We walked in after making a reservation and were immediately told that we could not sit all together. This led to us sitting apart from each other and having two different servers. This impacted us later when we had to split the check, and were declined paying together and splitting it among families. The food was ok, nothing to hype over, much better places around, like broken oar. The overall atmosphere was ok, uncomfortable chairs, kinda dirty area, and just not a very welcoming place. Would not recommend coming here. read more

We were a party of 6 and were seated very quickly. The service was good and we received our food very quickly. I had the green chili ravioli, my husband ordered the lobster ravioli and my son got the baked rigatoni. The other family with us go the spaghetti, small pizza (which is very large for a small). The portions were good. The green chili ravioli was very good. The restaurant was very full, but enough room everyone. Atmosphere was good. We would eat here again. read more

We had an awkward and frustrating visit. We were seated and given glasses of water (I'm assuming he was a busser) and then no one ever came back. We waited and waited and even finished the big glasses of water we were given and about 20 mins in still no one acknowledged us. If they were short handed I would totally understand! But there were sooooo many employees! I do not understand how not one approached us as they walked by us multiple times with our menus just sitting on the table waiting for someone to come take our order. I tried making eye contact with them as they went by but it's almost like they were trying to ignore us. It was the weirdest thing! We saw the server go to each table around us multiple times. We literally watched people get their food, eat and finish and yet not one server stoped by to check in and make sure someone had come by. I felt bad for the sweet girl at the host stand. I told her our situation and she kept apologizing. I reminded her that it wasn't her fault and that she really just needed to tell the manager about this. Also we were seated at the high top tables, I believe the sweet girl at the host stand said it was table #17. If I was the manager I would look into who was covering that area and have a little chat. It was very awkward and made us feel uncomfortable to the point of walking out and going somewhere else for dinner. read more

Fantastic pasta and great service. So many pasta dishes to choose from plus pizza pies. A casual dining experience I recommend.

Food was amazing, reasonably priced $15.00 for a big lasagna & garlic bread. Melissa B. Was our server- polite, attentive and knew the menu ingredients. We would definitely go back. read more

Pasta Jay's was a few steps outside our hotel so we headed over for a dinner after hiking. My expectations were low based on the pictures I saw of the food but I have to say it was a good meal overall. We had to wait 10 minutes for outdoor seating but it was worth it. I started with the dinner salad with the creamy Italian dressing. The salad had romaine, a pepper, a beet slice, garbanzo beans and mozzarella cheese. I had them hold the olives. It was very good. For dinner I ordered the eggplant parmigiana. It was good. The eggplant was not heavily breaded but I was okay with that. My husband tried the Shrimp Giacomo. He enjoyed his meal too. Both meals came with garlic bread. We finished with the lemon berry cake which was good although it seemed like it was recently thawed. The service was helpful, although we had two occasions where the assistants didn't know why they were bringing drinks to our table. One time was a mistake. The second time the waitress wanted us to have refills and asked the assistant to bring them but he didn't seem to understand that. Overall, Pasta Jay's is worth a stop after a day of enjoying the parks. read more

See all

So we decided to try this place while visiting more app. The young lady recommended the shelves. She said one of the best the stuff shells along with the chicken, the stuff chicken. Both of those were great selections. I can honestly say I would go. Again if I'm ever in the area. read more

Was able to make a same-day reservation for 11 people, which was awesome! Service was fast. They messed up 1 order and remade it quickly. Spinach salad was very mediocre and wouldn't order gain. Food is pricey, but pasta dishes did taste good. Ordered the cheese ravioli, which was fresh! Overall, good experience. read more

SO good! Was looking forward to this meal while visiting Moab, especially because so much is closed in the winter. It was just as good as we had hoped!! read more

Pasta Jay's - Chicken Alfredo, Garlic Bread with Trio of Sauces for Dipping, The Hagan Option - Italian Near Me - Moab, Utah

We were looking for a pet friendly restaurant and found Pasta Jays. We sat outside on the patio which the weather was amazing and they served us water and even brought a bowl of water for our dog. The waitress was amazing, had the best attitude told us a little about the town and suggested things to do. We ordered a pizza and it was delicious. For dessert we had a slice of the Lemon Berry cake and it was out of this world incrediable! read more

Pasta Jay's is a decent pasta place with lots of options. Went on a Thursday night and it was as pretty busy. Where we were sat it was so small and loud you couldn't hear the other people at your table. On the other side, decently quiet as you headed to the bathroom. One stall was missing a toilet seat, so only one stall for a whole restaurant of women. Just an observation and not a complaint. These things happen. Baked spaghetti could have had more cheese on top but was good. Chicken parm was a little salty but large portion. Side pasta could have had more sauce on top. They offer garlic bread as an appetizer but then we got free garlic bread for the table with our meals. Very tricky and I didn't like that. Wish I would have known and wouldn't have ordered the app. Overall decent meal. Decent, attentive service. If I'm back in Moab, I'd probably go again. read more

See all

First time in Moab, wanted to eat pasta for dinner. Their pasta noto was absolutely delicious. It was just the right amount of food !

Overall great experience, we were seated immediately, server was nice and attentive, we got all our order in time and food was delicious. Recommended read more

We really enjoyed our dinner. I got pasta noto, it was excellent. My friend thought the gluten free pizza, and thought it was the best she's ever had. My husband's regular pizza was also delicious. Carmen was a great server. Very knowledgeable and personable. We would definitely come back here if we were in town again. read more

Came here after a long day of hiking at Arches because this was the only place open past 10pm. We were blown away. The service here is excellent, and the food is just as amazing. I got gnocchi and my parents got a pizza, and we all left feeling happy and full. The atmosphere was perfect, especially out on the patio. Loved this place! Would come back again and recommend to all! read more

This place served delicious food! I wouldn't think there would be good Italian food in this small town of Moab, surrounded by rocks, but I was wrong. We were so hungry that we ordered a lot for just the two of us: minestrone, chicken alfredo, stuffed jumbo shells and tiramisu. Everything was delicious. Their minestrone was well seasoned with big chunks of zucchini. The alfredo was quite heavy and greasy, but if you had a full day of adventure, it's OK to eat more carbs haha. The garlic bread was very buttery and savory as well. And don't forget to finish off your meal with their tiramisu! If we were in the area again, we would definitely go back to try other dishes. read more

Oliver was great. We didn't have to wait long to order, the Caesar salad flatbread was a very good - good garlic dressing on it. Our kids were entertained by the activity menus. We sat outside on a perfect weather evening in Moab. The outside patio is big and there were ton of other families with kids also enjoying dinner. Baked rigatoni and lasagna were both yummy and the kids enjoyed their pastas as well. Thanks! read more

horrible. the service was non existent. took our order brought us the meal and they were gone. the pasta sauce was bitter. the pasta was dry. that antipasta salad was lunch meet 1/2 pieces tossed in a bowl with iceberg lettuce with beets. don't go. simply awful. read more

Only Italian we could find in Moab. That said, we were pleasantly surprised - food was really good. Service from Nick was spot on - he shakes a mean martini!! Lots of locals with their families on Saturday night, always a good sign in a tourist town. I had the Stuffed Chicken Genovese, she had the Tortellone Bellettini - both were excellent. Ceasar salad to start we good, but not great. No room for dessert - we will definitely be back on the next Moab trip. read more

We visited with a party of six and had a wonderful meal--everyone truly enjoyed their food! The patio seating was perfect, especially with the heaters on during the chilly weather we had on our vacation. The atmosphere was warm and inviting. That said, our experience with our server, Nick, left something to be desired. He was pretty sparse with his check-ins during the meal and removed our drink and dessert menus before our food even arrived. Then, without asking if we were finished or needed anything else, he brought the check. When we politely asked to have it split three ways, he responded with a sarcastic tone, saying something along the lines of "It would've been nice to know that earlier," which felt unnecessarily snarky. A little heads-up from him would've gone a long way--we would've been happy to let him know our preferences if he had just asked. To be honest, it felt like he was eager to rush us out the door, which put a bit of a damper on an otherwise great evening. So just a tip: let your server know upfront how you'd like to split the bill. Overall, the food and setting were fantastic, but the customer service could use some improvement read more

Wife & I are on a cross country road trip and while passing through Moab, we checked into our hotel and wanted to grab some takeout to eat at hotel. I called Pasta Jay's and the person who answered was very helpful, polite & friendly. My order was ready quickly and once I got back to hotel, the meals we ordered were delicious and if we were in town longer, we'd definitely go inside and eat in the restaurant. Only reason I'm giving 4 stars and not 5 is because we can't speak to the service inside. We strongly recommend this restaurant to anyone looking for some good Italian food options. read more

We went twice while in Moab. The first time he had baked rigatoni and I had eggplant parmigiana. The marinara sauce is to die for! The second time we went he had chicken Alfredo and I had chicken ravioli. The chicken for both of us was a little odd. In the ravioli it was just large chunks of boiled chicken with no seasoning. We had a group of six and they automatically added a service charge of greater than 30%. The service is very quick. It's a loud, crowded restaurant and anything with marinara is amazing. read more

If you're looking for a great pasta joint, look elsewhere. The service at this restaurant is slow even when not busy. You might also be seated at a table (outside) where the nearby crossing signal constantly beeps. You might also have the leaves from nearby plants blowing into your food. And about the food...it's bland, almost like they're afraid to use any type of spice. Even the garlic bread they serve is bland, like they forgot to add the garlic. But here's the thing...after a long day of hiking, you'll probably eat everything on your plate because you're that hungry. And the water in Moab is good. read more

The food was really great. The combo also tasted pretty good. The gnocchi was a bit too chewy and the sauce was not too complementing goving the entirity a really thick taste. The thick taste made me very thirsty and the waiter only refilled at the end. The waiter was nice though. It looked pretty good though. The setting of the place was very nice although right next to a busy main road. I would recommend to come here, but not my favorite. read more

Pasta Jay's - Pasta gnocchi pesto - Italian Near Me - Moab, Utah

My wife got chicken parm and it was very good. I ordered the special which was vodka bolognese sauce and pasta. It was good. Caesar salad was good and the large is plenty for two people. Garlic bread was just standard, nothing spectacular.Definitely would go here again! Service here was excellent! read more

The food was good. The fettuccine noodles were too firm for me, the garlic bread was delicious. Husband had the pepperoni pizza and said it was good too. Thin crust. read more

Best Restaurant in Moab! The food was so delicious. You will not go wrong with anything you order. The food is piping hot and the marinara sauce has so much flavor. The shells were my favorite out of everything! Come enjoy some Pasta after you are done hiking! read more

See all

I ordered the 26 dollar Alfredo.. fine food, child's portions. My little sister (10) received more food ordering off the kids menu. Waitress was spacey, unfortunately she didn't give her name so can't name her here. Incredibly forgetful and would disappear for 20 minutes at a time. Was never offered a refill. Again, the food tasted fine, nothing to write home about but left hungry and disappointed. read more

Amazing food! The baked Alonzo had amazing sauce and was a super hit! It was the perfect filling meal after a long day trekking around Moab.

Pasta - cardboard Sauce - bland Sausage - no flavor Meat sauce - ??? Boring food in a diner environment. read more

It was Valentine's Day and they were super busy but we were seated within 15 minutes and the service and food were amazing!

Small town Italian eateries can be a gamble, but Pasta Jay's is a surefire winner. After a day exploring Canyonlands, this spot was fire! Exceptional service paired with mouthwatering dishes made for a memorable dining experience. The baked spaghetti was piping hot and generously portioned, and the medium margarita pizza was perfect size and crispy AF! Make sure to treat yourself and give this restaurant a try next time you're in Moab. read more

Pasta Jay's - Marg pizza - was perfect! Great sauce. - Italian Near Me - Moab, Utah

See all

We were here for spring break and came for dinner. We enjoyed the food. Large portions, attentive service. We sat on the patio - it wasn't too hot yet! read more

Great food. The sauce was amazing. We arrived later in the evening and the staff was likely ready to go home after a long day of serving tourists. The staff was kind and attentive. You felt like you were walking into an Italian kitchen with red and white checkered table cloths and clean bathroom. Great spot to eat after after hiking or walking around town. Would eat here again. read more

I didn't really care for pasta Jay 's, it kind of reminded me of a pizza you would get at a gas station. I gave it a five star review because the service was good and they have other things on the menu and who the hell am I to judge this place and give them a bad review far up. I personally wouldn't go back but it wasn't so bad that I don't want you to go and try it so go give it a try and write your own review. Next time I'm in town I'll try a Different Pizza Place, maybe even Pizza Hut because I gotta be honest with you, we tried two different pizza places two different Mexican restaurants and they all sucked. Remember, nobody pizzas hut !! read more

Pasta Jay's - Italian Near Me - Moab, Utah

Watched the wait staff trying to set a table and drop all the silverware onto the floor. Picked it up from under the table and used it to set the table for the next unsuspecting guests. Thankfully we hadn't ordered yet and left and will never come back. Nasty! read more

Ambiance and service was good. Garlic bread and salad were good. Pizza was thin, burnt and did not like pizza sauce.

The pasta dishes were delicious! We are from NY/Jersey so we have pretty high standards for pasta/pizza and pasta jays didn't miss. The staff were super friendly and tentative. Best pasta in Moab!!!!!! read more

Pasta Jay's - baked Rigatoni with meat sauce - Italian Near Me - Moab, Utah

See all

The pasta is delicious. Huge portions. We split our dish. The waiter was very friendly and helpful. He even had an Italian accent. Nice and cozy. read more

See all

Extremely limited vegetarian options, particularly for an Italian restaurant. The marinara sauce is not vegetarian and many of the options including salads that you would assume are vegetarian are not. There is a separate vegetarian menu but the only sauce options are olive oil or Alfredo. They don't tell you it's not vegetarian unless you ask. The food is mediocre. The gnocchi catalina is a Gorgonzola based dish but tastes more like alfredo sauce. To top it off the gnocchi was overcooked. Moab has plenty of better vegetarian options than pasta jays. read more