Everything was so delicious and I'm kind of bummed we did not take a pic of the pizza! But I definitely recommend this place! It is a chill place but they have it all, drinks, food, tv's. Everyone there was super nice too and their service was great! Check this place out if you find yourself in flagstaff! read more

See all

Pizza was overcooked and Margherita pizza was the worst we ever had. Service was mediocre and the entrance of the business was filthy. We will not return. read more

Got a 12' inch pizza with shredded mozzarella and buffalo hot 10 wings Spent 35$ it is good the service was nice and fast, very simple and nice here I like the setting here FOOD OVERALL: it's a little greasy but the cheese is good it gave a cheese pull and I got some hot wings , it is pricey to be honest but the wings were good 3/5 in food overall the crust was good tho just expensive :/ read more

See all

We decided to get takeout because we were in the mood for pizza. They sell pizza by the slice here. It looks pretty busy and a chill environment. The service was good. The pizza was excellent. Nothing fancy, but it was still good. read more

Lumberjack Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

See all

Do not get the "margherita" pizza! I wish I had known this was their version beforehand because I wouldn't have ordered it. read more

Lumberjack Pizza - Margherita pizza - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

They are one of the more popular pizza places in Flag and my son's favorite. Order from the counter and then they bring you your food. You get your drinks and utensils from a bar at the back wall. Their pizza has a semolina based dough. Not my favorite but like I said, my son's likes it. My tastes are more Chicago or New York pizza. They do use quality ingredients and real deck ovens. They also have salads and other things. The ambiance is comfortable and casual. Great for families and kids as well as the college crowd. While I'm only going to give it 3 stars it's still an order of magnitude better than your chain pizza choices. read more

Lumberjack Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

See all

Honestly I thought this a pretty good pizza for being in Flagstaff. Usually not a place known for its pie's, but I respected it. The flavor of the wings were great too. The only knock is that they gave me only 1 flat in an 8 piece wing. I thought that was a little outrageous, but all good. Pizza was great, and the service was welcoming and informational. i'd go back here! read more

Lumberjack Pizza's Proclames boldy on their website that it is the "Flagstaffs Favorite Pizza" (with "favorite' underlined. Is this hyperbole? And what are the metrics by which this proclomation has been asserted? Allow me to enlighten you with my opinion of this establishments' pie. We ordered a Margherita pie- add garlic, a meat lovers pie and 3 sides (mozzarella sticks, fries and wings -medium.) First - the Meat lovers. Good proption of meat to cheese and sauce. Various meats were complementary. Crust- failry thin and crispy (the correct New York inspired way to make a pizza, Chicago need not apply.) The Margharita - well see the photo with the remaining 3 of 8 slices. Note that only 3 of the 5 removed were fully consumed by a group of college students (myself being the parent of the group). Where is the cheese on this thing? Simply put... this was the sadest and most unenthusiastic attempt to create a Margherita pizza Ive ever experienced. You would think for the obnoxiously high price of $23.95 at the time of this publishing for this moat basic of pizzas that they would include enough medalions of fresh mozzarella cheese to cover a majority of the pie... but you would be wrong to think this. Instead, the slices of fresh mozzarella look so thin they may have been cut on a deli slicer and cover, at best, 30% of the pizza. They might as well call this "A Pizza wit' nuttin!" Aside from this... the sauce overall was a touch too salty and the added garlic we requested seems was "jar-lic" (the pre-minced stuff you get at grocery stores for convenience. The bright spot was the wings. Really, quite good. Maybe Lumberjack pizza should consider hanging up the pizza peel and focus on the wings alone. The 4 stars this place shows as on yelp right now is totally undereserved on the pizza side. I could have done equally as well woth Dominos and spent 50% on the check. In short - if you like your pizza to be "mid"- yes... eat here. But instead, you may want to consider a cheaper option. read more

Lumberjack Pizza - Margherita pizza- about 70% sauce. - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

Very friendly, great service, got our food quickly. Salad for a side was a generous portion. Pizza dough was perfect

We came in for slices, and it was pretty disappointing. They didn't have a lot ready, and what was seemed to have been sitting around for quite a while. Both the cheese and veggie slices had that quality of day old pizza you heat up in a toaster oven. The crust on the cheese had a weird bitter flavor almost reminiscent of a cleaning product. We saw another table ordered a freshly made pizza, and it looked entirely different with melty cheese, so that seems to be the way to go here. On the bright side, though, the pizza was cheap! My side salad was an almost twice the price of a slice of cheese. read more

We were in Flagstaff for a golf weekend and about 10 of us went over to try out Lumberjack Pizza as it was just down the street from the Hotel Monte Vista where we were staying. We all enjoyed the pizza they had as we all got various pies. It's a place where you walk up to the counter and order your pizza. They give you a number for your seat and they bring it over to you. You can also get a beer at the counter while waiting for your pizza. The girl working behind the counter (I think she said her name was Elyse) was very sweet and helpful when ordering. Next time in Flagstaff I will return again. P.S. Lumberjack Brewery just south of Lumberjack Pizza across the tracks is pretty good too read more

Very fast service for making and entire pizza. Great taste, yummy cheese and toppings. Great pizza place. read more

See all

Excellent pizza and service. Would definitely come back. Friendly and right on Route 66

I went here with some friends and ordered a margarita pizza, everyone else's food came out in like 5 minutes. About 30 minutes pass and everyone else finished their food already, so i go up to the counter to ask for my pizza to go, and then they immediately put it in a box for me. If my pizza was done why did you not bring it to me??? I went back to the table and opened the box and the pizza was 80% sauce, it looked like a skinned pig with buboes, and tasted even worse. Their wings were good tho read more

We came to grab a pizza and we were happy to see they had a "stubby and slice" available. (A beer and a slice) We both had a pepperoni slice and coors light and hubby had PBR. Pizza was delicious. Customer service was outstanding- thank you Barry !! read more

Lumberjack Pizza - Business sign - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

See all

Unique and fun atmosphere. Salad and dressing was amazing. Pizza was delicious and best of all the service was friendly and fast. We will come back! read more

See all

Our Cheesy Bread was garlicky and delicious. The pepperoni pizza had the perfect crust and was piping hot.

Service. Only one person working and I was waiting 10 minutes (I'm Native American Navajo) and she looked at me and she continued to do her job at what she was doing and finally got her attention, bad management and when a white customer came up to the counter she was immediately helped unlike myself waiting 10 minutes. read more

Lumberjack Pizza - Bad service - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

The family loved the pizza. The patio is dog friendly. The side salad was very large. We all left full.

Came here with my coworker, we both haven't been here before. The slice and wings combo was filling and really good. The pizza had great sauce and the wings were perfect, crispy and sauced the right amount. The employee there was super nice and the place had a chill environment. The price wasn't bad either. Def going back since I can just walk here from work. read more

We waited for 7 minutes at the counter waiting for the person at counter to acknowledge us. He stared at us without a hello, or be with you right away or even a smile and continued a lengthy conversation with the white man he was chatting with. We left after 7 minutes and there wasn't a single word said. We are an couple of color with a child.. racism in 2023...how novel! I have shared an image of the person behind the counter who treated us such. Avoid this place , my 2 cents for people of all colors. read more

Lumberjack Pizza - The person in charge behind the counter.. - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

I ordered delivery, the driver was very professional no complaints with the service. That's what is saving this from a 1 star review. My reason for a low rating is that the pizza was not good, flat out, point blank. I threw the entire pie away after 3 bites. I was convinced they sold me an off brand frozen pizza from the grocery. If I were you I'd just skip it. read more

We came to Flagstaff Arizona with my grandmother to visit. All of the people in this town are extremely friendly. We were greeted with friendly smiles and welcomed by Jillian and Halle The Pizza was great and the atmosphere was very chill. They have a variety of food to choose from. Everything was great. The location was in a good spot to, because it was near the train station and the plaza. Pros: Great food Great prices Great service Cool location Thank you halle and jillian We will be coming back to visit read more

Lumberjack Pizza - The atmosphere is very chill. It's great for families - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

See all

I tried the Kachina White and Wilbur's Favorite (Lumberjack Special). Both were absolutely delicious and good sizes. I love the crust is very crisp. The staff was great and the service is great read more

Excellent pizza! First pizza I had in AZ so idk if this is the style out here, but the crust was very crispy and crunchy, perfectly baked - cheese chewy but not greasy. Highly recommend the pizza here! Boneless wings were good, but nothing to write home about. Overall, great experience! read more

Bad customer service, food was just ok. Takes forever to make a pie but most importantly bad customer service. Person upfront was rude and making rude sarcastic comments when I asked about my pizza being delayed. Regardless, would not recommend. Never had a single bad experience from all the pizza shops around and their pizza is much better. read more

Pizza and wings were awesome, they seemed to be short handed and I I feel that leads to rushing and that leads to mistakes. I had to come compliment the cook because I really enjoyed the food. I understand being a bigger family/party can be a little challenging but They were super helpful and apologized for the minor inconveniences but whenever we come back I'm willing to check them out again. Great food!!! read more

We were out of towner's visiting for a hockey tournament. It was late on a Saturday night after one of our games and we were starving! Tried Lumberjack pickup and we are all so glad we did! Pizza was hot and ready when they said it would be! The crust was amazing, pizza was perfectly cooked, and the flavors were rich and satisfying! Would definitely order from here again if we're in town. read more

Lumberjack Pizza is amazing! Anytime we are in Flagstaff we always make sure to come in for their pizza. The service is great too. They even brought our Dog fresh water. We are pizza snobs and this place is in our top 3 for all of Arizona! read more

Lumberjack Pizza - Perfection! - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

See all

Road trip from L.A. to Santa Fe. 1st stop: Flagstaff, along Route 66. Was craving pizza after a 7 hour drive, and Lumberjack was conveniently close to my downtown hotel. Cheese slices are my pizza benchmark, and this is excellent pizza! Thin, fresh dough and very tasty (much better than Fratelli across the street that I shall not review here.) $3.50 medium size slice. read more

Lumberjack Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

See all

Waiting an hour and 20 minutes for a 12"pepperoni pizza and 10 wings is crazy. Hire more people rather than 2 people on an obvious busy night. read more

How is this a 4 star? Should be a freaking 2 stars, super greasy to the max and no good flavor really, the caesar salad was the only good thing, glad i wont be eating here after this one. Rather eat a Peter Pipper Pizza than this read more

Lumberjack Pizza - Greasy ass pizza - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

Nick guess makes amazing pizza!! He is so attentive and caring. He helps us learn how to read, even. Love Nick Guess!!!

This is my new favorite place for wings, in the nation. I feel like bloody Marys and wings are my niche and the wings here are awesome. They are crispy on the outside and very well cooked and all sauce was awesome. Best in class for me and I'm sorry I don't live here. The pizza was very good but the stars of the place are the workers who give thier opinion on what they like and that goes a long way I can't wait to return and glad my son has two more years in college so I get the excuse to goobpe down 25 wings in one sitting. read more

[4.0/5.0] Craving pizza when i visited flagstaff. I can say this place is slightly better than lil C's. Got the half pep half cheese. They have $3 beers on Tuesday and Wednesday. This pizza is super crispy. The sauce is robust and not too sweet. Not floppy at all. The cheese is stringy and delectable. Really solid spot in flg. read more

See all

5 star rating for Sidney ! She's a promoter for this delicious pizza . She gave me so many recommendations, it was hard to pick. Definitely recommend this place if you're looking for a yummy meal. Well done Lumberjack pizza read more

Lumberjack Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

Very great pizza in Flagstaff! Great beer! Great owners! Thank you for the great conversation and I'll be back! Go Michigan read more

Lumberjack Pizza - Beer is cold and tastes excellent! - Pizza Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

See all

We came here on a Saturday night after some bar hopping in Flagstaff. It was just the ticket to soak up the excess alcohol. They have a good variety of pizza by the slice. I think we got one meat-y slice and one veggie slice (details are fuzzy due to the bar hopping that occurred prior to our arrival here). They had a special for a slice and a drink, and that drink could be a BEER not just a soft drink! YAY! They had three or four types of beer that were included in the special. The slices were great - loaded with cheese and toppings but still maintaining a crispy crust. I'm not going to comment on pricing because a) I don't remember so it likely wasn't overly cheap or overly expensive; and b) with inflation being what it is, what's the point?! Our stop here gave us the needed energy to hit one more bar before turning in for the night. Well done, Lumberjacks! read more

Pizza was excellent. Daily specials and happy hour . Nice chill environment with good classic rock music read more

See all

The people that work thr are supper nice. Pizza is Ok! I give it a 3 out of 5. But of course it's my opinion. (Note). It was a take out. So I'll give it another try maybe eating inside. Just because the customer service. They get half the stars. read more