizers. soups, salads, sandwiches, & entrees. They also have a Specials menu reflecting seasonal or holiday offerings. They have great music piped overhead that is audible but doesn't drown out conversation. It's clean & has the requisite tavern pub memorabilia throughout. It has a relaxing, casual but pleasant welcoming vibe. I REALLY like this place! This is definitely going to be a new addition to my CORE regular local restaurant choices. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED! ENJOY! read more

Stopped by here along our road trip from Rhode Island to Philadelphia and it was an easy stop to avoid fast food chains. Parking on the main street was available and there was no wait at 2pm on a Sunday. We dined upstairs where there were less people and tables were nicely spread out. I had the egg sandwich with bacon and my husband ordered a blt (not on the menu but wasn't an issue). Our server was nice and eagerly remedied a problem when I had to ask for another salad since I forgot to mention my food allergy. The coffee from Ashlawn was great so I had it black. Once you're done eating, walk along the strip to stop in some cute shops. Happy we made the stop! read more

See all

Penny Lane is becoming one of our favorite stops. They pay careful attention to food allergies and their grilled chicken salad is the best I've had in CT. Change my mind, you can't. The house balsamic Dijon mustard is so flavorful it truly complements the perfectly grilled chicken. My child's burger was cooked as requested and they oven baked fries to not contaminate with gluten. Our server was friendly and the location is perfect. We will be back! read more

See all

Was on an afternoon adventure with a friend and ended up in Old Saybrook...it was the day before Easter and honestly, not expecting much. I had been to Penny Lane years ago and remembered that the food was great! It was early afternoon and busy... we waited a very short time for a table at street level, second floor was out of the question for two "mature" ladies. The staff was fabulous and accommodating. We started with the spinach artichoke dip... the BEST I have had! I had the chopped Cobb salad, my friend had the potato leek soup, which she was trying for the first time. Delicious!! She also had cheese cake for dessert while I was trying to finish the huge, but tasty salad! We left there satisfied and knowing we'd be back! A delightful meal, the waitstaff attentive and friendly a charming atmosphere, a definite go to for anyone read more

Sorry to say now we're a little skeptical to go to the PLP again,but we will because we've always enjoyed it in the past.Recently I picked up a Chili to go and there wasn't anything in it.It had hardly any meat or beans for almost 10 dollars. A month later we went back. We dined in and ordered the Poached Pear Salad again.It wasn't the same as previous times. It had no flavor and didn't look too fresh. We also ordered their Steak tip nachos which weren't good at all. We never had them before,and would never order them again. The steak was ok but the whole appetizer as a whole was dry and lacking any flavor.I'd suggest maybe adding more salsa and more of the cilantro aioli.We will give the restaurant another chance. Hopefully next time it'll be better. read more

We went here because we were going to an event at the Kate. The food was unremarkable. Did like the atmosphere. Our waitress was lovely. Ultimately kind of forgettable, but a good location and cozy atmosphere. read more

Jackie is my favorite server here. I love to visit every time I'm in town. The food is great and the spinach artichoke dip is not to be missed! read more

My fave ever!! Service is always excellent, food is always good and it's a cozy place with a fireplace upstairs and outside seating when it's nice. Their appetizers always hit, especially the spinach and artichoke dip! The burgers are always good and the specials are seasonal and delicious. I bring everyone here when they are visiting and my kids always want to come here when they're home. Can't recommend more highly!! read more

Excellent service and very accommodating. Highly recommend fish and chips. Nice stop on our way home from cape cod.

Shout-out to Phillis for the ridiculously awesome belinis--both blood orange and peach! - Visited with my parents on a Saturday and she hooked us up. What a bubbly drink accompanied by a lovely bubbly bartender! Thanks, Phillis! read more

My husband and I came for lunch. We had a southwest salad with chicken and a roasted beet salad with salmon. Everything was delicious! The only thing I didn't finish was the beets. There were so many, and bland compared to everything else in the salad. Service was great and waitress was friendly. Bathroom was clean which is always a plus. We'll be back. read more

Penny Lane Pub - Southwest Chicken Salad Delicious! - American Near Me - Old Saybrook, Connecticut

See all