First time ordering from this place and they called back because I gave them their address by accident and it was a funny ordeal. However, the coworker employee called the Marriott for me to try to find me so I can give them the correct address or the correct hotel, which was awesome because then he called my cell phone and then got me and I gave him the correct address Employee of the month right there. The food was delicious coming from a pizza joint. I got buffalo wings and mozzarella sticks and the mozzarella sticks were cheesy and very good the buffalo wings I got mild sauce and that was even better. I also got ranch and blue cheese and that came as well with the six pack of Pepsi, which is a great deal considering I'm at a hotel and I need some soda. Thank you for your hospitality and customer service employees at the pizza guy i will be back. The delivery driver was amazing and came right to my room. Thank you. read more

See all

I absolutely love this place and I was so excited to get off of my shift today and get some wings from the best wing place in flagstaff. I even looked up the hours to make sure I would make it on time, I walked in at 9:49 and they would not serve me unless I placed a take out before 10pm. Their website specifically says open till 12am. really sad about this but please update your hours online. read more

worst service I've ever had in flagstaff. ordered 3 hours in advance, still 30 minutes late! pizza was not good. wings tasted like garbage. terrible cus service. absolutely awful place. do not order from them. you will be disappointed beyond words read more

If you know you know. This is the best pizza place in town hands down. Been coming here for years.

The best slice in Flagstaff, they crisp up the bottom which is perfect. The lunch special is a great deal. Always some good rock music playing when I walk in. read more

Best NYC style pizza for on the go! Wings and cheese pull apart were so tasty!! And their cannolis for a sweet treat are so delicious! Nice employees with the sweetest pup to greet you when you pick up read more

I had an amazing experience from beginning to end. The two kind men working at the time welcomed me and my friend with open arms. We shared a medium cheese pizza...to die for. My favorite pizza shop by home closed and I haven't had something so close to it as I did today. I also really enjoyed the interior design of the restaurant, I had something to look at in every direction including a furry friend! Highly recommend this joint!!! Will be back, my new favorite place! read more

Our local pizza place! We enjoy the pizza and deals that they offer. Their wings are good too! I've had good experiences with both delivery and pick up. We'll definitely be back! read more

Pizza so good they won our annual pizza contest! I won't say who the other contestants were... but it was stiff competition. Friendly staff and seriously Good pizza. There isn't much of an area to "dine in" but these are your best pick up or delivery pizza around! read more

See all

Ordered an excellent Hawaiian pizza. Lived the crust sauce and fixings. Will definitely eat their pizza again.

Terrible customer service from employee and manager on duty. Walk in when pizzza was supposed to be ready, one was ready and other one was just making the dough. They said another 20 min, waited in parking lot and came in 15 min later and both were on counter . Opened them up to check on them and one we waited for was wrong. Told them that there wasn't supposed to be mushrooms and black olives on half. They said they don't see a problem in that or the other cold pizza. I told them I wasn't paying for it and it was a long arguement before I could get a refund . I have gone there 4 times, 1st time was great and have problems last 3 times We are done, New management has turned this place upside down Very smug, arrogant, manager said he doesn't make mistakes! On other hand there are a lot of great pizza places in town to try, pizzacletta and fratelli's are some good recommendations read more

I am up in flagstaff weekly most of the time for work, and I make it on my list to always stop in and get a pie to go back to Prescott Valley with. best NY style around the northern part of AZ . Love coming in and seeing the pup who is just adorable . Friendly service . great pizza. read more

We ordered this pizza through GrubHub . The crust is chewy and delicious and it is definitely a step above any mass produced pizza. However, I have spent 10 minutes waiting to tell somebody but they would not respond my phone call, and I understand that they might be understaffed. our pizza arrived on time thank you to GrubHub. One of our pizzas was not cut at all and we are in a hotel so we had to use a credit card to slice it. Secondly I paid extra to have artichoke hearts and roasted red peppers on my pizza and it came with neither. If you wanna roll the dice, go ahead. The barbecue chicken pizza was phenomenal even though it was not cut. I would recommend that, if you don't mind picking it up whole and taking a big bite. I'd love for management to reach out to me with a coupon so on repeat visits I can try again at this establishment. read more

The pizza was ok. It's a really small suite so not really a good spot to dine in although there are a couple of seats in the storefront. Only took 20 mins to get our food. Wings we got were pretty hot but ordered mild. Personally I wouldn't go back but it wasn't bad. I'd call it okay, but would not recommend to anybody. read more

Wings we fantastic. Delivery on time. Food was hot. Certainly will use again when in town

On take out orders of $100 or more they charge you 18 % gratuity.. I think it's ridiculous especially since we were picking it up for take out . the pizza guy is crazy read more

18% gratuity?! Y'all tripping on king vons soul. Gang I was boutta pick it up and y'all talking bout some 18% gratuity. Food was hella wack too. read more

Normally a great place and I love eating and ordering from here. Tonight however, the employees seemed kind of off and gave me a pepperoni pizza when I ordered a cheese and didn't even cut said pizza. Pretty disappointed because I normally look forward to what I order from here read more

See all

Best pizza I've had in Flagstaff for sure, great service and delivery too. Will be back.

The best thing to happen to Flagstaff consistent hot true New York pizza I suggest eating here frequently if you love pizza

Mike, it was a pleasure to meet you. Your meat lovers pizza is the best I have tasted so far. The reason? Because the crust was nice and crispy, not soggy like the chains I've been. But here comes the main reason.... The meat WERE NOT SALTY like I have tasted everywhere. I am soooo glad your daughter is cancer free. Wishing her and you all the best. Kindest Regards, Tom read more

After a 10 hour drive, my family was starving and this place was open. We ordered an XL Sausage and Onion and it was great! Light cheese, quality sausage and sweet onions. The staff was super cool and very helpful. Plus, they are open until 2am read more

The Pizza Guy - Sliced sausage and onion - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

Very disappointed . Ordered cheese pizzas with additional toppings. Where was the cheese? Too much sauce and only a few slivers of cheese. Grr. The pineapple had about 2 pieces per slice. Yes the staff were very nice and the wings were good. I don't recommend the pizza at all. It is a pizza take-out, small waiting area, not a dine-in and of course no ambience read more

Pizza was crisp and tasty. Delivery guy, Alec was cool and delivered my order to my campsite on Ft Tuthill!!!

Wonderful pizza. Ham and garlic. Dude, every place closed at 9pm on thursday and this place was pretty quick, and DELICIOUS. My vegan fiance loved it (she was hungry lmfaooooo) amd I saw these reviews that didnt do justice. Pizza was dank. Sauce was great. read more

The Pizza Guy - Ham amd garlic dank pizza - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

Great gluten-free pizza and a good price too! Like seriously good, quick and friendly service too read more

A great pizza in Flagstaff delivered via UberEats. Great sauce and fresh crust. Yummy. read more

The Pizza Guy - Large Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

Great pizza and great customer service. Delivered all the way to camp Navajo. Delishious. Took about 45 mins for 5 xl pizzas and we were about 15 miles away. Brought it all the way to the gate read more

The Pizza Guy - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

After a day of non-stop walking, dancing, laughing and drinking - this pizza is a must have. We ordered it because we were starving and it was one of the few places open late - which is a must in Flag! Thank God for The Pizza Guy because it hit the spot perfectly. Me and three others destroyed the box and were so pleasantly satisfied. Give this place a try! We even wanted to order it our next night too!!! read more

Really good pizza! Camping in our RV at Woody Mountain Campground from Vegas and this was probably at the top of our list of pizzas we've tried. We ordered the extreme supreme. Fresh ingredients, thin crust and the sauce is really good. Whole thing was very flavorful. It was fast delivery too! Definitely will hit this place when we pass through again! read more

There I was, chilling at home with the chihuahuas when I suddenly found myself jonesing for a New York style pizza but not any ol' New York style pizza. I was thinking something "exotic"...ya know, something with feta, jalapeños, pineapple, bacon, and roasted red peppers (it's an acquired taste). Guess who came in CLUTCH during this pizza emergency? The (insert expletive here) Pizza Guy! Not only does the Pizza Guy delight my eclectic and classy palette, they must also use some serious Star Trek teleportation to deliver the pies because my pizza arrived in the blink of an eye! read more

The Pizza Guy - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

Was in town to pick up my bro from NAU due to the covid madness. Almost every business in town was closed at 9 but these guys were still open slinging pizza and wings. I ordered a 15 piece wing extra saucy and a ceasar salad . My wings were prepared exactly to my liking. Also the lettuce used in the salad was fresh, crisp, and clean. No complaints at all with these guys. Keep up the good work!!!!! read more

Alrighty. So a quick bit of backstory. Im local to here, have 10years of various line cooking experience. Also I Love a good slice of savory pie. To begin I tried ordering on their glitchy website/app. They have a deal known as "bad guys" which was xlarge with two toppings. We ordered over the phone. The female who answered didnt know what I was speaking of. So I decided to order online. Put the order in place, and even called to make sure/confirm it would be "crispy/well done". Hate to be nitpicking, but I know what that terminology means. We were quoted 45mins. It arrived over 20mins late. I complained about the cook (it wasn't well done/crispy), and was promised another one. The next one had a charred tasted, was over done (not well/crispy but overdone). We didn't complain a second time, but went ahead and ate the pizza. It was edible, but precisely what we didn't want. Also, we ordered a sierra mist, but got a 7up. Didn't mind that much....but as a customer for years. I was quite disappointed. It may be new staff, but still. I expect better from you guys. Anywho. That's all I needed to say. So thanks for the sub-par meal and service, and I hope it gets better. read more

The Pizza Guy - Charred pizza - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

See all

Great pizza for late night munchies, wish I would have gotten the suicide sauce instead of the hot, but other than that it was on point!

Best pizza in flagstaff in my opinion. Crust wasn't too thick or too thin, sauce had a lot of flavor and some spice. Perfect ratio of each ingredient on the pizza. Great service too! Overall highly recommend! read more

I stayed in flag for the weekend and needed a late night bite! Hop on yelp and find this pizza shop open late and near our hotel. We ended up getting pizza and wings two nights in a row! Medium wings were bomb and the pizza was so good! Highly recommend read more

The people who work here are nice just watch out where you sit the chairs are old wobbley and do break.

Yumm!! Really loved the taste of this pizza. Was delivered to me at Motel 6 earlier than I thought. Friendly staff. When you come to Flagstaff, do not hesitate to get this pizza. Wings were good though a little dry but nice and spicy read more

So heres the story. I used to be very cheap when it came to ordering pizza. Used to spring for the $5 pizzas. My fiance wanted to try The Pizza Guy out one time. Well since then I haven't been able to order from anywhere else. Food is more expensive but extremely good. I normally order same thing. Large meat lovers and a ton of wings. The wings are a pretty good size. This last time I went on their website and saw there is even a 20" XTRA Large. It is an extra bonus that they even will deliver to my house even though I live on the opposite side of town. read more

I can't even say enough... This business went above and beyond even after hours... That has never happened in my experience & the food was beyond exceptional!!! jtrue people that give a true care about their patrons.....highly recommend on every level read more