Pegasus has the best pizza in town. The crust is good and they have the best ingredients. Plenty of veggie and meat options. They make their own dough and prep all their ingredients in-house (no frozen pre-cooked chicken!). Our go-to favorites are the Hawaii 5-0, the Veggie Vortex, and the Mt. Saint Helen's. I don't mess around the food delivery services that take money from the restaurants. We go old-school and call in our order and then pick it up. Wish they still had their own drivers but those days are gone. Worth it to drive there and pick it up!! read more

I've been told by a duck that Pegasus Pizza is a cult classic amongst UO students, and I definitely caught this vibe. Situated within steps of the frats and student housing, Pegasus Pizza is your typical college town hangout spot -- draft beer, pizza, and good vibes all around. I kept it simple and got a slice of pep and a blackberry cider and it hit the spot. The slice was huge, cider was crisp, and service was so-so. But hey, if you're ISO a place to remind you of your peak college days OR for a night cap after the bars, this is your spot. What more can you ask for?! Be sure to check out the Pegasus Pizza on 14th Ave. (they've got other locations, but this one is in the heart of UO). I'll be back to win a duck from the Duck Catcher -- iykyk! read more

Pegasus Pizza - Cider + Slice of Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Eugene, Oregon

I showed up at 7:25 pm (they close at 8pm) and was told they had stopped taking orders inside a while ago. They already had so many online orders that their ovens would be full until closing time. I have NEVER heard such a thing. They should have a warning if that is their policy. Just turning off your open sign doesn't count since people often forget to turn them on. So get your orders in early or you will get nothing! I hear that they have great pizza. Not that I know. read more

Pegasus Pizza never disappoints us. We usually eat at the restaurant but this time had it delivered and it was just as good.

We ordered two small pizza's for dinner delivery thru Doordash. One was pepperoni. The other a delicious pie with feta, roasted garlic, olives and basil. Crust was excellent. Toppings were good. But a LOT of garlic cloves.... Oh my...... Pizza is not quite inexpensive anymore but I thought these were worth the money. Yumm. read more

Pegasus Pizza - Lots of garlic on that pizza - Pizza Near Me - Eugene, Oregon

Late night and needed something for a move, what's better than pizza. So we ordered from Pegasus pizza. Our order was basic, a cheese and olive pizza. The order was ready in 20min, the pizza was hot and good. Nothing extravagant but maybe that was the basic pizza we ordered. As far as pizza in Eugene goes this is definitely in the top three places I would recommend! read more

Delicious pizza: fresh ingredients and great taste. The workers were friendly, the restaurant was clean, and I received my pizza pretty quickly. The only downside was that the pizza was an absolute grease trap. If you look at my picture of the pepperoni pizza, you'll see literal puddles of grease in the pepperonis. If these can reduce the grease a little, I'd love to come back! read more

Pegasus Pizza - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Eugene, Oregon

See all

This company has taken a nosedive since 2020. Dropped $50 on two medium pizzas tonight and would have been better off with frozen pizza or Papa Murphy's. The crust was similar to particle board with not one air pocket, unpleasant crunch 1/4" thick, and zero flavor. the toppings just sat on top and slid off with the sauce completely barred from the crust. Ick read more

Sometimes you have a Big Craving for something you have enjoyed in the past. Today was that day. Nothing sounded better than a Pegasus Calif chicken pizza. White sauce, Garlic, bacon, great cheese. Do I ordered from Pegasus vis Grub Hub. Get an acknowledgment, get billed, get a tentative time. Time passes and I'm not getting any further updates so I call Pegasus on 14th street. Nice gal can't find my order, after much searching she finds it scheduled for tomorrow. Interesting I completed my order on Yelp before they opened at 4 and never checked the date. Nothing Pegasus Pizza can do to help me so I call Grub Hub. I have my order number, operator cancels my order and issues a refund. So back I go to Yelp and place my order...again. Get my tentative time.., time goes past...I give it an extra 20 and call Pegasus again. Gal checks, shows no order for me, sends me back to Grub Hub.. Grub Hub starts looking, finds my order, confirms its with the 14th street location and as we are on the phone says and they just updated showing its out for delivery. Ok, how can they not find my order and then within 5 minutes send out delivery?? How? Pizza comes I open... I decided that the fates were trying to tell me tonight wasn't pizza night. Calif chicken pizza is a White Sauce pizza--- nope red bbq sauce Chicken yes Red onion - yes I did 3 special instructions Extra bacon- maybe Extra cheese- nope No tomatoes- arrived with tomatoes. The pizza tough was overcooked and tough Some days are almost enough to make a grown man cry I order from the 14th street location versus Oakway because, in the past 14th street makes a better pizza !! Now,, So tonight didn't end up being an experience I enjoyed but it didn't kill me. Can't understand all the order and update issues. Maybe the first order with bad date was my fault.., but the 2nd one? The pizza is made of 8 items counting crust. 4 were wrong. How the heck does a white sauce pizza become a red sauce pizza. I want Pegasus to be great But maybe they don't want to put the basic effort into that Done read more

Staple for years! Never have I been disappointed by the pizza. It's bomb. Local. Delicious. The service on campus is my fave cuz they fun. And it's a fun atmosphere read more

Excellent place . Great people ..friendly staff and people . Love the Pizza . Good toppings . Great selection of beverages on tap . Cider Beer etc . Rock on with twenty billion garlic socks on !!! Go here . It rocks ..they play good music too read more

This pizza is ok. The entire experience of ordering and pickup went fine, but there wasn't much to write home about with the actual pizza. The foccacia was dry. Pizza was eh. Don't get me wrong... I ate it because pizza is delicious 95% of the time. read more

Pegasus Pizza - a whole pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Eugene, Oregon

I just enjoyed a most excellent piece of vegetarian pizza. butternut squash, pepitos, pesto and ricotta cheese. I've always enjoyed Pegasus pizza but this was over the top good so I thought I'd give it a five star review. I hope this will be a recurring special. read more

IT IS ALL GOOD! Don't forget they have salad too. Each location is very different. Same great taste at each one. Quality Italian meats. My favorite is the Veggie Vortex. read more

We used to love this pizza but the one we got delivered tonight was dry almost no cheese or sauce. The toppings so skimpy you could count the pieces. The crust was over cooked. Seems like everyone nowadays is skimping on ingredients. This pizza was really expensive. Sadly we will not order again. read more

Had a great time, huge pizzas, pitchers of beer and large salads. It was perfect. Stopped here after visiting out friend at UO. it seems like a great affordable place for students to go and enjoy. read more

See all

Love the pizza and salad. Clean and fun atmosphere....a little slow on service but it was game day so places in the area are busy! Will go back when in town for game day!! read more

Usually this is some decent bar style pizza, nothing special. Unfortunately I was bringing a buddy of mine from out of town to try some pizza, and when we got to the door at 10:30 (they close at 11) it was locked. We knocked on the door and a younger man who worked there Flipped is off and said to F off. TERRIBLE CUSTOMER SERVICE! read more

I've been here before and they have great pizza. But they were hardly busy tonight and it has been ALMOST ONE HOUR FOR TWO SALADS. We didn't even order pizza today??? So pretty disappointed and probably won't come back for awhile, especially if there's no compensation- I went up after about 30 minutes and asked where our food was and they said they had just put our ~bread~ in the oven and would GET STARTED on our salads... and they didn't seem to really care :// read more

"Go to Pegasus Pizza it's good" What the heck!!!?? Let's begin with the place itself. The place looked ok, not busy at all. Parking was good. The place was fargin cold and kept the fans full blast. Asked them to turn our overhead fan off, nope turn one off they all turn off. I'm trying hard not to be to picky here but at least have hot water to wash your hands and maybe warm them up. Employees: Thee worst of the worst, absolutely no clue of customer service or personality, borderline rude. Zero hospitality. Food: ordered two pizza's, salads some wing's, no big deal. 40 minuets later we got our food so I'm thinking they must be these great artisan pies. Nope. Degorno pizza may be its equal. Thin crust pies, low on flavor and salty. Wings were not that bad but don't ask for extra ranch, they will charge you. Refills on drinks!? Charge you. Spent $65 bucks on this nasty dive, won't be back. read more

Pegasus Pizza - the interior of a restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Eugene, Oregon

Pegasus Pizza is my go-to place for lunch when I'm on campus around lunchtime. A friend suggested we head there after studying late at the beginning of term. I was wary, because I'm vegan and I'm usually reluctant to go new places without reading their menus first, but my friend assured me they had vegan options. I ordered a vegan cheese pizza with pineapple. They use Daiya, which is what I use at home when we make pizza, and is a great substitute for the usual house made vegan cheese sauce I run into sometimes. The sauce was flavorful, and the crust was fluffy inside and crisp outside. Pegasus Pizza makes a fine vegan pie! I was really pleased. I asked for a cherry coke, and the nice employee working at the counter told me he could run downstairs and put grenadine in a regular soda, since they don't have a cherry coke fountain soda. So nice! It would be hard to justify buying a pizza just for myself for dinner, because they are kind of pricey (for the average college student) at night. I asked my boyfriend to meet me there for lunch a week or so later. They have a lunch special during certain afternoon hours, where you can order a personal pizza with 2 toppings for 5.75. It's a pretty good deal. He got dairy cheese, pineapple, and spinach, and I got another Daiya pizza with pineapple and black olives. The personal pizzas are good sized. My boyfriend is kind of picky about pizza crust and he really enjoyed eating there. Atmosphere wise, it gets pretty noisy at night, since they show games on their massive TVs, but it's not unpleasant. It was pretty calm around lunchtime when I went. They even have a couple pinball games you can play while you wait for their pizza. If I had endless money for food, I could easily eat here once a day and not get tired of it. Thank you Pegasus Pizza, for providing an easy to get to, tasty, pizza pie. I appreciate your existence. read more

See all

Pegasus is a great casual place to get some pizza, beer, and maybe a few drinks. There is a lot of open table and booth seating indoors and they have a few tables outside on a deck overlooking the street as well. They serve beer upstairs and have a full bar downstairs if you want something a little stronger. At this location you order at the counter and then your order is brought out to your table of choice as opposed to traditional wait service. Our tables were bused occasionally, a perfect amount of service IMO. The pies were fantastic. We had the Combo and a half Maui Wowie/Pepperoni. Both were hot, fresh and tasty and used quality toppings. We tried a couple orders of the Focaccia and the Garlic "Gnots". The Focaccia was a crowd pleaser, the "Gnots" not so much. They were not terrible, they just needed a bit more flavor. This was the 2nd time our group has come here and we will be back for sure! read more

Pegasus Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Eugene, Oregon

See all

Legendary. Before I moved to Eugene, I asked some friends who grew up here if they had any tips on how to get to know this unique town. Every one of them mentioned Pegasus Pizza. It's the best pizza in town. When my mom brought my niece down to see me, we took her here with us to watch the Duck game. She loved it (as everyone should). It's got the typical red pizza joint seats that make for an awesome family-friendly restaurant. Plus, it's so close to campus that it's the perfect college student hang out spot. Nowadays, whenever my friends or family head to Eugene for conferences or sports events, I tell them about Pegasus. I mean, we've got to help the legend continue, right? read more

I heard rave reviews about this place and I was pretty disappointed. I love calzones and heard they made the best in Eugene! Unfortunately, I disagree because I cannot stand calzones that do not have the toppings cooked before putting into the calzone even after requesting that. Oh well! read more

Pegasus won't change the way you think about pizza in Eugene. It won't cause you to make sounds of delight while you eat a slice or tell everyone you know that Pegasus has the best pizza around. Finally, and unfortunately, eating this pizza won't magically result in the appearance of a winged horse on loan from Zeus. With that said, Pegasus isn't a bad pizza joint. They have some good lunch specials and a full bar downstairs. For lunch you can get a slice, soda and a salad for about $5 or instead you can get a personal pizza for the same price. The dinner specials run from 4-6 and 10-close if I'm remembering correctly and are generally a discount on a full pie of a certain type. This deal may have only been going when I was there because Pegasus is celebrating an anniversary. Last night a buddy and I split the small pepperoni and had a pitcher of Rolling Rock for about 15 dollars. Apparently Rolling Rock is Pegasus' PBR replacement, just like Labatt's is Rennie's PBR replacement. Why the hell don't either of these campus eateries carry the blue ribbon? We sat on the deck, which is particularly great for scoping Greek Life beezies and bros as they stumble back to their homes on Alder and is in general one of the quieter outdoor seating setups. The nasty looking apartment across the street is certainly an eye sore though. Again, it won't blow your mind. But, if you desire a slice close to campus and want your crust on the Ally McBeal side, check out Peg. I also like that they don't charge for ranch. I hate it when pizza places charge for a side of ranch dressing. read more

Pegasus Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Eugene, Oregon

It didn't help that right before we started craving pizza, Guy Fieri was on the Food Channel gobbling down a slice of wood- baked oven pizza with the cheese practically melting off the side. We all took one look at each other and said, "We should order some pizza!!" 30 seconds later, it was off to the Pegasus website where we ordered a large pie called: LITTLE ITALY Garlic/olive oil base, fresh spinach, mozzarella, Italian sausage, roasted red pepper, gorgonzola, topped with fresh basil and parmesan. You guys can probably tell I just cut and pasted this description right off of the website to save me some time. Since there was only 3 of us, we thought that we would have been okay ordering a medium size. But after digging in, let's just say that a large was "sufficient." The crust was great-- not real thick, but still had the thin crusty taste. I could distinctly taste the crushed garlic, along with the sliced fresh spinach and the sprinkling of basil throughout. The roasted red pepper and melted gorgonzola used in place of mozarella made the pizza taste awesome as well. The few slices of pieces we have left will definitely make a great snack for tomorrow. I love the pizza in Eugene!! read more

I've never been into Pegasus but I've had their food at the bar in the basement, Fathom's. Having just completed a remodel, Fathom's is clean and comfortable with a great staff. They serve Pegasus' menu until bar close and have excellent food and drink specials. The U of O clientele can be obnoxious, but altogether this is a great spot. And shots of Pendelton are only $5.50! EDIT: I went into Pegasus for lunch and they were nice enough to let me leave my car in their parking lot while I went to talk to one of my professors. Considering how obnoxious parking can be on the UO campus, this was definitely a plus! read more

Pegasus Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Eugene, Oregon

Literally the WORST customer service of any place I've eaten at. Every person I've been helped by has been rude and short with me. Pizza ain't good enough for the sass you have to deal with. Wouldn't be surprised if they spit in ur food here. Also rt if u agree but it's just like the pizza place from the hot ABC series Make it or Break it read more

Somehow waited two hours for a slice of pizza on a Wednesday night... wasn't told upfront that they needed to make more slice pizzas. Even so, in what world does that take an hour? read more

This location is awful. I ordered a salad and it took over an hour for it to be ready. After complaining twice we found out they never actually made the salads. All of my friends had the exact same experience. DO NOT GO HERE unless you have a couple hours to kill! read more

We have been coming here for a couple years and although the pizza is still good it isnt great like it used to be. We had a pesto chicken pizza last evening and the crust was so dry as was the chicken. Not ready to give up on them but was disappointed last night. read more

Haley is the best bartender in the entire nation. We cried, we laughed, we fell in love. She's cute, she's funny, she's silly, she's a good. Her laugher and energy brings joy to anyone who walk even past pegasus. Everyone in town talks about her, we want her to be mayor. Haley is god. Haley is life. God bless America. read more

*This review is for delivery* I was pretty darn close to three stars... and then I took a bite of my chicken wings... ...After driving for 8+ hours my hubby and I checked into a Motel 6 (sweet digs) and found the Huskies v. Baylor bowl game on ESPN. (Go Dawgs!) And what goes better with football than pizza and wings?... Nothin'. (Obviously beer as well... I'm not an idiot). Pegasus was the best price I found on Yelp that served a gluten-free slice, had wings (not breaded), and delivered . There were no reviews regarding the gluten-free crust... so I prayed. For about 20 bucks we got a small gluten-free pepperoni and a half-order of chicken wings- and a 2.50 delivery charge. They utilize a delivery company called the Pony Express. Whatever, I don't care, just get me my food- I'm getting hangry.. They arrived in around an hour. Not bad. My gluten-free pizza was probably worth three stars. It wasn't too "rice-y" (fellow gluten-free foodies know what I'm talking about), nicely chewy, and a bit crunchy around the edges- which I don't mind and usually expect from these types of crusts. The cheese was a bit weird- a little rubbery, but not too shabs. Pepperoni was standard. Satisfied my craving but didn't wow me. Because of the gluten-free markup (add three dollars to a price of a small and you get a 12 inch) I didn't want to spend extra $ on fancy toppings. The wings were just gross. When I called to verify that they didn't bread the wings (blasphemy, I say!) the nice girl informed me that they are baked. Now, I can pull off a delicious baked wing in my own kitchen- crispy, but still healthy. These were... slimy. YES, maybe it was better before the delivery trip, but it was still unappetizing enough to knock off one star. MY husband requests that I say the wings were "to die from". It's a pun of "to die for". Sorta. The celery sticks and ranch were tasty, though. Next time I'm in the Eugene area while traveling I think I'll pretend that pad thai is a classic football food instead. read more

They have the best gluten-free pizza Del in Eugene Oregon. Get it a little crispy and you won't be disappointed even for those people who don't eat gluten-free this was the best. I ordered mushrooms olives and pepperoni and everything was so so fresh read more

There is something wrong with their cheese!!!!! I don't mind paying a little more for pizza, but my GAWD, use real cheese if you are going to charge as much as they do. I expect that crap more from dominos. It gave me a nasty tummy ache after eating it and I am not going back there again. Also, the crust got all soggy from the sauce. I am beginning to wonder if the whole stupid thing wasn't undercooked. Plus side, it's a cool little place and if their pizza didn't give me the nasties, I might just go back for a beer or something. But alas, it isn't meant to be between me and the Pegasus. Moving on! This isn't NY style as far as I am concerned. Sy's is better. read more

Best. Pizza. Ever. I always get the Zorba with smoked salmon and sun dried tomatoes... Last time I had it, the fish tasted more like lox... I still don't mind spending $50.00 there, no problem. read more

Good pizza, but not cheap! I like the Mt. St.Helens with mushrooms and olives added. I also like that they have Moose Drool beer on tap. The selection of beers is not just the old standbys. read more

All of the food here was amazing, it is perfect for a late lunch. The single slices are on New York proportions, you will need two hands. This is one of the best pizza places to eat at in Eugene! read more

Pegasus Pizza - Pepperoni, green olive, and pineapple with a side spinach salad. The salad: red onions, grape tomatoes and a generous amount of feta! - Pizza Near Me - Eugene, Oregon

The pizza here is okay. It is a bit more spendy though for the average college student. I'm sure you can find a better value elsewhere. Never had a bad experience with the place. Dark and woody inside, you get a real pizza parlor kind of ambiance. It's good for groups. I think they also have a deck outside that you can sit on and relax. It's a has a great neighborhood pizza parlor feel to it. Parking is street side and you may be able to find something in the lot to the side. read more

Other than the deck, there's nothing exceptional about this place. And a deck isn't really exceptional, is it? I guess if you have only ever eaten pizza in Eugene, you might feel like this is the best in town. Or maybe you just like the pinball... or maybe the place is wrapped up for you in some nostalgic wacky-zone in your brain with other various college shenanigans. But I'm going to guess that most of us have been somewhere that has actual good pizza, instead of best-you-can-get-pizza. Don't get me wrong -- it's not bad. Just painfully, shamefully average. And I prefer the New York style anyhow, while I see this place as synonymous with big chunks of toppings and thick crust. It's a little overpriced for what it is, but don't worry about that. You guys just go hang out here, convince each other it's the greatest, and leave Sy's to me. read more