Been driving past this place for many months finally stopped in to get some ice cream at scoopjoy located next-door(Great ice cream..btw) I ordered a slice of grandma's cheese and a slice of New York style cheese ..Absolutely surprisingly fantastic. The pizza in the window doesn't look too appetizing.. BUT once they reheat it and cook it properly as an ordered slice, it is fantastic, crispy fresh !! ... well worth stopping in. I will recommend this to the quality of a Bronx style /New York St. style pizza, thin thin, thin, Krispy and floppy depending on what you want. Services extremely fast as I waited four it was 4 minutes for two slices of cheese to be heated, the ambience is very simple pretty much a takeout place but nice enough to sit down on a quick date to get on with your night. I have eaten an over 500 pizza places in my lifetime. This is definitely a great little find here in (Suwanee GA). As far as the the Dave Portnoy rating scale. I would rate this an 7.9. read more

Grandmas NY Pizza - Final result reheated.DELICIOUS!! A Gradma's cheese and a New York style cheese. - Pizza Near Me - Suwanee, Georgia

Love the pizzas although sometimes they are not as cheesy as I hoped. Tried the wings, pretty good too. Will get back to it read more

Grandmas NY Pizza - Meat lover pizza - Pizza Near Me - Suwanee, Georgia

I like the pizza. And I really like the crust. But there is an issue. No gloves? I see that. And I asked for a mini pizza, but they gave me the biggest one instead read more

I had high hopes for this place given the buzz, but unfortunately, it didn't live up to the hype. The crust, which should be the star of any good pizza, was disappointingly bland and rock hard--more like over baked bread than a proper pizza base. The sauce lacked any real depth or seasoning; it tasted like canned tomatoes dumped straight onto the dough without much thought. We ordered a white pizza, a grandma pie and a supreme . All three, oddly enough, were somehow both dry and flavorless, with cheese that didn't melt properly and basil that looked like it was thrown on as an afterthought. I was really hoping this would be our new go to spot when we had the taste for pizza. $87 later, all I had was left with was uneaten pizza and a lighter wallet. read more

I was excited to try this place out. Sorry to say it was FAR from what I was expecting. The sauce was sour and the crust left a lot to be desired. If you're looking for a good cheesy foldable slice, sad to say, this was just not it. read more

Ugh, so sad that this place continues to disappoint as I really wanted it to be our weekly pizza spot. We've ordered about 6 times now so I feel like I can give a pretty comprehensive and fair review. First, the good...pepperoni pinwheels!! They are amazing, the pizza sauce that comes with it is perfect and generous (one cup per knot!). I don't love how much each of these things cost (would love a discounted 6 or 12 pack price!) but will still get these every time. Unfortunately, they are likely the only thing I ever get from here again. The other things we've tried include the fried zucchini, calamari, grandma's signature pie, bbq chicken pizza, a few other custom pizzas, broccoli knots. Where do I begin...broccoli knots were undercooked and raw on the inside both times we've ordered. The second time I called and demanded a refund (these puppies are $5 each!!) and instead was given the run around that they couldn't possibly give a refund but that I could call the NEXT time I wanted to order something and have them apply the amount then. What a bunch of bull and not exactly a legal way to handle poorly delivered goods. I typically am too busy between 2 toddlers and a high stress job to call in a pizza order. I use the online system while I'm in work meetings so I can go pick up on the way to pick up the kids. Needless to say I have yet to use my account credit that they so "conveniently" attached to my phone number... Anyway, that's the least of my complaints. Everything else we've ordered as been dry and terrible. The zucchini and calamari were like jerky versions of what you'd imagine they should be. The crust for the bbq chicken pizza was so bland and dry that even my kids refused to eat it. The chicken on the pizza...again dry like jerky. The grandma's signature was good the first time we got it and the crust was nice and fluffy. This last time we got it? like flat cardboard. WTF. It's hard to mess up bread cheese and sauce but that's what they did. This place has so much potential but has been so disappointing. read more

We came here to try NY style pizza because back in 1999 when I visited NYC never tried the pizza so this is suppose to be the style.The Italian guys up front were good at taking our special custom pizza. That's good service with a smile and an offer I couldn't refuse.Ambiance was casual with music and videos playing for relaxing. The pizza is great!very good crust; Only giving 4 stars because the pizza took to long in my opinion but not too long. read more

Grandmas NY Pizza - NYC style White Pizza Slice - Pizza Near Me - Suwanee, Georgia

Great pizza with fresh ingredients! The pepperoni pinwheel was amazing too. True NY style pizza. read more

Grandmas NY Pizza - Pepperoni with onions and peppers - Pizza Near Me - Suwanee, Georgia

See all

Friendly staff, good service, excellent crust, but the pizza needed twice as much marinara sauce and was waaaaay too garlicky for me. read more

First time trying Grandmas NY Pizza. Had a BBQ chicken pizza and caesar salad. The food was ok but for the price there are better options nearby. I was surprised to see a credit card surcharge of 3% tacked on as a hidden fee. This was not disclosed on the online menu that I ordered from (an online order). Since I did local pickup I didn't know about the fee until I drove there. Probably won't be going back. read more

Great pizza and great service highly recommend just saw it driving by and had to stop definitely coming back

I was looking for a place to have a late lunch with my daughter and Grandma's NY Pizza was a great place to stop! The pizza is great! Fresh ingredients crispy crust and delicious pizza! read more

Grandmas NY Pizza - Supreme Pizza from Grandma's NY Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Suwanee, Georgia

Tried a white pizza with a couple of toppings and it was delicious! The sausage is round and very thinly sliced which went really well with our other toppings. Crust was the perfect amount of crispy. We got to go so can't say much about the service but they got us our food right away! Place is small and cute. Has a small outdoor space too. read more

Momma now grand mamas . Excellent pizza; not what you would expect in Georgia! Clean well lit dining room . Fast and friendly service !

It's in the cheese! There is something about it. This pizza is the best that I have ever had. The cheese is soooo good. The crust is crispy and not too thick. The toppings are fresh. The place has only 3 tables and is not so fun to be in (minus a star) but I will be back over and over. read more

Grandmas NY Pizza - Margherita pizza and pepperoni pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Suwanee, Georgia

We tried this spot while staying at the springhill suites up the street. We had two calzones and one pizza. The kids loved the pizza and not a slice was left. The calzones were delicious. They made my sons incorrect but had no problem remaking and he was super happy. It is a newer shopping center so the area is really nice. For those in a hurry I did see that they also sell by the slice pizza (remind me of home). Don't be in a rush when you order, all the food is made to order. read more

My son and I decided to try a different pizza restaurant than where we usually go. We ordered their featured Grandma's Pie and added sausage. We had it delivered and it arrived hot and fresh. They were generous with the toppings and they were placed thoughtfully. The crust was perfectly crisp and not chewy. We will definitely be ordering again! read more

Grandmas NY Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Suwanee, Georgia

The food here is some of the best pizza I've had and the appetizers are amazing. The service was outstanding aswell. Overall just an amazing experience with an amazing ambiance. read more

Grandmas NY Pizza - Pizza and Cheesy Garlic Bread - Pizza Near Me - Suwanee, Georgia

We had the best meal here last night! I had been craving a Margherita pizza and Grandma's hit the spot. The ingredients were fresh and the pizza was well-made. We also ordered a Greek salad, chicken tenders and fries. The fries were surprisingly delicious and the Greek salad was so fresh. Thoroughly enjoyed everything. Can't wait to order here again! read more

We eat here almost once a week ... the pizza is delicious... would also recommend their chicken strips and mozzarella sticks - both are great! And their salads are always fresh read more

Ordered meat lovers via Door Dash. Less than average. Spent $30 and should have just run up the road to the place I can get the same thing for less than $10. I won't be back. read more

I wouldn't even give a 1 star but I had to select something. I ordered a grandmas pie, zeppoles, and a slice of cheese cake and this is what I received. There is zero excuse for this and they are lucky I didn't call servsafe on them. I would not recommend eating here at all from a food quality perspective!! read more

See all

Great menu. Super service for a night that was slammed due to Super Bowl. Easy parking and store entrance. Bigger menu than I was expecting and happy to see the crew putting out the orders like a well-oiled machine. The pizza crust was good with a solid chew. Sauce ticked the right boxes for flavor. Toppings were plentiful. read more

Great quality pizza, the staff is fantastic. This is our go to place for pizza. Love supporting this business!! Everything we've tried we've enjoyed. read more

Always great pizza and the love to support a local small business! The Grandmas pizza is the best on the menu

The wings were the best I've had in Suwanee. The pizza was amazing as well. We will return for sure!

Ordered online and received an email from GrubHub Delivery. They placed the pizza on the front porch in 30 degree weather without ringing the doorbell, knocking, or texting. $80 worth of COLD pizza. If I go back, it will be to dine in. Can't rate the pizza itself, but since they offer a delivery service online, it is the entire process. read more

Great food and a good price. What seems to be a family run business. My son and I enjoy it every time

We have had inconsistent experiences with Grandmas Pizza. While one order is fine the next is missing something. Last was the take out missing all salad dressing and utensils. It made everything difficult when all we needed was convenience. This was also our first time ordering their Sicilian. It was not very good and the crust was crackery and hard to chew. Definitely vincenzas for the thick pie next time. It'll be a while before we try here again. Too many other options that remember the dressing. read more

It was our first time eating here and all I can say is amazing! The food was so delicious and fresh! Amazing service from the staff. Clean place as well. Portions were very big in size, all of it was so worth it. We ordered the wings, Greek salad, meatball hero and chicken parmigiana! Will definitely come back!! read more

Came to this location after a very underwhelming visit to the Lawrenceville location earlier this week. I think this location was worse. The guy was literally making my pizza without any gloves (or washing his hands before making my pizza). After boxing up someone's else order without gloves, touching the Square machine for ordering, wiping his hands on his pant, etc., he was hands first in the toppings preparing pizza. I respectfully declined and just placed my order for my pasta. When I got home to eat my clams with linguine, there was barely any clams and clam sauce was extremely bland. It lacked basic salt. I really used to love Grandma's when I first started at the Suwanee location. However, I think as they have expanded to more locations, it isn't the same anymore. Food has rolled downhill. read more

I've never been a fan of pizza in general, however Grandmasnypizza completely changed my feeling towards pizza ... I've fallen in love with their pizza and will only eat pizza if it's from them.... It's a definite 5 star for me read more

Even though we were very disappointed tonight, I'm still giving it five star because of my past experiences were all excellent, and tonight was just off or something. We went in just wanting to grab a slice, but given the hour we went, there weren't many options (which was very understandable). We decided to get a Sicilian (I've had a slice of theirs before and really enjoyed it), and I guess I wish we hadn't. The bottom of the crust needed more time to have a crisper texture, but the middle of the dough was very dense; not that chewy/doughy middle I usually enjoy. It probably also could've used more sauce, but that did not bother me nearly as much as the crust. I'd like to attribute it to being kind of late (around 8:30) on a Sunday, maybe a new person making it, or maybe just an off day. I just know I didn't enjoy the half a slice that I ate at all. I'm hoping there is something I can do with the rest of the pizza that will make it better...ideas welcome!! read more

I rarely give 5 star review but tonight was the 1st trip trip for take out with Grandma's New York pizza. Ordered the vegetable and put pepperoni on it had the Greek salad the pizza was outstanding thec sauce was delicious not overbearing but the Greek salad could have had more condiments but was good. Until now Mangia had the best pizza but grandma's by far the better choice. read more

The pizza is totally legit and on point! The pizza place itself has a nice feel to it, and very welcoming.

Awesome pizza. I tried it for the first time and going to change my preferred pizza place!

I will say that both the grandmas pie and the slice were very good. However throwing jalapeños and sausage on top of a premade slice of pepperoni was a fail. All of that fell off as soon as I lifted it up. I will try again but I guess I need to order a fresh pie with toppings to see what it looks like. read more

Grandmas NY Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Suwanee, Georgia

best calzone I have ever had!!for a great price I will make this a spot I will always remember when I'm in the area! and the staff is awesome read more

Grandmas NY Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Suwanee, Georgia

Ordered a pizza for the family for dinner. They made it fresh right in front of us, came out hot and delicious. Staff was very nice. Seating was limited and simple but adequate for after a softball game... Would definitely return. read more

It may look like a small pizza shop to begin with but seriously there is so much more! The food is amazing! The place is super clean, and the staff is really nice! The dessert so good! Me and my family love this place and you should to! read more