A great find in Ohiopyle. The pizza is clearly homemade with attention to doing it well. We got a traditional Veggie Lovers pizza and a more unique BBQ chicken pie. Both of them were very enjoyable, and we'd order both again. We were staying a few blocks away, so we picked it up and ate out our place. They have some cute outdoor seating if you want to eat in. They are also very allergy friendly. They are peanut & tree nut FREE, and had signs that they can accommodate others with advance notice. It's really comforting to see this care. read more

Got a veggie lovers pizza with added pineapple and replacing green peppers w jalapeños, added well done for another minute bake and it's truly delicious!! Almost too many items for the beautifully thin crust!! read more

Paddler's Pizza - Veggie lover, ONE slice eaten. Personal pizza cut into 4 :) - Pizza Near Me - Ohiopyle, Pennsylvania

Delicious, cheap slices for $3.50 and busy spot even though a lot of their items needed restocked and were unavailable. Loved eating in the outdoor space with picnic tables because inside was tiny. read more

Pizza was done in 10 minutes. It was the best chicken bacon ranch pizza I have ever had. We got the 18 in and some cheesy bread sticks. It was more than filling. read more

Excellent food and best prices in town. Clearly the owner is trying to make a go of it and can't keep up, but I really liked it. Great ice cream too. read more

After a long day of hiking my friends and I were trying to find somewhere to eat dinner. Everywhere we tried seemed like it was closed. Thankfully, they stumbled on Paddler's Pizza. It met my three requirements. Food, Beer and it was actually open. I ordered a large meat lovers pizza and some cheesy bread sticks. My friends and I then went outside to find a table and wait for our food. I did not see any seating inside the restaurant. The food arrived in a reasonable amount of time. Unlike most other food places we went to the food didn't take forever to arrive. Both the meat lovers pizza and the cheesy breadsticks were very tasty. I was very happy with my meal (and beer) after a long day in the sun. read more

Paddler's Pizza - chessy bread. - Pizza Near Me - Ohiopyle, Pennsylvania

The Pizza Rat ventured far afield to whitewater raft on the Yough, and ended up here. I can enthusiastically say that you will not go wrong with this choice. The dough is wonderful, the sauce and cheese are top-notch delicious, and the ingredients are perfectly fresh. LOVE their large, thin pepperoni slices. The restaurant itself is small and unassuming, and it works because this kitchen mean business. Our order of multiple whole pies was swiftly ready. Also, very generous serving sizes of ice cream. There's a large outdoor seating area as well. Perhaps if this restaurant were in NYC it may get 4 stars, but due to its standout quality, as an oasis of pizza perfection in southwest PA, I am awarding the 5th ***NYC Pizza Rat Approved*** read more

Staff was friendly and helpful. My pizza was delicious and served very fast. Can't wait to eat outside.

AmaZing. Absolutely delicious pizza and the employees were knowledgeable as well. We got the veggie lovers pizza and it was the best we've ever had. read more

Paddler's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Ohiopyle, Pennsylvania

See all

Buffalo chicken personal pizza was kind of bland and light on the sauce and chicken but still solid. Probably worth just getting a slice or two if you are eating solo. Pie crust was a little doughier, not a New York style thin crust. read more

I'm vegan and I came prepared to get a slice and take the cheese off if I had to. Food is limited in this area and my hike had me starving! I saw they had some other things besides pizza so I ordered the Pasta with marinara sauce. They have a few seats inside but it is a slightly awkward layout. They also have outdoor seating. When my food came out, it was covered in a layer of thick mozzarella, which wasn't specified on the menu. I was able to pull it off the top and eat the pasta underneath, as it didn't get mixed in too much. Pasta was pretty good. Just regular tasting for a pizza shop. The bread had an unspecified oil on it (or butter) and garlic and was extremely greasy. It got all over my hands! This place is definitely edible enough to eat when starving, but not really anything to get excited about. I would have made a stink about all the cheese had I not been so hungry. read more

Paddler's Pizza - Pasta with marinara - Pizza Near Me - Ohiopyle, Pennsylvania

Excellent hand tossed thin crust that bubbles up. The sauce is savory with hints of herbs. Lots of cheesy goodness. A wonderful summer al fresco lunch on their picnic table. read more

Paddler's Pizza - Yummy goodness - Pizza Near Me - Ohiopyle, Pennsylvania

Top notch Pizza joint in the town of Ohiopyle. Hand tossed pizza and amazing Stromboli made fast and piping hot. You won't regret checking this place out. read more

My name is Hitt, I'm from Pittsburgh PA. I do many things but one of the things I like to do is experience everything I humanly can from foods to places plus people and things. Rather than write a long review and clutter the reviews with anymore long reviews (no knock, you guys are great) I'm just gonna get right to the point... This place? Go here if you're in town. Killer pizza. Good price. Clean eating area. Close to lots of other stuff. And it's pizza, enough said. read more

I stopped by with my out-of-town friend and her dad after a day hike in Ohiopyle State Park last Sat. After having hiked all day long, we were quite hungry, so, like the good Yelper I am, I whipped out my phone to scout out the local dining options. Of the places in the town of Ohiopyle, this one seemed like the best rated one that was open for dinner, so we decided to try it out. True to form as a casual pizzeria, you place and retrieve your order at the counter, rather than from your seat. There was ample seating both inside and outside of the restaurant, so we decided to sit inside. I saw the pizza maker tossing dough, which made me nostalgic for the time when all pizza parlors--even chain ones--did this, and indicated that the pies were MTO and fresh. Our order took about 15 min. to come up, so during this time, I sipped on Lorrie's homemade sweet tea. If you drink it, be forewarned that it's diabetes-inducing sweet--I love me some sweet tea, but this stuff was too sweet even for me! I recommend combining it with at least half unsweetened tea (I went 50-50 for my second cup, which was still sweeter than I like). For our pizza, we ordered a large (18") chicken bacon ranch pizza ($18.50). This pizza was more than enough to feed the three of us--indeed, it probably could have fed four people--but then again, as I said, we were quite hungry after hiking all day. The pizza was quite tasty, consisting of ranch sauce, mozzarella and cheddar cheese, and chicken. My only complaint was that the amount of chicken seemed a bit stingy, given that the pieces were quite small. Overall, we were quite happy with our visit to Paddler's Pizza. In addition to pizza, they offer ice cream, but we didn't get any. I'd definitely recommend it as an inexpensive and tasty post-hike meal in Ohiopyle. read more

Paddler's Pizza - Large chicken bacon ranch pizza - Pizza Near Me - Ohiopyle, Pennsylvania

See all

Yummmm.... best pizza we have had in a long time, fresh, hot, and fast. We will be going back again tomorrow! My husband is vegan, so we ordered the veggie pizza with no cheese on half, he said it was great. read more

Great pizza. Grumpy staff. We were referred here by our white water rafting guide at Laurel Highlands. Since there aren't that many options in the area, we decided to give it a shot. I'm sure the businesses have some sort of you scratch my back/ i'll scratch yours arrangement (based on the number of water rafting brochures on display), so I was surprised by the cashiers annoyed attitude at our presence. Yes, a lot of us needed change for a 20 so that we could give cash to the guy paying for our order, but we were also all buying our own drinks. Sorry for giving you more of the moneys! Pizza was good though. read more

The pizza is amazing! The ingredients are fresh! My BF and I came by this place last year and we will be visiting again whenever we go back to Ohiopyle! read more

Y Yelp site and website are INCORRECT At 4pm on WednesdaySept 8 it is closed Nowhere to get food in entire town read more

We stopped here since it was the only place open in town when we got in around 6pm. It's standard pizza and Italian sandwich fare. They have wi if and such. Food was okay and hospitality was a hit in many ways and in other ways it was a miss. read more

Very tasty pizza crust and pizza. Staff was brusque and said that they weren't giving out water for free! When I asked for an empty cup because we have kids and they wanted to share water/drinks, I was told that there were no cups, when the actual cups were right in front of me. They charged us $1.75 for an empty cup. This takes away from the overall customer experience of a unique tasty pizza. Slightly better customer service would be appreciated. read more

Really good NY style pizza. Fast friendly service. We'll go back next time we're in Ohiopyle.

Stopped to do some waterfall site seeing and smelled pizza. Glad we stopped. Delish!!! Even got to watch the guy hand toss the dough. #skillz we will be back in the summer and this will be a definite stop. read more

The pizza here is hand tossed, I witnessed it! Cute little hometown pizza place in the heart of Ohiopyle. Pizzas are thin crust, but more like a New York style where it's best to eat it folded. They use large size pepperoni slices, and a good sauce. Plenty of options for toppings. Prices were good as was the service. It hit the spot, but didn't bust the budget, and there are tables you can eat at outside. Great way to feed a group. read more

I stopped by here with some friends for a quick bite to eat after a rafting trip down the lower Yough. It has a great location in the middle of town, and it's one of only a few options downtown Ohiopyle. Pizza here is pretty good, however the only complaint I have about the food is that it is VERY greasy! Other than that great taste and it fills you up. The menu has some oddities and includes some specials as well as items displayed that are not available for purchase while you are there (only for delivery). If someone likes your special and wants to eat it there or get it for pickup, why wouldn't you accept that business? The staff here wasn't too pleasant with us upon our arrival which is fairly consistent with the other reviews on Yelp. Pizza is my go to after a long day rafting/biking/hiking at Ohiopyle. I will be back here for some more next time I make a trip out. read more

We always like to try pizza when we go somewhere new. Got a couple slices and it really hit the spot. The homemade sauce was perfect! This will definitely be a place we stop at when we are in town again. read more

Good dough but your cheap cheese and pepperoni leaves a big puddle of grease. Spend a little more on your toppings and your pizza will be great. read more

Paddler's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Ohiopyle, Pennsylvania

If you want to have perfect new York style pizza, this is your place! Now I have eaten a lot of pizza in my day, and this ranks in my top 5 in the world. Imagine you have had a long day of hiking, biking in Ohiopyle, and you and your children are starving/hangry. Casual dining on picnic tables outside with hot, delicious pizza becomes miraculous. Well priced as compared to most tourist places. Also, most importantly, the crust is think without being burnt. read more

Stopped as a last resort with a starving family couldn't have been any happier!!!! Great pizza and cheesy bread sticks.

Grew up in NY eating pizza and this is by far, the best pizza I've had in PA. Great salt balance, dough, sauce and crazy good cheese.

Great pizza and fresh toppings. Ok selection of beer, but after a day at Ohiopyle it was all delicious. I wish they recycled, but otherwise great place. The front door is a little hidden, but definitely a place for some good pie read more

Stopped in for a bite to eat after hiking. We had salads and a pepperoni mushroom pizza. The pizza was delicious! The staff was super friendly. Will stop again. read more

Food is excellent. All made to order and fresh. Staff is rude and not friendly. Limited seating as outdoor only is open right now.

For the pizza itself, I'd give it a 4-star rating -actually very good. However, the 2-star rating is due to the unfriendly staff. We took a party of 8, bought (2) 16 inch pizzas and (1) 14 inch pizza plus (2) 2-liter bottles of soda...not a small order. They have picnic tables outside and no seating for a party of 8 inside, so we were going to eat outside. As such, we needed cups for our soda. The disgust they conveyed that they had to give us 8 small cups was surprising and quite frankly, uncalled for. When we went back in later for some napkins, we got the same level of bother. We just didn't feel welcome, read more

Considering the lack of restaurants around, this pizza place suprised me. We order the medium buffalo pizza and it was very good. The crust was perfect and the spice level on the money. We also shared a chef salad and it was huge and substancial for us both to eat. It's not a fancy place, but it's good enough for the environment if your there to camp. The service was friendly and clean. I'll go back for sure for another slice! read more

We came in here after a night backpacking on the Laurel Highlands trail, and it hit the spot. Both the spinach and mushrooms were fresh and the service was great. Definitely recommend it. We didn't get a chance to try the ice cream, but will probably have some next time. read more

Super delicious pizza! We stopped here after spending the day at FallingWater and white water rafting the day before. I am a big fan of small businesses and family owned restaurants, and this was a great place to eat! read more

Great Za! We were touring the town of Ohiopyle & we're attracted by the scent, so of course we had to give it a try. For $16 we got an 18" cheese pizza and a drink, what a deal! read more

Was visiting the area and stopped in for some pizza. It's hand tossed and such great choices. We got the Lovers of Meat, and Buffalo Chicken. They were both very good and I LOVE watching them toss the pizza,so cool. The pepperoni was huge, and the buffalo chicken was just the right kind of heat. We also ordered the potato wedges. Gosh I hadn't had those in years. Reminded me of the ones I got as a teen. It came with this really good thick ranch. read more

**They are now closed for the winter and will reopen in April** We stopped in on the last day of the season and they were out of at least one ingredient for the first couple items we asked for. Once we found a menu item that was in stock, the food was quite delicious. read more