Always unreal. Been to Both locations (Centerville & Downtown) in the Dayton area and have always been super pleased. Super consistent, priced well, and good drinks if you're up for one (or 2 or 3) I enjoy the Centerville location because how spacious it is and there is typically not too long of a wait if any. Today I tried a 9" lunch special for the first time and when it was paired with a half salad it was extremely filling. No doubt I'll continue to enjoy this Za! read more

Old Scratch Pizza - Deluxe - Pizza Near Me - Centerville, Ohio

See all

Best Pizza in Ohio!!! Atmosphere on point, great food, beer and staff. Thanks for bringing an exceptional experience to Ohio!! Also, must try is the cauliflower angry bee keeper - delish! read more

Always delicious . The Angry Beekeeper is one of my personal favorites and I usually like to check in every 2 weeks to see what vegetable/pizza specials they are running. Some of my absolute favorite things are specials that get rotated in and out. Everyone at the Centerville location is exceptional. Amazing staff, excellent service. read more

Amazing Pizza similar to a Neapolitan style crust. Tons of flavor. Excellent pepperonis

Came here for lunch with some friends! You walk in, order, and the staff brings the pizza out to you! I got the lunch special which was a 9 inch pizza for $9. I thought it was a pretty good deal! I got the blanc pizza and enjoyed it. Lots of seating and nice space! Staff was friendly and service was quick! read more

Old Scratch Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Centerville, Ohio

We had been to this restaurant in downtown Dayton so we knew that this place in Miamisburg would be good. We were not disappointed. Their basic formula is that you can order the pizza of your choice (their combination with either marinara or white sauce or build your own) and then head over to the bar for your drinks (good selection of craft beers for us). The wood fires ovens are constantly going so the pizzas are ready quickly and brought directly to your table. Then you can hang there with your pizza and beer (and get another beer on your tab), enjoying the atmosphere and watching TV. This place must be packed on college football weekends! Glad to know that we can either go local or head downtown for a great experience. We will be back again and will bring family and friends. One note for the management: since you don't have the volume up on the TVs, you should turn on the closed captioning! read more

I travel a lot and of all the places I've eaten pizza OS is the best. Very food allergy friendly!

Great pizza, great salads, great experience. I've become a big fan of the online ordering and curbside delivery options.

We love Old Scratch Pizza! And, my husband was born in Italy The pizza has a thin, delicious crust with super fresh ingredients. The salads are amazing and the roasted cauliflower with romesco is so good! The icecream for a good cause is the cherry on top. read more

It's good but not my favorite, their ice cream is very good :) and the service is good too!

You cannot go wrong at Old Scratch pizza. I've been here several of times and keep coming back! My favorite pizza is the beekeeper. They also have divine salads. The half salad and one pizza is a perfect portion for me and my husband. They also have an affordable kids menu that my three year old enjoys. Their kids pizza is in the shape of Mickey Mouse! read more

Best pizza in town. Neapolitan style pizza and tons of craft beer choices. We will be coming back again and again. Also, the carafe wine is delish and served authentic. Update to say: if you are coming in a group and plan on paying separate, use Venmo. Have one person order and pay that person your share of your order through Venmo. I was behind a group of eight tonight that each paid separate and took about 20 extra minutes to order. read more

Old Scratch Pizza - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Centerville, Ohio

See all

Very good pizza A+ . B+ with their craft beer selection. The mushroom pizza is my favorite. The chicken bacon ranch is a great one as well.

The Centerville location is so delicious and consistent. We usually order to pickup and our order is always ready on time. Both the bacon ranch salad and the Mediterranean salad are fresh and so flavorful. The meatball appetizer is savory and filling. We have tried several pizzas: Angry Beekeeper, Mr Scratch, Sophie Mae, Shroom. They are all wonderful and reheat beautifully in a nonstick skillet. read more

ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS!!! My pizza is perfection every time I go. I recommend you give it a try. read more

The pizza is amazing. One of my favorites. The atmosphere is ver family oriented. Large bar area. Service is always great!

If you haven't tried Old Scratch Pizza in Centerville, Ohio...you need too! We love the Angry Beekeeper pizza, so yummy!!!! read more

Thank you Old Scratch for coming to Centerville! This place is amazing! It starts with the people. They have a great culture here and everyone who works here does it with passion. Always very friendly, helpful, and they make it fun. The location is great. Lots of parking, tons of seating, and a huge bar. They have about a dozen TVs and several video games to keep everyone entertained. We always sit at the bar. The bar has an excellent beer selection and they take pride in supporting local craft. They also offer wine and cocktails. The punch is excellent and the Bloody Mary will change your life. The pizza is one of the best I have ever had. Baked in wood fired ovens imported from Italy. They have a great pizza menu or you can always build your own. They are an organization that believes in paying it forward so they do a fundraiser for a different organization every month through their cones for cause project. In the end if you love awesome people making awesome food supporting awesome causes, you will become a regular here. read more

See all

Ok place if you like to not get waited on. Stand in line to order your pizza..stand in line to order a beer. Randomly seated beside people you don't know to dine. Very family friendly place. Kids running everywhere..I mean everywhere. High quality ingredients just not my type of floppy pizza. My kids love it but just not my cup of tea. read more

Old Scratch Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Centerville, Ohio

Great pizza and appetizers and this is a very nice casual place to eat and hang out with friends and family. The beer selection is good and tastes great! The staff is very friendly and the restaurant is clean. They gave a nice outdoor eating area too. read more

I'm old school pizza, more cheese, more dough the better. I'm not a fancy meatball, little mozzarella balls type of pizza lover, although I was surprised that I did live the flavor of this unusual crispy, crusted pie. But, what I especially loved about this place was the cold alcoholic beverages and full bar options. Nothing goes better with fancy pizza than some alcohol. This place has a fancy pizza joint feel that has collided with an upscale sports bar and has zero of the nasty bar ambiance that will make other parents turn their noses at you if you admit to taking the whole family. In fact, this is a great place to take the whole family. The seating is spacious, clean and has an open and airy feel. It offers plenty of light, even in the freakiest day. The menu is something that really takes time to study, especially if your a pizza old schooler like me, but be open to trying. I noticed too, that the side of the establishment has garage doors that can be opened up in the warmer months. I don't know what it is about places with garage doors opened up in the summer that gets me excited, but I'll be back to experience that. Too bad we live in the armpit of America and the garage doors wont be opening up to a sandy beach of an ocean or the crashing waves of lake erie... don't get excited, it's just a paved parking lot. read more

See all

Seems like things have changed here... We have been here three times since they opened. The 1st time, right after they opened, we ate in the store, and the pizza and sandwich we ordered were pretty darn tasty. The 2nd time was during the last year with the whole covid thing where you would call JM an order and pick up at the back door. Those pizzas were kind of awful. I'm sorry. But kind of felt the the way 'Real D' felt? Maybe it was whomever was making and cooking the pizzas. Well, the lovely Mrs wanted to meet one of our friends who lives close for dinner here. So we went, ate in, and I hoped that things were back to what we had during our initial visit. Well, the Italian sandwich was indeed, delicious but the pizza(Sophie Mae, white pizza with onion jam and bacon bits) was a bit less than I had remembered. Something has obviously changed, the pizzas base was as very thin, and not cooked? It's hard to describe but think of a lasagna noodle but a pizza crust? There was nothing to it? I left thinking I'd, for sure, do the sandwich again but I'm not too sure I'll ever try a pizza again. My favorite part was the ice cream cone? If you head up to the bar, donate some cash, they will hand you a soft serve ice cream cone which was delicious. read more

Old Scratch Pizza - Carbs.... mmmmm... - Pizza Near Me - Centerville, Ohio

I've been here a couple times with the grandkids. They have a really nice selection of pizza. The restaurant is huge, but very very well-maintained. Clean. The beer selection is also very impressive. BTW, the beers are for me not for the grandkids. read more

Ordered take out pizza and was surprised with the result when I got home. I ordered a gluten free marinara pizza with meatball and red pepper toppings. I did like the gluten free crust and that old scratch even had a gluten free option since many pizza places do not. However, after paying extra for both toppings, I was disappointed with the quantity for the extra cost. It appeared as though one singular meatball was cut up and placed on each slice individually and there was barely any red peppers as well. Definitely not what I expected. I would give them another try but the first impression wasn't great. read more

Old Scratch Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Centerville, Ohio

See all

There pizza is simply incredible!!! And nothing short of it and the ambiance/vibes of the place are AWESOME don't really know how to explain but it's chill and like warm and it's a comfortable cool place to be you can watch the game get ice cream or beer or whatever other alcohols they have I usually just go for the bomb.com pizza haha but of course in a place like this you can expect very good customer service!! Very and relaxing! They've even got the kitchen exposed it's pretty much the brightest spot in the building so the youngsters can go and check out how the pizza is made pretty cool to see even for adults haha but the dining area is kinda like dim warm evening setting pretty 1000% recommend!!! read more

Dirty tables, dirty floors, and dirty preparation but prices that one would find in a much higher quality restaurant. I saw some disgusting stuff that the kids making the pizzas were doing. Interesting variety of toppings but very light in quantity and not evenly spread. Two of the eight slices had no toppings. Whoever made our pizza didn't care at all. Noise bounces around so loud talking is necessary in order to hear others next to you over the children on the other side of the room. Chairs are horribly uncomfortable. read more

Always delicious, creative food, great service, and good value in a fun environment!Thanks, Old Scratch!

OH MOMMA MIA THATS A PIZZARIA!!! Love this second location room to move around and people watch. The pizza extra special crunchy,chewy crust baked in a stone ovens. Hot n ready to devour. Smacking my lips loudly between sips of cold craft beer. To all Dunkers...Dunking your crust into a garlic oil is a must to! Giant heads if cauliflower hit the ovens too a must try...assortment of rabbit worthy salads! Grab the hubby,friends or family you'll love this place. read more

For the life of me, I can't understand what all the excitement is about this place. It offers unique combinations of ingredients, but that doesn't make them better pizzas. In fact, we thought it made them worse. We ordered two different "personal" pizzas, ate 1/4 of each, and pitched the rest in the garbage. They were okay but nothing worth schlepping home and certainly not something I wanted to eat again. They were expensive, too, comparatively speaking - about twice the price of pizzas elsewhere. The decor is pathetic - like dining in someone's unfinished basement. What gets me most is the logo and the name. I didn't know this before I went in there: "Old Scratch" is a euphemism for satan himself, and after I learned that, I looked at the logo again. It looks like exactly that. The pizza fits the name. read more

I love that we have this location closer now to us! It is huge too. Ton of picnic tables inside. Same quality pizza that you find in their downtown location. As always, gotta get the angry beekeeper. All of their apps and drinks i've had are fantastic too. Can even get soft serve ice cream for dessert and donate money to a good cause. read more

Old Scratch Pizza - Pizza? Say no more. - Pizza Near Me - Centerville, Ohio

Was ok pizza , I wasn't crazy about the cafeteria style ordering & seating , the menu was pretty vague in my opinion.... I'm not a drinker so the bar area was of no interest to me..... just not my personal preference of a place read more

I didn't care for the pizza , we purchased 3 types of pizza , I tried all three the cheese was the best , just didn't care for the crust . My family gave it a 3 read more

Cavernous Pizza joint with 20 craft beers to choose from. I don't drink beer but the Pizzas were great!! The Shroom (mushroom with white cheese) was yummy. I especially loved The Angry Beekeeper (spicy sausage drizzled with honey) with a slightly sweet tomato sauce was wonderful! Great place to go to try some new gourmet pizzas ! But Old Scratch means The Devil ... so it makes you wonder the owners intention. We don't need more evil in this world ... read more

See all

Food was okay, nothing special. Crust was burnt. Wouldn't come back. Too many other great options in Centerville. read more

Old Scratch Pizza - Burnt crust - Pizza Near Me - Centerville, Ohio

Everything was so good! We just ordered out because it was super busy on a Friday night. Angry bee keeper was the favorite but we tried 4 different pizzas and they were all delicious. We will definitely be coming back. read more

The pizza has a nice buttery crust with plenty of topping to tantalize your taste buds. Seating is picnic-style. Decent beer selection. Family atmosphere. read more

I love that they have vegan options! Everything is so good and the staff is very friendly read more

Came here before a movie because it was close and we'd never been before. The inside is a lot bigger than it looks, plenty of places to sit as well as a good sized bar area. You walk up to the counter and place your order, they give you a number and then bring your food to your table once it's ready. We tried the Angry Beekeeper pizza (red sauce, fresh mozz, spicy salami, fresh basil and house made hot honey) and it was really good. I'd never had honey on a pizza before and the sweetness went really well with the saltiness of the salami. They're wood fired pizzas that are stretched pretty thin (which is my favorite) and I really enjoyed the nice charred areas of the crust. Girl at the counter and the bartender were really friendly and welcoming. The girl who took our order helped us decide by answering our questions since it was our first time. The pizzas are kind of the equivalent of a typical medium (6 slices) and we were starving so we also split an applewood bacon ranch salad. Salads come in two sizes and the small is advertised as feeding 1-2 people. Let me tell you, this salad was HUGE. It had really nice chunks of bacon, house made croutons, cherry tomatoes, purple cabbage and romaine tossed in a really delicious ranch. We had a hard time deciding on a salad because they all sounded so good. Price point was around mid range. I think the pizza, salad and one beer we ordered was around $30ish. We will definitely be back again sometime to try more things on the menu. read more

Old Scratch Pizza - Angry Beekeeper pizza with what's left of our bacon ranch salad in the background - Pizza Near Me - Centerville, Ohio

We love this place! The pizza is incredible, the location is really fun for families, and the staff is on top of everything. Just writing this review made me hungry for the angry beekeeper. read more

Fantastic! The pizza is great. The crust is perfect. So many delicious selections. Excellent salad. The atmosphere was amazing. Good service. read more