My husband and I have grown tired of every pizza place in town, EXCEPT Old Scratch Pizza! The ingredients are delicious and the sausage is homemade. Most places have started buying cheap ingredients, and its obvious in the flavors. We don't buy any other pizza anymore. read more

Old Scratch Pizza is a tasty spot to get your own personal sized pizza. Whether you are gluten free, a picky eater, or just wanting ice cream, Old Scratch has something for you! Keep reading to find out more! My family recently moved to Centerville just a day before we visited Old Scratch. However, my dad, who had come just a few weeks before, tried Old Scratch and praised it highly. He was very excited about bringing us there for multiple reasons, including the great atmosphere, the high rise gluten free crust, and the free custard. Eager to find out the hype, we decided to check it out for lunch. When you walk in, the place looks massive. There are lots of tables and the ceiling is high, unlike what you see from the outside. You order at the counter, which has a giant menu displayed above it, as well as special deals and promotions. The young man taking orders was very patient when we asked for a few minutes to scan the menu. After we decided what we wanted, he eagerly listened and recorded everything we wanted. I ordered a Margarita Pizza and the House Salad. Immediately after we ordered, we were able to fill up drinks and find a seat. I only ordered a water, but from the looks of it, there were lots of good drinks to choose from. My fruit obsessed self remembers the diet lemonade and house made drinks, like one called the Farmer's Punch. We filled up our waters and made way to a table in the back, passing by the open kitchen where you could see the chefs working. A few minutes later, our salads were brought out. This included one Caesar Salad, one regular House Salad, and one House Salad made gluten free. A few minutes after finishing our salads, the gluten free pizzas were brought out, followed by my Margarita Pizza. Let me just say, they were the highest rising gluten free dough I have ever seen! It looked so good! Unfortunately, the Prosciutto and Arugula pizza my mom had ordered wasn't brought out for another few minutes. I don't know if they forgot, or messed it up, or what. Other than that, we really didn't have a bad experience. After devouring my pizza, or at least two slices, I was ready for custard. There wasn't much flavor variety, other than the choice of a cone or bowl. However, it was the perfect way to finish off my meal! Overall, Old Scratch Pizza is a great restaurant that can hit spot for anyone! They offer gluten free crust, salads, fun drinks, and it is of course picky child approved! Thank you for reading and I hope you visit Old Scratch if you are in the area! Follow for more reviews! read more

See all

This is a great spot for a casual date night or night out with the family. The price point is reasonable, but it still feels like you're getting a really special meal. We went on a Friday night and were able to grab seats at the bar and had no trouble with a long wait. The layout of this place is not your typical sit down restaurant. You walk up to the counter and order, they present you with a table flag, and then you find your seats. Your food is brought out to you by the wait staff. They also have a full bar with a heavy focus on rotating drafts, but also a very fun cocktail list. I ordered the white pie and added arugula to the top. My husband ordered the shroom pizza. Both had a white base that was so garlicky and cheesy and just so delicious. We both really liked each one. The pizza was a good size, I couldn't finish mine. We each had a cocktail as well, I tried the Texas water which was excellent and he had a blood orange margarita, also good. This is a great neighborhood spot and we will definitely be back. read more

See all

Our favorite pizza in town. Staff is pretty friendly and accommodating. Always a good time.

Old Scratch Pizza is delicious. We enjoy their Dayton pizza with nice crispy pepperoni and their Applewood Bacon Ranch salad. Take out or dinning in their restaurants is equally satisfying! read more

We did take out tonight and it was ready when promised and brought it out to the car. It was very tasty and everyone enjoyed what they ordered! read more

Ordered take out. Four different pizzas. Order was almost done. Attendant was courteous, and double-checked the order before handing it over. The place was quiet at 3:30pm. read more

It's such a rip off. The pizza is good, sure. It's marinara and mozzarella on dough. ‍ And you pay $14.95. The waitress insisted these are Personal pizzas, but unless you're a 17 year old boy, no. But at the same time, there's nothing on them! She asked if I needed help ordering, and I said im looking for vegetables, and she said there's basil! Ok there were 4 pieces of wilted basil on our six pieces. And ours was barely cut. We had to rip it up with butter knives. And the girl who brought our food to the table didn't even take the # sign away. It sat there in our faces. (Sorry no pic, we were dying and i was too upset to dig out my phone.) read more

Quality, great tasting food. The employee who met me at my car was trained well--smiled, greeted, used eye contact & was quick.

We love OSP! It's our favorite, from the great service to the amazing food. We are always greeted with a smiling face and our food is always super tasty. Highly recommend! read more

Best pizza ever taste great presentation wonderful lots of variety on time pickup friendly service. Really appreciate gluten-free crust better than any we've had before. read more

I moved out of town from Dayton but still visit family and friends throughout the year. Old Scratch Pizza is always a regular pitstop for me each visit. Family favs include the Shroom (mushroom pizza), the Angry Beekeeper (pepperoni with hot honey), the Mr. Scratch (sausage and basil), house and Caesar salads (my notoriously picky brother and dad love the salads), and finally the oven roasted olives. Clearly we have a lot of favs lol. But everything tastes so good and the pizza crust and ingredients are just top notch! Dining in or takeout has always been a good experience. If you've been contemplating trying Old Scratch, just do it! You can't go wrong. read more

See all

First time ordering and margarita pizza was amazing as well as the garlic bread. Will definitely be ordering again from here.

I thought it was overpriced for additional toppings but the pizza wasn't bad. My family loved it but I thought mine was a bit soggy in the middle- ordered the Mr. Scratch pizza so it wasn't due to a custom order. The kids pizzas were reasonable price and I felt it was a good value. read more

Old Scratch Pizza - Shorty - kids pizza w/ pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Centerville, Ohio

See all

Customer service was great. Food was outstanding. Our group of 5 people had: salad, pimento cheese, roasted cauliflower, and pizza. We all loved everything. The place is really clean, parking is easy, prices were great. Highly recommend. read more

Came here on the recommendation of a local buddy. I wasn't sure what to expect but I was very surprised. Upon entering, I was shocked by how much open space there was. The place was huge. Off in the distance, I could see the beer counter which I loved this idea to separate food and beer. It makes for faster lines. The place was not packed but I could still understand the need for separate places due to volume. After reviewing the menu, there were so many choices. I would recommend them all because they sounded great. I am huge special guy so I grabbed the special of the week. Whatever it was, it had pears on it and it was tasty. I got the small pizza because I was just ordering for me. The pizza was big enough to enjoy twice. I had it for lunch the next day and it was just as good. You could eat half for dinner, grab some brews and enjoy the second half at home with a few more brews. The staff was super welcoming and friendly. They were very patient with all the question I had as well. Service was fast and the place was cool. This place is highly recommended. It is great for big groups (show early as it does get packed) or just small dates. It does get loud because of the open area but it wasn't too distracting to our party All in all, if you are looking for pizza and beer, this is the spot for you! read more

We love Old Scratch pizza! The angry beekeeper pizza is my absolute favorite!! I would also like to add, their cocktails are delicious!

amazing food, never have a bad experience with service and overall good vibes. I recommend Old Scratch to anyone in the south Dayton area

Quick, easy and unique flavors! A real standout in the pizza experience! An inviting setup with great music! read more

I've had carry-out from Old Scratch several times....it's always good and the service is excellent! My favorite pizza is the Angry Beekeeper! It's fantastic with just the right amount of heat! read more

This place NEVER disappoints. The salads are amazing and that pizza!!!! Our son has a dairy allergy and he loves the crust, red sauce, and loads it with toppings. My husband and I cant get enough of the 'shroom pizza. Especially if we add chicken sausage. It's wonderful. The staff at the centerville location is amazing (they probably all are but I can only speak to the Centerville one) . They really aim to please! read more

Great choice of unique pizza in a open festive atmosphere. Sat at the bar and the bartender changed a TV to the Basketball game I wanted to see and was always attentive and communicative. You can also see all of the kitchen activity from this view point. read more

Consistently good pizza! Look forward to trying their creative specials (one pizza and one side) offered every two weeks.

My husband had the bacon chicken ranch, and I had the shroom! Great service, fun atmosphere and delicious pizza! The truffle oil on the shroom was the perfect touch. We thoroughly enjoyed every bite. Our daughter's favorite was the angry bee. She's had it 6 times now. We will definitely be back! read more

I've eaten their pizza precisely once. It was VERY good. I started making my own else I'd buy more of theirs! It's definitely worth a try. Thumbs up I strongly recommend. read more

Wonderful service, as always! A packed house on a Friday night, but the line moves quickly. Enjoy seeing the same familiar faces working and managing this location. Food is consistently served exactly as ordered. Love the variety of menu items! read more

Old Scratch Pizza - Blood Orange Margarita - Pizza Near Me - Centerville, Ohio

Came here for lunch at noon on a Tuesday. You go order first and then sit down. It was very quick and easier to order. Also I've ordered on the app before and it is very nice. The cashier and person that brought our food were very nice. They had a lunch special for a 9" pizza for $8.50. I thought it was a great deal and a perfect size for lunch! Lots of seating options and very open! A very nice lunch! read more

Old Scratch Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Centerville, Ohio

I was Skeptical about coming. I have heard mixed reviews. My husband and I decided to choose old scratch pizza for our date night Friday night. It was very busy but the people who work on the floor and at the counter or absolutely amazing! We ordered the Dayton pizza and added chicken sausage and mushrooms. The crust was delicious the toppings were amazing I was very pleased. We also ordered the large Caesar salad. Great amount of salad fresh delicious right amount of dressing and croutons were great! I'm glad we decided to go and we will certainly return. read more

Old Scratch Pizza - Cesar salad - Pizza Near Me - Centerville, Ohio

See all

I love Old scratch pizza; have been several times; I like the thinner crust cooked to perfection. My favorite is/was the angry beekeeper until switching to more of a plant based/vegan diet. I was glad to hear they started offering a dairy free cheese and tried it today with the margarita pizza. It did not disappoint read more

Old Scratch Pizza - VEGAN Margarita pizza - Pizza Near Me - Centerville, Ohio

Wow! I've heard really great things about this pizza but didn't believe the GF crust could really live up to the hype. I was wrong!!! Best GF pizza I've ever had. And I've tried them all. Everything was perfect. I'll be here all the time now. read more

Old Scratch Pizza - GF the Dayton and margherita pizza - Pizza Near Me - Centerville, Ohio

See all

Amazing pizza !!!!! Cool atmosphere and impeccable service. This is how you run a business !

Great pizza and beer... quick! Stopped in for their lunch specials during the week and great service. Pep Rally white pizza was bomb.

The pizza is good, without a doubt. The crust stands out as premium - it is really good. There are so many options for pizza that you can get more food for the same price (just about anywhere) and enjoy it all the same. So a big part of my rating is about price, more so than taste. Service isn't really expected here so that is not an issue. The ambiance is warehouse-like. It's great if you are bringing a big crowd - plenty of space. Not a warm and cozy space. This is not my place to go based largely on price. I come here only when other people want to go. read more

Amazing Pizza similar to a Neapolitan style crust. Tons of flavor. Excellent pepperonis

Bee Keeper pizza is the best! Service was fast with friendly staff everywhere. Add a delicious salad and we both are satisfied. I'm

$11 carrots way over priced for such a tiny amount. Love the pizza but this order of to go carrots was so small not even enough for one. I've ordered these for dine in before and you get 4 times this much. Super disappointed read more

Old Scratch Pizza - Their special carrots $11 for hardly even 1 carrot. I've order them before to dine in and it was easily 4 times as much . This was pathetic - Pizza Near Me - Centerville, Ohio

We can always count on Old Scratch for great pizza. Whether at the restaurant or carryout!!!!

Visiting my folks in Centerville -- was looking for a vegan pizza. Ordered a vegan shroom and a margherita pizza online. Quick and easy process and friendly staff when I picked them up. And the pizzas disappointed quick. Will have some again when I'm in the area. read more

Great pizza, laid back place, great for big groups. We love eating here with friends. A staple for us - love this place!

Love the pizza but it's become more and more expensive with scarce toppings. Great family atmosphere. Great choices with original unique types of wood fire oven pizzas. read more