Came in for a quick dinner after work with a colleague, and has a solid experience. Pros - Speed- From the time I ordered my Philly steak and fries until I got it at the table, was about 7 minutes, so not bad. - Quality- The fries were hot and fresh, and the sandwich had a solid amount of steak (always good) Con - Temp- It was cold out, but it was also freezing inside, so the food didn't stay hot for long, but otherwise it was great. read more

Penn Station - Philly steak sandwich with banana peppers and a little pizza sauce for extra flavor - Sandwiches Near Me - Lafayette, Indiana

After avoiding this place for 4 years I decided to try again. Much has improved since my last visit. Things appear to be a lot more organized and efficient. I came for a late lunch so the place was pretty quiet. I like the new multi grain bread and the white bread is good too. My fries were a little past their prime and likely left over from the lunch crowd but still good. I'll put Penn Station back on my list. read more

Huge shoutout to Matthew at Penn Station! He called me to confirm my order because it looked like it might be missing toppings, and I was so impressed. It was a Friday night and an Instacart order, so he absolutely didn't have to do that, but he took the time to make sure it was right. That kind of customer care really stands out. Thank you for going the extra mile! read more

we order here all the time. The food is always hot and fresh. The fries are the best in town. Out of dozens of orders we've only had 2 issues. The manager went above and beyond to correct it. I highly recommend the Penn Station on 38. The whole staff is great. read more

This is a fantastic restaurant. I recommend the club and I'm not joking when I say--in my opinion--it is the best food ever. I get the large sub on white and grilled with all the toppings it comes with. You can add extra mayo and honey mustard if you want to add just a bit more flavor but it is amazing how originally comes. The manager is very nice and so is his staff. I eat here 1-2 times a week. read more

Service is always great here and the sandwiches always hit the spot. Best Penn Station to go to for consistent quality food.

Customer service was awful, a young lady with dyed hair was very rude to me and a short young short man with dark hair forgot to cook my meat and I watched him put it directly on the sandwich and not on the grill. The bathrooms were disgusting and none of the tables were clean. read more

I don't leave reviews, but there are a lot of bad penn stations and this one is definitely not one of them. Food is always good and the manager is a really cool guy. I placed an online order and forgot and placed another in the store, got home and realised and when I called he refunded one of them without me asking. read more

I have NEVER had such a problem with this place. The food has always been good. I always get the lemonade because I love it so much. The customer service is generally okay. Today was terrible. I got a lemonade and it tasted like lemon water with no sugar at all. I made my complaint, and asked if it could be fixed. The cashier said something to another worker (possibly a shift leader) He said something like "nobody else has complained so don't add any sugar" Are you kidding me? The cashier did add some sweetener and let me taste it. It still didn't taste like lemonade, but I wasn't about to continue arguing with someone that clearly didn't want to help me. I dumped it out and got a Pepsi instead. They basically gave me crap about it, and then didn't offer a refund or anything. The only worker that was actually polite was the order taker. Thanks for being the highlight of my experience random order taker. Edit: the general manager contacted me about it and found out they made the lemonade wrong. He apologized profusely, and said he would be coaching his team. Hopefully next time I go, things are settled there! Greatly appreciate his concern. read more

review... Covid has over taken us all. It's hard and we are all feeling it. We see the effects everywhere. With that said, does the give a business the right to charge $12 for sub par fries? $40 for two steak sandwiches, drinks and a shared large fry? You get to judge how you are treated during with the after effect! Right? Truth the sandwiches and fry order we took home and enjoyed. But the experience was flawed, onions missing from the regular cheese steak sandwich; soggy bland fries which is typical of this chain. The service was on par with the current pandemic. Funny how we change our standards!? Penn Station is a good chain of restaurants but I think they have taken advantage of pricing in the current situation. Non the less we get to choose to eat there food or not! Happy eating! read more

Went to grab some subs for dinner they were so quick and food was good was hot i honestly cant say 1 bad thing about this Penn station its taste gave me my extra meat like I ordered and they were probably the quickest I habe ever seen a sub place be thanks Penn station for keeping ur fast food fast read more

Just spent nearly $30 for 1 meal and 1 sandwich. Specifically ASKED the order taker if the LARGE special meal came with a LARGE fry. Was immediately told "YES". (I asked because their menu board on the wall is roped off, and I could not read the fine print from a distance.) Based on that answer, I ordered the large special meal with a large fry. And a second sandwich for my wife. I even told the order taker that we would be sharing the LARGE fry when he asked if we wanted fries with the other sandwich. Received my order with a small fry. Apparently the order-taker rang the meal with a small fry. Okay, that happens. But, this is a "meal special"... it comes with fries and drink... so... wouldn't the LARGE meal special come with the LARGE fries, and a LARGE drink - just like the order-taker TOLD US?! Apparently... NO, it doesn't! I asked the manager to correct it since I was told otherwise. He would not correct it. Says he's not allowed to "cost the company money." And, proceeded to correct the employee that made the mistake right in front of me! Told me I was wrong because I couldn't read the small print on their roped off, far away, menu board. Well, that just cost the company two customers that would spend $30+ a visit... ... all for about $1 in potatoes (@ your cost). That's just... what can I say... DUMB. Your employee made a legit mistake. Fix it, and you could have kept a happy - and RETURNING - customer. However, I will not be back. (And, I sure would NOT want to work there if my manager was going to throw me under the bus like that...) read more

I saw a Penn Station advertisement for a philly steak and cheese sandwich. The picture looked so good I simply had to go get one! Needless to say, the sandwich I received looked nothing like the picture... however, it was pretty tasty! I ordered a 12-inch philly cheese sandwich combo. It came with medium fries and a medium drink. The fries were somewhere between mediocre and bad. As I mentioned, the sandwich was good. Here's the problem: the total price for my medium fries, medium drink, and 12-inch sandwich was $14. I did a double-check and scanned the receipt, because I thought they made a mistake and overcharged me. nope! the philly cheese steak combo meal cost $14. That price took the taste right out of the sandwich. read more

Penn Station is a sandwich shop, located in the Kmart plaza on 38 east. They make great tasting grilled east coast style submarine sandwiches. They serve with hearth-baked fresh bread and quality ingredients. They put it all together, then magic seems to take place because the sandwiches are too amazing to describe- gourmet comes to mind though. Every sandwich I have ever had the joy of eating from there has been a taste bud pleaser! I now mainly order the grilled artichoke which always makes me a happy customer. I sometimes will have them add chicken, which is not much extra cash. Don't worry if you hate artichoke, they have 13 different sandwiches to choose from, for example the PHILADELPHIA CHEESESTEAK is a superb classic and always amazing. I am not a french fry eater, but I have to admit, I will help my wife eat a few of her fries when when we go there. The potatoes are hand selected, fresh-cut and flash-fried in cholesterol-free peanut oil. This simply means they are unlike any fast food fries you will likely find in the area. The staff at the Lafayette restaurant are always friendly and helpful. The prices are just a bit higher than subway, but there is no comparison when it comes to taste and quality. Penn Station is the best. It is a great eastside find in a sea of Lafayette's mostly boring fast food options. read more

They have the best steak sandwich in town and the boy by the name Christian is always super friendly and nice.

Had the Ruben and it was really good! Also had the fries with malt vinegar it was good too! Hate that fries aren't included and are over $2 for a small but will be back again. read more

My mother would move into Penn Station if they would let her. They grill their meats before throwing them on the sandwich and have fresh cut fries. That seems to be their schticks. I've tried many subs. My favorite is the italian sausage with peppers and onions. I had a club last week and it was just okay. I've never had a bad sandwich, though. I have had a bad glass of lemonade or two. I think they may not stick to a recipe when they make it because it varies so much from visit to visit. Easy enough to switch over to a soda, though. My only real gripe is that they seem to change their order placement system every time I go in. They've changed it at least three times this year. Can't they just pick a method and stick with it? read more

Philly steak and cheese with onions, peppers, mushrooms and mayo is the best sandwich around. The key to this sandwich is the bread and it is hot from the oven I have tried several of there sandwiches but the Philly is my favorite. The only downside is the price. Couldn't eat here very often for lunch and still be able to make the house payment. If you plan to indulge for lunch, you have to get the fries and fresh squeezed lemonade read more

Very good sandwiches and some if the best fries anywhere. I like the cheesesteak best. While it is not as good as one you would get in Philly, it is the best you will find in Lafayette. The Staff seemed to be polite and competent. During my last visit I came in during a rush which they were not prepared. The worked as fast as they could and I could tell they were trying their best. Unlike some other fast food places that show no sense of urgency. read more

Sandwich was a five star. Unfortunately the workers don't wear gloves. Never saw anyone wash their hands or a sink in sight. The cashier even handled money (which is dirty and disgusting) then went to to prep the people behind my order's food. Overall a dirty store. Plenty of other delicious sandwich shops in the area. read more

As far as sandwich shops go, this is as good as it gets!! When my husband and I come home to visit, this is the first restaurant we hit up. My favorite sandwich is the chicken cordon bleu and my husband's in the club. The ingredients are always fresh and your sandwich is cooked to order. The REAL fresh-cut fries are amazing!! read more

The food is phenomenal and Maurice was super polite. Both employees were working very hard! My complaint? GET CHANGING TABLES IN THE BATHROOMS!!! read more

Their Philadelphia Cheese Steak sandwich (although not authentic) is a great choice. The hand-cut fries are excellent. A good meal when in the mood for a great sandwich. read more

Food is fantastic, as usual. However, out of the 3 staff that I spoke with, only the lady who brought the food to my family actually made us feel like we were welcome in the restaurant. Guess a "to-go" order would have been a better option. read more

Penn Station has really improved over the last few years. The subs and fries are great. It's a little pricey but it's worth it.

Was amazed by how well they didn't follow instructions. Some how, light onions means, make the sandwich 3/4 onion. Thank you Nathian, I will not be going back. The fries were wonderfully stale too. So, for stale fries and onions instead of meat, go ask for Nathian. read more