I have to admit, I was skeptical when I first heard that pizza was "a thing" in New Haven. I had never heard of New Haven style pizza, and certainly didn't expect it to wow me. And now here I am asking all my friends "Did you know New Haven has some of the best pizza?!" I ordered via Uber Eats with delivery to my hotel. They messed up the delivery, so unfortunately the pizza wasn't piping hot once I finally found it. However, it didn't need to be. The flavor was a masterpiece! It was spicy, with just the right amount of cheese and sauce. The sauce was not the tangy cheap-tasting sauce that I sometimes stumble upon so I was happy about that. The crust was not hard, but not soft. I was pleasantly surprised that it had so much flavor, yet was not at all greasy. I wish I knew how to describe it better, but I guess you'll have to try it for yourself! ;) read more

Next Door - Spicy meatball pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

See all

Every time I drive back down from my travels up the north, I stopover here at Next Door. For good reason, it's not just the pizza but everything here is great. Of course the pizza is awesome, it's what they are known for but the dam the Penne ala vodka is incredible! Brussels roots awesome! The garlic knots are so addictive! The mashed potato and Margharita pies are my favorite. The White Clam isn't the best but a good option as well. On one occasion I received a complimentary dessert by the owner which pretty much deals the deal on my returning. The hospitality is golden and I shall return. read more

See all

I went to Next Door in New Haven earlier this year. It had been on my Try List for a while. I ordered a first ever pizza for me for takeout. I call it the "BaeBae". Bacon and Basil. Kind of like an herbier BLT. It was perfect. Good char. Simply delicious red sauce. So terrific, the BaeBae inspired the following Hot Take . . . I don't know where I would rank Next Door among the best New Haven pizza spots. But I bet Next Door, would be the best pizza place, in at least 85 percent of CT's cities and towns. That's how good New Haven is. That's how good Next Door is. 5 Stars read more

See all

There is no shortage of pizza joints in this area, but we keep Next Door in the regular rotation because the parking and crowds are manageable, the happy hour (4-6 PM M-F) & service are great, and the place is spacious and family friendly. Plenty of items to try on the menu - here are some of our favorites: Buffalo Cauliflower, Meatballs, Vinnie's Veggie & Honey Brussels Bacon Pies read more

I was looking for a place to go with my two sons (7 and 5) and my wife that we A. had not been before and B. Looked either interesting or tasty... or both. We decided to try next door. The night we went it was rainy. It was not a really big deal because the parking is very manageable - especially considering it's New Haven. We ordered some pizza, chicken wings and dessert. The food was AMAZING. Super fresh, very tasty and presentation was perfect. We literally ate everything. The only thing I snapped a photo of was my dessert. The wait staff were very kind. They provided my boys crayons and stuff to keep them busy. They always smiled and were very attentive. The Resturaunt itself was spacious, beautiful and clean. I got the impression that everyone that was working there, was happy to be there. And we were too!! 9.1/10 read more

Next Door - Apple Crumble - Pizza Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

Honestly crushed! Found out they were closing 2 weeks ago and we came last weekend and dined in and came for take out just now and on both occasions, complete debacle! Dine in experience the service at the bar from Jose was probably one of the worst experiences ever and the food matched it as the pies were undercooked and we never had the chance to say anything as Jose couldn't understand hand signals or stares of help! Our pick up experience their last weekend was even more so disappointing. 2/3 pies were dry and the third pie was undercooked. Called them to let them know immediately and the girl who picked up with a slight accent never apologized nor did she even let us speak to manager or offer to even remake the one pie I really complained about which was the New Haven Pie. Sadly they are leaving a bad taste in my mouth and wish I had never gone back so as not to tarnish the positive experience that we had a few years back-nothing near what I remembered! read more

See all

Excellent neighborhood pizza joint with a separate smallish bar area that gets busy when university is in session. We appreciate that Dining room tables aren't on top of one another here. We also appreciate that Next Door has more than just quality pizza, in fact their apps & salads are fresh & interesting & are at a nice portion size for sharing. All of the pies made here have a wonderful chewy crust & great sauce. Next Door also makes a reasonably priced & tasty New Haven style clam pie for folks not wanting to shell out 30 bucks or more as Zu ¶¶ard!s charges, the difference being that with Z's pie you are getting fresh shucked clams at market prices & Next Door uses canned. Service is excellent & very efficient. Go for the homemade molasses cookies afterwards. PS: good parking in their own lot. read more

Next Door - Next Door's dining room. - Pizza Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

So the ambiance is fantastic with comfortable seating and a relaxed vibe. The service is top notch. Our server was very friendly and the food came out super fast. My espresso martini was incredible. (No Bailey's just as I like it.) The Caesar salad was absolutely delicious and a delightful surprise. As far as the pizza goes, I need to preface this with the fact that I am a complete pizza snob. The reason we ended up here tonight was because Modern Apizza was mobbed and I wasn't waiting an hour with a toddler in tow. (For the record I would have totally waited an hour sans toddler.) Anyway - the cheese pie has potential. The cheese and sauce are great but I can't get over the flop. The crust was a huge let down. With that said - I couldn't see their oven so maybe that's the difference. You see char so you think there will be crunch - but no such luck. The clams casino was just meh and I am very confused about the bell peppers. They were an unwelcomed surprise. So all in all, the highs were high, but the pizza was a letdown. Again - great vibe and service. I would totally go back for drinks and salads! read more

See all

While this was not my first time here I was lucky enough to have a mother daughter date at Next Door this past week. The Rossi Rita (Next Door's take on a strawberry margarita) hit the spot! My mom couldn't get over how this restaurant was so empty and served just as good pizza as the restaurants on Wooster street. We were immediately able to grab a parking space and once inside were able to select a table of our choosing. No need to wait outside! Food was served promptly and fresh. Do not sleep on this hidden gem! read more

See all

We drove all the way from Durham NC for some New Haven pizza and Next Door did not disappoint!!!! You MUST order the garlic knots. Swimming in garlic...these are gooey-stretchy yeasty delights. The Clams Casino pizza was packed with flavor. Claudia and Doug were super friendly and welcoming. We will definitely be back!!! Oh and the ambiance is super cute. read more

Next Door - Unfortunately, the food was SO RIDICULOUSLY DELICIOUS this is all we have to show for the Clams Casino and Garlic Knots. - Pizza Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

Next Door is so much more then a pizza restaurant. We went there to try their great New Haven style thin crust pizza. We ordered a half mushroom, half sausage, mozz pizza. It was absolutely delicious, and perfectly cooked. But they also serve great appetizers, soups, stews, entrées, and sandwiches. They also make all their desserts on the premises. They even make their own ice cream. We ordered the strawberry shortcake made with their homemade biscuit.OMG it was so good. Our server was excellent, and the staff is very friendly.They also have a bar with seating, and a private party room. read more

See all

Every time I go to Next Door, I'm surprised at how good it is. You'd think eventually I'd remember for the next time, but somehow I always forget. We have ordered many things here. Obviously the pizza is the star. They do a really excellent New Haven style pizza. I really like the mashed potato pizza here in particular. Their wings are also excellent, and I highly recommend the buffalo cauliflower. The service is always fast and friendly. The owner is a great contributor to the community, which is nice. The front room is high top bar tables with TVs, and the back room is slightly quieter with tables. Overall, a great joint that holds its own in a town full of top notch pizza. read more

Just tried Next Door for the first time this month and it was so good! New Haven Style Apizza was on point - we had the Mashed Potato and the Fresh Mozzarella. The crust and toppings were all perfect. They also have gluten-free, vegan, and vegetarian options. We tried the Penne Alla Vodka, which was delicious. The sauce was great, and excellent portion size. For a starter we had the Housemade Meatballs, which were very good. If you're a salad lover or want a side with your pizza the Winter Berry Salad was a great choice. If you saved room for dessert go for the Ice Cream Sammie, you won't be disappointed! Definitely make sure to check this place out. Staff is excellent, very friendly and accommodating. There's a small parking lot onsite and plenty of street parking. Also, spacious seating inside. read more

See all

Our new Trivia Tuesday spot! I recommend the butternut squash soup and fried cauliflower bites in a mango habanero sauce. read more

Well - call me generous perhaps! But it is so refreshing to have another choice for pizza in New Haven... I should have written this long ago, but here it is now. I love the place. TBH, I only get pizza and salad, so this reflects that. The salads change with the seasons and what is fresh and tasty at the time... my favorite is when they have their berry salad - OMG - so delicious. The name says it all peppered with raspberries, blackberries... and more... but I must commend the balsamic vinaigrette!! I've never had a more delicately flavored dressing. I got one for a friend as take out once, and they too raved over it. The pizza is great as well. To each their own when it comes to pizza for certain. I feel you need to give your 'touchstone' pie for reference... mine is Sally's. Next door is not like that at all. But has a good sauce (a must) and gets the cheese amount right. It has some char on the crust, but not enough to be inedible. Last time I tried the sausage and . It deserves a spot on your to do list. BTW / ran into the owner there once - talked a bit - great guy and very appreciative! Keep it up Next Door!! read more

So my friend and I came here for dinner and ordered half a barbecue chicken and half cheese. The pizza was floppy but good. If I rate it 7.3 only one slice, my fingers got dirty from the crust, and it was oily in the cheese read more

Next Door - Half chicken barbecue and half cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

Really good gluten free pizza with non-dairy cheese in New Haven known for its pizza. The regular pizza was rated highly by our friends who ate with us. Service was vey good. Lots of tables with a back room for special events. One Saturday night there was Blue Grass music. read more

There's something here for everyone! Great pizza, burgers, fettuccine Alfredo and a huge salad that fed our party of 8. Although they have their own desserts, they graciously let us bring in our own (two!) birthday cakes, supplying plates, forks, candles and singing at no extra charge. Nice folks, relaxed atmosphere. read more

I got mash potato pie and it was SO GOOD!! I highly recommend it. The toppings were perfectly balanced with its dough, it's so savory and fluffy! read more

Next Door - Mashed Potato Pie - Pizza Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

My husband and I had a great dinner at Next Door last weekend. It is a welcome change from the more hectic pizza places. Parking is easy. The vibe is "perfect neighborhood", roomy enough but still cozy. We sat at a high top table in the bar, enough buzz to be lively but quiet enough to hear each other. We had the fried calamari - delicious and pizza - also delicious. The service was superb and friendly. We will make it a regular spot. read more

This was my first time here and as a pizza lover I had to try it out. The restaurant is cozy with a great bar area. Since it was my first time here, I wanted to try just a small half plain and bacon pizza. When it's my first time trying a new pizza place, I always get plain pizza because if you can't make plain pizza good then it's not good pizza. Also, when I try a new pizza place, I want to taste the flavors and if the pizza is good, then I'll go back and try different toppings. The pizza was very good and had great flavor. The dough was great and the customer was awesome. I would definitely be back again. As you can see, I ate the whole pizza. It was delicious. read more

See all

Saturday night in New Haven. I want really good pizza without hassle I come here. I drive by people standing out in rain in line for Modern. Meanwhile I order online here 15 min later drive up and grab some perfection. This pizza is seasoned perfectly. The garlic is all over it. Popping with flavor. tomato sauce, pecorino romano, evoo, oregano & fresh garlic are the ingredients. Nothing more needed for this slice of heaven. read more

Next Door - New Haven Pizza Plain - Pizza Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

Next Door is a New Haven-style pizzeria that opened in New Haven, Connecticut in November 2018. It was founded by partners Doug Coffin, Robin Bodak and Domenic Giannotti. Coffin had originally founded and run 'Big Green Truck Pizza' (a fleet of green mobile wood-fired pizza oven trucks) in 2003. The fleet of trucks are stored inside a building at 530 East Street. Right next store is a building that housed Humphrey's East Restaurant for several years. Eventually Coffin and his business partners decided to acquire the building themselves and open a brick & mortar version of Big Green Pizza. Since the building was next door to where their pizza trucks were stored, it was decided to name the new venture 'Next Door'. My wife and I have visited and ordered takeout from Next Door several times. It is one of our favorite local pizzerias. Our most recent visit was last week for my job's Holiday Party. We had a seemingly endless amount of pies coming out for the the party. Some of the delicious pizzas included "New Haven Plain" (tomato sauce, Pecorino Romano, EVOO, oregano, fresh garlic), "Plain Cheese", "Fresh Mozzarella", "Buffalo Chicken", "Spicy Meatball", "Vinnie's Veggie Pie" (mozzarella, seasoned kale, caramelized onions, mushroom, gorgonzola), "Barbecue Chicken", "White Broccoli", and "Bacon & Onion". Everything was spectacular as always. The party was also served some salad, wings, garlic knots, and gelato for dessert. In addition to their great food, Next Door also has an excellent selection of craft beer and craft cocktails. I ordered a draught pour of Hooker Brewing's "#NoFilter" (New England IPA) and later on I had a glass of their "Holiday Nog" (eggnog spiked with rum). It's always a great time at Next Door. read more

See all

Let me begin by saying next door had been a staple in my list of restaurants I loved going to when I first moved back to New Haven and my daughter was young and every staff person was nice and respectful and it was a great place to be. Tonight left a horrible taste in my mouth. Nicole my server, was extremely nice. She was attentive and friendly and personable. I would visit again just for her. Let me tell you who was awful and does not need to be a bartender anywhere. Tessa is the bartender who made my old fashioned incorrectly and slammed my glass on the table and stormed off. And when questioned about it, she feigned ignorance and indifference. I requested that she not make another drink for me. And the drink she made matched her disposition and attitude: awful. I sent it back to have Nicole make it. My question is why hire someone so inexperienced and unfriendly and unfit for a job as a bartender? She was sour and unpleasant and unprofessional. I told the owner and he tutt tutted but I doubt she'll be reprimanded at all. It made the entire experience terrible. I won't go back. read more

My group came here on a recommendation, and we are so glad we did. We started off with the green salad-- classic and refreshing-- and French fries, which were crispy and addicting. The pizzas also truly lived up to what we hoped they'd be - we got 2 large pizzas, so we tried fresh mozzarella, brussel bacon, and spicy meatball (we appreciated that you are able to do half and half on larges). All were delicious and worth coming back to New Haven for. We also were pleasantly surprised to be offered a delicious free dessert-- the chocolate pot de creme-- on our way out. It was so yummy and the loveliest surprise. Fantastic service and food-- will definitely come back!! read more

Next Door - Outdoor of restaurant - Pizza Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

Pretty good pizza. The wait was not long and I've been wanting to try new places in New Haven. read more

Next Door - Bacon and Honey Brussel Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

Great option for New Haven pizza. I especially like the mashed potato pizza, it's so good. They always deliver fast.

Over an hour wait at Modern, so we walked over to Next Door. More or less just as good, and we were able to sit down immediately. All the pies were great - crispy, cracker New Haven-style crusts: - New Haven Plain - red sauce, garlic, pecorino - would never have normally ordered this, but loved it - Rabe + Sausage - great - Mashed potato - potatoes, bacon, caramelized onions - this was the winner of the table - White clam - maybe the one pie where Modern has the clear edge, but still tasty Also got the Buffalo cauliflower, some beers and a cocktail. Really can't beat the fact that there was no wait and the pies easily stack up to the other New Haven spots. read more

Next Door - Mashed potato / rabe + sausage / white clam - Pizza Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

Wow! Absolutely impressed with Next Door! We're already big fans of Big Green Pizza Truck so we definitely had high expectations for their brick & mortar location, literally next door. See what they did there? We came on a Friday night and had a couple gift cards to spend. It was pretty quiet, especially compared to other New Haven Apizza hot spots, so we were seated right away. They have a full bar and cocktail menu with really good prces! The staff was super friendly and the owner even came out to chat with us. Very cool! We ordered 3 pies but definitely was hard to decide on these 3. We went with the Fresh Tomato Pie (a summer special and the groups #1 favorite), Bacon & Brussels, and Sausage & Broccoli Rabe. All of them were absolutely incredible!!! Classic New Haven and just as good as some of our other local faves. The prices were pretty good too. If one of the hot spots is a bit too crowded, come over to Next Door and you won't be disappointed!!! We'll absolutely be back! read more

See all

Nice place! One good thing to note for being in New Haven is that there is a small parking lot! It's a very interesting space. A bar in the front and in the back with tables in the middle. Our server was friendly and helpful. We couldn't decide between two pizzas so she suggested get them both! Half on one side half on the other. The best of both worlds. We got the honey Brussels sprout with bacon and ricotta and half mashed potato, bacon and caramelized onions. Both were good. We liked the Brussels sprout half better. We had the meatball app too. The meatballs were juicy and delicious! My son had his cheese pizza, but not as impressed with it. He liked the meatballs and would probably have that for dinner next time. Desserts were good the brownie was a solid choice. The ice cream Sammie was good too . read more

See all

Large clean establishment. The pizza is New Haven style and fights hard against its contenders. The bacon Brussels hot honey pizza is my favorite from them. The other pizza choices are also great. This place is definitely a go to for a less traditional pie. The staff was kind and courteous. read more

Next Door - Bacon Brussel Hot honey pizza - Pizza Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

Ordered from Uber ... WOW!!! Wooster Street be afraid Next Door has ya beat. Crust-perfect Toppings-perfect Price- perfect Delivery-perfect read more

Next Door knows how to throw a party! New Haven style Pizza--check! Birthdays, anniversaries, bridal showers, engagements, life remembrances and more, Next Door's private event space is now open. There's a private entrance, dedicated bar, soaring ceilings, a view of the wood burning pizza oven and free parking, the event space is also DJ, entertainment and add your own décor friendly. The basic pizza party menu includes all you can eat pizza, salad, and gelato for $25/per person. Items from Next Door's menu and/or bar are available as add ons. Gluten free, and vegan pizza options available at no extra cost. Doug Coffin, founder of the Big Green Truck and owner/chef of Next Door is a super great guy. Next Door is an offshoot of the beloved Big Green Truck, Connecticut's first mobile brick oven pizza. Next Door serves up great New Haven style pizza and a full menu of eclectic comfort food including gluten free, vegan, and vegetarian options. In fact, the Big Green Trucks are parked next door (thus the name). My favorite was the Mashed Potato Pizza, the Clam Pizza and the Buffalo Chicken Pizza! So good! We also tried bartender Nick's Daiquiris and they were super refreshing. Also try the Tiki Sour! Very good! Hope you find the hidden door- keep your eyes peeled! read more

See all

Food was very good. Very good attention to food allergies, with the chef coming out and making a special meal for my daughter.

Sunday I was able to attend the Next Door Pizza Party! What a wonderful event. The Next Door is the Big Green Truck Pizza. This place is filled with so much history and love. They have a Beautiful spacious room to have events and parties. It's also a family restaurant. Everyone is so Nice and welcoming! I was honored to meet Doug the owner along with some of his wonderful staff (Maria, Stacy and the bartender). All kinds of pizzas were put out and they all Looked delicious. I have to say my Gluten-free pizza was the best ! The best I had. It was excellent and full Of flavor!! The drinks were delicious and refreshing as well. The Next Door will make it a special Place for whatever it is you plan to celebrate. And if you aren't celebrating, go for the pizza, it's New Haven Style pizza with GF and vegetarian/ vegan options as well. Thank You for having us and I was excited I got to go . Now I know where to go for my GF pizza! Even if I need to drive the 30 min! :-) read more

See all

Delicious New Haven Pizza, expertly made And the decor inside, if you decide to sit in there and eat, reminds one of a brewpub, nice atmosphere, pleasant destination. read more

Wanted to switch up our pizza game so we grabbed some takeout recently from next door. I had the big green salad and a small meatball and my bf had his standard cheese pizza. We also ordered the garlic knots. Salad and pizza were great and my BF approved of his pizza. Great chew to crust and sauce so good. Was super bummed we ordered 6 garlic knots and we were only given 3 and charged for 6. Bummer. Had to knock a star off there. Hopefully next time we come they'll get the knot order right. read more

See all

I will go out on a limb here. Next Door deserves to be included in the discussion of best New Haven pizza. Nice college publike atmosphere. Walked in on a Sunday evening - no line, no attitude. Good selection of beers on tap. Lots of great pizza options - quality ingredients, great char. If I had to pick out the most outstanding element, it would have to be the crust. Looking forward to returning. read more

One of the hidden pizza gems in New Haven is hands down Next Door. This place should not be slept on. The garlic knots alone should get you there!!! They also own the Big Green Truck and can bring their goodness right to you! They offer vegan and gluten free too. A definite must try! read more

See all

Extremely underrated New Haven pizza place. This place is amazing and love going back every time!