My biggest beef with Papa Murphy's in the past has been their crust. Unlike some other reviewers I feel it's too soft and spongy, especially to be used the next day as leftovers. But, I'll admit it's been years since we've been there until the night before I wrote this review. We called ours in ahead of time and it was ready when I got there. We wanted to put it on our own metal pizza tray when we got home but it seemed kinda stuck on the cardboard one they provided. We just put the pizza, tray and all, on our metal pizza tray and it worked fine. Pizza was ok. Dough seemed a bit more solid than years before, but I'm still not sure it would be good for eating the next day. I also didn't feel as full as I'd normally feel after eating that much. Good enough, though. We'll likely be trying them again next time we're both too tired to hassle with dinner as Papa Murphy's is just a few blocks from us, thus pretty convenient and inexpensive. read more

i will not buy another pizza from Papa Murphy's because they are to expenses for $25.00 for a family size and have to bring it home to bake it. read more

We would order Papa Murphy's probably once every other month and we loved it we also love babes and we have tried Mountain Mike's in Eureka. I have to say Papa Murphy's is the worst pizza I have had out of the three we ordered a stuffed combination pizza which consisted of mostly pizza sauce cheese and bread absolutely no meat no onion no bell pepper horrible horrible horrible. Mountain Mike's is $20 more for the same size pizza but is a loaded with meat and veggies and it is the most delicious pizza ever pay the extra money. don't order pizza where you get sauce cheese and bread yucky. Stay away from Papa Murphys read more

I have had it with this pizza place. 2nd time I went to get my pizza that was ordered 50 minutes prior to my showing up. workers standing around, pie wasnt ready AGAIN, no one else in shop. What the fu-k is the problem with management, it seems like they dont give a crap about being on time at all, and the crew certainly doesnt give a crap either. I passed on the pie and cookie dough, and there are more pizza places in Eureka, so I will be doing business elsewhere from now on. Extremely crappy attitude and service and I have not seen a positive report for them on any website. read more

Extra slow, took almost 2 hours for order to be ready, crust was tough, hardly any sauce on .bottom. All the while the manager was on his phone, not helping prep, threw some dough in machine then plopped it on tray.. read more

This place is garbage. I'm sick and tired of placing my orders over an hour in advance, only to show up and discover that they never even bothered to start work on it. Now you have to PAY IN ADVANCE online, which means you're already out however much money, but they also can't refund your order so you're just boned. You clowns got too many second chances, and I'm done with you. read more

My wife and I were looking for something different for dinner. We decided it was time to try Papa Murphy's. I placed my order online and that was a breeze. I was told to pick up my order about a half hour later. When I get there the place is empty except for two workers. They ask if I want the specials and I tell them I ordered on line. The lady took her time and looked around then found my ticket and said it's not done yet it will be a few minutes. No real customer service or apology maybe an explanation. Why give me a time to pick up if it's not ready. Also with no cooking involved you would think 30 minutes was long enough. The guy making pizzas was left to do it all while the coworker looked like to me could have given a hand. Pizza was just ok really. That could have been my fault by letting it brown a little to long. It a one and done for Papa. read more

Apparently Papa Murphys changed the dough recipe and huge bubbles form on pizza when it's baking, I went into restaurant and they did give me another pizza however similar bubbles popped up on that one too. read more

Papa Murphy's - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Eureka, California

See all

I ordered a Family Style, thin crust, with extra sauce, onions, green pepper, pepperoni, ground beef and italian sausage. I did this over the web. I was promised that it would be ready to pick up in 20 minutes. Well, I arrived 30 minutes later. It wasn't done and I had to wait an additional 15 minutes. Ok, no worries. The girl called my name and I picked up the pizza, which was covered in pepperoni. Maybe everything else was buried? Got it home, put it in the oven. Took it out after the ascribed time. It wasn't what we ordered. There were no veggies at all. There was no sausage or ground beef. The sauce was spare, AND it was a regular crust. If this had been the first time this has happened, that would be one thing. I've learned my lesson: don't order from Papa Murphy. Never again. read more

Waste of time an hour wait. Ran out of Canadian bacon so was unable to get the salad I paid for online. Couldn't refund back on to my card they refunded cash. Won't be back. Horrible customer service. read more

I called in an order at 5 o'clock I was told it would be ready and 30 to 45 minutes I'll showed up an hour after I called it in and I ended up sitting there for another hour other hour while they worked worked on the pizza supposedly the entire time I was there They need to give either accurate time that they're gonna be done or they need to get more organized because the organization in there was ridiculous they had people coming in and they would start their orders as they came in instead of in the order they received them which is what they told somebody else as I was leaving which was funny I doubt I'll be going back read more

Not only called in an order at 5 pm and not picking up until 6:30 pm. They did not have the pizza ready and started to make the pizza after arrival and then tried to just give one instead of both that was ordered. And over charged for the special, it should have been 11.99 and was charged 19.00. Want a refund. read more

Wish I could give zero. We have been sitting a waiting for 45 minutes for them to make us cheesy bread. Which now they are saying they don't have any. No one said anything. Just saw us waiting. So mad. read more

This place is a absolute joke! They don't even cook the pizza and they say it will take 40 minutes then you go in and wait another 20 minutes for a uncooked pizza. This place needs to get it together!!! read more

Came in to pick up an order pickup time 7:09pm. & only for one pizza !! I went to the front desk to get my order Evan (employee) was pretty rude & told me it'd be another 15 minutes before they start on it. As other are walking in and other employees are moving there orders up in line, 5 people have came and gone. The staff in today were quite rude and couldn't handle the rush. My pizza wasn't started until 7:30pm. Not coming back at this rate. read more

This place is a fucking joke. Half the time when I show up, the pizza I ordered isn't even started. Sometimes I call and they put me on hold forever and then hang up. This last time (THE last time) the employees were screwing around and laughing and basically playing grabass right there in the store, with me on the phone listening while they goof around. After a few minutes of this, I just gave up and went to Safeway. Fuck you guys. You suck. read more

Ordered online and it said a 35 minut wait. It took an hour, its only a mile and a half from my residence. And then they forgot the marinara for my cheese cheese bread when I ordered multiple. read more

The pizzas are exactly what you would want from a take and bake pizza. We have no problems with the pizza but since there are other choices available for take and bake, I would expect good customer service. My husband looks forward to his cheese pizzas every Tuesday when their ad says "$10 Tuesday - any large pizza for $10." He has been getting pizza at this location for the past year, faithfully every Tuesday. He sometimes orders pepperoni or sausage or bacon, never anything more complicated. Today he was told the bacon was an extra topping and he had to pay 50 cents more. He couldn't get a straight answer as to why ANY LARGE PIZZA FOR $10 was suddenly $10.50. Should we call it a bacon pizza? Should we call it an all meat pizza-hold the pepperoni, sausage, salami? He questioned the assistant manager about the change and was told bacon was an extra topping. The $10 Tuesday was only one topping pizzas. (Now mind you, we have been getting $10 pizzas happily with no problems for quite some time) He was told the first topping is the cheese. Following this logic, the only one-topping pizza they make is a cheese pizza. This, at its core, is false advertising. I will pay more for my pizza at an honest establishment. read more

Crust is REALLY good.... sauce is ehhhhh but you sure cant beat the price thats for dang sure Oh and don't forget to grab a tub'o cookie dough!!! read more

Great take and bake in a hurry. Always good deals and I like the salads also. You know what you get and its a good value for the price read more

See all

Always good pizza but I don't understand how 6 people can have an output of 1 pizza every 5 minutes. The most innefficient pizza restaurant I e ever been to. read more

I am so done with this place. They need to get their shit together. I called in an order at 4:30 and they said 35 minutes. It is now 5:30 and I'm still waiting. read more

We go to papa Murphy's often because it's close to home and inexpensive. The pizza is pretty good. They always take forever to make your pizza and they don't even cook them. The staff is normally really nice but the last time I called, one female employee was rude and short. I asked to hear the specials, she delivered a long sigh through the phone, asked me to hold on for a second, then came back and never told me the specials. She didn't say thank you, have a good night, anything. She just hung up once I said "that will be all" I like this place enough to eat here. But my favorite pizza is the Chicago stuffed pizza and the last time I ordered it, it was so thin and not very stuffed. I was disappointed for the first time. I hope that was just one mistake. read more

I had a serious problem with a visit when they were extremely busy.the manager Ray said he would take care of the problem and he did.very satisfied, great customer service. read more

Call ahead for quick pickup. Pretty good thin crust pizza and very well priced. The chicken artichoke delight is the bomb!

The Thai Chicken is a poor buy...not much topping on it...the flavor is ok but it's not much more than pizza dough.

The staff here has always been very friendly. Great pizza at a great price plus exceptional cookie dough!

Best pizzeria in Eureka! I had gone in and asked how fast they could get me a pizza ready and that I was on a tight time schedule. The woman at the counter got me one within 5 minutes. Epicness. Prices are pretty good too! read more

The pizza tasted good... the customer service was horrible. No one greeted us for what felt like forever. They don't have a public restroom but we're very rude when I asked if my three year old could pee while we wait for our already paid for pizza. My daughter got paint on her dress from a pole in the middle of the waiting area that has been painted in the middle of the day with a small wet paint sign way out of eyesight ... good food horrible in store experience. read more

The customer service here was phenomenal. I came in asking about a pizza, it wasn't what I thought, the manager steps in and offers to make something, not on their menu, for me free of any upgrade charge. I interacted with 3 staff members, all were pleasant. All employees had good attitudes and smiled at me. It was like old fashioned customer service. I took the survey while they were making my pizza and walked out with free cookie dough. Everyone was so accommodating and kind. Also, I paid with EBT and sometimes people treat you badly when you do, but they treated me like a valued customer. My pizza, salad, and cheesy bread all look very fresh and I can't wait to dig in. Definitely coming back, because the employees made my night awesome! read more

I like that I can splurge on a delite pizza since I've been on Weight Watchers. The Veggie Delite will fill you up. Service is standard

Consistent is the best way to describe this place. I like being able to phone in at the last minute and pick up dinner in a pinch. The pizza is actually pretty good considering it is take and bake. I also like to pick up one of their pre-made salads as a side, however, they are often out of the specific salad option I want. The cookie dough is a nice touch but I would recommend staying away from the breadsticks. Also the family style pizza represents a significantly greater amount of pizza for a slightly higher price and clearly seems like the best value. I like ordering more than I know I will eat for dinner and having leftovers for lunch the next couple of days. From my experience the pizza still tastes good in lunches for two days after baking (after it starts to get dried out and hard). read more

I love coming here! The pizza is always fresh and yummy! The staff is nice and work clean. My only complaint is that the person who answers the phone always sounds board and not interested in what your saying. read more

Kelsey is my favorite! He has amazing customer service. I come here once a week and he hooks it up.

We have been going into this location for years, whenever we have had a looooong day and there isn't time to cook or energy to shop. I recommend the Cicago stuffed pizza.....great for breakfast the next day too. Sevice is always friendly and excellent and the pizza is what you expect it to be....great. We love Papa Murphy's and the way that they run this location. read more

Got their heart shaped pepperoni pizza for Valentine's Day..SUPER cute! It tasted REALLY well, especially with ranch! GOOD prices, GOOD staff! Loooong line.. read more

purpasly gave me less toppings because i wanted them on the side, and bitched about it the whole time i was in the store; give me what i ordered, then wait till i leave to bitch like a normal person read more

Service couldn't have been worse. Ordered on-line with pizza to be picked up at 5:45. Arrived at said time and waited and waited at the on-line pick up counter. They kept making pizzas and calling names for pick up. No one ever asked what my name was or even if I had ordered on-line. Then I realized that the last two orders made were for people that had come in long after I had and actually placed their order at the counter and were leaving with their pizzas. At this time I have waited 30 minutes. I managed to get a credit with some odd explanation of they can't really credit for what I bought so they have to make something up to equal that amount and he stamped my card twice. Then was told if I didn't have a credit within two days to contact them. Are you kidding me...how do they stay in business. If I don't have a credit tomorrow morning I'm going to be on their doorstep when they open. read more