Stephen S. Is the absolute GOAT. Some say the LeBron James of service! Friendly domineer, positive and attentive service truly brings this place to the next level. Ask for Stephen and expect a smile when leavin'. read more

This is the extra celery I paid for to have with my wings. Disappointed is understatement. read more

NYPD Pizza - This is the extra celery I paid for to have with my wings. Disappointed is understatement. - Italian Near Me - Avondale, Arizona

We really enjoyed NYPD pizzas location in Phoenix so we came to give this location a try. We arrived or a pretty empty lunch time which was great because we were seated right away. We started with salad and zucchini as an appetizer while we decided on why pizza to get. Our server was quick to bring our drinks over. Once we ordered our pizza it took quite a while and that's when we were informed they made it wrong so they were remaking it. While I appreciate that they told us we were literally starving at that point. While the pizza was good it was a big doughy like they were in a rush to get the second one out. Service was good and we left so full. Inside is pretty nice. I loved the large mirrors it makes the place feel larger when the light hits them. Even with the mishap we'd come again. read more

See all

First time here and I don't think u will go back. I tried the margarita pizza and it had no flavor. I had to put salt on my pizza who does that well I had to because that's how bad it didn't have flavor. I did enjoy there honey hot wings but other then that I don't think I will go back. read more

NYPD Pizza - Margarita pizza - Italian Near Me - Avondale, Arizona

See all

Place was one of the best around. Last few times we've ordered absolutely disappointing. So many places start great and then just seem like the passion is gone or something. Not sure if it's management or workers that just don't care. But definitely will not be ordering from them again. read more

NYPD Pizza - Hope you weren't expecting salad with your salad or reduction sauce with you Mozz - Italian Near Me - Avondale, Arizona

See all

This was my first visit to the establishment. I was greeted by the staff with unprofessional jokes directed at me, even made the cashier feel uncomfortable. The individuals preparing the pizzas clearly lacked basic skills in pizza-making. I specifically requested that both pies be cooked well done. Unfortunately, the cheese pizza and the Margherita pizza were both bland and flavorless. The Margherita, in particular, was severely undercooked, with raw dough in the center. This left me with no confidence that the food had been prepared in good faith or with proper care. I did not feel comfortable bringing the pizzas home. Instead, I went to Barros to provide my family with a proper meal and to avoid any potential cross-contamination risks from the original order. The overall experience reflected a clear lack of attention to quality, food safety, and customer service. I brought my concerns to the manager; however, witnessing how unhinged and unprofessional his staff behaved in his immediate presence gave me serious concerns about his lack of control. It left me wondering what might occur behind the scenes. Very unprofessional. read more

Ordered the Brooklyn family, a small pepperoni pizza, and a salad. Everything was awesome- as always. This is the first time I've been to this location and they knocked it out of the park. What used to be an "east side of town" favorite is nearby and I couldn't be happier. Everything was flavorful and amazing! read more

total of $40 for a mini and a medium pizza with 3 toppings. Almost 45 minute wait. Pizza was okay but not outstanding to warrant the price. Will probably not return.. read more

I moved to Goodyear and wanted to try something close by. The pizza is delicious but way too pricey. Staff is very friendly and I say the same for their downtown Phoenix location :) read more

empty restaurant and a long wait is just some BS especially when they tell you it's only gonna take five minutes and it takes a lot longer than five minutes read more

It's hard to find good pizza that is consistent and NYPD always is good. They have a menu with a variety of options and everything is good. Tonight we ordered a large pepperoni pizza and boneless wings. The large pepperoni pizza is cooked to perfection and not all greasy. You can tell some love was put into this pizza. The wings were lacking a little tonight. They usually come a lot saucier and I asked for saucy, but they came really dry. This is like the only time these have disappointed. The employees are always very nice and acquainting for any replacements. The restaurant is very cute too. My review is a 8.5 read more

Went to NYPD on Sunday afternoon. I don't have the name of our waitress. I'm sorry I don't have it because she paid no attention to my complaints about the cleanliness of the floor around our table, the chairs and the table top. She was completely disinterested in making our discomfort better. If there hadn't been 9 of us, we would have left. If I had paid the ticket, I wouldn't have given her any tip. Sadly, this place used to be really good; but it's gone downhill the past couple of years. The pizza and wings were good - the salad wasn't fresh or plentiful. Considering the other reviews I see, I wonder if they're from actual customers or perhaps employees. read more

This was the first time we have been to this restaurant. Our experience was fantastic! We were greeted by Nadia, who was super friendly and very conscientious about our allergies to gluten and dairy. We had the meat lovers pizza and loved it! We will definitely be back! read more

We went to NYPD on Saturday for lunch and this is no ordinary lunch I haven't seen my nephew in about a year and we wanted to spend some quality time together and have a really nice lunch so I thought NYPD would be good since he's never eaten there before. When we got our large pepperoni pizza it was so hard couldn't even cut it with a knife and a fork. It was very disappointing especially the first time he's eating there. And then I got a 10 inch gluten free vegan pizza which of course was only good the first two slices when it was hot. Then after that it wasn't edible just like the pepperoni pizza.. Very disappointing he got chicken wings which that was the only thing that everybody ate all of. Needless to say there was pepperoni pizza and vegan pizza and it was four people eating with lots of leftovers. The bad thing is I gave him a couple options to places to eat and he picked NYPD cuz she's never eaten there. Bad bad experience. And nobody there smiles not sure if they are happy at their jobs or not it'd be nice to see somebody smile the atmosphere I guess didn't feel happy or pleasant. This is the first time I've ever wrote a bad review.. read more

This is our family's favorite pizza spot! My four-year-old absolutely loves it. The staff are always so kind and genuine, and the restaurant is always clean. No matter what we order, it's always delicious. Our server, Stephen, went above and beyond during our visit. He took the time to acknowledge my son, and now my son always remembers him. On our last visit, Stephen even remembered my son's name--that was the sweetest thing, and it made our experience extra special! read more

I finally found my go-to pizza place in the far west valley!! Our friends picked up some pizza on Pie day so lots of places were pretty busy but you'd never know with the attitude of the staff at NYPD. We also had no idea they closed at 8 and called a little before to order they said no problem and were happy to make it. The customer service was awesome and the pizza was so good!! My husband is a bbq chicken pizza connoisseur & he loved it! It was loaded too, every piece had plenty of chicken & onions. The pepperoni was perfect, not too greasy, not too thin, good amount of sauce, flavor, even the crust, I added some crushed red pepper to mine. We were really satisfied and hope to dine in soon! read more

NYPD Pizza - Pepperoni and bbq chicken pizza - Italian Near Me - Avondale, Arizona

1st timers , the people there were great and helpful. Will definitely be going back . Best Sicilian pizza my husband and I have ever had.

I reached out as requested after my last review but never heard anything further. But in spite of that, we decided to give this place another try today. We ordered two pizzas to take out, one small pizza and one medium. When we opened the boxes, the small pizza very generous with toppings, medium again very sparse, five pieces of sausage on whole pizza. We were so surprised we counted them. More sausage on small one! Same inconsistency, so we give up! read more

Wasn't impressed. Did not enjoy. Ingredients didn't reach the edge of the dough. Not even close.

You can't go wrong with NYPD pizza the crust and dough are good and the toppings as well. Every time I've been inside to pick up my food to go the staff has been great very helpful and nice . I try to go here every time I see there is a sale or special going on and always will can't wait to stop by again for another pizza. read more

See all

Best Pizza I have ever had. Pepperonis, Italian sausage, black olives, onions..Wow. Not over sauced. Crust was crisp, but not too. New to Goodyear. Will definitely be back. Great job NYPD read more

NYPD Pizza - Brooklyn Pizza. With pepperonis, sausage, onions, black olives. - Italian Near Me - Avondale, Arizona

The counter lady which I later found out her name was Natalie, bought my food after my card declined. She was so sweet also so well spoken for a young lady and the next day I came in and gave her a nice tip. And the food was really good too. I must say I haven't been impressed with this pizza joint in a while and decided to give it one more chance and I'll be coming back. read more

There's one five minutes from my house and I love their upstate style wings and ranch every Sunday. Soooo good. I love them. We love this place!! It's got amazing food amazing service and amazing atmosphere. Try everything because you will not be disappointed by anything. I love the attention you get from everyone plus the perfect flavors in every bite. You have to try it I highly recommend it!!!! read more

See all

I have previously reviewed this place glowingly, and the last 2-3 times we've been there it's been a near disaster. Pizza coming out undercooked, food being served out of order, and tonight was the last straw. Soda was flat. Food took over 40 minutes to arrive; my baked zitii was bordering on cold, meatballs hard & dry (old?), and the plating / presentation looked miserable. (See my photo!) I have never seen such a decline in food quality over the last few months; seems like every pizza comes out late and undercooked. Service is clearly massively stressed because the kitchen is blowing it-- our server was kind and doing her best to salvage a terrible experience. read more

NYPD Pizza - Traditional New York Baked Ziti - Italian Near Me - Avondale, Arizona

Customer service not friendly. Pizza just ok. Ordered a personal pepp and sausage and a Sicilian. Sicilian had hardly any toppings and was all bread. I love Sicilian pizza but this was not the best. Especially considering the price. Atmosphere seemed ok. read more

Super tasty pizza We ordered delivery and I was wondering where our pizza was. We were informed that pizza would be delivered by 6:37 pm. I went back later to see if there was an update , and it said pizza was delivered at 6:08 pm. How about ringing the doorbell or knocking on the door. Pizza was yummy but very COLD. read more

My experience here was amazing. My waiter, Nicholas, was very kind and had great customer service, and didn't forget about us in the outside area. The gluten-free pizza is amazing; it's a must-try! Thank you, Nicholas. read more

If you haven't been to NYPD pizza, it's a must! Service is friendly and welcoming. The pizza is flavorful, the honey hot wings are to die for, the sauce, literally everything! Wait! Best part, is they have a lunch deal that is affordable and super tasty! Variety of options to choose from! read more

Service is awesome, pizza is great! Went there the first time with friends and have been back twice since then! Have never had a bad experience (okay, the calzone leaves something to be desired--wayyy too much ricotta and it was cold in the middle---I don't recommend), but they did take the calzone back and warmed it up (still wouldn't get it again). The pizza dough is very good! read more

New Yorker /Brooklyn . This is the real deal in Arizona.Excellent my style pizza tried them all. Best round pizzas any variety in Arizona. Crust cheeses on point as are all specialty pizzas. Excellent boneless wing with a perfect sauce. Don't need to look for better or spend for high end pizza. You might find as good but you will never find any better. Don't need award winning pizzas just authentic pizza as New York or Brooklyn. I don't buy round style anywhere else. That would be wasting my time and money read more

This place used to be a really good value. I've been getting the large antipasto salad for years and it used to be have so much more in it. Now it's just a chopped romaine salad with some tomatoes, olives, some small pieces of salami, chunks of cheese and a few mushrooms, not at all worth the $15.99 they charge. No more artichoke hearts, pepperoncini, or red peppers. It used to be brimming with a variety of meats and cheeses. Anyway, this is the third time in a row that I've had this romaine salad with a little meat and cheese, tomatoes, mushrooms and olives. I really don't think I'll be back. Sad, because it used to really be awesome! What happened? read more

I am from NY and know pizza. I been going there for a while and something has changed. I dont know if it the ingredients a new pizza maker or what but the pizza is no where as good as it use to be. The pizza is becoming progressively worse. the last 4 pies have been bad. No joke. The last one was super floppy and fell apart as I picked it up. The price is too expensive to get this type of quality. Maybe the other locations are still good but Avondale spot is not good at all. read more

They are very slow tonight wanted for over five minutes for server .... Tho is a normal hangout for us for Pizza. Let's see if they do the pizza right tonight, as last time it was off , and we began the night with slow poor service. Food was much better tonight! read more

I really like the pizza here rare for me in Arizona definitely worth you trying money well spent!

Honestly a tough review to leave. Used to be one of my family's favorite pizza spots in AZ. Haven't been in years maybe 10 and to come back and try it and be somewhat let down was a bummer. Brooklyn family is what we used to order. They changed the type of sausage put on it. The ingredients and even the crust of it just aren't the same. Sill better than a lot of places but not exceptional. Service was decent. The atmosphere is somewhat a vibe. read more

NYPD Pizza - 18" Brooklyn Family Pizza - Italian Near Me - Avondale, Arizona

Great pizza-the cheese was amazing and the sausage was really good. Homemade ranch dressing made it even better. Nadia gave me recommendations and definitely knew what she was talking about-great customer service. I'll be back! read more

Very Disappointing Tonight, we decided to have pizza for for dinner and headed to NYPD to pick up a few pies. On this visit we ordered (1) medium pepperoni, (1) medium Margarita, and an order of San Gennaro Zeppolis with Rasberry and Chocolate sauce. When we called in our order we were given a 30 minute pick up time, perfect. Arrived at the store within 25 minutes, grabbed our order, the girl working the counter showed us our pies and I have to be honest I wasn't happy with they way the margarita looked. I was offered a replacement but didn't want to wait another 25 minutes and have the other pie get cold. The manager then gave me a $15 discount, appreciated. When I got home noticied that the rasberry and chocolate sauce were missing. Called the store and was offered a replacement on my next visit, again, appreciated. Now for the pizza. I really do enjoy NYPD but this visit was very disappointing. First, the pizza, one pie was cold and the other barely warm and to be honest we threw most of both pies out, after eating a slice each. Both pizza's lacked flavor which I haven't experienced before at NYPD. We paid $40.50 after the discount just to toss the pizza's. Just a disappointing expeirence. read more

NYPD Pizza - Italian Near Me - Avondale, Arizona

See all

The pizza is solid. This is one of my go-to's. While it may not be the best pizza I've had, I continue to have it over and over because it's consistently good. read more

Fantastic service & pizza!! Manager went out of his way to make an awesome experience for our kids!! Love this place!

Review is for the service, not the food. We were just in and approached the booth to be seated. Nobody was willing to acknowledge us or even say "please wait, we'll be right with you". We made eye contact with multiple servers and even held out hope that one would help us but instead she turned the other direction without any form of hello or I'll be with you shortly. We left for the other place across the street and were greeted and seated promptly. It doesn't matter how good your food is if you leave guests feeling like an imposition. read more