My recent visit to Peggy's Place left me disappointed on multiple fronts. The restaurant displayed a lack of openness towards people with different political views, while the service was rude and the food failed to impress. From the moment I arrived, I felt an unwelcoming atmosphere due to the establishment's bias towards specific political ideologies. The staff exhibited disinterest and a lack of attentiveness, making the dining experience far from pleasant. The food itself was average at best. In today's diverse society, it's crucial for restaurants to foster inclusivity. Unfortunately, Peggy's Place fell short in this regard. With its unwelcoming environment, rude service, and average food, I find it difficult to recommend this establishment. There are undoubtedly better dining options available in the city that prioritize customer satisfaction and offer a more enjoyable experience. We ended up eating delicious chilaquiles at Michelle's down the road. read more

Peggy's Place - American Near Me - Keystone, South Dakota

See all

Peggy's Place has made some renovations since the last time I was in Keystone. The front facing looks the same but the interior has been updated. Parking in front of the restaurant is still limited but there is additional parking nearby. The capacity is stated as 159 but the three times I have been there, I have only seen a maximum of 20 people. I do eat dinner early when I can, I shoot for 4 pm and do not eat anything until the next morning. I like the fact that it is family run business and the the food is made to order and homemade. I had the cheese omelette and hashbrowns which were reasonably priced and no complaints on the preparation. Breakfast is served until 11 am. They serve breakfast, lunch and dinner with a descent number of options on the menu. In early July their credit card machine was down and they only excepted cash. I saw strawberry rhubarb pie on the menu and took a slice to go, really good. read more

Peggy's Place - Peggy's Place - American Near Me - Keystone, South Dakota

See all

We have been to Peggy's Place several times. You want some down home food you will find it here at Peggy's Place. It is convenient for us right now since we are in the RV Park next door. So we just walk over. Frantic service with a smile and everyone are so friendly. Food is outstanding!! I especially love the biscuits and gravy. They serve breakfast until 11:00. Don't know if they are open on Sunday. They close at 2:00 daily. They have awesome hamburgers and everything is well cooked and very tasty!! read more

Our server turned my Son's morning around - he made him a dragon pancake, and taught him how to use a payphone! And breakfast was great, but our server made our morning magical Excellent stop for breakfast!!!! read more

Peggy's Place - American Near Me - Keystone, South Dakota

See all

On our road trip to Mount Rushmore, we stopped at Peggy's for breakfast. It was within walking distance of our hotel, The Rosevelt Inn. We also like places that have that family owned diner kind of vibe - and this place fit the bill. Although the service was friendly and the food was basic breakfast fare, there were a few issues I had with Peggy's. First, the coffee isn't great, but if you're ok with Folgers, then you'll be fine. However, the tea was watered down and not very flavorful, so if you're not a coffee drinker go with a soda or juice. Second, my wife ordered ham and eggs, but received bacon instead. When we brought it to the waiters attention, he simply said, "Sorry, I thought you said bacon," and then walked away. She never did get any ham. Third, their credit card machine was down and they had a sign to use their in-house ATM. Luckily, I had cash so that wasn't a big concern. However, being a little bit of a NY cynic, I wanted to document this just in case 3 week's from now it's still down and they are still raking in fees from their ATM. The sign looked old and the whole thing just struck me as a little shady. In a tourist town filled with several other choices, Peggy's might be close to "home-style cooking", but depending on your expectations it may not be the best option. read more

This family-friendly "mom & pop" restaurant is the BEST & CLOSEST RESTAURANT to Mt. Rushmore! And best of all, it's OPEN for dine in during these uncertain times! Our family loved it! It was my little sister's birthday and after enjoying a great breakfast, our waiter, Birds (I thought that's what his name was) came out to our table with his guitar and sang "Happy Birthday" to her wishing her a happy 9th birthday! If you're going here on vacation, it'll be a great change from the standard hotel breakfast. (Well, at least in our opinion) All in all, Great food Open for DINE IN & Sanitary (for Covid) Quick & Made to Order Close to Mt. Rushmore & Rapid City Friendly Staff Exceptional Breakfast ~ Oh yeah and SHOUT OUT TO OUR WAITER "Birds" (I hope I got the name right) ~ read more

Peggy's Place - Yelp won't allow you to post a video so instead, I took a screenshot! - American Near Me - Keystone, South Dakota

Wow for big sign saying open 7 days a week breakfast lunch and dinner , today they are randomly closed . How do you expect tourist in this town to get a hot meal. Just because your season is ending doesn't mean tourists aren't hungry .. read more

Peggy's Place - So day 2 trying to find food.. yesterday sign on door closed for the day and today sign down and no one there - American Near Me - Keystone, South Dakota

We ate breakfast at Peggy's while on vacation. This place is wonderful! The people are friendly, the service was great - and fast! The food was good, tasty breakfast food - no one left hungry! The omelet was big and tasty, the pancakes were fluffy and yummy - and the eggs were fresh and delicious. We highly recommend Peggy's if you are looking for a place to eat in this area. We will go again before we leave! read more

Just great! Friendly staff, great tasting food, not an overpriced tourest trap. Definitely will stop by again. read more

Peggy's Place - American Near Me - Keystone, South Dakota

We went here twice while vacationing. The first time we had a male waiter who was phenomenal! The food was awesome and he made us feel very welcome. The second time we had an Asian female who brought my 15 year old boys baby drinks as well as myself. She was nice, but never around when we needed her. The food was still great! read more

See all

Decor - 3 stars. Clean but a little tacky. Staff - 5 stars. Friendly host and waiter. The young man who served us was enthusiastic and attentive. He really enjoys meeting the people and his joy is contagious! Food - 3 stars. Ordered a beef stew soup for our baby. It was not too salty and has lots of meat and veggies. Hubby got the half pound burger and customized with jalapeños. It was a bit dry but tasty nonetheless. I got the everything salads and it was a generous portion. However I suspected that the greens came from a bag. The place is at the foothills of Mt Rushmore so lots of tourists go there. I wish they would take credit cards! read more

We stopped in to Peggy's Place after visiting Mount Rushmore in the pouring rain. We were cold and wet and it looked like a good spot to get some warm comfort food. First impressions were nice. Classic midwest diner decor (anyone reading my Yelp reviews will see that I have an affinity for midwest diners) and a bit of a crowd. Service was extremely friendly, but quite slow. We were apparently on the early side for lunch (11:40am) and were told the kitchen was still converting over from breakfast mode. After a little prompting, our waitress confirmed that they did have mashed potatoes and gravy (something that the entirely family wanted on this cold, wet day). That brings me to the food. I was quite disappointed. I had an open faced hot beef sandwich. The beef was tough and the gravy was clearly out of a can or jar. My wife ordered Chicken Fried Steak. After being informed they were out of this, she switched to a Chicken Fried Chicken, which was maybe 1/8" thick and tough. Though the coating was crunchy, it was pretty clear to us that this was institutional frozen fare that had been dropped in a fryer (which needed an oil change). The country gravy was thick as porridge and again seemed to be out of a can. Lack of seasoning across all our dishes reinforced that this was basically hospital food. Sorry, Peggy and crew. We really wanted to be enchanted by your diner. While our waitress was sweet and helpful, what came out of the kitchen left us wanting. read more

Peggy's Place - Cute country decor - American Near Me - Keystone, South Dakota

See all

Stopped in here with family and friends for some breakfast while in Keystone. First off, breakfast goes till noon but pancakes and french toast are done at 11am, so that was a disapointing surprise. As for food, biscuits were soft and stick-to-your-gut type, super good. Hashbrowns were overly thin and crisped. Bacon was a bit overdone, but overall a fine place to eat. read more

Peggy's Place - Biscuits and gravy - American Near Me - Keystone, South Dakota

See all

Like my husband says "they all can't be a 10" This place is farrr from it! Our hamburgers we're over cooked and dry...almost to the point you could not eat them. They were not busy at all when we got there and that should have told us something. They only take cash which is a joke, they just don't want to pay the fees because we were told the machine has been broke for months . Oh well we tried... read more

Homemade food is the best and Peggy's was delicious. We stopped while on vacation in Keystone. Giving three stars because nobody wore masks which is important right now and it was cash only which I didn't see posted outside before we walked in. Otherwise it was a great place and experience! read more

Great food! Not sure what the bad reviews are about. Biscuits were yummy and fluffy, omelets was huge, hash browns crispy, and our server, Farrah was so sweet and attentive! Highly recommend. All 4 of us enjoyed our meals. read more

While on this year's Epic Road Trip with my Boy (age 10), we were in Keystone for a couple of days. We age at Peggy's a couple of times, and had good experiences. It is not cheap, but we learned that nothing in Keystone is cheap. Our nearby hotel offered a breakfast, but it was basically all starches. The breakfast at Peggy's was very good, and a nice variety of things were available. The food was both well-prepared and tasty, and the coffee was also good. The Boy accidentally left his art supplies there when we headed out, and they set them aside for us to collect later. That was very appreciated. The next night, we ate dinner at Peggy's while our laundry washed in the laundromat next door. It was a choice born specifically of convenience, and the dinner was good as well. The Boy said his hamburger was great, and my buffalo steak was quite tasty. I agree with the review that rates the decor at 3 stars. "Clean but tacky" is accurate. But it's a pleasant kind of tacky. And I also agree with the same review's comment about the staff being very friendly. If I were back in Keystone again, I'd eat at Peggy's again. read more

I thought I did this review, but apparently I did not! We were there in June, so that was 2-1/2 months ago. The food here was horrible. It wasn't very busy when we went there...it was a late lunch. My husband got the special which was meatloaf. That was not edible. Long story short, it didn't matter what it was, no one finished their lunch. I love frozen fries, but those were awful. I suggest to anyone who thinks about going there....DON'T! read more

Great location, the ingredients are good, the food preparation skills are fine but oh my goodness, can it be any less flavorful? Like come on, watch some Gordon Ramsey and add some funk to that menu. Get that blandness out of here Peggy. Also, the presentation is horrible!! I mean look at the pic and now the steak was served to me. No excuse for this. Would love to visit again if/when this place gets spiced up. read more

Peggy's Place - American Near Me - Keystone, South Dakota

I ordered chicken fried steak and eggs yesterday and it was good. Today I ordered biscuits and gravy and the biscuits were cold really cold the waitress kindof got a little attitude and she took it away and brought it back 2 min later after they out it in the microwave. It was actually not bad after warmed up. read more

Great breakfast! They aren't kidding when they say BIG cinnamon roll - be ready to share. We had chicken fried steak, bacon and eggs and the country breakfast. Plenty of food, pleasant people and great service. Great way to start the day! read more

Sweetest staff, good homestyle food, easy going, they only take cash tho which is odd but they have an atm read more

Peggy's Place - Delicious homemade chicken noodle soup, thick and creamy - American Near Me - Keystone, South Dakota

WARNING!! CASH ONLY! Just an average to below average greasy spoon. Very loud at late breakfast (10 AM). Many tables with dirty dishes. read more

It was alright when your really hungry, I had the salad with fried chicken, the chicken was alright but the lettuce and cucumbers were old and wilted. My hubby had the hot beef sandwich and it was small, he said it was just OK. Better options in Keystone! read more

Saw a bunch of people here so we stoped by. I had a buffalo burger but it was over cooked. My mom had the buffalo brat that she said was a bit crispy. I was not impressed. The service was great. But the food was lacking. I'm not sure if they were having a off day. read more

My husband and I like local places, diners and what we used to call "coffee shops," especially for breakfast. We knew Keystone was very touristy but most of the breakfast places in Custer (we were camping nearby) were closed on Tuesdays, and the reviews of Peggy's were pretty good, so we went there before going to Mt. Rushmore. Don't do it! This was basically a factory for capturing tourists for breakfast. There are two large rooms with basic tables and chairs (no booths). The "decor" is 1980's "country" -- stuffed cows, farm implements and signs with cutesy country sayings on the walls. It took a long time for the waitress to come to ask us what we wanted to drink. The menu is VERY basic and the food is bland and poorly cooked. There are no specialties and no fresh fruit or even sliced tomatoes. I had to cajole the waitress into letting me have a mushroom and cheese omelette, even though the menu listed a cheese omelette and a veggie omelette that included mushrooms. My husband's ham and cheese omelette was completely brown (overcooked) on the outside. The hash browns were undercooked and clearly came straight out of a bag from the freezer. When we were there, at about 9 am, they were already out of apple and orange juice. Additionally, as Phil B's review notes, there is a sign at the cashier saying that their credit card machine is out of order so they only take cash -- but they have an ATM. Phil wrote his review almost a year ago -- lots of time to get that machine fixed! Why not just be honest and say you don't take credit cards? (Because then you can pretend to be customer-friendly but still avoid vendor credit card fees AND rake in some ATM fees!) Only pluses: they bring the (warm and weak) coffee in a carafe, so you don't have to wait for refills, and the biscuits were pretty good (only grape and strawberry jam). We would have been MUCH better off with cereal and berries and good strong hot coffee in our cute 1954 camper! read more

I wouldn't if I were you... Peggy's is a perfectly average cafe that serves perfectly average meals. The staff is average; friendly without making any extra effort. The food is average; everything on my breakfast plate tasted the same. The coffee was so bad as to be undrinkable. read more

Don't bother. It looks inviting but the service is completely terrible, rude and even my children were surprised at how rude our waitress was, it was a young girl with long dark hair and a green t shirt with faces on it, she was awful, ignored people and was miserable and unhelpful. The food was terrible too. And for some pancakes and an omelette it came to $46. Expensive and AWFUL. Avoid this place!! read more

Fancy, it is not. Gourmet? Not a chance? Good food? Well, you're goddamn right, good buddy. This is some good food. We drove all night to have a quick weekend in the Black Hills and pulled in here around 8AM. I had read the reviews on here previously, and was ready to give it a shot but not enthusiastic. I grew up in a tourist trap. I know about low expectations in a place where all customers are tourists. The food usually sucks and you are glad to have it. Well, not here. We ordered (for 4 of us - 2 kids, 2 adults) French Toast, Kids Breakfast, Biscuits and Gravy and the Chicken Fried Steak Breakfast....my advice. Do it. We put the plates in the middle and shared - family style. I'm a northern boy, so granted may not know good pork gravy if it slapped me in the face. But the little lady, she was born in Georgia...and she started fighting me for the plate. Oh, and she stabbed me when I went for the chicken fried steak. So, ya....it was good. On top of that, the staff was about as friendly as you will find. Again, nothing fancy. They did not wear white jackets any extra garbage. But they were about the friendliest people you could hope to meet.... read more

Too many places in South Dakota take the passing tourist for granted and serve poor quality food with a bad attitude. On the contrary the folks at Peggy's place will go out of their way to make you feel welcome and they stand behind the food they serve. All we ordered was good. Excellent Ruben and Swiss mushroom burger. Really good homemade chips Bottom line, a good and solid place to stop by for lunch. read more

We loved our waiter. I think his name was Birds. He was cheerful, happy, amazing! Good food! Recommend breakfast! read more

Peggy's Place - Our waiter played Happy Birthday to our daughter who turned 9 years old! Good food! - American Near Me - Keystone, South Dakota

Avoid this place! The service is so awful its infuriating. We waited ages to be served and when we finally were served our miserable waitress was so incredibly rude, there was a young man running around the place like a maniac, if he's your server you probably will be served promptly, we heard him yelling orders around across the cafe. it came to $46 for some crappy pancakes and warm weak coffee. I don't particularly care about decor or price if the food and service is good but this was awful on all accounts. read more

There's probably not a good place to eat in this tourist trap of a town and this is one to avoid. My wife and 3 kids got tired of looking around and a failed attempt at Barlees where their menu on line is way different than the worn out crap they handed us. Back to Peggy's food was subpar and overpriced 90.52 for dinner. Salad wilted fried chicken over cooked just like the kids hamburger. read more

The service was great in this very busy place. We had breakfast. The food was OK and the menu had enough choices.

I went to Peggy's place during the rally. The food was OK, had chicken fried steak that seamed to be mass produced with a bland gravy that was, in my opinion, not home made. The place was clean, excellent service by foreign exchange students and the bathrooms were nice. To get good food during the rally is very difficult, especially during rally, I will go back. read more

The food....it didn't stand out.....Not many vegan options. Ordered extra crispy hash browns with onions and peppers....very disappointed that they cooked the hash browns and THEN topped with the uncooked veggies. Would have tasted better if they had fried the veggies with the potatoes. Hubby liked his skillet breakfast and we did have a nice server. I will say that I think the boys who were cleaning the tables should have not been gossiping.....not very professional. read more

Huge pancakes, great staff, great chocolate milk. Good grilled chicken breast. Overall great read more

Peggy's Place - Huge pancakes - American Near Me - Keystone, South Dakota

I feel a bit badly because I haven't had a chance to give this establishment a rating and it's been some time since I dined here on one of mine and my girlfriend's summer excursions. From what I remember it was a great place to eat and offered a great tasting classic country breakfast that was just the right amount of filling. It's proximity to Mount Rushmore and Custer State Park made it a jewel of a find before we started exploring day! read more

This place got four stars because of the service. The food was good. We ate there for lunch. My wife had a patty melt, and I had a club sandwich. Both of them were good. However, the good part comes when you talk about service. It was the time between lunch and dinner so there's only about eight tables full at the time. At one of the tables a baby started to cry. The waiter went behind the counter pulled out his guitar and played for the baby until it calmed down and stop crying. I thought that was very sweet. When the couple bank Timmy said it was no big deal he plays for his daughter all the time. read more

We came to Peggy's for breakfast and the food was delicious! The experience overall was good, but there were definitely a few pros and cons Pro's: -Food was delicious! I had the everything omelette with hash browns and toast, and my husband had the French toast with sausage links. Everything tasted fresh and homemade. -The service was fairly quick, we only waited about 10 minutes for food to be in front of us after ordering. - good prices and large servings Cons: - the summer staff could barely speak English and had trouble figuring out correct change. - they were cash only - our waiter was incredibly over the top, loud and energetic (this could be a pro or a con depending on who you are, but for us it seemed like a bit much) Overall we would definitely go back again if we were in the area for another good, hearty meal. read more