Food: The burger this time was drenched in sauce, so a little disappointed with that aspect. Fries were not that salty this time! Yah! Service is you order at the counter and you get a buzzer when your food is ready to come and pick it up. Ambiance-. It's located inside precarious beer project. Lots of long tables with benches, and some bar seating as well as a few couches and tables. read more

See all

Great burger, great service, great atmosphere Had some bbq burgers with fried onions and jalapeño, horseradish mayo. Best burger I've ever had. Underrated at 3 stars. read more

See all

As a fry lover, these fries might be the worst I've ever had. They are sooo undercooked and under seasoned. The burger was as dry as a bone. I definitely wouldn't eat here again. read more

I love burgers. It's pretty bad here though. But you're stuck, so maybe it's still the best you can find here? I'm not sure. The fries were ok. My burger came without any mayo or ketchup or anything (didn't ask for any alterations). It's not inedible though, maybe this is what people refer to as "mid" these days? Pretty sure every ingredient could be bought at the local supermarket. read more

2/15/25. 1 PM Spent the morning walking around Williamsburg. The hubster suggested burgers. I'm open. But I'm also picky. When I want a burger, I want a juicy , full flavored, soft bun, culinary experience. Three of us ordered the OG and I ordered the monthly special. The line was relatively short so we ordered rather quickly. We were given a buzzer to let us know when our food was ready to pick up at the counter. And then we waited......and waited...then waited some more. It was quite awhile so my husband was getting ready to tell them he thinks his buzzer was broken! Then it buzzed. It was about a half an hour before we got our burgers. I can't imagine the wait on a busy day. Canned sodas came with our order but we had to wait in another line for cups with ice. The burgers and fries were what I wanted them to be. The long wait was a 30 second distant memory as we sunk our teeth into these delicious burgers!! read more

Ol' Dominion Burger Bar - Burgers Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

See all

Old Dominion Burger is a fast food burger place in the Precarious Beer Hall. The burgers are thin and presented on buttered buns. They have different toppings to make your burger more interesting, like BBQ sauce, or blue cheese, among others. The fries are good with a spicy seasoning. You order at a counter and get a pager to alert you when your food is ready. This is a fun place to visit with lots of games like air hockey, pinball, and other large games, plus big screen TVs. Parking is across the street, with the first two hours free. read more

See all

This review is like the classic novel by Charles Dickens, A Tale of Two Cities. I ordered the OG Burger and fries. Pretty basic order. On one side, you have a decent smash burger. Not bad yet nothing spectacular. The burger alone was a 3 star burger.... on the other side, we have the fries. HOW DO YOU FUCK UP FRIES ???? Its like they are trying to be the Temu of 5 Guys. Your fries come in a cup with some extra in the tray. Unfortunately, the person dropping them into the fryer and then removing them from the fryer jacked up step 2. My fries were so undercooked, they were damn near raw inside. The potato was very firm and the fries were half cold. Obviously they failed Fry 101 at Old Dominion University.... If you want a decent burger swing by. Anything more than that, keep driving, or just hit the taco joint around the corner inside the building. Update: Came back to the beer hall with some friends a few days later. A few guys had the burgers and they were ok, but AGAIN, the fucking fries were undercooked!!! Come on now folks how hard is it to get this right??? But that's not the kicker.... was in using the bathroom, and saw the cooking from this establishment walk out of the shutter and leave the bathroom WITHOUT washing his hands!!! He's making our food for Christmas sake!! Where is the health department when you need them???? Someone is gonna contract the Black Death from either this guy's unsanitary habits or his shitty fries, not sure which... Anyway, avoid this place if you value your safety and health..... hence going from 2 stars to 1 star.... well deserved.... read more

This was more of a 3.5. The food was good. I got some wings )kewl ranch dry rub) and some fries. Both were very good and well cooked. This was a food counter, it was clean and the staff was personable. The order took over 45 minutes, that was tough. Get the speed of service figured out abs this place will be really good! read more

Ol' Dominion Burger Bar - Burgers Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

Maybe I'm a bad person, but I ordered this burger expecting to make fun of it. It was this concoction of brie, balsamic, fried onion, and I don't remember what else, but there was stuff.... It was in the top 3 burgers I ever had in my life. It was so good. And even a single patty (there was an option for more patties) was very filling. Downsides? The fries were just OK. Not bad, but just OK. The wait time was a little much, although it WAS Friday night so that might get a pass. And there were a lot of children....which this place has no control over. And I have children. I generally like children. But like......a LOT of children. BUT that aside, I might go back tomorrow because the burger was that good. read more

The food was very good and was ready pretty quickly. There are lots of kids running around because it's inside an arcade. Not a fan of canned / bottled sodas in restaurants. I prefer fountain drinks so I can get a refill. It was overpriced, but it's Williamsburg. read more

I know it doesn't sound like much, but their beef hot dog was one of the best hot dogs I've ever had. Their dirty fries are also delicious. Reasonably priced and geniusly located inside Precarious. Get the hot dog. Get the fries. So good! read more

Ol' Dominion Burger Bar - Hot dog - really good - Burgers Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

See all

Undercooked burgers and fries.. some fries were over cooked and hard. The burgers were extremely inconsistent.. a couple were ok with small raw spots. My son's burger was barely cooked. Noticed halfway through him eating. Games are cool but way overpriced for an arcade. Cool concept and they definitely have a crowd but for $86 (5 people)... yeah, you can find better. read more

Ol' Dominion Burger Bar - Burger - Burgers Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

Great options inside the Precarious brewing location. I had the ground beef nachos and my husband had the nacho fries. Both were excellent. No table service so head to the counter to order but they will bring it out. There is also free water if you need it but the beers from precarious were great read more

Ol' Dominion Burger Bar - Nachos - Burgers Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

Overall: 2/5 it does not know its identity. Seemed like it tried to go an old style diner burger yet had fancy modern flavor profiles that did not hit the mark. Food: 2/5 the burgers and fries were not worth it. Above average for price and the amount of food you get. The Creeper meant to be spicy, but completely lacked any heat and couldn't even tell if it had any flavor. The Veggie burger fell apart and somehow was overcooked. The fries were simply crinkle cut and had Cajun/Old bay seasoning for $5. Way overpriced for these! Atmosphere: 3/5 great place to hangout since it's styled like a food hall. They had games, some restaurants, and good seating inside with limited outside. It can get very noisy here. Service: 1/5 not sure if it was the timing of the season and day, but it took an extremely long time to order our food (30 minutes on Sunday around 1300). It then took around another 25 minutes for the burgers to come out. read more

Ol' Dominion Burger Bar - Creeper and veggie burger - Burgers Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

Kinda surprised by the 3 star rating overall. I grabbed a smashburger (The Rodeo) and it was awesome. I got a double and it was a big ass burger and it was amazing. I didnt get any fries or sides but didnt really need them after I saw the burger. The food came out quickly. This location is inside the brewery and is super convenient given the location. read more

This review is strictly for the food at Ol Dominion. Precarious beer project is awesome in and of itself. We ordered an odb burger abd the nacho fries with beef. The burger was so saturated in sauce on both sides of the bun that my husband scraped everything he could off, threw the bun out, and just ate the patty. Now for the fries. The meat was cold. The fries soggy. The guac looked like it came out of a tube and I am still wondering if the soupy stuff in the bottom was supposed to be the queso? The place wasn't busy, and we still had a wait. I have zero problem waiting for good made to order food, but this was a trainwreck. read more

Burger is a 7 out of 10 and fries were a 7 out of 10. The burger was constructed well and the beef patties had good browning but the bun (maybe brioche) ruined it for me. It was not toasted and it was too soft that it would not of held up if I did not take bigger bites. The fries were crinkle cut but a little soggy and over seasoned. The price to portion did not see all that bad but I would only eat there again if I was in the food hall to drink. read more

This is a decent joint. There's a lot going on there, and it's kind of a sensory overload, but the food was decent. It's in a sort of food court, so be aware if you go further in, there's also a brew bar and there is also a taco place. It is not full service. You order at the counter and they give you a pager for when it's ready. If I wanted full service, I'd go to Mellow Mushroom on the other side of the building, but the Burger Bar is a great fallback plan if the wait is too long at Mellow Mushroom. read more

Ol' Dominion Burger Bar - enu and prices - Burgers Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

My kids got the hamburger and the chicken tenders and seemed to like them well-enough, but the parts I had were only OK fast food, which made me happy I got the tacos which are also located in precarious beer project. The fries were fine if a bit overly seasoned. The burger was simple and a bit too salty. read more

The service was amazing and the burgers were perfect. Just perfect, it was not loud and it was very peaceful. I would love to go again read more

Ol' Dominion Burger Bar - My amazing burger and fries - Burgers Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

Burger was average and fries were not good. Half the pieces were overcooked and burnt. I couldn't understand it. I looked at Yelp pics and my fries looked nothing like the ones pictured. Buns on the burger were too dense and stiff too. And it wasn't cheap. I should've listened to the other Yelp reviews but I decided to chance it. I lost. read more

Ol' Dominion Burger Bar - Double smash burger with burnt fries - Burgers Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

Doesn't really jump out except for the neon lighting in the window. Walk in and find out that none of the food is customizable. Like seriously. If you don't want mushrooms? Too bad, so sad. A member of our party wanted just a cheeseburger and the guy behind the counter smirked and said "we don't have 'just' a cheeseburger." He seemed quite amused by the dilemma of the picker eaters in our party, tbh. Now I ask you: how can a place that bills itself as "best burger in town" be so against making something their patrons would like? Asking for a friend... Ok, that friend is me :-) read more

Hate to be a naysayer, but I don't know what the other reviewer's are talking about. This is one of the best burgers in Williamsburg definitely my favorite. Hit them up on Thursdays. They've been doing a Smashburger special: fries, smash burger, and a draft beer from Precarious all for $15. What an incredible value. read more

Ol' Dominion Burger Bar - I forget which one this is, but here's an example of a Smashburger - Burgers Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

See all

Amazing burgers in a really great establishment! We stopped by around dinner time and tried their burgers (we had the ODB and the pimento cheese) with some fries and we were not disappointed. Their ODB is the best in my opinion. read more

See all

Always stop for a beer at Precarious when we come to Williamsburg and was surprised to see that there has been an expansion. Couldn't turn down a smash burger so I went with the First Rodeo I believe it was called. Never had a burger with bacon jam or bbq sauce (I'm typically a cheese and ketchup only kind of person) and I thought it was fantastic! Fries were pretty good too, maybe a little too much seasoning but that might be my taste. Will definitely be incorporating into my Precarious tradition. read more

Stopped at Precarious Brewing and decided to hang out on a Friday night to hear the comedian. But my wife and I were hungry. No problem--Dominion Burger is right there. So we ordered the nacho fries for a snack. It was a mound of food covered in drizzle of various sauces with the tiniest bit of guacamole perched on top. As soon as we tried it, my wife knew she couldn't eat it--it was so salty, greasy and full of msg flavor that it was amazing. Maybe some people are used to that--and such food is engineered in the lab to appeal to our taste buds--but it is really nasty for those accustomed to preparing fresh, quality food. Service was fine and we enjoyed the comedian, but I think the only way I avoided getting sick--I didn't stop immediately the way my wife did--is that I went home and took a serving of activated charcoal. Will never touch anything from this place again. read more

Veggie patty has a grit to it on the outside that taste like they dipped it in the sand. Fries were way overcooked and the grease needs to be changed. They gave me "fresh" fries when I returned them and to they credit refunded them because the 2nd batch was very soggy. Very disappointed. Customer service was good, food just wasn't salvageable. Save yourself the trouble and go elsewhere. read more

One of the best burgers I've had was the pastrami seasoned burger. We ate here twice it was so good. They had other burgers that were good too. Didn't try the nachos but the chicken was a little bland. read more

I don't write many reviews but I have to leave one here. When you pay $34 dollars for a burger, fries, tenders and two cokes they should be half decent. The burger was cold, bland and was not the one I ordered. secondly the tenders for my son were so bad that he wouldn't even eat them. The fries were good though....... read more

The prices are outrageous the hell am i spending 15 dollars for some fries that arent even cooked fully loaded up with stuff that wasnt even on the menu read more

Line was slow (but whatever on that). 3 canned soda options - I went elsewhere looking for sodas while my husband stood in the long line. But the actual reason for the one star was the disgusting, fatty, all dark meat chicken I was served. I only eat chicken, the family didn't complain about the burgers, but never in my thousands of chicken sandwiches have I ever been served a non white meat Nashville chicken. And again, as if that wasn't off putting enough the amount of fat and cartilage in said sandwich that was inedible - gross. read more

Maybe I've just had too many good burgers in California, but think that my burger lacked just about everything. It was dry and had no flavor. I thought it'd be good based on reviews, but no it wasn't and I was very disappointed. read more

This place is in walking distance to work so it's a quick option. Burgers and fries are good. Almost $20 for double burger with fries and no drink. Beer Hall attached with arcade games and a very large selection of craft beers. read more

First, it took forever to find this restaurant. Actually it is a stand inside a craft brew restaurant. Once we found it, I was not impressed with the person at the register. He did not give us a lot of guidance on the menu. We ordered the simple burger with the restaurant's sauce on the side. My husband ordered fries as well. The burgers were okay, yet nothing spectacular. The fries had spices on them that did not appeal to me. Overall, not that impressed for a restaurant you cannot find! Also, it was so. loud inside we had to sit outside. Between the blaring music (if you can call it music) and the loud games inside the brew pub area, there is no way to carry on a conversation or relax inside. read more

I went with two friends to Old Dominion Burger on Wednesday evening. We ordered three burgers, three fries and nothing to drink and our bill ended up (with a tip) at $58. The fries were lukewarm and seasoned, the burger I had, which had goat cheese and onion relish, was underwhelming. I asked for mushrooms and they said they could take things off a burger, but not add things. The other two burgers were OK but nothing to write home about. What a disappointment! I would not waste my money going back there when there are so many other great choices for burgers in town. read more