Only Italian we could find in Moab. That said, we were pleasantly surprised - food was really good. Service from Nick was spot on - he shakes a mean martini!! Lots of locals with their families on Saturday night, always a good sign in a tourist town. I had the Stuffed Chicken Genovese, she had the Tortellone Bellettini - both were excellent. Ceasar salad to start we good, but not great. No room for dessert - we will definitely be back on the next Moab trip. read more

Pasta - cardboard Sauce - bland Sausage - no flavor Meat sauce - ??? Boring food in a diner environment. read more

Extremely limited vegetarian options, particularly for an Italian restaurant. The marinara sauce is not vegetarian and many of the options including salads that you would assume are vegetarian are not. There is a separate vegetarian menu but the only sauce options are olive oil or Alfredo. They don't tell you it's not vegetarian unless you ask. The food is mediocre. The gnocchi catalina is a Gorgonzola based dish but tastes more like alfredo sauce. To top it off the gnocchi was overcooked. Moab has plenty of better vegetarian options than pasta jays. read more

Food was amazing. Service was really good. Table was smaller for the 4 of us. Sangria was yummy. Inside Has that Italian feel. Definitely a must go to place. read more

Pasta Jay's - The Hagan Option - Italian Near Me - Moab, Utah

See all

The pasta dishes were delicious! We are from NY/Jersey so we have pretty high standards for pasta/pizza and pasta jays didn't miss. The staff were super friendly and tentative. Best pasta in Moab!!!!!! read more

Pasta Jay's - baked Rigatoni with meat sauce - Italian Near Me - Moab, Utah

See all

Best Restaurant in Moab! The food was so delicious. You will not go wrong with anything you order. The food is piping hot and the marinara sauce has so much flavor. The shells were my favorite out of everything! Come enjoy some Pasta after you are done hiking! read more

See all

Small town Italian eateries can be a gamble, but Pasta Jay's is a surefire winner. After a day exploring Canyonlands, this spot was fire! Exceptional service paired with mouthwatering dishes made for a memorable dining experience. The baked spaghetti was piping hot and generously portioned, and the medium margarita pizza was perfect size and crispy AF! Make sure to treat yourself and give this restaurant a try next time you're in Moab. read more

Pasta Jay's - Marg pizza - was perfect! Great sauce. - Italian Near Me - Moab, Utah

See all

The gnocchi was pretty good, however, some were hard. The garlic bread was pretty good. Not a bad wait time. Would come back.

I thought the service was very good! The eggplant parm is not made the traditional way. Not worth the $18. Three small Japanese eggplant size sliced pieces. The marinara sauce was very good! The garlic bread is pretty greasy. read more

Pasta Jays is better than some of the big time Italian chains back in Denver. This is the second time my work crew and I come here for the food and service. We arrived on a Monday evening. 5 people, got sat down right away with no reservation. Our waitress was great, thank you so much Carmen. The ambiance of this place is cute and charming. Don't come here if you're gonna complain about the decor. 5 of 5. Go get you some pasta dude!! read more

Based on our experience, if you're looking for customer service, you won't find it at Pasta Jay's in Moab. This is because the poor customer service we encountered started from the top in the manager, Thania Carrillo. Driving in from out of town, we called in an order for two take out pasta dishes. This was our FIRST time ordering from Pasta Jay's. When I arrived for pick up, and after I paid, I noticed two container charges on the bill (I've never seen such a charge at any other restaurant). I politely asked for them to be removed, since the person we ordered from never mentioned there was a container charge for takeout, even though we discussed the order price on the phone. The cashier asked the manager, Thania to come over, and she stridently said she "can't" remove the container charge. Of course, she "can" remove it, she just chose not to. So I said as much. Then she said the container charge was on the menu (which we didn't use since we ordered over the phone) and on the website. When I checked both later after I got home (https://www.pastajays.com/moab/), I searched for "container" and didn't find it listed in either place. I suggested to Thania that the best course would be to remove it this time, for customer good will purposes, and then we would know next time. She refused to consider this, even if it meant she would lose us as a customer and we wouldn't return, which tells you all you need to know about Pasta Jay's poor customer service approach. Later, I asked to speak with the owner, but the manager, Thania, refused to provide his contact information as well. Since I don't want to take the time to hunt down the owner, I decided to share our experience with others in this review. I notice the restaurant has only a 3.8 rating, which suggests that when customer service is lacking, so are other important qualities most good restaurants have. I hope this is helpful. read more

Delicious food! Had the tortellone alfredo with chicken and spinach dip! Both great! Clean, cute atmosphere. read more

Pasta Jay's - Italian Near Me - Moab, Utah

I was visiting Moab last week. The restaurant was recommended and next door to my hotel. Ambience is casual, pleasant polite service from a Mexican American young man (sorry.. I forgot your name!). I had the eggplant parmigiana which was served hot and delicious! Dinner came with pasta, a tasty/tangy marinara and garlic bread. They also serve pizza. I highly recommend. read more

In last 5 days that we have been in Utah this was so far the best food we had. The portion was good for two of us for lunch. They where quick and on time service. read more

My baked ravioli was good and my husband said his pizza was good as well, but nothing special or delicious The service was extremely slow, long waits for everything, no follow up or drink refills. It was hot and we were thirsty! Staff members kept gathering around the bar, talking and just hanging out. Finally, it was hot so we ate inside for the air conditioning; which wasn't working. A very disappointing experience. read more

I didn't really care for pasta Jay 's, it kind of reminded me of a pizza you would get at a gas station. I gave it a five star review because the service was good and they have other things on the menu and who the hell am I to judge this place and give them a bad review far up. I personally wouldn't go back but it wasn't so bad that I don't want you to go and try it so go give it a try and write your own review. Next time I'm in town I'll try a Different Pizza Place, maybe even Pizza Hut because I gotta be honest with you, we tried two different pizza places two different Mexican restaurants and they all sucked. Remember, nobody pizzas hut !! read more

Pasta Jay's - Italian Near Me - Moab, Utah

The pasta is delicious. Huge portions. We split our dish. The waiter was very friendly and helpful. He even had an Italian accent. Nice and cozy. read more

See all

We had a great dinner and great service by Carmen on 5/6, so we were back for dinner on 5/7. Sorry to say, the service was really bad. Our waiter took our order, then disappeared. I had to get up from our table and ask if we were going to get our dinner. The manager finally showed up with dinner and apologized for reassigning our waiter to a large group that had shown up. We had no service after that, even had to find someone to bring us our check. I delivered my disappointment to the manager, her response was very neutral. We loved the food, but the service was terrible. read more

The pizza was paper thin and it cost us over $80 for 3 large pizzas and a salad. Incredibly expensive and 2 people in our party got sick after eating it. I don't recommend the pizza. read more

My husband and I LOVE pasta Jays! We've been to both locations (Boulder & Moab) and both locations are great. The decor is the same, very traditional Italian themed. I would always recommend doing family style. I love eating small bites of different dishes so whenever my husband and I go we usually do an app, salad, and pizza. Portions can feed up to two people. All the times we've been there, we haven't had an issue with the staff. They're always so accommodating and sincere. The only part that sucks is if you don't have a reservation and have to wait but that's just because their food is so damn good. read more

Good, but not great Italian food.service was good. The garlic bread could have had more garlic on it.

Thank you for having a gluten free option. They even made me a gluten free flatbread. Pasta Jay's is our fabricate and recently diagnosed with gluten and dairy allergies I was so bummed. But they made me an amazing dish! It was so good! Thank you for these options!! read more

Pasta Jay's - Italian Near Me - Moab, Utah

Great food and ambiance, really liked the Hagan combo dish - I had the big shells, gnocchi, and Eggplant Parmesan - they were all very good.

We recently had dinner at Pasta Jay's on a Saturday evening. The restaurant is located on a corner in front of the Best Western Canyonlands. We arrived around 6 pm and were seated promptly, outdoors as we requested. It took awhile before drink orders were taken, but once service began everything moved like clockwork. Our waiter, Jethro, was very helpful and personable. We ordered a Caesar salad and a 14" Jay's Roman Orgy Pizza to share. The salad was fresh and good, and the pizza wonderful. The very thin crust was excellent, as was the combination of sauce and toppings. It was more than enough food for the 2 of us, so a couple of pieces went home in a box. The selection of pasta entrees was excellent, and we saw plenty of options for other visits. My only complaint was that the draft beer selection was very limited. All in all, Pasta Jay's was a great dinner choice. read more

Pasta Jay's - 14" Jay's Roman Orgy pizza. Yum! - Italian Near Me - Moab, Utah

See all

If you are in Moab you've probably been out exploring and burning calories all day, what better time for a carb overload! That's why we chose Pasta Jays for dinner. It was a Friday night but we arrived at 4 hoping to beat the rush. We were seated quickly. We ordered our drinks and an app. They didn't get our app correct, but brought out the correct item pretty quickly! We were disappointed in the service for the rest of the night. No one checked up on us after our food was brought. We would have LOVED to spend more money on a couple of more drinks but no such luck. The food was average but sufficed. I had the Hagen option. You choose 3 different pastas. The problem was they all taste the same. The ambience is fine. It's a big open area great for kids because it's loud. We will try a different Italian place next time. read more

Pasta Jay's - Hagen option - Italian Near Me - Moab, Utah

I tried Pasta Jay's on a Wednesday night, and despite the city being very busy, our party of 5 was seated immediately. The restaurant was very busy and we were given water immediately. After a few minutes, our waiter arrived and took our drink orders, and since we were ready to order, we also ordered our food. It took about 10 minutes for drinks and 20 minutes for food. I had a Coke to drink and it was flat (in fairness I did not say anything to the waiter about it). I ordered the 10 inch make your own pizza with pepperoni, ground beef, sausage, and mushrooms, all "classic" toppings. It only is 1 dollar per standard topping, but if you want specialty toppings, it costs 3-5 dollars to add it to the 10 inch pizza, which seems like a lot of money (to me at least). The pizza itself had a crispy crust, and there were a good amount of toppings on the pizza. The sauce was also pretty good and there was a good amount of it. Other people in my party ordered items with pasta and it was slightly undercooked, not inedible though. The waiter was mostly attentive (except for a period of about 15 minutes when he was nowhere to be seen.) Would recommend for someone who is looking for decent Italian food in Moab. read more

Pasta Jay's - Custom Pizza - Italian Near Me - Moab, Utah

We had an amazing experience at Pasta Jay's. From the amazing food to the great service, it was hard not to enjoy!!

DELICIOUS food, amazing service from Omar, and the aesthetic was beautiful with the red rocks within view of the outside seating. Food came out hot and was delicious. My daughter loved her kids meal & the coloring page. Very family friendly! read more

Anything is Pastabowl at Pasta Jay's! I am a big fan of pasta and I love finding a good Italian spot. While exploring Moab for Jeep Safari, it was getting late and I was hoping to stop somewhere for dinner. This place was open later than other places, so I decided to give them a go. Parking is tricky everywhere in Moab, but I am a lucky girl. I was able to park right in front of Pasta Jay's on Main Street. However, be prepared that you may need to find a spot and do a little bit of walking to get there. I was seated immediately, not because they weren't busy, but because this is a massive restaurant. They have all kinds of seating inside and then they also have a covered, sheltered patio for extra seating. The overall atmosphere of the restaurant is...interesting. The lighting is quite dim and it is giving Italian picnic vibes. They had a massive menu, but the Hagan option stood out to me the most. It's like a flight for pasta and I love being able to choose a few different things. I opted for the gnocchi, ravioli, and chicken parm. This seemed similar to a tour of Italy, but I especially loved that I was able to choose, rather than it just already coming with three preselected menu items. For starters, they give you some garlic bread. It's pretty mediocre garlic bread in my opinion. It's not horrible and I did like it, but it is nothing outstanding. The Hagan was okay, but I have had much better. The gnocchi was good. It felt a bit heavy but the sauce over the top of the pasta was good. The ravioli was probably my favorite--it tasted great! The chicken was probably my least favorite out of the meal. It was greasy and just not cooked the best. Still, it was nice to be able to try a few different things from the menu, instead of just one thing. The service was pretty slow. I mean, I know they were busy for Jeep Safari, but there was lots of staff everywhere and I only saw my server twice. I sat at my table for 20 minutes after I was done eating, waiting for someone to make it over to my area. Not a big deal but just a small annoyance. Overall, I did like my visit to Pasta Jays. I think there are a few Italian places I prefer over them, but it's Moab so this is one of few options in the area. They bring a cool vibe and have some decent food. I would consider going back next time I am in Moab! read more

Pasta Jay's is a cute Italian restaurant located off the main street in Moab. After a long day of hiking, I recommend their Alfredo William or their famous jumbo shells. Each table will receive a complementary order of their buttery garlic bread that pairs well with pasta. Seating Outdoor seating is available, but I would only recommend during the warmer months. Indoor seating is limited so I recommend arriving early or splitting your party if you have a big party. Limited high top and low top seating so arrive early to beat the crowd. Best food in Moab! read more

See all

Meh. Never been to an Italian spot with limited vegetarian and vegan items-it's usually a no brainer. This place however added fish to the marinara sauce and chicken broth to the tomato basil. Which then cuts the entire pasta and pizza menu down to a quarter. Outside patio would be nice if not for the gnats buzzing about. Big bill for little flavor. read more

As we walked in, I noticed the portions were big, we decided to share a salad and main entre. They brought out the main entre and when I asked about the salad, the server looked confused. A few minutes later, the waiter came back and said there had been a computer glitch and they were working on the salad. The food wasn't great and I didn't buy the excuse of there being a computer glitch and there were no apologies. read more

For a busy Saturday evening, our group of 9 was sat quickly in the outside patio, which was perfect outside evening temperature; server gave recommendations and great service; food was fresh, hot, and delicious. read more

Perfect place for a satisfying meal after a long day of hiking! We called our order in for pick-up and it was ready at the time promised. I had the Fresh Eggplant Parmigiana which comes with a side of pasta, my husband had the Spaghetti with Mushroom Sauce, both came with garlic bread, and we shared a Dinner Salad. The dinner salad was more than just iceberg lettuce and canned olives as another reviewer stated. It also had onions, pepperoncini peppers, tomatoes, beets, red onions, garbanzo beans, cheese- and it was plenty to share given how generous our dinner portions were! My only complaint would be that we could have used another container of salad dressing on the side. As for our entrees, there was so much food that we had leftovers. All was tasty and filling. The place itself was inviting so it would be nice to come back someday to dine at the restaurant. read more

See all

We spent 4 days in Moab checking out all the state and national parks in the area. We mostly ate fast food but wanted one really good meal before we moved on to Sonora. We chose Pasta Jay's and it was delicious. We had the green chili ravioli and we both absolutely loved it. Never had better Italian food. I wish we had one in Houston! TRY IT! YOU'LL LOVE IT! read more

Best pasta dishes we have ever had in the states. Baking the pasta is a game changer. We were in Moab for a week and visited Pasta Jays 4 times - it was that good. read more

See all

Ate there twice. Had pizza twice. Both times the pizza was less than average in taste. No real flavor other than garlic. No better than fast food. The service was less than average. No refills on beverages, no plates when pizza arrived. read more

Nice food, good atmosphere, the wait staff is attentive, but not intrusive. Good place to have dinner, after a day experiencing the wonders of the Moab national parks.. read more

Let me start by saying we had a nice experience at Pasta Jay's and the food was beyond amazing. We ordered the caprese salad, tortellini Alfredo, with added chicken as well as lobster ravioli. The garlic bread was something else! The problem we encountered several hours after returning to our Airbnb and feeling quite satisfied was that we became ill shortly 4 hours later. I don't just mean upset stomach, I mean full blown sick for hours. We had left the establishment with hopes of returning but now certainly will not. read more

The food is always great. Also the service is always amazing. Always stop here went I go though Moab read more

Pasta Jay's - Great pasta and Baked Spaghetti Marinara - Italian Near Me - Moab, Utah