We recently moved here and had a craving for pizza. After looking over all the different spots and checking out the reviews, we decided to give NYPD Pizza a try. We called in our order initially for delivery but were out of their delivery zone, they are kind enough to give us 10% off since we decided to come pick it up and we were not disappointed. The medium pizza was way larger than expected and it was fresh, with crispy crust and not greasy. And the wings were spicy enough. It may be a bit pricey than a pizza hut but trust me this actually taste like New York pizza and will fill up the whole family. Bookmarked definitely in our Arizona spots. read more

NYPD Pizza - Vinny's Pizza with the spicy traditional wings. - Italian Near Me - Avondale, Arizona

For some reason, I was expecting a more takeout pizza shop. NYPD Pizza is a full service sit down restaurant. (Being a pizza place, there is still a takeout line.) Dining room is a fairly decent size. Decor is Italian New York. Red walls could meke the space feel small, but large mirrors and high ceilings keep the space feeling open. Texture on the walls adds to the old world feel. I love the vintage looking tiles on the floor. Mini framed Broadway musical posters are little touches of NYC. Menu has pizzas, appetizers, salads, wings, pastas and calzones. Pizzas are made with New York water. We ordered a Joey's Favorite Pizza and the SOHO Salad Pizza. Joey's is their classic vegetarian pizza. My children said they were VERY hungry. Rather than classic NY style, we went with the Sicilian style pizza. This pizza is thick and rectangular. We ordered it extra crispy as recommended. Crisp bottom and fluffy center were an enjoyable textural contrast. Plenty of toppings on the pizza. Sauce is well flavored. FYI, this pizza does take much longer to cook. Thankfully the SOHO Pizza Salad was out sooner. Salad was fresh. All the toppings worked well together. Pizza underneath was not crisp as described. Pizza was more chewy. It probably absorbed moisture from the salad. Still an enjoyable pizza/salad. I would be torn as to ordering the Sicilian style pizza again or trying one of their NY style pizzas. A large Sicilian style pizza and pizza salad was more than enough for all of us. We left with leftovers. Service was friendly. Our server checked on us several times during our visit. He did apologize for the wait. Someone else, maybe a manager came around asking people if they were doing alright. read more

See all

I had the Greek salad and pepperoni pizza . It was delicious! Excellent customer service ! The manager /gentlemen , truly went above and beyond ! Hard to find good customer service and good food these days :) read more

We had a group of ten people for dinner. Quick service for us. The traditional wings are very good - had honey and uptown. Garlic knots hot and fresh. Pizza was good had a couple different kinds. Meatballs were big. The penne ala vodka - sauce was average. Overall, they can handle a big group and the service was fast and the food was good. We come here once a year when we are out for a golf tournament. read more

Love coming here on saturdays kids eat free and I enjoy the Buffalo Caesar salad. We also got the meat lovers pizza they were good.

This place is awesome, we are always treated like gold here and the food is absolutely amazing!

Excellent pizza service is great a little slow but you expect that when everything is made fresh, can't recommend this place enough excellent food excellent service read more

Let's start with the customer service, lots of young people very nice customer service. The food was definitely good ! This place had its own unique taste in pizza. The boneless wings were decent not my favorite. Definitely recommend the bone in wings instead. read more

Our server was very nice. In fact , she was the best from our entire experience at NYPD. We are somewhat of a pizza snob ( hometown New Haven , Ct ) where pizza is rated the best in the country ( Dave Portnoy -One Bite App) where the bar is set. The Margarita Pizza not only lacked flavor, the sauce was minimal . The Pie was just plain awful ( just no flavor ) and such a waste of money. The server (Brook) was the only bright spot . read more

Amazing! I was dying of hunger after having had chemo this afternoon, and pizza sounded so good. This did not disappoint! I had the Big Kahuna Hawaiian which was thick and tons of cheese with the pineapple, Canadian Bacon and fresh Basil! I also got an order of San Gennaro Zeppolis Fried and tossed with powdered sugar, these little nuggets of pizza dough are so sweet and tasty. Served with Ghirardelli chocolate and raspberry sauces.oh my goodness, each bite was a little taste of heaven! I will order from them again. I have to stay in hotel while here for cancer treatment, and the order was delivered to my door within an hour. Just one thing.... I asked for paper plates and napkins since I'm in a hotel, and also some ranch dressing cups, which they did not send, but other than that, it was great. read more

See all

Love this place, amazing service and ambiance. They have great pizza selections and my fave salad in the world the strawberry fields

Burnt overpriced pizza, and if you send an email about the poor service they won't even respond. read more

NYPD Pizza - Cold, hard, burnt pizza - Italian Near Me - Avondale, Arizona

I just ordered my pizza and it was cold. Wtf Kali get some pizza that is blending and creamy when ordering.

Super friendly service, and their pizza is the closest to tasting like Ny pizza! Highly recommend

I was on a traveling work business and after a long hot day, this place was near my hotel. And you can say I went into a food coma right after downing the whole box. Pizza was fresh and hot. The crew on shift were very polite and friendly. Personally, it's a classic pizza that exceeds my expectations. read more

I love bringing my son for dinner here! Never disappoints!! Hell's Kitchen wings are my favorite! Go see Stephen, he provides great service every time! read more

My absolute favorite place for pizza! Can never go wrong with the Big Kahuna pizza, the Upstate Wings and the fried mozzarella. The service is amazing, they're very welcoming and are always checking up on you. The environment is very welcoming and well decorated/lit! read more

Rude service! No one greeted us. We tired walking further in then they decided to walk towards us and wanted us to go back to the entrance and wait to be seated! he started saying how they were busy but the place isn't packed and he and another server are just standing there talking and laughing. Very unwelcoming place read more

Had margarit pizza. Absolutely terrible. Mostly crust not nearl Enough ingredients just big waste of money. Never again read more

I went to NYPD before and it was so delicious. New York Style Cheese pizza is my favorite! read more

NYPD Pizza - Getting a New York style cheese pizza! - Italian Near Me - Avondale, Arizona

See all

Looking for a good East Coast pie? NYPD is as close as I've found to a true NY pizza.

The pizza here is awesome-the cheese is really good and the crust tastes like New York pizza. Nadia was super nice and gave me some great recommendations. Their ranch dressing is homemade and was great with the pizza-we will definitely be coming back again. read more

Tried the lunch special of any slice and a salad for about eight bucks. This was a giant lasagna slice which had beef meatballs, ricotta and onions on some thick dough. It came with a large salad that had raspberry vingarette dressing and some good croutons. The hostess is a bit pushy, but still a good lunch for price, but they never heat the slices up enough. read more

NYPD Pizza - Lasagna pizza - Italian Near Me - Avondale, Arizona

See all

Great pizza and service all around! Is our new go to place for pizza at restaurant or to go!

NYDP has reallly good pizza. But if they have a bad manager everything suffers. Luckily everytime I've had a bad experience the people above the middle management make things right. read more

Really tasty pizza and good kids meals. Kids eat free with a large pizza (or entree) on Wednesday and Saturday. Don't come on Sunday and expect the deal lol still the food is worth it read more

Delicious! Perfect spice on the Hell's Kitchen traditional wings...& the boneless...*chefs kiss* pizza was also great!

Easily the best NY style pizza I have had outside of NY. The staff was polite, and helpful. The ambiance was cool and clean. Large Pepperoni Pizza - Great Garlic Cheese Bread - 12 is too many, but it was great Marinara dipping sauce is great read more

NYPD Pizza - Cheese Garlic Knots... :) - Italian Near Me - Avondale, Arizona

My family had dinner this evening and our pizza, garlic knots & salads were delicious! Steven was our waiter and he could not have been more pleasant or accommodating! He made our dining experience even more enjoyable! read more

I ordered a personal pizza and salad directly from the restaurant to be delivered to my hotel. After all of the great reviews, I went with the meat lovers pie. Sadly, it was underwhelming. It was light on toppings and the flavor was dull and bland. I included in the comments of my order my room number, and still was not given any napins nor plastic ware. Tough to eat a salad without a fork. I was able to eat part of it after I decided to just think of it as a weird veggie tray. Next time I'm in Goodyear, this will not be on my list of joints to visit. read more

I love this location of NYPD. We have been going since I was 8 and have truly never had a bad experience here. I love their food and their housemade ranch is a dream. More importantly, the service is constantly incredible. I never feel compelled to go out of my way to reward good service but my husband and I felt like it was necessary to let their manager know how kind our server was. They are usually pretty understaffed so sometimes a little slow so it's not a quick eat kind of place, but we love to celebrate birthdays and date nights here. read more

Worst calzone EVER!!! The calzone was stuffed with so much ricotta cheese , that the bread was gooeyand not cooked well all the way thru.

Gave this place another shot today. I ordered for delivery and the customer service was good. I stand by my previous review that it is pricy for what you get but the food was more satisfying this time. We ordered 2 my'za pizzas so we could split them and try a little more than we could otherwise which is nice but 8.50+ is a little much. The Buffalo chicken pizza was not our thing. It tasted more like hot sauce rather than Buffalo sauce and that kind of messed with the flavor. There was also cilantro on it which made the whole overall flavor kind of confusing and overwhelming. However, the pizza wasn't stingy on the ingredients so for someone who would like the flavor this would be a well made pizza. BUT we also got the Brooklyn pizza. That was very good. The crust was crispy and not burnt. The sauce was very good and the ingredient ratio was perfect. Not super saucy or dry without enough sauce. It was perfect. I'm very picky on my pizza sauce and I love this sauce. I'd highly recommend that one. We also ordered the fried mozzarella which was good. It came with the marinara sauce and balsamic vinegar reduction sauce. I like that they're not arrogant enough to charge extra for that like some places. Both sauces were fine. The mozzarella itself was really good. Overall I'd probably order again but I'd have to keep the price in mind. read more

See all

Today is Friday and I feel like pizza. Full video review: https://youtu.be/yGLO6T2U9Dg I ordered take-out because everyone is still social distancing and restaurants are still not fully open. There are many pizza restaurants to choose from, but I knew I wanted to go to NYPD Pizza. I had been there a few times before but had only ever ordered their lunch special, which is two slices and a soda. Based on my lunch special experiences, I knew I wanted to do a full review of NYPD Pizza. NYPD Pizza doesn't disappoint, the food was good and the service was great. They have a neat menu with items like The Big Kahuna, Vinny's Favorite, and the Al Capone Calzone. But I didn't order any of those items today. I ordered a pizza pie, but I couldn't order just a pie, I wanted to do a proper review and so I ordered several other items as well. The first thing I ate was an appetizer. I got the Garlic Cheese Knots. The knots weren't really knots at all, they were balls. I imagine they were probably traditional pizza dough knots at some point in the past but have since become pizza dough balls. But don't that that minor detail turn you off, indeed these little balls were packed with flavor. The garlic was there but not overpowering, and NYPD was generous with the mozzarella cheese. Additionally, the marinara dipping sauce at NYPD is really good. Overall a good appetizer and a good start to my meal. The next thing I tried was another appetizer. This time it was the panko-breaded fried mozzarella which surprised me when I opened the box to see flat mozzarella patties. I have only ever had fried mozzarella in stick form, so it was a nice surprise to see a flat patty. I dipped the fried mozzarella into a sweet balsamic vinegar dipping sauce. Again, a pleasant surprise and a good match with the fried mozzarella. The next appetizer I tried NYPD's chicken wings. I ordered the Honey BBQ wings and the Hell's Kitchen Wings. The first wing I tried was a Honey BBQ wing, and I wasn't impressed. It didn't disappoint, but it was the just same as every other honey bbq wing I have ever had. Then I tried a Hell's Kitchen Wing and I was impressed. Not only was it fiery hot, like mouth-tingling hot, but the flavor was really good, no let me correct that, the flavor was great. The Hell's Kitchen Wings might be on my all-time favorite list for wings so far. It's worth mentioning here that the chicken wings themselves were of high quality. They were large, meaty, and cooked perfectly with a slight crisp. After the appetizers, I moved on to the main course, the pie. Since I am a meat lover, I ordered The Wall Street, a pie topped with pepperoni, sausage, bacon, and mushrooms. The first thing I noticed when I opened the box was that the crust of the pizza seemed a little undercooked. The dough wasn't raw, but it wasn't crispy either. It was on the softer side and I had doubts as to whether it was going to be good or not. My doubts were quickly put to rest when I took the first bite. The pizza was topped generously by the folks over at NYPD Pizza. They didn't skimp on the toppings, which so many places seem to do these days. The flavors were great with a special shout out tot he sausage. I typically try to avoid Italian style sausage because every time I try it, the overpowering flavor of fennel seed is just too much for me. But the Italian sausage at NYPD Pizza was really top-notch, not at all overpowered with fennel seeds. All and all, yeah, I would have looked my crust to be crispy, but every other aspect of The Wall Street pizza was great. Lot's of cheese, high-quality toppings, and a generous amount of toppings across the pizza. I will order it again for sure, but I will ask them to cook it so the crust is crispy. OK, the main course was finished and I moved on to dessert. I ordered two desserts because, well because, two is always better than one. The first dessert I tried was the San Gennaro Zeppolis. Fried dough balls coated with powdered sugar, these little treats were awesome. They came with two different dipping sauces, a chocolate sauce, and a raspberry sauce. Both of the sauces were great and the dessert overall was something special. If the classic donut hole had a big brother, these would be it. The second dessert I had was a slice of New York Cheesecake with a little caramel drizzled on top. Again, a huge winner in my book. While I love cheesecake in general, a good New York style cheesecake always tops the list. I was so full that I ended up only being able to eat one bite of the cheesecake, but the wife was eager to help, so nothing went to waste. NYPD Pizza did many things great. There were there a few things that could have been better, like the pizza crust and the honey bbq wings. But overall those things weren't that bad, and the things that were done right were really done great! NYPD Pizza is a little on the expensive side though so be sure to keep that in mind. read more

See all

If you are interested in destroying your bathroom by all means eat here. Enjoy your burned over cooked over priced pizza while choking down the wings which were flavorless and clearly not handled correctly (see above bathroom destruction) you may be asking yourselves, well that seems harsh. This is literally the second time in 6 mos this restaurant has gotten me sick. I really used to love eating here but I'm officially out. read more

Vegan cheese (daiya) and gluten-free crust. The gluten-free crust is pretty basic: rather hard and flavor-neutral. The toppings were legit. The jalapenos were nice and spicy. I'd like to taste more pizzazz in the red sauce. Great service. Our order was ready for pick up on time and the staff was friendly. An agreeable place for plant-based and other diners alike. read more

Good pizza, wings, cheese covered garlic knots. We ordered out here last Friday after arriving in town. The estimated deliver was 1.5-2 hours, But we got it much sooner than expected. The driver forgot the cheese garlic knots apologizing he had taken so long and forgotten. He explained he was the only driver and would be back ASAP with the knots. A lot of other places would have just said sorry, we'll reimburse you, so I appreciate his effort given he had so many deliveries. We had a large group with varying pizza preferences we were trying to please and everyone was happy. The leftovers even heated up well. Will definitely order from here again next time I'm in the area read more

Tried it once before and had a good experience. Unfortunately, our 2-9-23 purchase did not make the grade or worth the cost. We had purchased two large pizzas. One was supposed to be a pesto chicken but ended up being on off the menu grilled chicken breast and they were very stingy with the chicken. This time they did not open the box to show us if it was good to go. Stupid me allowed my first positive visit to not even think of checking. Our Joeys favorite pizza also had a scarcity of veggies. I ended up paying for overpriced bland flatbread. Shame on me. AZ Pizza Co. would of been a better choice and I hate to say it but maybe even Barros. Only advice I can give is to follow the crowds. read more

Was upset at the poor customer service this place has. Ordered the bruschetta pizza and the online menu does not mention onions anywhere in the ingredients. Got my $30 pizza and there were onions everywhere. Making it to were I couldn't even try the pizza. Called to ask for a refund and they refused because the onions are in the bruschetta mix, so there for, it's pretty much my fault for not knowing what was all in their interpretation of bruschetta. Even though I told them you still have to have it listed they begged to differ. So now i have to throw out a $30 pizza. Also order another pizza and we explicitly said no mushrooms. Guess what they were still on the pizza. Wonder if that's our fault too???? Will never order pizza from here again. read more

They are rude, screw up the orders and blame it on the computer. Lost another customer.