I remember eating here many years ago when it was Mr. Macho's with my dad as a kid, so this place always holds great memories for me. So needless to say, I was excited when the original owner's kids came back and turned it into My Boys. I came in here for dinner with my husband over the weekend. It had been many years since I've enjoyed their pizza, and it was like coming home, if that makes sense. There is always a sense of nostalgia when you eat something you love from childhood. There are certain restaurants that do the same thing for my husband, so he knew I wanted to go here. Their menu and taste reminds me of Roaring Rapids Pizza, and that isn't a bad thing. We ordered a medium pizza and my husband's half was some kind of meat combination. I forget the actual name. I picked mushroom and sausage for my half. Plus we decided to do the salad bar. The salad bar is impressive. There are more choices than just the basic average salad bar, and the one time through addition to our pizza was perfect for both of us. It is rare that my husband will order a salad on his own accord, but that salad bar was calling his name. Staff is friendly and helpful when needed. Although our order was pretty straightforward, so they really didn't have to do anything special. But they were still great. I love that they have plenty of space for kids, and TVs to watch sports on while we ate. It is such a great local family-oriented restaurant. It is a very relaxed and fun place to enjoy a meal. Would I return? Of course! I've sent my husband down to Creswell specifically for food more than once. I will gladly do it again. Lol. But really, they totally deserve a return trip. I'm definitely looking forward to coming back in the near future. read more

My Boys Pizza - pepperoni, mushrooms, and cheese - Pizza Near Me - Creswell, Oregon

See all

We got a large pizza with 2 different types. (Chicken, bacon, ranch & pepperoni, Canadian bacon, and beef) We also got a 6 piece buffalo wing. The crust coulda been cooked a bit longer was a tad soft-and the cheese was not fully melted so was kinda a thick blob of stringy unmelted cheese. The wings were okay but lacked enough sauce. I've had their pizza a few times years ago and remember it being better. A friend mentioned it the other day so we decided to get it while in town. I don't know that we will be making the trip again anytime soon. Just not a great experience this time unfortunately! read more

My Boys Pizza - Half chicken bacon ranch pizza & half pepperoni, Canadian, & beef. Large - Pizza Near Me - Creswell, Oregon

See all

Ordered taco pizza looks like figaros cold and chips are stale absolutely appalled same great price half the toppings

After coming here half a dozen times it's been a consensus that the service is just terrible each time. Workers are stressed out and you feel it with the establishment, salad bar is not stocked, long waits, machines eating your kids change, cashiers are grouchy. It may be ok if it is slow but if it's busy any little bit it's a really off putting place to be. 1 star establishment but 2 stars because the kids love the play area. read more

This is a great spot to take the kids to get some energy out especially during the wet and cold months. Their staff is either awesome or grumpy, depending on who you get. I will say I've been getting better service as of late. Foodwise, you know about the pizza but the best thing on their menu is the fresh chicken strips. I will get a bucket for the family, go through the drive through to pick up, and eat it for a couple days making awesome sandwiches, it's like 16 half chicken breast's for $22. read more

Great little play zone with games and an indoor play structure. Really good salad bar. Pizza was pretty good, about the same as other places like papas pizza and roaring rapids. Younger guy that took our order (redhead) was super nice. One thing I'd recommend is that they get a speaker for the playroom because we had no idea our order was ready because we were all in the playroom so I don't know how long it was sitting there, another customer actually let us know that it had been sitting there and they had called our name earlier. read more

We have tried this restaurant at least 8 times and every single time we got burnt pizza and the calzones are not kneaded enough and they are thick and doughy. The place has a lot of turnover with their staff. We will not go back because it's a waste of money. read more

The food wasn't bad but the service for 6 adults 5 kids (2 families) for a small birthday party was horrible! The manager was very grumpy (this isn't the first time HER being grumpy) she told the mother of the birthday boy, to tell the kids to stop playing so loudly ... no one else was in the parlor but us! kids screaming and playing in the very back, where kids are meant to run and play isn't the first time hearing kids have fun, but the manager doesn't like it at all! Either they find a new manager or we find a new place to have our parties! She was moody when asked if we could get the OR Football game on too. Not sure if she should stay in the background making pizzas and such, but as a manager ... I wouldnt want my teenager working there With her in charge! read more

The pizza is good and I like the crust. I've been in a few times and the people working there were nice. It's a bit expensive, but what isn't nowadays? read more

I love this place. I am recently traveling to Creswell twice a month on business. We brought pizza in from another place for a meeting, not as good My boys. I ordered room service to my hotel and it delivered in under 30 minutes. Some of the best pizza I have had. I just visited again and took a co-worker to the restaurant, same thing, great service, good salad bar the pizza is so good. Will make it a twice a month visit on my trips. read more

I would even call it Pizza. I went for lunch buffet. They had 2 old slices of what looked like pepperoni & pineapple?? Only 1 teenager with a bad attitude was working. She said she was going to make another pizza, it was undercooked and just slimy and inedible. Never again. She was only one working and couldn't pour beer and shorted me on change as well. read more

Good pizza, great service. Not sure why it's not higher. We've been in a few times and not been disappointed.

Pretty good pizza. I stopped in here to get a small pizza. I had the Bulldog but added smoked oysters to it..(I'm a sucker for smoked oysters)! I also had the stuffed jalapeno poppers. Great meal. The pizza was very fresh with fresh ingredients, a good amount of toppings too. The poppers were actually one of the best I've had in a restaurant. They were big and full of cheese and flavor and a great lil kick to them. This is a small town and it has been hard to find somewhere decent to eat. The service was friendly. I'm a fan and will come back! read more

Love My Boys! Their staff is amazing, their food, is amazing, and appreciate their top notch service. Super easy online ordering. If you call in or order in person they offer a senior or military discount. They support the local community. Couldn't ask for better staff! read more

It can be expensive and wait is long. But the food is decent. It's good for a kids birthday party if it's raining out and you can't just have it at a park. read more

My family and I really enjoy the pizza here. It is definitely the best choice in town. The crust is great and pizza itself is delicious. If you like taco pizza, I highly recommend their version. I love that they have a salad bar option. I have been disappointed the last two times in to see that the options have been scaled back and are frequently low or not restocked. I love the online ordering option but it is difficult to navigate. I find it easier to call the order in. My kids love the arcade and the play area. It can get crazy especially on the weekends but lots of fun entertainment for kids and adults alike. read more

These guys have the best pizza ever! It's a great place for children to play, and the parents can see them, from where seated, It's wonderful for gatherings of any kind, Many other choices for meals, aside from pizza. read more

Service is extremely SLOW. Orders are incorrect (wrong/missing ingredient) and after driving from Eugene for pickup, to get home and not have edible food is incredibly irritating. This isn't the first time but it is the last for me. Never Again. read more

Over charge, second time I've ordered a pizza and they forgot to make my pizza. Didn't even receive an apology, if anything I received an attitude due to their mistake. The mangers are terrible and lack customer service etiquette. They should hold a team meeting to see where they could do better in all areas! read more

I went to the only pizza place that on Tuesdays exclusively serves fried chicken. It was GOOD fried chicken. Obviously when I called to order a pizza (from this PIZZA restaurant) and they denied my request (say "no" to me daddy), I was INTRIGUED. I highly recommend checking them out and I should have some knowledge of their pizza by...this evening.... read more

Tried calling to place an order 1:00pm. Was on hold for over 8 minutes. GAVE UP... How do they expect to sale food if they never answer the phone??1 read more

Their pizza is some of the best around these days. Nice play area for the kids too. And, they to delivery!

Has to be the worst chicken strips and poppers I've ever had. You could tell the oil was old and who knows how old the chicken was terribly overcooked and dry. You can get better from a gas station for HALF the price I will not return. If your going to charge the high prices the product shouldn't come from a cash and carry frozen food section. read more

My Boys Pizza - Burnt jalapeño poppers also old oil definitely a frozen cheap product. I won't be back. - Pizza Near Me - Creswell, Oregon

See all

It hurts me to say it, but the pizza was overpriced, took a long time to make, and I would've rather just driven to cottage Grove and gotten dominos. Pizza quality wasn't as good as I expected eating here. Tl;Dr: undercooked and greasy as sin. read more

Decent pizza on the expensive side. If you get a salad, get the $9.99 all you can eat (big plate) versus the $6.50 one time through plate (little plate). The pizza is good. I'd like to see the top a little more cooked and more sauce. Ive been here a couple of times and always leave thinking "it needs more sauce." Tonight I remembered to ask and sure enough - it had the same amount of sauce as always... "needs more sauce!" Other than that its your typical kid friendly with games and arcade - clean, locally owned, type of pizzeria. It has a cool stone fireplace in the center. No table service. Few beers. read more

Driving through Oregon, and MY BOYS PIZZA happened to be nearby. MY BOYS PIZZA seems busy, BUT the price.of the pizzas here are astronomical. And there are no single slices. The place has a few tables waiting like 3 total, and is doing a brisk trade in to go Atorders. There are no single slices. We ordered and waited for a good while, and when we were called up the pizza boys realized they stuck out name on a wrong order. So we reordered and went back to wait. Finally pizza was served and it was delicous, thin crust with a good selection of toppings. Check out the menu for prices. The main complaint is the cost- I imagine most.everyone will enjoy the pizza. 16" inch pizzas with toppings.run well over $30. 8" pizza run 1/2 the ptice.for $16; however remember that a 16" is 4 times more pizza than a 8. Or 4 smalls equal.one large. A 16" is big enough for 4 people give or take how hungry everyone is. So pizza here stars at $8 per person, isf.eith a group and around a $12 per person, of just a couple of people share a pizza. FYI [We at first went to Gate House Pizza, BUT found a syringe in the window! It was open, but doing very little business on a Saturday night.] read more

My Boys Pizza - MY BOYS PIZZA Menu & Prices $$$ - Pizza Near Me - Creswell, Oregon

Pizza and salad bar are to die for! My daughter loves the play place as well. Great family place

I ordered a 4 chicken tenders meal for myself and a 2 piece fried chicken with 2 sides meal for my spouse. It cost less than $18 which, in today's world of extreme inflation, is pretty dang good! The chicken tenders were big, plump, crispy and juicy. The fries looked like, and tasted, homemade. The fried chicken was excellent and the sides (mac and cheese and baked beans) were delicious! DQ, you lost a chicken strip basket customer! And I'm not sorry! No Name read more

Love My Boys Pizza, I do live in Eugene so I don't get it often but when I visit family in Cresswell I have to stop and get a pizza! I love the staff always friendly. Last time I went there I got to use the drive-thru and it was a easy experience to getting my pizza and going on about my day. Plus they give you the right amount of condiments when asked. read more

Pizza crust perfection Now - greet your patrons, introduce your business - tell them how your ordering process works and smile like you're enjoying what you do ! Then and only then will you get the 5 stars you easily could be getting ! I say again - about the best damn crust anywhere! read more

The crust and sauce are incredibly bland! They put zero toppings. One piece of sausage on each piece. The bell peppers are cut ridiculously large. What a disappointment. I first ate there in July and it was decent. Now, it's I edible even when I doctor it up at home. read more

A place that I am missing to the freakin max! I called in an order for a Small Bull Dog Special and it was waiting for me when I got there 25 minutes later. It was amazing to me that the waitress who waited on me did not have any idea what I was talking about when I asked her if they could fill my growler. She spoke with a Southern accent and said she wasn't from here. I was flabbergasted! This is no reason whatsoever to knock the restaurant at all. I just thought it was incredibly amusing that wherever that girl is from does not have any idea what a growler might be. To make a long story short. My Boys Pizza took care of me and I am still giggling about the girl who never heard of a growler... ;) read more

Ordered delivery. 2 hours later called and asked where my pizza was, told driver "gave up" because they were frustrated. Told I could come get it. This is what I got after driving in, also did not get any of the sauces or dips I requested. read more

My Boys Pizza - Their idea of Taco Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Creswell, Oregon

Good pizza and fast friendly service. They are a bit pricey which is why I gave them 4 stars. I would definitely go back.

Came here with a large group kids and adults it was a great atmosphere for everyone, the pizza was great!

My family and I love this place.Clean+fun play area for the kids. Great pizza and calzones. Actually, it is the best pizza I have tried since moving to in the Eugene/Springfield area. I highly recommend My Boys over any pizza place in Eugene. Worth the 20 min drive! read more

Great place for birthday paries. They no longer have Oregon Lottery which I think is awesome. Instead that room is available for reservations at no charge. The play area could use some updating in my opinion, but the kids seem to love it. I feel like since they changed ownership and are now My Boys (instead of Mr. Machos) there has been positive changes. The pizza is delicious upon order, but not so hot as leftovers the next day. The staff has all been very friendly. read more

If you like thick cardboard crust and tasteless sauce and toppings then this is the pizza of your dreams. Schwan's is better pizza than this ridiculously overpriced crap. Better you should go here for the sweet potato fries. They are excellent. read more

Not a bad pizza. A bit pricey but still good pizza. Friendly staff and relatively fast. Much better than the chain pizza places. All the ingredients tasted fresh and flavorful. read more

Pizza is just okay that being said is way overpriced! We go there for their salad bar which is pretty good if we really want to pay that much for pizza there's much better options read more