Their pizza is pretty good compared to the other places in town. I got the lunch special - which is a good deal for two slices, but not as fresh as ordering a whole freshly made pie. Arcata needs better pizza. read more

Best pizza around! The way they fold the sauce into the crust then out garlic butter on it..... ooo man! Great value for the delicious options, highly recommended read more

Scenario: You're back in your college town for a visit but you only have 48 hours to hit all your favorite spots. Smugs is definitely on that list! Super hole in the wall, literally. As a college student, I loved being able to just grab a slice instead of having to order the whole pie and it's perfect walking distance from school, the square, all the good spots. The crust is really the highlight of the slice--nice and chewy and puffy, with the right amount of garlic flavor! Stop by to grab a slice to go! read more

I don't understand how such an old-school place like Smug's, in its memorably tiny location, doesn't have more reviews on Yelp. It's basically a tradition to grab a slice at Smug's for hungry college students or alumni. It still offers good value and taste for the price, and IMO should be as well-known and regarded as Blondie's was at Cal Berkeley. Not earth-shattering, but a staple of Arcata visits for my family. read more

Mugs me a great pizza for the occasion! Whether there's going by for lunch, grabbing one pizza, or grabbing six for a meeting they do a great job of accommodating. The ingredients always taste fresh and the dough is to die for. Totally recommend. read more

Pizza is pretty good, it used to be cheap for a slice of pizza but it's pretty expensive now. Service is okay, sometimes they're a little rude, it's small inside but welcoming. If you want a quick piece of pizza I would go here. read more

Great little hole in the wall place (when you go, you'll chuckle at my delightful humor). Stopped in to grab pizza as we came into town shortly before they closed. We ordered a delicious classic pie and a couple of slices of chicken ranch, I believe. This isn't where you go if you're looking for fancy, in-house dining. But if you and your boo are hungry and want to grab a quick bite to take home to watch Netflix and snuggle, this is a great option. read more

Great food. Very nice service by the young gentleman working. In town visiting my son. You have to stop by for a slice of pizza. The homemade Cookies are delicious. Great vibe and Service. Can't miss it right next to the theatre. :) read more

I was staying over in Eureka, and when I was looking for a place for pick-up, Smug's came up. However, the one closest to us closed early and this location stayed open late. Though it was only 8 miles away, I thought what the heck. Called it in while I was driving over. Friendly greeting from the two workers! The dough was crispy on the outside, doughy on the inside. We had chicken, sundried tomatoes, and spinach. A perfect light combination since it was late. Saved two slices for the next day's road travel and they made the perfect lunch! I would come back if I was in the area! read more

Smug's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Arcata, California

See all

Nice lil hole in the wall pizza shop. Place is more of a grab and go spot since seating is non-existent. Shop might be small but pizza is phenomenal. This is the type of place where you know everything is good. Employees are always kind and laidback, never any issues. Smugs is definitely worth a try if you're hanging in Arcata. read more

PIZZA ! Smugs is our Favorite Pizza joint ! They really make a tasty pie ! Highly recommended by us , we have enjoyed many pies from Arcata and several from McKinleyville too but we have not ventured to the Eureka store yet . read more

This place seems like a good place for people who are just randomly walking down the street and feel a sudden urge to eat pizza. I don't see why anyone would go out of their way to eat at this place because they never have anything ready, and the place is so small that you'd have to wait outside with all of the weird stuff that goes on in the area. I get that it's a chill city, but still... In all seriousness though, this is a solid establishment, their pizza isn't out of this world, but it's good and that's all that matters at this point. read more

Smug's Pizza - Inside - Pizza Near Me - Arcata, California

See all

Bare minimum interior with poor seating . So best order to go. Huge pie with fresh toppings. Crust is soft rather than crisp but delicious. About 20 minutes from order to eating. We ordered the "omnivore " lots of white meat chicken, bell peppers, green onions and mushrooms. read more

Tried to eat here but the restaurant still wasn't open despite signage saying I was indeed there during "open" hours. Only had a little bit of time for lunch and I walked here, so now I'm out of options. read more

The pizza is always fresh and hot as well as delicious. Service is very efficient. The counter is kept clean.

Website says $14 for a pie and they didn't correct over the phone only to get charged 19.50 when I pick it up. They admit they knew about it but it's not been corrected...convenient read more

Yikes! People are giving this 5 stars??? really???? Were you high?? The only person that's smug is whoever owns this joint and passes this off as pizza for $3.00 a slice! The good: Guys were friendly. The bad: place is dirty. Cutting surface looks like it's from 1970 and harboring a lot of bacteria. The ceiling looks like it's gonna cave in any second. This is a walk up storefront. There is no seating. Cash or local check only. Most of all the pizza is terrible! Where do I start? The crust was it crisp and thin. The sauce tasted like uncooked canned tomato with no seasoning. The cheese was flavorless but the artichoke and onion were ok. I've had better frozen pizzas. I typically do not give one star right away until I have tried a place more than once but this was so bad there is no going back. read more

Smug's Pizza - No sign on the building. Next to Arcata Theater. - Pizza Near Me - Arcata, California

cheap prices, pizza quality matches the price point. Not the best you ever had but not bad at all. I got two slices, a cookie, and soda for around $8 I think. The chocolate chip was super bomb. I don't even like cookies like that and this was one do the best ones I've had. read more

so delicious and the service is fantastic! if you're getting just a slice or two I highly recommend! if you want higher end tasting Dominios pizza, this is place! read more

So I fricking love this pizza place. If I had no moral code I would give it a good 4 star because their staff is always very friendly and sweet, their pizza tastes decent and their crust is pretty good and they really load it up with cheese every time I go. The reason why I took the one star off is because In all truth. It's a really good medium place, they don't really stay open late and their food is JUST OK. ITS great when you want it but one pizza down you've realized that we don't really have a good pizza place up here. The marinara is pretty good but again. It's just good. This place has a special place in my heart so if you're looking for an arcata classic inexpensive pizza place come here and support these friendly folks. If you're looking for a top of the line artisan pizza, there are other places, honey. read more

Best slice. Ive been going here for years. Its not the best. Its not the worst... but two alices of oie and a soda is all you need! More Hawaiian read more

Great quality and delicious. They spread the sauce and cheese to the edge and roll it into the crust. I lived in New York. This is good pizza. read more

Smug's has a reputation for good pizza in Arcata, and it's a reputation that's well deserved. The pizza is pretty good, and the dough is fresh daily. They do a thing where they fold the crust back over, which is kinda neat. Tiny little shop next to the movie theater, there's no seating to speak of but you can stand at the counter space if you need. Most people just grab and go. Pizza is sold by the slice or the pie, which is nice. Because of the theatre and just Arcata, parking can be a pain. Friendly staff. read more

This was okay. The person I went with really talked it up and they love it, so maybe I just got over hyped. I was rather disappointed though. It was good pizza but nothing to write home about. The service wasn't amazing and not patient with anyone who hadn't been there or had been there since their policies changed. The space was cool and tiny. I just wish the food and service was better. Some patio tables would be really nice so there was a spot to eat. read more

Smug's Pizza - Sausage and peperoni and veggie. - Pizza Near Me - Arcata, California

Legit the best pizza ypu can get in arcata staff is really chill and pizza is honestly the best highly recommended 100%/100% read more

Loved it at lunch when I was in high school and stop in for a slice and in eureka old town there's another one just as good same great taste awesome atmosphere read more

Ok pizza, not really the best. When I walked in I got a pineapple bell pepper on cheese and I was offered the Pineapple Pesto but it wasn't ready, so I promised to come back in a few.I came back literally 40 minutes later and it was all gone! I don't even know if it was sold out or not because she told me, "I didn't think you were gonna come back and it got old soo....". Wow really? Maybe they are used to people flaking. I just ate a damn slice 30 minutes ago, needed to digest walk around and then come back for more. I don't even want to go back now, because I've had way better pizza elsewhere. Just wanted to give Smug's a try and so I did. read more

This pizza joint is BOMB. You walk in and it's just a counter and a side table with all the cheese, pepper flakes, sriracha and whatever you could need to enjoy your pizza. The toppings options are clutch and they always have pizza ready for your stroll around the plaza. Also the staff there is super friendly and helpful, they care about giving you great service, especially the dude with the rad hair. I don't go to the square without getting a slice or two. read more

Two words: Cash only. Smug's is delicious. They have the best steal in Arcata, 2 for $4, can't go wrong! read more

One of the most underrated pizza spots in Arcata for sure. Good affordable pizza and the staff is always super sweet. In a good spot close to the plaza. read more

best pizza in arcata!!!!! but don't expect to eat there hahaha. My favorte: chicken, tomato, and artichoke hearts with a pesto sauce!!! to die for really fresh ingredients and unique flavor. read more

This is my favorite pizza in Arcata. The slices they have in the restaurant are the best! Their tomato garlic mixture pizza is really delicious along with their pineapple and jalapeno read more

Last week I ordered three pizzas to go. When I got to the restaurant they told me that they were out of some of the ingredients for one of the pizzas, so they give me a discount and some complimentary cookies. The service was great. The pizzas were delicious and the snickerdoodles were out of this world. read more

I've lived in Arcata for all of my life, and I have always thought that Smug's had the best tasting pizza around. Pros: Decent price to quantity ratio The best crust (and everything else if you ask me) Cons: Very small cash only read more

It's hard to pass up good tasting pizza for $2.50. Their Hawaiian pizza proves that pinapple deserves to be on pizza. I also prefer a cruchy crust, however the soft doughiness of Smugs is quite delightful. They usually have a decent selection of slices to go and they will also make you a whole pie. Worth a quick stop if you are near it! read more

For me, being from New York, its all about the quality of the pie, and this is sub par pizza. The only reasons to go here are: you're starving and standing right in front of it its usually pretty quick its cheap: 3 slices for $5, good deal. read more

Smugs is the best pizza by the slice in Arcata. Their staff is always very curtious and friendly. Of course the buy one slice, get a 2nd for $1 is a no brainer!! Smugs has THE BEST Hawaiian Pizza I have ever tasted, it is a must try, I sometimes just go in and order 2 of those. In reality, however, you can't go wrong with any selection. The dough is tasty, the sauce is delicious, perfect amount of cheese. And the crust is delightful. Folded over for extra thickness & crisp. And the best part is the thin layer of pizza sauce through the middle with a buttery garlic spread on top. In Short, this place is great for a quick cheap $4 to $5.25 (depending on if you want a drink and chips or cookie) stop for lunch in Arcata. Or if you want to order a large pie for the family. Highly recommend read more

Nostalgia is a powerful thing. During my college years at HSU Smugs pizza had an iconic status. In the years since it has only grown in my mind. Can a slice of pizza really be that good? Can crust be that golden and tasty? Can pizza toppings be that fresh and delicious? Can a couple bucks for a cheesy treat possibly equal the eleven years of rose-tinted memories that built it up? The answer is YES. read more

First review was 3 stars, I admit I was wrong. This place is heaven on earth. The crust. For the love of god. The crust. read more

I'm not for the area. But I've been coming up here for over 25 years and I come from a place of many pizza joints. Every time I make it to Arcata, my first stop is to Smug's. I'm not going to say I'm an expert. But I have eaten many pizza's in my day. And I know a good slice of pizza. So I give this place 6 stars. Petrillo's (San Gabriel) Angelo's (Alhambra) read more