We were hungry and bbq sounded good. Well it was Taco Wednesday at a bbq joint. My wife and I each ordered 3. I had fries and we shared a fried pickles appetizer. Oh don't forget the margaritas. The pickles were the best fried pickles I've ever had. And they were a first for my wife. She loved them. House pickled and cut thick, then deep fried to perfection. Taco's were great we didn't have one we didn't like, but the loaded brisket taco was the best. Great margaritas not too sweet, and enough tequila to get a nice flavor. Paul was our server and was the perfect blend of attentiveness, professionalism,and friendliness, without hovering. Definitely added to our experience. We left stuffed and felt we had gotten our money's worth. The restaurant itself was comfortable , clean, and made you feel at home. Hope to return soon. read more

You will not walk away hungry!! The food it top notch, huge portions and Excellent service (Mariah), perfect Bbq atmosphere! Coming back for more read more

Came in for lunch! Had the Mac Attack and the GGG for the table, and we enjoyed both! Also, they have a nice selection of beer to pair with the BBQ. Seating is limited on the inside, but we didn't feel squeezed in. Nice little spot in the Gaffer's District. read more

See all

Stopped in for lunch on a summer weekday. Relaxed atmosphere and friendly service inside. We did the brisket and pulled pork combo with three pig wings added on. I thought the brisket and pulled pork were both good. Brisket I usually prefer fattier and this tasted quite lean to me. Very good for north of the Mason-Dixon line, but if you're finicky about BBQ then maybe this isn't the choice for you. The sauces were a mixed bag - to my taste buds they were just a little too meek flavorwise. The pig wings are an absolute star! Super tender but still great meaty texture. All the flavor and fat is locked in a thin crust. They are a must-try. They make me think their regular ribs are probably very good too. The combo plate alone (with the included sides) was more than enough food for two. read more

Went here with my family when we were visiting and my sister had been here before and said it was a good lunch spot in Corning. We got there a little later on the weekend and they were sold out of brisket and all pork which was disappointing because it was about two or three hours or so before they would close. We saw many people turn away due to the shortage of the meat. Sad to go to a BBQ place with no good meat to eat. My mom was going to get one of the other meals but they said that it would have cost the same even though there was no meat on it which we thought was ridiculous. Instead we got some wings and loaded tots. My sister said that they might have forgotten to put on some seasoning on the tots as they did not taste as flavorful as the last time she had them. Food overall was good, but would need to come back to see how the actual BBQ is. read more

A busy evening in Corning with eateries filling up fast! Glad that Nickel's had a reasonable (15-20 minute) wait time. Clearly it had been a busy day, because they were selling out of specific items. Thankful that they had exactly what we needed to fill us up! The food and service were awesome. The sandwiches are huge! The restaurant has a comfortable interior. With COVID still a thing, tables are nicely spaced out. There are also two tables out on the sidewalk. And several people picking up large to-go orders, so that is an option. read more

Nickel's Pit BBQ - Corning - Pulled pork BLT with southern greens on the side. - Barbeque Near Me - Corning, New York

See all

Parking was no problem 5:30 on a Friday night, service was fast & friendly. And the barbecue brisket and pulled pork were moist and delicious! The fries were hot and tasty but after the wonderful reviews of baked beans - they didn't have any! Bummer! The macaroni salad was a good side. After driving I86 for hours, the dinner was perfect and it was quick to get back on the road! read more

My pulled pork sandwich was tasty. I REALLY enjoyed my bf's chicken wings with the BBQ sauce. They were crispy and the sauce was generously slathered. P.S. The orders are provided with moist wipes, so don't be afraid to get a little messy when enjoying your food! (I really appreciated those wipes lol.) read more

Nickel's Pit BBQ - Corning - Wings with BBQ sauce - Barbeque Near Me - Corning, New York

See all

We were in the Corning area on vacation and were not aware of Nickels. We just happened to stop by for a late lunch. What a great decision! The food was outstanding. We had the pulled pork. Delicious! The service Ryan provided was excellent. Highly recommend. read more

There's a wide selection of BBQ options including chicken and pork! The waiter is on top of things and checks in at all the right times!! The drinks are strong but still pretty good. My only downside is the door was by our table and I was pretty cold, but that's not really their fault! read more

Nickel's Pit BBQ - Corning - Pork & Brisket Combo and Pulled Pork Nachos - Barbeque Near Me - Corning, New York

Came here for lunch after the Corning Museum. We were greeted by friendly staff and seated immediately. The place is small but cool ambiance. Our family enjoyed the pulled pork / ribs and pulled pork / brisket platters. Had a great drink as well. Good food and service. Can't ask for anything else! read more

Nickel's Pit BBQ - Corning - Barbeque Near Me - Corning, New York

Had dinner at Nickel's last night. Crowded for a Tuesday early evening. Place was full at 6 pm so we sat outside. Lots of additional customers came by, but no seating. Food was very good. Loved the cucumber pickles and kale sides. The corn and black bean was good, but standard. The coleslaw was good, but standard fare. Had the pulled pork which was tender and juicy. They offer several different bbq sauces as one would expect. Mustard. Sweet. Spicy. Etc. Service was attentive. read more

Nickel's Pit BBQ - Corning - Pulled pork. Coleslaw. Black bean and corn salad. Pickles. - Barbeque Near Me - Corning, New York

We had a quasi dinner last night of pulled pork nachos and onion rings. Both were delicious! They were very busy but our service was friendly, quick and efficient! The ambiance was good! read more

Nickel's Pit BBQ - Corning - The bar - Barbeque Near Me - Corning, New York

See all

Good lord this place was amazing! I just spent a weekend in corning less than three months ago and I somehow missed this gem of a place! I loved their food and their sauces were just the best. The staff was very friendly and helpful throughout and pricing was good as well. The Mac and cheese is to die for I'd of eaten just a big bowl of that but the pulled pork was so good I'd of missed it too much! They have loads of drinks and beer choices as well and then decor inside is hilarious. I especially loved the picture by the bathroom I posted with this review. Loved it here can't wait to come back and enjoy more delish bbq food! read more

See all

Outstanding! This place is right around the corner from the Rockwell Museum and a great place to stop for lunch before the delightful 15 minute walk to the Corning museum. There were six of us and we had various pork-related foods with something from their considerable collection of beers and ciders. All of us left hoping for an opportunity to return. If you're visiting the glass museum then add this to your itinerary. You can thank me later. read more

I thought I didn't like bbq but this meal was delicious. Our waitress recommended brisket so I went for the Butchie sandwich with tater tots. The onion ring was perfectly done. The brisket had the required smoke ring and was so tender. We had great service and all our meals were finished off. read more

Nickel's Pit BBQ - Corning - Butchie sandwich - Barbeque Near Me - Corning, New York

See all

Great restaurant. We decided to try it when we were passing by Corning, and the hosts were so kind and friendly. The food was delicious and the portions are huge! (We ordered 2 combos and had to take a lot with us). It is very family friendly. Would definitely recommend! read more

what can I say? perfect barbecu, perfect service! thank you Abby and thank you Nickels for a great date night!

Got a table right away, nice variety on the menu.. server was friendly And knowledgeable.. food was some of the best we've had in a long time!! Definitely will go back when in the area read more

The service was good! typical "gen z" setting, we sat quick, place was clean, wings were awesome, nachos, fries, were good. The only downside even tho our server was super nice, didn't ask if we needed a high chair. I assumed they didnt have any, I asked, and she did grab one after. our food was delicious, BUT the ribs. they were so rubbery, lots of fat, no taste. We gave it 3 stars because ribs we spent 45 bucks on sucked. But, I guess not everywhere can have ribs as good as Dinosaur BBQ. read more

See all

This place is small but mighty! The waitstaff is incredibly nice and accommodating and the food is absolutely amazing. The flavor combinations were out of this world which is likely why it appeared to be steadily busy all day. The aromas will call to you from down the street and it is a perfect blend of small town bbq meets flavor explosion! Definitely recommend trying it out if you happen to be in Corning! We will definitely be back again. read more

See all

The food was great! And Ryan, our server , made our meal even more enjoyable! He was wonderful.

Great food, great atmosphere. The staff were very friendly. We loved the old school interior. Our food came fast and was well made.

We went 10/6/24 The manager?? I asked his name and then forgot it. He greeted you at the door and kept checking in with us until a table was ready for us super helpful, pleasant and gave us good service.!! read more

Cute place but very trendy. First timers. Showed up two hrs prior to close on Sunday and they were out of half of their brunch menu. Can't complain too much because we just wanted a place to sit and eat and they were open. Started off with bloody Mary and house mimosa, drinks were good! The for a starter we tried their loaded tots. They were ok. I prefer some flavor versus total crisp. Main items: Brisket sandwich with Mac salad ( very blah) meat tasted like it was from the oven and not impressed by the sauces. Breakfast tacos, filling, meat wasn't bad. And Mac salad had 50% way too much onion in it. I like Mac salad not onion salad. Cute place but will not rush back. read more

See all

Have called there 4 times in a week between the hours of 5 and 6:30 pm and wanted there number 1 appetizer pig wings and have been sold out!! Do they only make 10 of them a day ? Won't be trying to order anymore... place is a joke read more

We needed a quick stop after a hospital visit and before heading home, so we stopped for an early supper. Selections all looked great. Our server, Paul, was excellent. Food was delicious!! Will definitely stop again when in Corning. read more

A great little BBQ joint. The staff was very friendly and informative. The food would make any Texan proud as it had great flavor and portions. read more

Family came here for lunch. The decor and ambiance were cool, casual. Kitchen in the front, walk to the back for seating and a big full bar. TV screens and projectors I'm sure play all the big games. Early 2010's country music playing at a decent volume so you could hear it and carry a conversation. Child friendly- high chairs were available. I was excited to try the brisket and the mac n cheese- but didn't see mac n cheese on the menu. We ended up with fried mushrooms and a family platter with brisket, texas toast, salad, macaroni salad and french fries. Plenty for our two adults and one kid, we took home leftovers. The brisket was really the standout of our order. It was smoky, tender and full of flavor without sauce. The added sauce plus the chipotle bbq on the table kicked it up to another level. The sides were adequate and filling but not special enough to mention in this review. Beer was cold on tap and had good variety of large domestic and local options. read more

Nickel's Pit BBQ - Corning - Family platter sides (minus the salad that came first) - Barbeque Near Me - Corning, New York

See all

The place was very busy but the wait staff was pleasant and very attentive. The food is excellent, good variety of sauces, all reasonably priced read more

We were in Elmira looking for some food in that area, nothing seemed worth giving a shot...so we headed to Corning and ended up here. We both had pulled pork sandwiches of differing varieties...food was good. Service was quick and friendly. If we are in the area again, we could like to comeback. On a side note, Corning is a very beautiful city! read more

Overall very good food -- I especially recommend the mac salad. I appreciate that the food came pretty quickly, and that the portions were not too large. There were a few people waiting for the restaurant to open when we got there, and I could see why. To be honest, the meat was good but didn't blow us away, even though the sides were delicious. read more

We started with the deep fried pickles. They were delicious and the batter was excellent. For our entrees had pulled pork and brisket. Both meats were on point along with the tots. We also had the chili as a side. I would go for a swim in that chili. It was just right, not overly spicy but, not bland. Just right. Service was excellent. read more

Nickel's Pit BBQ - Corning - Deep fried pickles. - Barbeque Near Me - Corning, New York

See all

We had a bit of a wait because we came to town while there was a festival going on, but the staff worked quickly to get us a table. The food was delicious - it was hot, the portions are very generous, and it came to our table super quickly. The restaurant was bright, and the staff was very friendly. We were very full and happy at the end of our meal. I would absolutely recommend this spot. read more

Food portions are quite small but service is good. It was too bad that they ran out of brisket on a Friday night.

This Place is awesome. For someone who doesn't like beer battered onion rings there's have made me change my mind. The homemade batter Is well seasoned. But most of all I want to take a bath in the homemade ranch. Yes that needs to be bottled. so I can buy it. Yes it's even better than Cheesecake Factory. And that's saying a lot from this for this foodie person. They had ran out of the pig wings when I came, but was very accommodating on letting me try something else. Love the cocktails by wandering barman cutest concept ever. Big kudos to our server Jaime she was a bubble of positivity. read more

Nickel's Pit BBQ - Corning - Barbeque Near Me - Corning, New York

See all

Can't say enough good things about Nickel's! Food was fantastic! Loved the whole vibe! Family Friendly! Just amazing! What incredible service with dedication to making your experience favourable and enjoyable! Definitely one of our new favourites... read more

I had a good time and a wonderful dinner. The service was good and the food was very good. Pleasant environment in a great location.

Probably the best BBQ we have had (we're Northerners so YMMV.) The deep fried pickles were not just slices, they were the whole pickle. I had brisket and my wife had ribs, both were very tender and nicely flavored. There was a good variety of sauces to try and other sides. The seating is limited but they have some tables outside. If the restaurant weren't three hours from us we would be up there monthly. read more

Everything was delicious! The service was friendly and fast. Definitely recommend! We went in for lunch on a Saturday afternoon. They got us right in, but we had to sit at the bar. They need a bigger place! read more

See all