Nicky's II Pizza

Legitimately some of the best pizza in Rockland. I really…read morelike what they do and they come up with some interesting topping for their pizza and the best part is the service. I would definitely come again.

The MVP slice is my go-to!!! Every-time I come here the owners are always so nice. This place…read morereminds me of a little spot in Europe, the music is so jazzy and it's honestly a vibe inside. 10/10 I love coming here!!

See all

Mille Luci Pizzeria

4.7(91 reviews)

2.5 mi

another great dinner. had to come to try the new pasta dishes that they have weekly. i had gnocchi…read morewith lamb ragu. it was simply amazing little puffs of clouds with a awesome ragu. pizza great as usual. Brussels sprouts so crunchy and tasty. love this place you have to come here.

I finally got to try Mili Lucci Pizza in New City, and overall, I liked it! I ordered the Snow…read moreWhite pizza and thought it was really good. I'm glad I went with that one because I definitely enjoyed it! My only complaint would have to be the pricing. I felt like it was a little expensive for pizza, especially since it doesn't come with anything on the side. Don't get me wrong, I don't mind paying more for good food, but I do feel like the price should match what you're getting. Other than that, I had a good experience! I wouldn't mind coming back and trying something different on the menu. I just wish the prices were a little more reasonable. If you're in the area, I'd say it's worth giving a try!

1 ft

See all

Cheese pull

Dutan And Duffy Restauran

4.2(102 reviews)

2.2 mi

The service and owner are wonderful! They are fast, friendly, and remember you if you go there…read moreoften. Everything we have tried, we love. It's our go to pizza spot. The delivery is reliable.

Despite having food allergies (shellfish/pork intolerant/lactose intolerant), the restaurant was…read morewilling to make adjustments in the culinary department. I received a six-slice pizza. I have no idea what the size is categorized as or what the price was since I did not pay. This is an old review for Father's Day of 2024. For some reason, I thought this place was called Deanna or Diana Maria, so trying to figure out the correct name took some time. My family enjoys the food here and has been going here for quite some time, too. They enjoy the food here. The vegetables on the pizza and the sauce were not bad. It was just the crust that ruined the experience. Hence, the one-star deduction. The waitress was quite comedic, friendly, and still professional. The other waiter seemed more shy, friendly, and professional. It is mainly the outstanding service, yet I don't know if we received this type of service since my family knows the owner. I would hope everyone receives the same service, haha. Otherwise, the ambiance seems cozy, friendly, and family-style, although it is a bit smaller than I thought it would be. ( :

Vegetable/Vegetarian Pizza

See all

SALAD SLICE!

The Pieman Pizza

3.8(41 reviews)

2.4 mi

Aside from being voted The Best Pizza in Rockland County and having some of the best food and…read moreportions in my opinion, the Burgers here are the best I've had hands down. I've eaten all kinds of food, all over the World and always look forward to eating at Pieman. The recent new addition of The Smashburger which I had yesterday (in addition to a Cheeseburger) was again, big, bold, flavorful, savory and sweet with its own toppings. Perfectly seasoned and my new favorite. Now, I'll order both burgers, take one home with Sweet Potato Fries that are a home run and the only Fries I won't have with Ketchup, they don't need it. Seriously, go eat this. Like, now.

Update! Yup, Pie Man…read moreis still solid. Just came back with some coworkers to grab a pie, and I seriously underestimated a 10". Thought it would be enough, but that's definitely a personal size. My bad, lol. No worries though, we just grabbed another pie with zero regrets. When we got to the restaurant, they whipped up a fresh 16" (legit only $3 more) in just a few minutes. Love to see it. The Salty G.O.A.T. truly is the GOAT. Already planning my next visit to try the Sausage and Spicy Pickled Peppers pie since I've heard it's a fan favorite too. Their beer selection is nice, and the staff is super friendly with good energy all around. I've only ever done takeout (with a drink at the bar), but their outdoor seating looks nice, and there's plenty of room inside too. The whole place feels really welcoming. By the way, don't get it twisted. This isn't just a pizza spot. They also host events with live artists, making it more than just great food. Backed by their delicious menu and cold beers on tap, Pie Man provides the full experience. Definitely worth the visit! Looking forward to many more visits :)

Taco pizza!

See all

Meat lovers

Norcina

4.0(235 reviews)

2.4 mi

uber order some great Sicilian pizza from here it was crispy and thick…read more screwed my order up but still was good. alayws on point never disappointed

Always great. Milan, Nick and the staff are welcoming. Food is on point every time. They are also…read morecommunity minded people. A+

Norcina - Top row - right to left: Roasted Chicken Salmon Trapanese Knots/dipping dough Bottom row: Marinara Rigatoni meatballs Spaghetti Aglio Olio

Top row - right to left: Roasted Chicken Salmon Trapanese Knots/dipping dough Bottom row: Marinara Rigatoni meatballs Spaghetti Aglio Olio

See all

Patricia's II Pizza & Pasta

2.4(21 reviews)

0.4 mi

This place has a new owner and he's already made numerous improvements. There are additional types…read moreof pizza that have been added. We have tried several of them and enjoyed them all. For those that haven't been there for a while I would give it another try.

Went tonight to try the food at Patricia's since they are under new management.We have already…read moreeaten the pizza and it was delicious, so we wanted to try something else. I had the chicken Marsala and my husband had the veal parmigiana. Wow! Everything was awesome! The sauce was perfection on the veal and the Marsala dish was one of the best I've ever tasted! We will most certainly be dining here often. Highly recommend!

The worst chicken soup I've ever had. The stringy yellowish bits mixed in with the noodles is the chicken.

See all

The calamari is comprised of mostly these tentacle pieces (ie the cheaper/poorer quality pieces).

Valley Pizza

4.1(38 reviews)

2.0 mi

I am obsessed with their Chicken Marsala pizza and if you need a quick slice or lunch in the…read moreClarkstown area, this is the place to go. I've also enjoyed their rolls (spinach rolls, especially) and chicken parm.

Always the best food regardless of what you order. And always a smile when you walk in. Hats off to…read moreIsabel who assisted us yesterday. Can't recommend this place enough.

Pizza with onions and peppers

Sliders - skippable

See all

Turiello's Pizza House & Restaurant

4.2(198 reviews)

4.2 mi

Outstanding slices, fair prices, great service. As soon as…read morewe walked in, I had a good vibe, family operated, clean, friendly, the smell was reminiscent of my grandmother's kitchen We were only there for a quick lunch and the slices looked great. This is not "craft pizza", which can get annoying when you just want a good slice. They had regular slices and a nice variety with quality toppings including stuffed. My wife and I both ordered a white slice and I also had a rice ball with meat (Arancini). The arancini was the size of a softball, great flavors and fried perfectly. The white pizza was creamy and delicious. Not greasy at all, quality cheese! So perfect, we took two slices to go. I wish I knew about this place when I lived in Rockland They have a great story too, a real organically grown American success story.

Quick stop on our way to Jersey shore. Two great slices and an eggplant sub. All were perfect ! We…read morecame off hours and had the place to ourselves.

See all

Rocco's Family Restaurant & Pizzeria

4.2(199 reviews)

2.7 mi

Amazingly delicious food... Attentive wait staff and wait until you see all the State of the Art…read more Remodeling inside!!!!

Rocco's is easily one of the best spots in New City, and it's quickly become my go-to anytime I'm…read morecraving real Italian. We went in last weekend with a huge appetite after a long day, and you could immediately notice how great the place looks with the new renovations. The service was on point right away--our server brought out an order of garlic knots, and we polished them off in about two minutes flat. For the main meal, we split a large pie and a plate of chicken parm. The pizza was unreal--super crispy NY crust with zero flop, incredible sauce, and just the right amount of cheese--and the chicken parm portion was so generous we still had leftovers for lunch the next day. The staff genuinely treated us like family from start to finish, and it was just a great experience overall. If you live around here and haven't tried Rocco's yet, you're missing out!

Best garlic knots

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

11 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Kevin M.

8 years ago

The Food, service, and atmosphere are amazing. Workers are very friendly and diligent. The pizza is great, and there is such a variety of slices to choose from. If you are more of a plain Jane, then the regular slice is for you. The best around! read more

Vincent L.

8 years ago

What an incredible slice of pizza! A pizzeria right in the heart of congers that provides the best quality food along with great service, results in a overall top of the line experience every time. Go try it you won't regret! read more

Paulie D.

12 years ago

A hidden gem! This place is great; there is a new menu with a variety of different dishes! Not only is the pizza delicious, but the dinner entrees are as well! The veal parm hits the spot. I highly recommend nickys. read more

Olivia R.

7 years ago

I've ordered food from here many times and it is amazing it really really hits the spot when your craving good Italian food. They are very good with delivery and they really have delicious food and Italian ice. read more

Rob B.

8 years ago

I highly recommend this place to anybody looking for good pizza/food in Rockland County .. Friendly customer service and a very cozy place to eat with your family and friends. Highly recommended read more

Mercedes M.

12 years ago

I always have an awesome experience at Nicky's. The food and service are both awesome. Felt good to get great food on a night I didn't want to cook. They ROCK! read more

Coby H.

8 years ago

The best pizza I've had in a long time. From out of town expecting a New York style of pizza and this place did not disappoint. Also great customer service. read more

Mary Z.

155

10 years ago

My favorite pizza place around not just because the food but also because the friendly workers.

Saurabh S.

8 years ago

Warm hosts and good food. Great combination. Had a lovely time and would definitely go back.

Fort K.

8 years ago

For regular style pizza-you can't beat it!! And great service as well. -Vinny Congers, NY read more

Brianne R.

4 years ago

Highly recommend! This is what all pizza should taste like!

Nicky's II Pizza - pizza - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Congers, New York Things to Do near Nicky's II Pizza

BEST of Congers, New York Restaurants near Nicky's II Pizza

BEST of Congers, New York Desserts near Nicky's II Pizza

BEST of Congers, New York Coffee near Nicky's II Pizza

BEST of Congers, New York Burgers near Nicky's II Pizza

BEST of Congers, New York Breakfast near Nicky's II Pizza

BEST of Congers, New York Dinner near Nicky's II Pizza

BEST of Congers, New York Shopping near Nicky's II Pizza

BEST of Congers, New York Thrift Stores near Nicky's II Pizza

Best of Congers

Things to do in Congers

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Nicky's II Pizza also viewed

Seconda Vita

4.6

(54 reviews)

Warning : if you order a sandwich here, you will have lunch for two day!…read moreStopped into the new location under their new name to try a focaccia sandwich and it did not disappoint. Staff was friendly and it took everything in me not to get a slice of focaccia pizza while I waited (it smelt SO good). My only disappointment was that the blueberry focaccia wasn't available to try. I will be back!

We had the Hot Honey Pepperoni pizza, and the family loved it! Margherita pizza and regular pizza…read morewere also good, crust was not soggy. Wings were great. The chicken parm was good, the cheese was cold on a hot chicken parm-we ended sharing among 4 ppl- but for the price I would have just ordered another pepperoni pizza. Pan and Pizza is just a place to order at their window and sit next to the Brewery. Street parking only-good luck finding a spot, Shares the place with "GENTLE giant Brewery. Great for families and groups. Great ambience! Would recommend and looking forward to visiting again.

Village Pizza

4.6

(33 reviews)

If you don't wanna read: I ABSOLUTELY RECOMMEND!…read more I originally started looking to try a new pizza spot when I noticed our local pizzerias would reheat whole plain pies they had out all day and sell them to us. Needless to say, they tasted stale! Fast forward to finding Village Pizza. Let's talk about the customer service, just for a second. I'm telling you their customer service cannot be matched. I have not had exceptional customer service from an establishment and/or pizzeria on day one that does not wither at some point down the line. Until I started ordering from Village Pizza. Everyone, and I mean everyone I've met has been nothing short of delightful. Which is refreshing if you've tried other pizzerias. From remembering names to remembering orders. I have personally seen this treatment of every person that walks through their door. And! The time they tell you it's gonna be ready, is the actual time. Now on to the food. The garlic knots are flaky and flavorful. Pizza is delicious with or without toppings. It's a thinner crust. It's tasted fresh every time and this has become a regular spot so I can't tell you how many times I've ordered from them. Quality food every time. Quality service every time. I've said it once. I'll say it again. I'm a sucker for consistency. I recommend this place to anyone who will listen. Go pay them a visit. I promise you won't regret it.

Best slice in Nyack and it's not even close…read more Not trying to be controversial, but when I moved here from Brooklyn in '22 I tried both of the "T" pizza spots and was horrified that these were my options. Greasy, flavorless, a mess of a pie. When Village Pizza changed ownership a few years back I tried a slice, and I never turned back. The Village Pizza slice is on par with any great Brooklyn/NYC spot... Crispy and gooey like a slice should be. The real test? You'll want to eat the whole slice crust and all, no pizza bones left at the end! Those other spots? The crust is pale, doughy, bland. Just because those places have been here longer, or have a more prime location, doesn't mean they're better. In fact, that's probably why they're slacking on their product. No motivation to excell. Village Pizza came out swinging with the best slice in town and they've maintained quality slice after slice after slice. Don't even hesitate, if you're looking for real NYC style pizza forget those other places. Village Pizza is where it's at.

Calabria Pizza & Pasta

3.5

(28 reviews)

Been a customer for a few years now. We really like their food and really appreciate they're still…read moreopen during this Pandemic. Placed the order over the phone, paid with credit card and picked it up 20 minutes later. Doors were already open so I didn't have to touch anything except the box to carry the tray in. Ordered their family style Chicken Parm with Penne special (today, Monday) which is supposed to feed 4 but it was more like for 6, all for $20 but if you order before 4/8 they taking off 20%. Here is a text I got from the business: Calabria 20% Coupon DELIVERY & PICKUP Mention this code WHEN ORDERING: CP13872 Expires: 4/8/2020. Can not be combined w/ other discounts. View our Menu: bit.ly/OrbMenu Call to order: (845) 365-2300 #500 NY 303, Orangeburg, N.Y. 10962 Reply "stop" to optout. Text Marketing by: SendSationalText.com. All, support your local businesses! Thank you Calabria's!

Whenever I'm visiting family I make sure Calabria is where we eat. Love the pizza - it holds its…read moreshape and doesn't sag, and the taste is divine! Great entrees too, and everything is fresh and delicious.

Martio's Pizza

4.2

(172 reviews)

Everything was great from the pizza to the service! I'm a…read moreretired chef from Boston and I was traveling from Delaware were I trying to enjoy my retirement! I had the best pizza that I remember in the USA! Congratulazioni!

was in the area so we finally came here. soon as h walk in you feel like your in a tiny…read moregrandmothers home. . we ordered a wood burning margarita pizza. was cooked good but still soggy. wasn't bad. sauce is good. just soggy we shared a chicken parmigiana. comes with a piece of garlic bread. had to order side of pasta. the marinara is very good very old school. service ok. they give you tiny paper plates to use and cheapest napkins. prices are very reasonable

Pizza City

3.3

(32 reviews)

the owner made my husband and my experience unforgettable. we got slices to go and the staff was so…read morekind and the food was phenomenal. definitely will be back!

Its ok. could be far better, i didn't enjoy the sauce they use on their pies. Service was pretty ok…read moresome of the staff seemed like they were having a bad day. Will maybe go back

The Mountain House

3.8

(234 reviews)

We love returning to the Mountain House time and time again. If you're a spicy pepper fan, the…read morecherry pepper pie is an absolute MUST! Their pizzas are perfectly consistent-there's never a bad day. Service was friendly but not as quick or attentive as usual.

Okay so I'm rating this place a solid 3 stars. Mainly because of the ambience and the staff. Staff…read morewas great manager Jeanine was super nice & accommodating. food wise not my favorite probably won't be back . Pizza is eh the calamari was okay. The bolognese was one of the worst we've ever had . Oily minced meat and soft over cooked ravioli. We sent it back. The chicken vodka sandwich and steak fries were alright maybe a 6/10 even the fries were ok idk if it was the oil they were using but something was not good.

Doro Pizza & Pasta

3.1

(9 reviews)

Craving for pizza so cousin brought me here after church!!…read more Casual Italian restaurant known for their gourmet pizza and hearty Italian -American menu!! For sure I enjoyed the Meat Lovers Pizza which had toppings of pepperoni, sausage and meatballs!! Friendly service!! I wish I could just have them all and regretted not ordering pasta !!!!

Avoid this place. First off, the people working there have the personality of a wet sponge. Very…read moreunfriendly. Second of all, I needed a dough to make my own pizza and when she rang me up it was $9. For one dough??? I commented that other local pizza places charge $4 and she just shrugged and didn't care in the least. Pizza isn't even that good. Way better places to go to in the area. They lost a few customers from that experience.

New City Pizza

3.4

(36 reviews)

Ordered for delivery and was quite satisfied. The meatball and onion was probably my favorite,…read moremostly due to the flavor of the meatballs. They reminded me of gyros! The veggie pie and chicken with broccoli were both fine. It was extremely easy to place an order and the delivery guy was on time. The only negative is that our gluten free family member was not a fan of the gluten free crust they made. If that person is not eating though, I will gladly order from New City pizza again.

Hands down, THE BEST PIZZA and hero sandwiches in New City! Service is excellent with consistent…read morefriendliness and hospitality, both on the phone and in person, no matter lunch or dinner. The ambience is enhanced with a clean vibe, both restaurant and staff. A real treat to look forward to!

Bob's Thin Crust Pizza

4.7

(124 reviews)