We were greeted as soon as we walked in. We came in for pizza by the slice. The guy making pizzas in the back asked what we wanted so he could make us something fresh. The pizza was so delicious! Thin crust, crispy edges, love the taste of yeast in the crust. Sauce was light and flavorful. We also got some wings (not so spicy sauce). My daughter has very discerning taste when it comes to wings. She was impressed (small miracles happen sometimes). This is one of 2 places where she REALLY likes the wings. Wings came out with a nice crunchy outside and super juicy inside. Plenty of sauce too! Oh and if you're a ranch fan, you'll find comfort here. I'm very happy to see that NiMarco's is doing well. This was my favorite pizza place when I was going to NAU in the early 2000's. I don't make it back to town much, but being able to introduce this place to my daughter is a treat. read more

Our group ordered online as we were finishing a camping trip nearby. Staff were friendly and the order was ready on time. Initially, the pizza looked fresh and tasty. Unfortunately, it did not taste great and was very bland. The crust was missing something and tasted more like stale focaccia bread which I was not expecting. The sauce was also unseasoned and flavorless. All in all, not a great pizza and our group of 3 did not finish it as it left a poor impression. I would not recommend or revisit in the future. read more

NiMarco's Pizza - Downtown - Half cheese half pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

My group of five arrived in Flagstaff after 7pm and were hungry. We wanted something good, fairly quick, and would fill up the group. NiMarco's Pizza seemed to fit the bill. The downtown location was on our way to our Airbnb, so we called ahead to place an order. We ordered: Large half cheese, half meat Medium Hawaiian bbq 8-piece wings Small caesar salad Parking can be challenging as it's mostly if not all, street parking. Once we got to our Airbnb, I tried the cheese pizza and salad and they satisfied my hunger. The rest of the group also enjoyed the pizzas and wings and we had plenty of leftovers for the next day. The portions were great and prices were reasonable. read more

See all

We got a large supreme pizza, a small salad, and two sodas for $50 + tip. The salad was good, but the pizza was soggy and flavorless. I would've rather eaten a frozen pizza. read more

Huge pizza! Delicious! Had enough for breakfast and lunch the next day! Curbside service was a plus, too!

Such a cool local place, I wish I found out for this earlier on our stays. Spacious place, family friendly, clean, nice decorations. Nice young people are working here and super friendly. Their pizzas is also delicious we tried cheese and peperoni, later on I find out they have fool menu like calamari, cheese bread.... I also likes that you can buy pizza slice but it is cheaper if ou buy the whole pizza. read more

See all

This was by our hotel and within walking distance. I have to say this was the best tasting pizza. The sauce was very tasty, not spicy but not sweet and the crust had a great taste and was baked to perfection. It was busy but you had to order at the counter and drinks were self serving. They had tv's going but it seems to be a pizza joint that I would like to find back home. This is a place to visit if you are in Flagstaff. But not in the business district across the railroad tracks. read more

NiMarco's Pizza - Downtown - Pepperoni, extra cheese and onions - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

A dog friendly local gem! My family and I had dinner on the patio at Ni-Marco's Pizza with five dogs. Yep, five. The whole crew adored this Flagstaff pizzeria and everything they had to offer. We might have went a little overboard on the food, but everyone left a happy camper. Our meal consisted of the house salad, bone-in wings, boneless wings, fried zucchini, a meat lovers pizza, Popeye pizza, and a whole lotta ranch. My favorite item was the Popeye pizza. We customized this a bit by removing the bacon and adding chicken. Otherwise the pizza included garlic butter base, tomatoes, spinach, and red onions. The crust was also soo crunchy, my favorite. I also was obsessed with their beer selection and price point. Yummy pizza and cheap beer? I'm in. read more

Good pizza and pretty quick to serve. I like that they offer pizza by the slice, which is helpful when with a small group. For kids, aside from the pizza it was pretty limited. No lemonade or kids option for a drink other than Gatorade. Id go back again. read more

Drove by on the way home, stoped by for quick bites with the kids. This is our 2nd time here, first time was during Christmas and it was packed and very lovely's. This time, just lunch time so not much of crowed, most are take seat/to go. You can do street parking or there is a lot right across the street, they got outside patio upon entrance with is great to sit and enjoy the foods with breezes, especially in the summer. Clean with laid back simi loud music ambiance and friendly staff. The foods are great, the wings are super crispy and tasty with the sauces. The pizza's dough is nice crispy, abit thicker than I would like but still yummy. If we're in the area again, will definitely stop by for more pizza and wings. read more

See all

We had a few pizzas, beer, and some apps that were great! The restaurant was clean, food was delicious and hot, and the beer was crisp and cold. Great spot! read more

Our favorite pizza in all of Flagstaff! It's always clean... staff are kind and pizza and wings are perfect! read more

See all

I ordered delivery and the food was delivered well before the expected drop off time, which was excellent! I couldn't find the pizza measurements listed in their delivery service, so I accidentally ended up buying too much.... I wanted to try something new, so I got the hot honey drizzle and it was very yummy. The toasted ravioli was also very delish. I'd order both of these items again! read more

NiMarco's Pizza - Downtown - Large Cheese Pizza with Ricotta Cheese and Hot-Honey Drizzle - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

See all

The pizza crust has changed for the worse!! I was ok spending $48 for what I thought would be a friday night dinner. Sad what happenend?

Love this place. We sat outside with our dog and enjoyed a great pizza (love the crisp on bottom of crust) and a cold beer. It's beautiful at night and parking was easy to find. read more

This is my favorite pizza spot ever! They always have the best crust. I grew up eating this pizza and every time I come back to flagstaff I come here. read more

NiMarco's Pizza - Downtown - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

NiMarco's Pizza 101 S Beaver St Flagstaff, AZ August 24, 2024 Food: 5/5 Service: 5/5 Portion size: 5/5 Visit: Girls brought me to try NiMarco's for My Birthday dinner. Lunch: Ordered one Medium Pepperoni and Black olive pizza with a dozen bone-in Mild wings. Service: Dine-In, Service was great and food was prepared correctly and under 20 minutes, service was fast and the pizza was amazing. Dinner for us three cost $53 great deal for amount of food we got. read more

See all

Seriously, BEST PIZZA EVER! I believe it was June 18th 2026 we enjoyed a special pizza with most ingredients. The pizza dough and crust in particularly stood out. The ingredients were fresh, and the staff were friendly and helpful. It is cozy inside, and also has a nice outdoor sitting area. My wife and I highly recommend NiMarco's if you are hungry for pizza in Flagstaff Az. read more

Great, consistent, delicious and old fashion in the best possible way. The young crowd behind the counter always seem to be professional and on point read more

This place is an easy 100% overall. In flagstaff for a couple days and this put a cherry on top of our experience. Would recommend. Food is great. Service is great. This place is bangin. read more

NiMarco's Pizza - Downtown - Cheesy garlic bread, and pepperoni pizza with bacon - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

I was in Flagstaff for work meetings and one of my coworkers went to NAU and recommended NiMarco's as a good lunch option. We had some gluten allergies and appreciated the gluten free crust option. Lots of choices for your slice/s of pizza with multiple vegetarian pizzas. They have good lunch deals as well as a good selection of beers on tap. The staff took time to explain the menu, answer our questions and give their recommendations. We sat outside to enjoy the nice weather. read more

I love this food so much! Recently visited a few weeks ago, and it's still amazing. Service is great. It is counter service, which I prefer. If you sit outside, the ambiance is great. They also serve draft beer. read more

NiMarco's Pizza - Downtown - Hawaiian BBQ Chicken. - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

Delicious pizza! We live in Phoenix and stopping by for a meal at NiMarco's is a must for my family when we're in Flagstaff. We wish we had one back home, we've yet to find a pizzeria as good as NiMarco's in Phx. The hawaiian and pepperoni with Jalapeño are our favorite. read more

We stopped in for dinner tonight at the recommendation of the front desk staff at our hotel and it was great. This is an order at the counter and they bring the pizza to your table when ready. The service was fast and the pizza was great. Hot fresh and delicious. The cost wasn't bad either $17 for a cheese and half pepperoni medium pizza. We would definitely come back. The place was casual family style and for a Sunday night it was decently busy. read more

See all

My favorite pizza joint since I was a kid. Good memories with my mom and always a place I stop at on my return home.

Everyone was friendly. I was told the food would come out in 25 min and it came out much faster, around 10-15 minutes. Cheesy garlic bread was fantastic and the pizza was amazing. Great tasting sauce and dough. read more

Loved it! What a great atmosphere and good pizza. We travelled for the weekend from the Valley and wished there was a NiMarcos down here.

Love the pizza but this employee named beck was really rude to me and my friends which honestly ruined the experience

The pizza was excellent. The service was very friendly. We will come back again and recommend to friends visiting Flagstaff. read more

NiMarco's Pizza - Downtown - Two slices left over from a large pizza. Two people. We are stuffed. - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

went to visit nimarco's as we were in town for two days. it was the best salad and pizza. the portions, quality and presentation was perfect! i also love the the inside/ outside look it was cozy and felt homey. the service was excellent. the workers were kind and kept the place clean. highly recommend! read more

NiMarco's Pizza - Downtown - garden salad / dr. pepper - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

See all

When in flagstaff, this place is a must for great pizza. Zucchini, and wings! The staff are quick and attentive. read more

NiMarco's Pizza - Downtown - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

See all

Excellent pizza! The sauce is great and the crust is amazing! Crunchy and delicious. So glad we stopped in!

Definitely enjoyed this pizza spot it was delicious. Me and my wife ordered the bbq pineapple chicken pizza. It was by far the best pizza. Pizza was nice and crispy around the crust and super cheesy and delicious. read more

NiMarco's Pizza - Downtown - BBQ chicken pineapple pizza medium - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

Best pizza ever, been coming here for 20 years! Pizza by the slice and the have wings. Pizza has a nice crispy crust. Outdoor seating! read more

NiMarco's Pizza - Downtown - Patio - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

If you're in Flagstaff, this is a great spot for delicious, fresh-made pizza with a crispy crust and creative toppings. The ambience is warm and relaxing, with a laid-back vibe that makes it perfect for a casual meal. The friendly staff, good pizza, and a nice atmosphere make this place a new favorite!! read more

NiMarco's Pizza - Downtown - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

See all

Pizza was excellent and hot wings fantastic. Got my order on time. Web site easy to use.

If you like a lot of cheese and toppings, this may be your place. Personally, I found the tomato sauce thin. I like more sauce. The pizza had a smoky flavor I enjoyed. Overall, just ok for me. This place is LOUD. Forget trying to have a conversation. read more

Ok this pizza place is legit!! The crust is incredible, flavors on point & service top notch. Thr cheesey breadsticks were the perfect crunch!! Love that you can order at the counter then go sit & wait on the open patio. My husband been talking about this place for years and im so glad I finally tried it! read more

NiMarco's Pizza - Downtown - Incredible pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

This is one of my favorite pizza joints, not only in Flagstaff, but in AZ and beyond. The Gary's Special is our go to, and comes with pepperoni, sausage, olives, onions, mushrooms, and bell peppers. We always order this well done to get an extra crisp on the crust and toppings. On our last visit, we also tried the cheese curds, ceasar salad, and wings (ordered well done, with sauce on the side) on our last visit. Everything was incredible! Both locations I have been to, the downtown and west side, are comfortable and have great staff/service. The west side location is a little more comfortable, while the downtown location has a cooler aesthetic. Long story short...eat here! read more

See all

Well, yes fried food and cheese can be so fried food and cheesy sure? But, when that craving hits you and grabs you, there's no denying that simple pleasure right? Fried zucchini was Ahhhhmazing, coupled with a slice of the Monster Melt and Pesto Chicken, and that my friend was an Epic meal well spent, enjoyed, and devoured. NiMarco's pizza is one of my top spots in Flagstaff for sure! read more