They have new staff and the rotten apple is no longer there. This is without question the best pizza out of Hingham. Nothing else in the area compares and I've tried everything. Perfect thin crust and just the right amount of sauce and toppings. They don't over load it and the flavor is always on point. Super friendly staff as well. They're always busy but they do a great job. OH and their calzones are just as good if not better. read more

On my delivery order, they removed the Greek salad from my order and just sent a note stating, they didn't have it so they will refund the money. It would it been great to get a call and it would be an easy replacement. Now my vegetarian guess has nothing to eat... :( read more

All very good. I would really say 4.5, but I can't do half stars. Nice service. Efficient. Really nice-sized pie. Good value. read more

See all

Hands down the best pizza in the south shore area. Between the flavor and the texture all around amazing. read more

Peel Pizza - Truffle Shuffle Signature White Pie - Pizza Near Me - Hingham, Massachusetts

Would leave zero stars if possible! Got takeout. Completely wrong toppings on pizza and calzone wasn't cooked. Called for a refund and staff and manager were completely incapable of processing. read more

Peel is our go-to Hingham pizza. Always delicious, we love the thin crust and the sauce is perfect. Highly recommended!

Going to down grade from a 3.0 to a 2.5 Reason, they seem to be failing with on line order "special instructions" Example, I always order wings extra crispy, last 2x they are no where close, NOT crispy, done, but barely. Suggestions, add a thicker crust pizza , I get your NY style, but they are getting so cracker thin, I don't enjoy as much. Looking forward to Red Sky reopening Wings... Read special instructions or just don't offer a comment section. Back to Burtons for Memphis dry rub/ crispy for me. :-(. :-( read more

How do you forget a topping on a Margherita pizza, which only has the THREE? One might argue it's the most crucial of the three. I mean for instance, they dedicate a whole subsection of their menu to tomato sauce-less pies, but never do they forget the cheese. Except on mine :( This might have less to do with them and more to do with delivery -- but it wasn't hot when it arrived and the crust/dough had hardened to the point of assaulting my gums read more

Peel Pizza - They forgot the mozzarella on the Classic Margherita Signature Red Pie - Pizza Near Me - Hingham, Massachusetts

Ordered through door dash and was beyond disappointed. Pizza came burnt, not crisp, not charred with seasoning from a brick oven, it was burnt. It was burst no bad it was so hard to chew I hurt my teeth. On top of the the top of the pizza was undercooked somehow. To add to this disaster, I asked for a white pizza in my instructions and they sent one with red sauce which did not at all work with the toppings I asked for. Gross! Ordered wings and got a box full of flats. Sending blend had potential but was screaming for salt. Maybe try brining the wings or something to add salt if you don't want to improve your blend. But seriously, what's up with the only flats? Is that normal? I happen to like a mix and like drums. Overall we were super disappointed in a place with a good reputation. Maybe it's because we did DoorDash and they didn't care... just sad. read more

Staff is incredibly rude. I called at 8pm on Saturday July 23rd and the high school girl at the counter just hung up on my 3x. The close at 830pm. I drop down and got there at 810pm. She told me they don't accept orders -- however I have frequented Peel for 15 years and the guys who used to be there always took orders with 20-30 minutes before close. Even if it is a new policy -- hanging up on customers is rude. I found a new spot - done with this joint. I suggest others do the same. read more

This is the 3rd time we've tried Peel and the 3rd time I've said "this pizza has no taste". I really want to love it because I love the crispy crust. This time - Got a pineapple jalapeño pie and honestly it tasted like a plain cheese slice . The buffalo chicken was a little tastier but not amazing. Unfortunately won't likely be back. read more

We came here for dinner last night after an event at the South Shore Model Railway Club since the event organizers suggested to come here for dinner. I'm so glad we did! This little shop is right in town center so parking is tight on a Friday night. It's mainly a take out place, , but they do have about 6 tables and a counter space with about 3 chairs on each side of the door. We dined in. It was sooo worth the 20 something minute wait. It's now my favorite pizza place in Mass and I'm so sad we are so far away. The pizza crust (and garlic cheese stick crust) is VERY thin, but the cheese and sauce is very flavorful! I admit the seasoning on it wasn't 5 year old grumpy tired kid approved , but I think his tiredness might have been a factor. If he won't eat it, we have leftovers, and it's then more for us ! I'm normally not a leftover pizza fan. I don't usually look forward to reheating pizza. But there's something about this that tells me I'll like this pizza fresh , nuked, or cold. I ate a few slices of the garlic cheese sticks for breakfast and it was a great start to my day! Take out tip: the door opens inward on the inside , do if you are ordering a lot of food, bring someone with you to open the door :) Don't know when we will be back in Hingham but I'll be recommending to my friends in the area. read more

Great picture, huge selection, and a little pricey, but the pies are enormous. Highly recommend this if you want a healthy pizza read more

Tried this place AGAIN after two years and bad decision on my part. It was worse than the first time around. The cheese was rubber and it was the greasiest pizza I've ever had. Really disappointed. Will not go again. read more

Peel Pizza - Bad pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hingham, Massachusetts

This pizza was delicious! Love the thin crispy crush and fresh tomatoes! I was late to the party and slices were cold.....can't wait to get this with my family one of these nights! read more

A family favorite ! Friendly staff and timely service albeit a little overpriced in my opinion. My kids love it so even if they increase the prices I'll still have to order it every Friday... Peel has done a great job maintaining service and quality throughout the pandemic and is a great local buisness - please support them if you can ! read more

Delicious! Last minute (prior to closing) order. Still amazing pizza and friendly staff.

Hands down best pizza! Gluten free fabulous, truffle shuffle is a favorite. Everyone we have introduced has been blown away. read more

i cant speak on some of the bad reviews but my pizza was cooked perfectly crispy thin and tasted unreal. ate the whole thing.. picked up at 8pm and the staff was friendly. would return ! read more

Peel Pizza - Touchdown Signature Red Pie - Pizza Near Me - Hingham, Massachusetts

Pizza is delicious the crust is thin and ingredients are fresh. Just check your box when picking up your order to be sure you're getting the right one. read more

The wings are next level, folks! Pizza was very good, but the wings are what will keep me coming back. I look forward to exploring the menu. read more

Peel Pizza - White Lite Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hingham, Massachusetts

See all

The pizza was good unfortunately the driver left it outside the door never contacted me by the time I got it it was cold.

Great pizza, horrible business and never get it delivered. They will inevitably deliver to the wrong address or just not at all and then deliver stone cold an hour late. I wish they weren't such a mess. read more

Place was great. I prefer a thicker crust, and this is super thin, but still had a good crunch and great flavor. Great selection, I opted for the Arrabiata with parm cheese and no motz. Really, really good. The wings were also great. They serve them plain so they can crisp them up nicely and it works well. read more

Worst customer service, even though pizza is good. We called at 7:25 pm (they close at 8) and no one picked up the phone. We were close, so arrived at 7:32 to place an order in person. They were wrapped up for the night. Cleaned up and done. We counted on picking up food on the way home from a meeting that ended at 7:20. If you say you're open until 8, be open until 8. If you're going stop taking orders at 7:30, then say so. read more

Pizza and sides are unreal. Always a good bet. But, just wondering if it's a prerequisite to be grumpy to work for this company? read more

Don't be on GrubHub if you are not going to check your GrubHub orders. Your restaurant completely ignored an order that I placed and then gave me big time attitude when I came in to pick up what the app told me was a pizza tready for me and my family. Update: Brendan from Peel reached out to address the issue and helped rectify it by offering to buy us some pizza the following week. He came through and we enjoyed our meal as always. read more

Our favorite pizza ev-ah! If they were in locations closer to us, we would eat there all the time. Definitely worth the drive, though. Even our picky kid who doesn't normally eat pizza likes it - and their chicken wings too! Love that they are baked, not fried. So good! read more

Please update your hours. If you stop taking orders way before closing just change the posted schedule.

Tried this place recently, the pizza was really good, thin crust, toppings distributed evenly and in good portions. The wings left much to be desired, very basic, not seasoned at all and very pricey. The floor, tables were dirty, and the staff was not very friendly overall disappointing experience. read more

Service is the worst! I thought the guy on the phone was really rude and then my son said he was really rude when he went in there. What the hell is their problem in there? After reading all the bad reviews about them you would think that they would change their employees. Please change your employees or leave Hingham ty. read more

Excellent taste, GENEROUS portions and amazing menu selection too go with the fast and friendly service.

They keep getting orders wrong, and no one is there when you call to rectify the problem. Honestly, it's great pizza as long as you're ok with getting a completely wrong order. read more

Great pizza! Thin crust just how I like it, toppings, sauce and cheese is on point. I also had their wings and they were fantastic. Oven baked so not greasy! As long as they keep using quality ingredients ill keep coming back! read more

Waited 2 hour 20 minutes for order. Called three times to check status. Each time was told the delivery was on their way and they were really busy. Upon third call and explaining I've been told it's on it's way got annoyed teenaged girl response. CUSTOMER SERVICE FAIL. Two-and-a-half hour old cold pizza not worth the wait nor the 16 year-old snark. UPDATE: After receiving an apology and offer for free food from the company, we have dared to try again... We are now on to 1 hr 45 min with no food... On a Tuesday evening... Not a prime night. read more

One star for this place. Not only are they rude when you place an order but also condescending. Guess they don't need the business? Love the pizza but not enough to spend my money at this local place. read more

This place is by far the best pizza I have had since I've moved to the area. And one of the best pizzas I've had in years. I prefer a thin crust, so that I am not full after one slice and I get to taste and enjoy the toppings, instead of tasting bread. I've tried a new one each time I've ordered and have love everyone of them. The owner is very attentive to his customers and to the quality of food he offers. I find them to be very consistent. The employees are also very polite and professional. I will continue to be a regular. read more

Grabbed 6 large pizzas for one of my customers that I had ordered the day before..... They were cooked and ready when I showed up. Tried a few different kinds, all were unbelievably good. It's thin crust Italian style, which is hard to find around the area. They're not giving them away, but well worth it. I will definitely go back soon. read more

The food was excellent; this review score is due to the Grub hub delivery. After waiting 90 minutes for this delivery, we were told the delay was due to a wait for delivery pickup. Of course, we provided a 15% gratuity to our driver in advance, on a credit card to aid contactless delivery; but wound up picking the order up ourselves. Our Grub-hub gratuity was not returned, despite the fact that the delivery service was not provided. Peel is excellent; Grub hub made money off us, without providing us any service. Our recommendation is to order from Peel, but order takeout. read more

The pizza here is among the best on the south shore. Great slices. Have not tried anything beyond the pizza but the menu looks good.