If the restaurant doesn't smell like pizza, and the take out box in your car doesn't make the…read moreinterior smell like pizza on the trip home, then it's not pizza! 1/2 combo, 1/2 Hawaiian...the worst, gummiest, tasteless pizza I have ever had...had to toss it out..it couldn't be called a pizza Too bad the vermin overwhelmed Angelo's..it was the worlds best pizza.

Iconic location. Clean and welcoming environment. Excellent pizza! Brings back lots of memories.read more

So I love pizza. Like even my kids would tell you at my wake of life my mom would want it catered…read morewith pizza. This stuff is GREAT!!!! I wasn't solid I like India food but on pizza? Yes! It will be a staple on vacation.

Great pizza! They have all of the usual italian pizzas, but they also have indian inspired pizzas…read more Both are excellent. I'm usually not too adventurous with food, so I was glad to find their pizza offerings included the same as one would expect at any pizza restaurant; however, I did try a couple indian inspired pizzas that my family ordered and they were excellent. I recommend it and I will be back.

Well this use to be my fave place, called about ordering and applying my rewards for a discount,…read morethe girl that answer said she didn't know how and the other person was to busy to help. I get it I also do customer service work, but there's a certain way to treat customers. So the cook Gee called me back! I ended up getting my rewards and ordering from the app, went in to pick up and Gee came out to apologize and gave me a free order or bread sticks, he was super nice. He said a couple people called out, I appreciate his efforts thou. I was having an off day too, say this made my night! & I got my Pizza with a 49% off since the 49ers won

Great Pizza. Great owner!…read more While ordering there was a mistake which the owner ractified and ensure that we received a great service.

My husband and I were on a road trip and staying in Eureka for the night and decided to eat here…read morefor dinner, which also happened to fall on Father's Day. The place was pretty busy at 8pm and we sat outside since we had our pup with us. I ordered 3 oysters as an app. I had just read that Humboldt Bay provided a large percentage of the oysters consumed in CA and NV so figured I should order some since we're so close to the source! I was surprised when I slurped it down and it was warm but they were delicious and the sauce on top was very flavorful. (That was my fault for not reading the description well enough; I'm just accustomed to eating oysters chilled) For entree's, I went with the Polenta Veghie lasagna and my husband ordered the Italian Mac n cheese. Both dishes were very good and very filling. I loved the crust of the polenta and the eggplant and cheese filling was delicious. The staff was very friendly and helpful and I was impressed with the coziness and warmth of the interior. Great spot for dinner, I'm glad I chose this restaurant!

I was visiting Eureka and decided to check this place out. So glad I was able to try this…read morerestaurant and the delicious food they serve. My wife and I ordered the Italian Mac and cheese, beef bolognese, seafood soup (almost like a cioppino) of the day , and mushroom cobbler. All dishes were amazing and so flavorful. It was hard to pick a favorite but the beef bolognese and soup stood out to me. Our servers were so delightful and incredibly friendly. The ambience is great too; lively and homey. If I am back in town this is the first place I am coming back to. I wish I had this exact restaurant in my area!

Good food and service has a good fresh buffet my daughter loves the staff very funny and niceread more

My partner and I had never been to a Round Table and decided to go on a whim while not having high…read moreexpectations - it was phenomenal and Darrel went above and beyond making the experience all the more enjoyable. He truly made every customer feel so welcomed and was wildly sweet and accommodating.

i will not buy another pizza from Papa Murphy's because they are to expenses for $25.00 for a…read morefamily size and have to bring it home to bake it.

We would order Papa Murphy's probably once every other month and we loved it we also love babes and…read morewe have tried Mountain Mike's in Eureka. I have to say Papa Murphy's is the worst pizza I have had out of the three we ordered a stuffed combination pizza which consisted of mostly pizza sauce cheese and bread absolutely no meat no onion no bell pepper horrible horrible horrible. Mountain Mike's is $20 more for the same size pizza but is a loaded with meat and veggies and it is the most delicious pizza ever pay the extra money. don't order pizza where you get sauce cheese and bread yucky. Stay away from Papa Murphys

So Memorial Day weekend 2026 our halibut fishing crew rolled into old town…read more Our guest of honor was my father in law who grew up in the Eureka area. Instead of Babes pizza this year my father in law led us to PAUL'S LIVE FROM NEW YORK!!! Rolled into Paul's and examined the menu in a giant pizza booth adjacent to the kitchen. As the fish crew was discussing the order a pizza chef revealed himself over the wall and told us we needed to order the 6-meat King Kong!!! Sign us up brother! I couldn't find King Kong on the menu! Awesome it's top secret. So order up...one 18 inch pepperoni pizza, one hitman, one King Kong, and two sausage rolls. That's a Yelpstar elite order folks. Pizza rolled out piping hot and fabulous. The food was 5-star tasty and from sea to shining sea some of the best NYC style pizza I've tasted. Thanks PAUL'S LIVE FROM NEW YORK! I'll be back.

The food and friendliness were a . French Fries were crispy and among the best I've ever had…read more Pizza crust - and overall - were excellent!

I was so happy to find this little spot in downtown Eureka. The space itself is super fun with…read morewonderful energy and really cool aesthetic touches. We were served right away and the hostess was very nice and located at two top for us. The wait person was lovely and immediately accommodating. The menu was interesting and inviting. I had to laugh out loud as there is an item on the menu referencing Pee-wee's Playhouse from my childhood. I even asked if it was a Gen X restaurant and sure enough the chef is of my generation. I'm including a picture so IYKYK! The waitress had shared all of the specials, and I was intrigued by the flat iron steak option. It was a flat iron steak with marsala mushroom sauce, and mushroom risotto and asparagus. It was delightful! The meat was perfectly cooked and tender with a lot of beef flavor, offset by a rich marsala mushroom sauce. It was perfectly complimented by one of the top mushroom risotto I have had in my life. It was delectable. And the grilled asparagus side paired nicely with the beef and marsala sauce. It even had a little bit of lemon on the asparagus, which is my preference for it! Overall, this is probably in the top five of all of the restaurant meals I've had in my life. My husband had the mixed beef burger with fries. He said he really enjoyed the burger, and I did steal a tiny taste, and it was perfectly cooked and had a slight gameness that gave it some depth. My husband said that the bun was very nice as well. The fries were perfectly cooked. The burger was perfectly cooked and it wasn't over juicing nor dry. Overall, a really great burger! Funniest thing we noticed was that all of the chairs that were sitting on a cement floor had been given rubber caps for each of the legs so that when you moved the chair, it didn't make a horrible sound. Literally extra 10 points for that alone! I wish this location well and look forward to stopping in the next time we are in the area.

First off to start, I'm unsure why they have bar in their name. They only have beer, cider and…read morewine. That's fine. Was just misled by their name, expecting more. I had oven roasted salmon with what was supposed to be a teriyaki glaze on top but it was more like a syrup. The mushroom risotto was good. The pizzas that we ordered were good. The price for the child's slider was crazy for the tiny thing that we received. My personal opinion otherwise are the chairs. They are cold and uncomfortable.