Next to Cava I ordered a 12" meatball sub. It's very tasty & not messy to eat. I couldn't find the exact ingredients & left before asking but the meatballs don't look like beef. Didn't take away from the flavor. Plenty of seating for big or small groups. Note: 3% charge applied when paying with credit card read more

NYC Pizza Company - Meatball sub - Pizza Near Me - Duluth, Georgia

Went here on a weeknight with a friend. The place is actually pretty small. The ambiance is very laid back and relaxed. We were seated promptly and given menus. We were first asked what we wanted to drink and ordered a glass of House red wine and a Coke Zero. The red wine was brought to the table but my Coke Zero was not. We had a different waiter come by to the table and she was super nice. We never got her name though. I explained to her I never got my soda and she apologized and brought it promptly. The menu had pizza, salad and subs from what I can remember. They also have lunch specials. We ordered a half Deluxe and half Vegetable and a Margherita. There was so little meat on the Deluxe I couldn't tell the difference from the vegetable. We also ordered a small Caesar Salad which was enough for both of us to share. The salad was really cold and refreshing. So many people had been raving about this place. It was good but it wasn't great. It isn't exactly NY pizza either - although pretty close. The undercarriage of the pizza had that slight char and when you folded it to eat, there was that oil drip out of the crust. That's about all the similarities to a NY slice that it had. The table had red pepper flakes but no Garlic Powder. Before anyone comes for me - I grew up in NYC, The Bronx and Queens. I would say it was more like 3.5 stars. The staff is friendly. The pizza was pretty good. The salad was good. My friend said that the House wine was "really good". I would say it's worth a try. Most people I've spoken to love their pizza. It might just be I'm a bit of a pizza snob. I have yet to find a NY slice. But that's hard to replicate when the water is different. My friend that also grew up in NY/NJ loved the pizza. You should go get a slice and decide for yourself. You might love it too! read more

I have been here in the past but it had been about a year since my last visit. When I went this past Saturday I was super impressed. I immediately thought this must be new ownership because Wow what a difference. We were greeted at the door by a super friendly hostess who showed us to a table. Our waitress was attentive and friendly. The atmosphere was wonderful. We ordered a supreme pizza and it was delicious! It was cooked perfectly! I ordered the cheesecake for dessert which I was told they have shipped in from Brooklyn and oh my it was so yummy. Best pizza and best service! read more

NYC Pizza Company - 12" Supreme Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Duluth, Georgia

As a New York transplant, I'm used to being markedly disappointed by most pizzeria's - ESPECIALLY those who DARE to profess to serve NY Style pizza. HOWEVER, at NYC Pizza Company, they live up to their name! Foldable, greasy, slightly charred crust, PERFECT cheese to sauce to toppings ratio. I am at the same time pleasantly surprised and homesick. You WILL be pleased! read more

NYC Pizza Company - 16" Triple Threat Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Duluth, Georgia

Delicious pizza. I especially love the crispy cup-and-char pizza. This is the first brick oven pizza place I've seen that offers large "16 pizzas. Next time I want to try their white pizza. read more

NYC Pizza Company - 14" pizza with crispy cup-and-char pepperoni. - Pizza Near Me - Duluth, Georgia

Excellent service I was first to arrive and she offer a taste of a beer while I was waiting which was excellent so I ordered before they arrived. The pizza was excellent and ambiance. read more

NYC Pizza Company - Great place our server was excellent she was attentive and very friendly and professional and to boot the pizza and salad was all very good - Pizza Near Me - Duluth, Georgia

First time eating here and we had it to go. A large cheese and a custom pizza with pepperoni, onions, olives, and jalapeños. When we got it home and ate the pizzas...so good! We really enjoyed the pizzas! Will definitely be back! read more

NYC has good pizza. This was my second visit, on my first visit we dropped by for cheese pizza on Christmas Eve, amazingly good.... So good I brought my son back for his favorite which is supreme pizza, half just veggies for me and half regular supreme, the 16in is plenty for a group of 4 and cold beer on tap.... Great! Service was great and the restaurant was nice and clean. read more

NYC Pizza Company - Pizza Near Me - Duluth, Georgia

I tried this place and did pick up. Now this is the only pizza place that I've tried. Unfortunately, I do not have hope that Duluth will have really good New York pizza, but as a New Yorker (New York accent), I definitely recommend this pizza place. It taste really good, it was really fresh and it's as close as I think, I will get to good pizza in Atlanta. The service was good and they had my pizza out quick. read more

My wife saw a suggestion for them on Nextdoor so we decided to give it a try. They took over the old Forenza Pizza location near the now-empty Sprouts store. It was kind of funny that all the chars still had a big "F" logo on the back. We were greeted as soon as we walked in and were told to pick any table. Menus were given to us and water was brought by within a minute. Since it was 3pm we decided to make it our dinner and ordered a 16" with pepperoni, onions, bell pepper, jalapenos, and garlic. The Pizza was served in about 10 minutes and the crust was perfectly cooked. While my wife would have preferred the toppings to have been cooked a little more, I kind of like them to be a bit crisp. Overall, it was a good pie and we enjoyed it. Service was very attentive and refills were brought without us having to flag the server down. The only minus is that they are among a growing number of establishments which charge a 3% credit card surcharge. I didn't notice if it was disclosed on the menu, but at least it was noted on the itemized check we received before paying. They do have a special on Thursday. $1.50 cheese slices (with up to 5 topping available for an additional charge) and 50% off beer. We will be back. read more

Great food, great service! Pizza was foldable! Sub bread was to die for! 5* all the way! read more

NYC Pizza Company - 12" supreme pizza and Italian sub - Pizza Near Me - Duluth, Georgia

Excellent and excellent value. My wife likes straight pepperoni and I like the Supreme and we split a large 1/2 & 1/2. They are friendly and have delicious crust with fresh and well-chosen toppings. Generous cheese. So glad to have NYCPC so close! read more

Great service definitely would recommend this place. Everyone was friendly and polite and the pizza was pretty good too. read more

See all

Let me first start by stating two items here: 1) Pizza is subjective 2) If you put the letters NYC in your business name you have zero margin of error if you are not located in the city. I came here for a slice with my wife as we were visiting and passing through. Sadly I wish I kept going and didn't stop. Yes, the people working there were friendly and the place runs just fine. The issue is the actual food. I read all reviews before coming here, especially the owners responses specifically and there was mention of how they stay true to keeping it "like the boroughs" -- for starters each borough is known for doing thing a little different but whether you are in SI or BKLYN or in the city the common denominator is the dough and sauce and yes the water but let's let that slide for now. Making a foldable slice doesn't make it NY. Sourcing the freshest ingredients doesn't either. There's a spot in Austin called Homeslice. I highly recommend anyone who wants a real NY slice to check it out. What makes it a NY slice / pizza? Your guessed it. The ingredients. The owners are from the area and use the exact ingredients found in 99% of the stores in the city. I think the food here is fine but it's not NY. As I mentioned it's entirely subjective and what I like someone will dislike. I recommend they figure out what they want to be first and then solve for that. read more

Nice and friendly staff. Like all restaurants, their prices are too high. The food, in my opinion, is not worth what they are charging. When I order from them, I always pick-up. When I pick-up and pay for the pizza, I am provided the opportunity to leave a tip. For what? For staff doing the least work needed to hand me the pizza? They are not the only ones, but come on. read more

Good NY style pizza. Love their specials on door dash. Delivery is always quick and pizza is yummy for the whole family. We love the light thin crust. read more

If I could give more than 5 stars I would! Literally the pizza my dreams are made of! Best pizza outside of actually being in New York. Light, thin yet crispy crust, plenty of sauce and just the right amount of cheese. Also the best Greek salad! Service was prompt and friendly; love when to-go drinks are offered! I live about 35-40 minutes away and will continue to drive just to eat here. read more

NYC Pizza Company - Regular Greek Salad - Pizza Near Me - Duluth, Georgia

See all

Best pizza and customer service in town!!! And their specials are great, every Thursday they do 1.50 cheese slices read more

NYC Pizza Company - Pizza Near Me - Duluth, Georgia

Came in expecting true NYC-style pizza and honestly... it's not really NYC style. Not even close in terms of crust texture or overall vibe. That said -- it's still pretty good pizza. The flavors were solid and everything tasted fresh. What really stood out was the service. Super friendly, attentive, and welcoming staff. That alone makes it worth coming back. If you're looking for authentic New York pizza, this may not fully scratch that itch. But if you want good pizza with great service, it's definitely a solid local spot. read more

I'm kind of torn on one hand I want to leave that 5 star review because this place is unbelievable. The food is great. The staff is so friendly and helpful. But uh, don't come and make this place over busy. :) read more

NYC Pizza Company - Greek salad with grilled chicken outstanding. - Pizza Near Me - Duluth, Georgia

Very good brick oven pizza. Quick service and pizza dough tasted fresh. Recommend their house pepperoni pizza.

A taste of Brooklyn in Gwinnett - from the crust to the sauce to the fresh toppings - full yum! Friendly, welcoming service. Inside and patio dining available read more

Wait time a bit longer than expected but the pizza was delicious and worth it in the end. We had the meat lovers, which my son loved and the triple pepperoni. read more

Love this place - have been here a few times now and always glad I made the drive to come back. Pizza is extremely good - looking forward to trying some other menu items as well but hard to deviate from the pizza. Lunch specials are extremely reasonable and the people working at this location are so friendly and quick. Great atmosphere with TVs that will have your sports on and casual family feel. read more

i love any ny style pizza. wuick easy and to the point. worth rvery 1.50$ short and sweet the perfect combination

Thankfully, a business in GA that actually gets NY pizza. For those of us from the Northeast, it is highly frustrating to see New York listed for a pizza place and to then spend money on a crunchy and bland mess. This place does it right...easy to fold, flavorful pizza sauce that isn't sugar tomato paste, and damn it's good!!!!! Keep doing what you are doing New York Pizza Company. They are next to Cava for those looking for it. read more

Food and service was awesome. I really enjoyed the antipasto salad and I got 2 slices that I couldn't finish but the pizza was great too read more

NYC Pizza Company - Incredible Regular Antipasto Salad! - Pizza Near Me - Duluth, Georgia

Great pizza & great service! Always able to walk in, order a pie and enjoy a beer while it bakes. Pizza is quick and hot and out before I finish my beer! read more

The staff here is very nice and their food is always good. The pricing is good to, even if you don't want to spend much, you can still order a slice of pizza and it's like having 3 slices in one for less than $4! Even when they're busy and you can see the stress on the staffs face during their rush hours, THEY STILLLLLL produce excellent customer service!!!! That's rare. I like this place and thursdays they have specials on the pizza! read more

I've only had the pizza and it's really good but I'm impressed by the staff every time I go! They are very attentive and offer seasonings like Parmesan and red pepper when the pizza comes out. read more

Coming from a born and raised New Yorker the pizza and service was very good. One slice hit the spot!

Omg! The pizza slices we ordered were huge!! I customized my order which arrived just as I wanted. The store manager is right on top of everything as is the wait staff. I'll return!!! read more

Hands down the best NYC pizza I've had....and I've eaten lots of NYC pizza in NYC! The slices are huge and perfectly cooked and always fresh! But right up there with their delicious pizza is their garlic sauce....definitely the best garlic sauce of any pizza place and I am not trying to oversell it, it sells itself. On top of that, the staff and owner are absolutely delightful, friendly... another BIG reason to love this place. Grab your friends and go...you will not be disappointed. read more

Excellent New York pizza. Decent price. My wife had Greek salad. Enough to feed a family of 4. We will be back soon.

Holy Smokes! So good, all homemade and the crust is perfect. We got the Triple Threat Pepp and it was loaded down with three types of pepperoni and cheese. The Garlic Knots were top shelf too! Will definitely return. read more

First off, pizza was good. We ordered a supreme with extra cheese and no mushrooms. With that said, when I ordered online, I specifically stated no mushrooms on the pizza. The pizza was for 3 of us, and the person buying the pizza is deathly allergic to mushrooms. By the time we realized there were mushrooms on the pizza, it was too late. We had already ate 2 slices. Thankfully, I was able to warn the person who had a mushroom allergy, so thankfully, no ER visit today. To the person(s) taking orders, please be mindful of special requests. Other than that, great pizza! read more

The pizza was excellent. I had gone in the previous day to see what the place was about and they told me about their $1.50 slices on Thursday so I said I'd be back to try it. When I came back, they remembered me so the customer service was awesome. The slices were great, a crispy crust and the pizza while foldable wasn't too soggy either. I will definitely be back. read more

Love the pizza! Brings me back to NYC! This is now our go to pizza place! We eat here at least once a month

Ordered online. Was ready when promised. Staff were friendly. Pizza is fantastic. I will definitely come back to NYC Pizza when I'm in town.

Love the pizzas and the subs. Best anywhere. We really love the Italian sub. The folks are very friendly as well.