So yummy! Hot honey is bomb and the slices are huge and fresh! The prices are super reasonable and it's located right downtown but set off the sidewalk, giving it a more private feel. I'll be back! read more

Otto's has become our "go to" pizza. So yummy! This is exactly what Exeter needed. Consistently great food and good vibe. Highly recommend. read more

The food is great, but I wouldn't call it worth the wait. Fix your website if it's going to say that food will be ready at a certain time and it takes an extra 20 minutes. NOT worth the price. Happens every time I order from here. I wish I could review it separately as a sit down restaurant, that side is great. But the take out side seems to be run by one guy who cannot catch up. read more

1st time in the restaurant. Had amazing (very large) Italian Sub One of the best and I'm a harsh critic. Have also Had pizza for takeout and it too has be read more

My family enjoyed Otto's. They have some really good options. We love the potato pizza.

$19 for a cheese pizza and $30 for a three topping??? No thanks. There are better for much less in the area.

I stopped in today for the first time with my husband and we ordered a plain cheese pizza to go. We brought it home to enjoy and we both agreed it was delicious pizza!! Perfect amount of sauce/cheese and quality ingredients. Very similar to north end Italian style pizza (thin crust) . Wait time was 20 minutes and was ready within that quoted time. We will definitely be back for more. read more

OTTO - Large plain cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Exeter, New Hampshire

The pizza is fabulous! Atmosphere and staff are warm, friendly, and inviting. I have done take out and eaten there. Both are phenomenal.

Otto pizza can be really delicious - but prices are too high, service is careless, and why the hell would I tip for a slice that I'm picking up? Pay your workers, I'm not tipping a cashier for a to-go order. read more

Ordered my pizza at 3:57pm and got a text saying my pizza was ready at 4:09pm. It's been an hour and 45 minutes and I still haven't gotten it. I called and asked what the status was and she said the driver must have forgotten "or something like that." was looking forward to eating it as I have ordered from Otto before, but now I have to wait at work passed my hours to wait for a pizza they didn't offer a refund or anything. read more

Ordered takeout.....Pizza crust is my favorite and I wouldn't even eat the crust because it was so hard and over cooked. Ended up eating one slice, throwing the whole pizza in the trash and cooking dinner at home. Worst pizza experience in years read more

Great service - good pizza and really nice drinks and dessert (cookies). You can even keep the bill reasonable if you're smart about it. BUT the "ranch" dressing is the worst salad dressing I have ever had in my life. It's like someone mixed sour cream and water and blanched the lettuce in it. It is awful - get some Costco or Hidden Valley on those salads and this is a five star spot read more

I had only ever gotten slices of Otto's in Cambridge and loved it, so was excited when they came to Exeter. Ordered a to-go order of two large pizzas and 2 Ceasar salads and the bill came to $75! Perhaps I'm old school, but since when should that amount of food cost that much (even with "inflation")?! And while the pizza was good, it didn't blow me away and was cold by the time I got home (5 min away). I will probably stop in for a slice occasionally, but that's it. read more

My daughter and I tried Otto recently and can't wait to go back. We ordered a Cauli / Shroom and a 4 Cheese to go. Online ordering is easy and has great flexibility for customizing your order - she added sauce to her 4 cheese. Both pies were delicious, savory, great texture, and plenty of toppings. Looking forward to trying other flavors!! read more

I've tried Otto twice. Same issue both times, good pizza horrendous service. First time: dined in. Hostess fouled up the wait list. 15 minutes turned into 45 with multiple tables seated before us because she crossed our name off the list even though I was standing right outside and she had contact with me multiple times. An "I'm sorry " tossed over your shoulder is not the way to handle the problem. Once inside the service was okay and the pizza was good. Second time: ordered online, given 6:50-7 for pick up. Arrived at 7 left at 730. No apology, it looked like no one knew what they were doing. Pizza was also good. Otto I want to love you but your service and management is horrific. I pizza is worth this level of abuse. read more

Delicious pizza. Fast, efficient service. Got it to go so didn't have a chance to review the restaurant.

Best Caesar salad! Really great service and pizza. We are making this out "go to" spot! I do wish they had reservations or a waitlist but the wait was worth it read more

Food is completely not worth it. We had to wait for an hour and they tried to convince us it had only been 15 minutes since we had ordered. Even though the time on the receipt said otherwise. If this is on your mind for food tonight choose somewhere else. read more

Our new favorite! Especially during happy hour. Great bourbon old fashioned. Mashed potato pizza. Or Margarita pizza. Live their red sauce and crust. Cozy bar area. read more

New to the area, we have been trying out all the local pizza spots and after many, many disappointments, we found OTTO. Delicious, creative, the best crust ever, and an inviting place to eat in. We have both ordered takeout and dined onsite, and our experience has always been top notch with quick delivery and great service. read more

Let's be clear - the two stars is because when the pizza is right, it's a great pizza! Not being told the wait time for a takeout order is over an hour after ordering IN THE RESTAURANT is unacceptable. We sat at the tables on the takeout side that were "seat yourself" and as a group of 7, we used two normal sized booths. We were told the water glasses and carafes were only for the restaurant side and that we were not to use them and as you can imagine... waiting an hour for the food and the during the time you're eating the food... you get thirsty. As we were finishing our pizza, the manager came and started picking up our pizza boxes and told us that she got complaints that our "trash was taking up tables." It was uncomfortable to tell her that there was actually leftover pizza in those boxes that we would be taking home with us. It's a little funny to call their own pizza in pizza boxes trash! After she still insisted we clear one of our two tables and squish 7 into a single booth... no one sat down to use that table and one person in our party pointed out another takeout table that had been completely empty the entire time we had been there. Such an odd encounter. More recently the pizza we ordered old school was not prepared old school and after being told it was (I had to actually show her the pizza twice for her to understand because she told me I was wrong and that what they'd prepared was old school) and we were told we could wait at least 20 minutes for another cheese pizza that was actually made old school. This takeout employee is not new and I'm surprised she didn't see the error when I showed her. The three stars not earned is due to the lack of care for the customer experience. Communication is so important. Proper training and positive attitude on the takeout side seems to be a recurring issue. And yes, I did reach out to the restaurant before just posting a review. read more

Ordered a plain cheese to try the quality of the pie with out all the fancy toppings. Pizza was really greasy and not very good.

Have been to Portland Otto's a few times , nice to have one close. Ordered online takeout pizzas on a Saturday afternoon ,had a butternut squash pizza and a four cheese pizza * note if you want sauce need to specify "Old School Sauce "and side salad .All were good,prompt service easy pick up. read more

Having been very impressed with the Andover location we were pleased to find out OTTO was in Exeter 10 minutes form our house. We called ahead for a party of 7 earlier in the day but told reservations were for parties of 10 or more. No problem for pizza this good we would take our chances. We arrived and were told 45-55 minutes, again no problem this is about the only pizza I would wait that long for. At 35 minutes into the wait the host said they were too busy and the manager had told her they would not be seating anyone else for the night. We eat out 4 nights a week and often run into glitches in service but I felt the manager should have stepped up and not left a young girl to tell patrons that had been waiting for sometime that they could not seat them. Again I did not eat at this location and can say that the Andover location has the best pizza around. Hopefully Exeter can get things in order and have the same success. I did email Eric yesterday based on his reply, but have not yet received a response. read more

I was hoping it would get better but it hasn't. Our pizza always comes so soggy or so chewy it's uncomfortable to eat it. And the warmer they put in the take out side isn't super safe. I burned my fingers pretty significantly on it. The high school help is to busy chatting or on their phones to care about the orders too. Missing half an order today. Last time going there. So much for a good pizza place coming to town read more

OTTO - Basic cheese pizza or soggy piece of dough - Pizza Near Me - Exeter, New Hampshire

Horrible Service and Customer Experience! It's pizza that is also marketed and sold frozen in the grocery store and the Exeter Otto location staff are about as bad as buying a frozen pie although the grocery store worker probably has better manners. We were greated at the door with a nasty look on a Saturday afternoon at 130PM. Four hungry kids and the woman glared at us and simply said "We don't have anything available for you for at least a half hour. As we stood there contemplating our next move , the manager came over and said "Even though it looks like we have tables available we don't!" In disbelief we simply exited the building and will never go back again. We are Exeter residents and will simply scratch this place off our list. No reason to be rude when your getting a $150 lunch group in, but hey their pizzas are $25 each and Exeter Otto won't last long here anyway. I just hope the next restaurant takes a better approach to customers. Station 19 didn't make it in this location and neither will this sad excuse for a restaurant. Back to Flatbread....don't waste your time with this pizza....Beware! read more

Bartender was very rude when I asked what beers they had on tap. So rude that we didn't even order anything and got up and left. Will never go back and would not recommend them to anyone. read more

Love Otto pizza! Ordering online, not so much. Do try the mashed potato, bacon and scallion!

I ordered 2 pizzas a salad and garlic bread online on Friday night. Super easy ordering. My husband was able to leave his shift at the hospital and pop in to pick up our dinner with no problem even though it was packed on a busy Friday night in Exeter. Food was so yummy- the spicy pulled pork was new for us but we always get the mashed potato bacon which is soooo good! read more

Otto has two different types of ovens depending on where you order from in the beginning I was getting my pizza or Newburyport the Pizza's were always burnt. They never follow the directions but then I tried the one in Exeter, New Hampshire, and they use a an entirely different oven system when I order from them, I never get a burnt pizza. the people who work there are extremely pleasant. They have gone out of their way several times to accommodate. I would personally like to thank the Exeter New Hampshire store for going out of their way, and helping me out in a situation that due to no fault of theirs or myself, it was the delivery company. An employee of that restaurant when they finished shift delivered a pizza to my house personally, I was very appreciative. This was after ordering a pizza through the delivery company twice and waited for 2 1/2 hours one time and over three hours the second time. I personally would like to thank them. The owners of the company should consider every employee of the Exeter pizzeria as a major asset to the company Thank you kindly read more

Ever since Luigi's closed (hopefully temporarily) in Portsmouth, I've been searching for a replacement to satisfy my pizza tooth. Otto in Exeter has proved themselves to worthy of comparison. I ordered a large build-your-own online, adding blue cheese to a large cheese. The crust was delightfully chewy. My one criticism was it was a tad undercooked for my liking, but I could have and will ask for it to be cooked well-done in the future. The sauce is delicious, reminiscent of Regina and the cheese combination reminds me of a Papa Gino's consistency. Generous dollops of blue cheese covered the entire pie. Ordering online was easy and efficient. read more

SO glad they opened in town. Pizza is very tasty and bread id is to die for. Service is okay depending on the night. Would eat here again

Great food great service wonderful time. Would recommend to anyone really good pizza. Meatballs are awesome.

Try the mashed potato pizza... amazing!, so many great and out of the ordinary options..

Best Otto we have had in a long time. First time from Exeter. We ordered 13 pizzas for take out for a birthday party they were all cooked perfectly and the customer service was excellent. Thank you! read more

Terrible pizza greasy oil dripping. I gave them a star should have been less. the pizza was good when they first opened. don't recommend. take out order from the person that took the call wrote down wrong order didn't listen. after I told her 3 times what I wanted . Exeter location read more

The food is low quality, pizza is greasy, and a lot of time the service is quite slow. I don't find it worth the wait and it just isn't good. read more

I ate there with family last evening. The pizza was very good. Service was excellent. However. . . . DO NOT order the Tiramisu. It is NOT Tiramasu; it is simply vanilla pudding sprinkled with cocoa powder and cinnamon. That for $5.95 when I can get REAL tiramusi at my Market Basket for $4.79. Maybe Otto's dessert bakers should check with Market Basket's bakers for a recipe. read more

Great pizza. Ready when they tell you! Variety of pizzas served many family members tastes over the holidays

We love the food and the customer service is excellent. I accidentally ordered the wrong pizza and the team was able to fix it with my online order. They even still delivered earlier than expected. Our favorite pizza place in Exeter. read more