5/10/25 Ate List: Pepperoni pizza - 8.0 Solid slice joint. Warmed in the oven. This was great. Slices are BIG, like I genuinely think they were a foot long. Will definitely be back! read more

Paisano's - Pepperoni pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

9/12/23 Picked up a Steak Wedge last night and it was SUPER! I ordered it with extra meat & extra cheese and there wasn't a single bite lacking either. I always request both dressings- mayo + ital dressing and it was the same for this wedge. I haven't ordered anything here that I wouldn't order again. Everything is delicious... Btw- for the review that says "The owner is an ass"... that's not the owner. The place is busy, the work is hard, the a/c doesn't work when you have a pizza oven cranking out 300+ degrees. Plus... Too many people come into this place trying to run some sort of game, trying to get something for free. So... if you're looking to walk in and get a nice warm hug or a 'Welcome to Moes' type greeting, I'd go somewhere else. BTW- if you can't get through on the phone, order on Slice. If Slice doesn't want to let you order, as it wasn't letting me select 'Pick up asap' last night, they still might be open. Slice has been acting up, from what I hear. read more

Really enjoyed the pizza here! This place is walking distance for us and we walk our dog by this pizza shop all the time. Finally the one night my boyfriend went in here on a whim and got us a pie- and we were really happy we tried it!! Read some great reviews about the hoagies and we love a good italian hoagie so that's what we will be trying next time! read more

Paisano's - pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

We love this place best Italian hoagie ever, slices of pizza are huge, my favorite place to order, every time we order we always get the same thing, they always know our name, before we tell them. read more

Great food wonderful people working there. Even though they are so short staffed they took great care of us and the food was great

Food is not good. I got an Italian hoagie that was so greasy that I couldn't even eat it. The owner is an ass, he yells at his employees and customers. I don't know how the health department hasn't shut them down. read more

Man, those pies really glamped my mamped. The fries are the prize. Slurp up peoples, this is the real deal. The peps mad my perm shine read more

Paisano's - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

Ordered a large pizza online with peppers, mushrooms, extra cheese, and pepperoni for only $20. Picked it up ourselves and it was still piping hot when we got it home (5 minute drive max). It was a bit soggy on the bottom, possibly due to all the toppings, but still very good. Not the best pizza I've ever had, but tasty nonetheless. I'd order from here again. read more

Best Italian hoagie in the City! Great place for take out and delivery. Pizza was just okay but we will always return for the hoagies. read more

Paisano's - Small Italian Hoagie -- super good! - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

Steak hoagies & pizza is always amazing. Sometimes have to call multiple times to get an answer but definitely worth it

I gave them 5 because the food is always delicious. Their Italian & Steak hoagies are fantastic but you HAVE to try the Hippie Roll. Ate there yesterday & thinking about going again. Food is consistently hot and delicious. I highly recommend Paisano's, you won't be disappointed. read more

What's for dinner? (Tuesday~ March 17, 2020) Cheesesteak hoagie & a seafood pie. Because of the COVID-19 virus I got take out after a busy day of liquor & grocery food shopping!!! Meal specs: Not the best experience but not horrible either. This time my hoagie seemed like it was done before the pie! Meaning, it wasn't hot as it usually is & how I like it best. Typically, it is like it was just taken out of the oven! They usually time everything to have things done @ the same time. The bread wasn't as crispy & they gave me onions when I didn't ask for them. But, since the onions where cooked properly I was able to deal with it! The seafood pie wasn't @ it's usual greatness either. I can't really put my finger on why! It just wasn't as tasty! Bon appétit!! Picture I only have my seafood pie portion since I ate mine in the car on my way home! I wasn't thinking about a picture! read more

Steak hoagie was very good fries are very good and you get a lot fresh fries wings are good as well

My steak wedgie was so bomb i got two in one week Their steak hoagies are fire too!!! read more

Paisano's - Steak Wedgie! Worth EVERY penny!! - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

This restaurant has gone "downhill" !!! This used to be my favorite for YEARS. over the last few weeks I have been unable to get an order delivered to my house - and given no explanation as to a reason by either the restaurant or the delivery service (slice) just left "hanging" And having to spend more time to tract down the the problem myself. We will no longer use this restaurant, and sorry to say that, because it used to be very good. read more

Kay wasn't feeling much like Julia Childs or Danica Patrick this evening, so to the internet we looked for (a) A pizza parlor that would deliver to Beechview. (b) A pizza parlor we hadn't tried yet. Alas! There was Paisano's! The middling first review almost deterred us, but in trying Paisano's, we found that a "tough skin" was not required. In actuality, Paisano's is a bit of a softie, from the lady that answered the phone to take down my order to the pie itself. Doughy and malleable, the cushy crust was the clear high point to our sausage-only pizza (Kay surprisingly detoured from the Kay Kombo this evening). "Greasy" this pizza was not. The cheese itself was dairy divinity incarnate, and the sausage approached the correct balance of crispness and succulence. I would have liked to have been able to detect more of the pasty sauce, however. Conversely, the dozen garlic wings we also ordered were brittle, fatty, and thus almost foolproof. The delivery time took less that 20 minutes. Top. That. No one heckled us, either. Us paisanos eat pretty well, don't we? I just learned that "paisano" is Italian for "peasant." I aimz ta educate yinz when possible. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-gvsgwmAfdU read more

Paisano's - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

I ordered a large steak hoagie with everything on it & white cheese fries . The food was great read more

Paisano's - Steak hoagie - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

The Allentown/Mt. Oliver area is lacking an outstanding pizza place that will deliver, so usually I'll hop in the car and just go pick up Fiori's pizza in Brookline because it's worth the drive. On this occasion, delivery was necessary so I decided to give Paisano's a try after not having their pizza since the late 90's. Tonight's experience convinced me to either just make the drive to Fiori's every time, or just try elsewhere next time. When I placed the call to order, the woman who answered was abrasive and impolite. The order wasn't complicated; a large pizza with 2 toppings was all I ordered. The price, I thought, was a bit high, but I wasn't angry about. Was not given an estimated wait time, which I'm wasn't too mad about, but that usually is helpful. When the pizza arrived, the delivery driver was polite. However, one of the toppings I ordered was completely omitted. So I paid for a topping that I didn't receive. The pizza, as far as taste was concerned, was average at best. I'm not usually the one to give negative reviews, but the unpleasant phone order, plus the order error, plus the overall averageness of the pizza taste has driven me to decide to explore other options in the future rather than give Paisano's another shot. read more

We just recently moved to the area and decided to give this place a try today, and I'm so glad we did!! The guy that took the order on the phone was great, even though I had a few special requests. The food came exactly the way I ordered and was amazing!! We had an extra large pepperoni and a half of an Italian hoagie, the pizza was super cheesy with nice crispy pepperoni, and the hoagie was probably the best one I've ever had in Pittsburgh from a delivery place. We'll definitely be ordering from here again soon! read more

My brother and I ordered the curly fries, the Italian calzone, and a small half cheese/half pepperoni pizza. The calzone was the size of Pennsylvania, and had plenty of meat fillings, sauce, and ricotta inside. I would have enjoyed a nice cup of marinara sauce to go with it, but that wasn't a deal breaker, for me. The curly fries were nicely salted, and freshly cut, on site. All-in-all a good experience, although I would suggest doing take-away over eating in. The back room is full of 'stuff', and not very inviting. read more

I've ordered delivery from Paisano's a handful of times. The pizza is good, not my top favorite place for it, but the curly fries are so good that I usually order from here anyway. The curly fries are simple and look like whole potatoes that were just spiral cut (sometimes you get the end pieces) and briefly deep fried, but they're ridiculously good. The guy that has always picked up the phone is extremely curt on the phone, with a lot of one word questions/replies. When I call and ask to place an order for delivery, the answer is just "address" then "phone" then "order" or "what can I get you". Not a huge deal, but don't have high expectations for niceties and politeness. The pricing for delivery orders is a little confusing and also seems high. There seem to be separate prices for each item based on whether they're for delivery or eat in/pick up, rather than an additional flat delivery fee. My order total always seems well above the menu prices, but maybe I'm misunderstanding something. They also charge an extra fee for paying with a credit card, which I have never seen a restaurant do before, and feels at least questionable when I'm making a $30+ order. The customer service attitude and strange pricing policies definitely detract from my impression of Paisano's, but I enjoy the food so they won't stop me from continuing to order here in the future. read more

Paisano's - Large cheese pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

I got a pizza from Paisanos yesterday first time in about 4 or 5 years. It was a 16 cut it looked like a little kid sliced it. It tasted like a grocery store pizza. If I wasn't hungry and if it didn't cost so much i probably would have thrown it away. I do not recommend this place read more

If you want attitude when you order your pizza, this is the place to go. Cheap prices in a questionable neighborhood for the greasiest pizza I've had in a long time. But it's definitely cheap and I can walk there. The star attraction at Paisano's is the man who works behind the counter. He grilled my group on our origins - we clearly aren't Pittsburgh natives. We didn't take it personally because he heckled everyone who stopped by. In Allentown, you meet some interesting characters, and this guy is one of them. So if you're craving a big greasy pizza, head over to Paisano's with your tough skin intact. read more

Had a small Italian hoagie and 4 cut pie. Price was good, food was ready in no time. I was looking forward to hearing from Mark (the guy I was warned about) but apparently it was past his bedtime. The pizza was what you would expect. Four cuts half pepperoni half extra cheese. The hoagie I asked for well done with what it normally comes with. From what I understand Mark makes the dressing himself. It's pretty good. Service was the nicest part of Paisano's very friendly and helpful! read more

This place is insanely hit or miss so don't blame me if you dislike your order. I will say they make a hell of a bacon cheeseburger, hand pressed and broccoli cheddar poppers I could eat all day. They don't hold a candle to Pizza Company but in a pinch it works. They have been here 45 years so they gotta be doing something right. Eat at your own risk, good or bad. read more

Called in for delivery and ordered a larger pepperoni with 12 hot wings. Being rather brash myself, the guy on the phone sounded rather meek and hospitable. The pizza was delivered in no time and was piping hot as were the wings. The crust on the pizza was a little yeasty and a tad over-proofed, but it had decent flavor. There was a little grease on it, but it had pepperoni on it. I have NEVER had a pepperoni pizza that was not a little greasy. I didn't get to eat the wings right away, but even though they were cold when I got to them the wings still tasted good. Not really hot by my standards, more of a mild for me; but it may be too much for the regular Pittsburgher. I will definitely be ordering from here again. Feeding three people, it was much less than $10 per person with enough left for a fourth person. read more

Not open during advertised hours. Ordered on Slice and had my order cancel after about 30 minutes. Refund expected 3-5 days.

Still one of our favorite pizza places even though we live a good 30 minutes away! My 8 year old requested this pizza for his birthday dinner! Italian hoagies are so good here and the fries are delicious, too. We'll never tire of the pizza though-very generous toppings! read more

This is the worst pizza I've ever received. not only did the driver wake up the sleeping parents of two kids next door looking for my house, porch light on, visible address, but the pizza is actually intolerable. It was supposed to be white so it's the absolute wrong pizza, but also even if that wasn't the situation it's still worse than the worst dominos I've had at an Ohio turnpike stop. read more

We have ordered from here several times and the food is consistently decent and fairly priced. The delivery has always been nicely timed, too. I live close by and was out for a walk one day and decided to try dining in there. That was a mistake. The place is filthy, really, just gross. I wish I hadn't gone in there. It's the best tasting pizza delivered to Mount Washington. If I can forget about how dirty the shop is, I will order from there again.... Delivered read more

I eat here often and would recommend the food. There is an area to sit down, but I like to get my food to go. The people who work here are friendly. Try the pizza combo sub or breadsticks read more

I have been eating here for 30 years. I have NEVER had a bad order from here. You will never find a hoagie better than Mark"s famous Italian or Steak hoagies. The pizza is amazing and is always perfect!! All of Marks toppings are 100% fresh every time. Everything is priced very low and under competitive for the quality of the food that they sell which a lot of it is homemade. Mark has his recipes and he has never changed them to my knowledge. I will continue to eat there for hopefully the next 30 years Mark, keep up the good work!!!! Parking is also tight. read more

I ate here for the first time tonight. I was waiting for the bus so only had a few minutes before it arrived. The gentleman working was so accommodating and hurried my pizza and i still made the bus. However, in the case that i would have missed the bus, it would've been sooo worth it! This pizza was amazing and I'm thrilled that i discovered this little gem! You've got a customer for life! Thank you! read more

They have a to die for seafood supreme pie. Italian n steak hoagies, Pizza, fries all wonderful. We Order often. Mark can be unpleasant on days, but he has good food and he knows it. The public can be difficult to deal with and I'm sure he had his share in the neighborhood. He gets buisness. 30 years ago I used to hate calling n would make my husband because I love the pie so much. Now I don't care we've come to expect it. read more

I love, love this place! The pizza, wings and hoagies are amazing! Don't expect warm fuzzy customer service. Take it in stride, they're busy busy busy.... ~ M.L.M. read more

I've been living in Pittsburgh my entire life and had Paisano's pizza about 35 years ago when I was a kid. I moved to My Washington 3 years ago and did pick up mostly at Fiori's or Mineo's because we couldn't find any place that delivered who had anything worth eating, up until last night that is. Superbowl Sunday so cheated and got a few things to try. Steak sandwich was awesome and so was the meatball. We couldn't believe how big they were for the price, but the quality was amazing. The taste was really great. The Pizza as well was so good. I saw a picture someone posted of a pepperoni pizza w extra cheese so that's what we got. Could have had more pepperoni but only a few pieces more to fill a gap here n there. We have wasted Soo much money trying pizza from all over using Uber Eats or Door Dash when we had a little gem of a joint 8 minutes away. We have FINALLY found our pizza spot. Thank you Paisono's. read more

Just moved to the area and really wanted to try this place. I called and the woman that answered the phone gave me an immediate attitude. I hung up because I refuse to service a place with poor customer service skills. read more

The delivery was fast, the pizza was soft and gooey, and the wings were ubercrisp yet moist. What else ya wanna know? :) Order!

Delivery was fast and the pizza was great. If you're going to order pick up just know that there isn't a lot of parking. Other than that, the place was great. Highly recommended. read more

Been going here my entire life. I love it especially the swigs he pizza. Perfect for any occasion.